whitepaper ASSESSING AUTHENTICITY An Analysis of Questionable Degrees and Diploma Mills whitepaper ASSESSING AUTHENTICITY Diploma mills are a problem that plagues completion of little or no education or coursework 4 secondary and higher education institutions and to obtain a degree, diploma, or certificate. Instead, diploma mills offer illegitimate academic degrees, subsequently impacts the applicant screening diplomas, or certificates for a fee. services conducted by consumer reporting agencies. As technology advances and evolves, Because nationally recognized accrediting agencies diploma mills are becoming more industrious do not accredit diploma mills, diploma mills will often and sophisticated. New tactics and strategies are be supported by accreditation mills.5 Accreditation employed on a continual basis to defraud consumers mills are fictitious, illegitimate entities that claim and employers. These tactics involve drawing to be an accreditation agency.6 Accreditation mills in consumers with advertisements that offer the offer accreditation to a diploma mill for a fee without opportunity to earn a “degree” fast, with just a “click” reviewing the diploma mills’ program, teachers, or or for a negligible fee.1 In turn, consumer reporting quality of education. Many diploma mills claim to be agencies have been incited to review education accredited by the accreditation mill in order to attract verification results more closely and carefully. students and appear legitimate. WHAT IS A DIPLOMA MILL? HOW DIPLOMA MILLS WORK? Diploma mills (also known as “degree mills”) are Diploma mills are multidimensional and transnational defined by the Higher Education Opportunity Act operations. While there are nationally recognized as “Entities that lack accreditation by a recognized accreditation agencies, a lack of centralized national accrediting agency, and offer degrees, diplomas, or oversight has allowed diploma mills to thrive in the certificates that may be used to represent that the United States. Additionally, diploma mills often claim individual who possesses the degree, diploma, or to be operating in one country, but actually operate in certificate has completed a program of postsecondary another. In 2017, the World Education Services found education or training”.2 3 These entities require the that there were an estimated 2,615 diploma mills in 1 “The Truth Behind Diploma Mills” Better Business Bureau, Mar. 22, 2018, https://www.bbb.org/article/news-releases/17303-the-truth-behind-diploma-mills 2 The Higher Education Opportunity Act, https://ifap.ed.gov/dpcletters/attachments/GEN0812FP0810AttachHEOADCL.pdf 3 Similarly, Vertical Screen defines a diploma mill as an organization that is not accredited or recognized by any education governing bodies and for a fee offers illegitimate diplomas without ensuring that students are properly qualified. Diploma mills are not properly vetted for ongoing quality control, regulatory compliance, and are not legally authorized to provide a program of education. 4 Id. 5 “Diploma Mills and Accreditation- Diploma Mills” U.S. Department of Education, https://www2.ed.gov/students/prep/college/diplomamills/diploma-mills.html 6 “College Degree Scams” Federal Trade Commission https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0206-college-degree-scams All Rights Reserved © 2019 Certiphi Screening, Inc. 091119 This document and/or presentation is provided as a service to our customers. Its contents are designed solely for informational purposes, and should not be inferred or understood as legal advice or binding case law, nor shared with any third parties. Persons in need of legal assistance should seek the advice of competent legal counsel. Although care has been taken in preparation of these materials, we cannot guarantee the accuracy, currency or completeness of the information contained within it. Anyone using this information does so at his or her own risk. 1 whitepaper ASSESSING AUTHENTICITY the world, with 1,008 diploma mills diploma mills will offer verification from the “school” to verify their operating in the United States. 7 services for the degrees they confer attendance. In some cases, the Furthermore, the World Education by providing a number that can be individual may not know that the Service estimates 500 fictitious called to “verify” the degree. 11 diploma mill is not a real school and Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.) that the diploma is not legitimate. degrees are given out monthly by In 2005, the federal government Individuals may be tricked by 400 diploma mills in the United was able to stop a prolific diploma diploma mills through the use of States.8 mill operated by a couple in persuasive advertising and enticed Washington.12 This diploma mill, by the ability to easily obtain a Diploma mills often use aggressive frequently operating as St. Regis degree. advertising to draw individuals University but also as 120 other in, charging a flat fee per degree fictitious universities, issued RESPONSE TO rather than per credit or course as is more than 10,000 diplomas in 131 customary in legitimate institutions. countries before being shut down.13 DIPLOMA MILLS The individual often obtains the This diploma mill offered degrees Diploma mills are designed to degree by completing little or no for “life experiences” and in one dupe and defraud individuals and work. Diploma mills rarely require instance gave an investigator, employers. To prevent this, some substantial coursework or exams claiming to be a retired Syrian states including Hawaii, Michigan, and offer little to no interaction with military officer, three undergraduate Maine, and New Jersey have passed professors or teachers. 9 and advanced degrees in chemistry laws that prohibit the issuance or and environmental engineering for a manufacturing of false academic Diploma mills use technology to fee of $1,277.14 credentials and/or prohibit employ tactics in order to appear individuals from knowingly using more legitimate to consumers and HOW THESE DEGREES false academic degrees. 16 employers. Often, these entities will create sophisticated websites ARE USED? Diploma mills offer degrees and send email advertisements. Individuals often buy degrees not only for undergraduate and Many diploma mills will offer from diploma mills to obtain a advanced degrees but for high false transcripts, reference job, attend college, or attain a school diplomas as well. In recent letters by “professors,” student promotion or raise.15 The individuals years, the FTC has worked to stop identification cards, and other then report that they earned the and prevent diploma mills that supporting documents that provide degree from the institution listed have been identified for fraudulent, an individual with a sense of the and may provide other paperwork deceptive, and unfair business “college experience.”10 Some 7 “Diploma Mills: 9 Strategies for Tackling One of Higher Education’s Most Wicked Problems” World Education Services, https://wenr.wes.org/2017/12/diploma-mills-9-strategies- for-tackling-one-of-higher-educations-most-wicked-problems 8 Id. 9 Id. 10 http://users.eecs.northwestern.edu/~jennie/documents/jduggan_diploma_mills.pdf 11 Schemo, Diana Jean “Diploma Mill Concerns Extend Beyond Fraud” Jun. 29, 2008, https://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/29/us/29diploma.html 12 Id. 13 Id. 14 Id. 15 “Diploma Mills: 9 Strategies for Tackling One of Higher Education’s Most Wicked Problems” World Education Services, https://wenr.wes.org/2017/12/diploma-mills-9-strategies- for-tackling-one-of-higher-educations-most-wicked-problems 16 Hi Rev Stat §446E et seq.; MCL §390.1601 et seq.; 20-A MRSA §10801-10804; N.J.S.A. 18A:3-15.1et seq., All Rights Reserved © 2019 Certiphi Screening, Inc. 091119 This document and/or presentation is provided as a service to our customers. Its contents are designed solely for informational purposes, and should not be inferred or understood as legal advice or binding case law, nor shared with any third parties. Persons in need of legal assistance should seek the advice of competent legal counsel. Although care has been taken in preparation of these materials, we cannot guarantee the accuracy, currency or completeness of the information contained within it. Anyone using this information does so at his or her own risk. 2 whitepaper ASSESSING AUTHENTICITY practices.17 In 2017, two diploma mills settled with the clicks through a website and a purchase. FTC, after the FTC alleged that the entities deceptively • No physical location of the institution claimed that their online “high schools” were The institution may offer degrees to U.S. citizens 18 accredited. but will be located in a foreign county that lacks any system of academic accreditation. SIGNS OF A DIPLOMA MILL • Advertised flat fees and low costs It is important that employers and consumer reporting • Accredited by illegitimate accreditation mills. agencies review and verify an individual’s credentials. Signs of a diploma mill include: • The name of the institution sounds similar to WHAT CERTIPHI SCREENING DOES another well-known university TO ASSIST CLIENTS WITH Cornwell University instead of Cornell University in New York. SCREENING DIPLOMA MILLS • Credit for work or life experiences Certiphi Screening works to ensure that an In contrast to legitimate universities that offer individual’s education credentials originate from an small amounts of academic credit for work accredited and legitimate degree-granting institution. experience, diploma mills grant credit based Certiphi Screening verifies all education