Islamic Philosophy from its to Origin thePresent Philosophy in the Land of Prophecy Seyyed Hossein Nasr ISLAMIC PHILOSOPHY FROM ITS ORIGIN TO THE PRESENT SUNY series in Islam Seyyed Hossein Nasr, editor ISLAMIC PHILOSOPHY FROM ITS ORIGIN TO THE PRESENT Philosophy in the Land of Prophecy Seyyed Hossein Nasr State University of New York Press Published by State University of New York Press © 2006 State University of New York All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission. No part of this book may be stored in a retrieval system or transmitte in any form or by any means including elecronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise without the prior permission in writing of the publisher. For information, address State University of New York Press, 194 Washington Avenue, Suite 305, Albany, NY 12210-2384 Production by Marilyn P. Semerad Marketing by Fran Keneston Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Nasr, Seyyed Hossein. Islamic philosophy from its origin to the present : philosophy in the land of prophecy / Seyyed Hossein Nasr. p. cm. — (SUNY series in Islam) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-7914-6799-6 (hardcover : alk. paper) — ISBN 0-7914-6800-3 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Philosophy, Islamic. I. Title. II. Series. B741.N384 2006 181'.07—dc22 2005023943 ISBN-13: 978-0-7914-6799-2 (hardcover : alk. paper) ISBN-13: 978-0-7914-6800-5 (pbk. : alk. paper) 10987654321 ማሜምሞ The Quranic revelation is the light which enables one to see. It is like the sun which casts light lavishly. Philosophical intelligence is the eye that sees this light and without this light one cannot see anything. If one closes one’s eyes, that is, if one pretends to pass by philosophical intelligence, this light itself will not be seen because there will not be any eyes to see it. —Mullå S• adrå Contents Preface ix Transliteration x Introduction: Philosophy and Prophecy 1 PART 1. ISLAMIC PHILOSOPHY AND ITS STUDY 1. The Study of Islamic Philosophy in the West in Recent Times: An Overview 13 2. The Meaning and Role of Philosophy in Islam 31 3. Al-¡ikmat al-Ilåhiyyah and Kalåm 49 PART 2. PHILOSOPHICAL ISSUES 4. The Question of Existence and Quiddity and Ontology in Islamic Philosophy 63 5. Post-Avicennan Islamic Philosophy and the Study of Being 85 6. Epistemological Questions: Relations among Intellect, Reason, and Intuition within Diverse Islamic Intellectual Perspectives 93 PART 3. ISLAMIC PHILOSOPHY IN HISTORY 7. A Framework for the Study of the History of Islamic Philosophy 107 8. Dimensions of the Islamic Intellectual Tradition: Kalåm, Philosophy, and Spirituality 119 9. The Poet-Scientist ‘Umar Khayyåm as Philosopher 165 10. Philosophy in Azarbaijan and the School of Shiraz 185 11. The School of Isfahan Revisited 209 vii viii Contents 12. Mullå S• adrå and the Full Flowering of Prophetic Philosophy 223 13. From the School of Isfahan to the School of Tehran 235 PART 4. THE CURRENT SITUATION 14. Reflections on Islam and Modern Thought 259 15. Philosophy in the Land of Prophecy Yesterday and Today 273 Notes 281 Index 343 Contents ix Preface This book is the result of nearly fifty years of study and meditation upon philosophy and philosophical issues as seen in light of the reali- ties revealed through prophecy both objective and inward in the form of illumination. In a world in which philosophy has become so di- vorced from revealed realities and secular thought has sought to marginalize and even annihilate knowledge imbued with the sacred, it is necessary to return, whenever possible, to the theme of the rela- tion between philosophy and prophecy through different perspectives and angles of vision. Years ago we dealt with the heart of the question of the relation between knowledge and the reality of the sacred in Knowledge ad the Sacred and have returned to this subject from other angles of vision in later works such as The Need for a Sacred Science. In the present work we turn our gaze specifically upon philoso- phy and especially Islamic philosophy. We deal with over a millen- nium of Islamic philosophy, its doctrines, history, and approaches, from the angle of vision of the relation between that long philosophi- cal tradition and the realities of prophecy that have always dominated the horizon of the Islamic cosmos and the intellectual climate and space of the Islamic people. Some of the chapters of this book were written as essays over the years. They have all been thoroughly re- vised and integrated into the framework of this book. Many other chapters are new and were written specifically as integral parts of the present work in order to complete the picture that we have sought to depict in the pages that follow. We wish to thank the Radius Foundation, which provided finan- cial help to make the preparation of this text possible. We are also especially grateful to Katherine O’Brien, who prepared and readied the text for the press. Having had to endure reading hundreds of pages of handwritten material and numerous alterations required patience, know- how, and energy to carry out a Herculean task. Without her help it would not have been possible to present the text for publication. ix Transliteration Introduction Philosophy and Prophecy In the current cultural climate in the West as well as other parts of the globe affected by modernism and postmodernism, philosophy and prophecy are seen as two very different and, in the eyes of many, antithetical approaches to the understanding of the nature of reality. Such was not, however, the case in the various traditional civilizations preceding the advent of the modern world. Nor is it the case even today to the extent that the traditional worldview has survived. Need- less to say, by “prophecy” we do not mean foretelling of the future, but bringing a message from higher or deeper orders of reality to a particular human collectivity. Now the modes of this function have differed from religion to religion, but the reality of “prophecy” is evident in worlds as diverse as the ancient Egyptian, the classical Greek, and the Hindu, not to speak of the Abrahamic monotheisms in which the role of prophecy is so central. If we do not limit our under- standing of prophecy to the Abrahamic view of it, we can see the presence of prophecy in very diverse religious climes in nearly all of which it is not only of a legal, ethical, and spiritual significance but also of a sapiental one concerned with knowledge. We see this reality in the world of the rishis in India and the shamans of diverse Shamanic religions as well as in the iatromantis of the Greek religion and the immortals of Taoism, in the illumination of the Buddha and later in the Zen Buddhist masters who have experienced illumination or satori, as well as the prophets of the Iranian religions such as Zoroaster and of course in the Abrahamic prophets. Consequently in all of these worlds, whenever and wherever philosophy in its universal sense has flourished, it has been related to prophecy in numerous ways. Even if we limit the definition of philosophy to the intellectual activity in ancient Greece known by that name, an activity that the modern Western understanding of history considers to be the origin of philosophical speculation as such, the rapport between philosophy and prophecy can be seen to be a very close one at the very moment of the genesis of Greek philosophy. We also come to realize that the 1 2 Introduction two drifted apart only later and were not separated from each other at the beginning of the Greek philosophical tradition. Let us just con- sider the three most important figures at the origin of Greek philo- sophical speculation. Pythagoras, who is said to have coined the term philosophy, was certainly not an ordinary philosopher like Descartes or Kant. He was said to have had extraordinary prophetic powers and was himself like a prophet who founded a new religious community.1 The Muslims in fact called him a monotheist (muwa÷÷id) and some referred to him as a prophet. The person often called the “father” of Western logic and phi- losophy was Parmenides, who is usually presented as a rationalist who happened to have written a poem of mediocre quality. But as the recent brilliant studies of Peter Kingsley have clearly demonstrated, far from being a rationalist in the modern sense, he was deeply im- mersed in the world of prophecy in its Greek religious sense and was a seer and visionary.2 In his poem, which contains his philosophical message, Parmenides is led to the other world by the Daughters of the Sun who came from the Mansion of Light situated at the farthest degree of existence.3 The answer to the question as to how this journey took place is “incubation,” a spiritual practice well known in Greek religion, one in which a person would rest completely still until his or her soul would be taken to higher levels of reality, and the mysteries of existence would be revealed. Thus Parmenides undertakes the inner journey until he meets the goddess who teaches him everything of importance, that is, teaches him what is considered to be the origin of Greek philosophical specu- lation. It is remarkable that when the goddess confronts Parmenides, she addresses him as kouros, that is, young man. This fact is remark- able and fascinating because in the Islamic tradition the very term for spiritual chivalry (futuwwah in Arabic and jawånmard¥ in Persian) is associated with the word for youth (fatå/jawån), and this spiritual chiv- alry is said to have existed before Islam and to have been given new life in Islam where its source is associated with ‘Al¥,4 who received it from the Prophet of Islam and where it was integrated into Sufism.