From: Lynne Birkinbine To: Dave Koss; Lofgreen, Jessica Date: 12/17/2010 4:14 PM Subject: Final Phase II for Earl Scheib Jessica and Dave- Our office has reviewed the final Phase II ESA report prepared by Terracon for the Earl Scheib Auto Paint site at 1555 E. 22nd Street. We concur with the findings of the report. This property has been adequately characterized. No further action is warranted at this time. Please advise the contractor before construction to be vigilant when any suspicious odors, discolored soil, or metal debris are encountered during excavation activities, and to contact the city PM if necessary. If an unknown UST is uncovered, all construction activities must cease, and the TFD must be contacted immediately for field inspection. A hard copy of the final report has been sent via interoffice mail. - Lynne Lynne Birkinbine Environmental Manager City of Tucson Environmental Services 520-837-3708 direct 520-791-3175 central office 520-791-4155 fax EMAIL:[email protected] A Class III Cultural Resource Survey for the Proposed Road Improvements along 22nd Street from Park Avenue to Tucson Boulevard, and along Kino Parkway from Silverlake Road to Warehouse Avenue, in Tucson, Pima County, Arizona Prepared by: Jeffrey T. Jones City of Tucson Project No. 09-45 Tierra Archaeological Report No. 2009-83 ASM Accession No. 2009-832 May 24, 2011 A Class III Cultural Resource Survey for the Proposed Road Improvements along 22nd Street from Park Avenue to Tucson Boulevard, and along Kino Parkway from Silverlake Road to Warehouse Avenue, in Tucson, Pima County, Arizona Prepared by: Jeffrey T. Jones Submitted to: Jonathan Mabry, Historic Preservation Officer City of Tucson Department of Urban Planning and Design 149 North Stone Avenue P.O. Box 27210 Tucson, Arizona 85726-7210 Submitted by: Tierra Right of Way Services, Ltd. 1575 East River Road, Suite 201 Tucson, Arizona 85718 City of Tucson Project No. 09-45 Tierra Archaeological Report No. 2009-83 ASM Accession No. 2009-832 May 24, 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract .............................................................................................................................................................. iii Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................ 1 Project Area ........................................................................................................................................................ 1 Previous Research ............................................................................................................................................ 15 Cultural History ................................................................................................................................................ 21 Paleoindian and Early Archaic Periods (11,000–6000 B.C.) .................................................................. 21 Middle Archaic Period (6000–2100 B.C.) ................................................................................................. 22 Late Archaic–Early Agricultural Period (2100 B.C.–A.D. 150) .............................................................. 22 Early Ceramic Period (A.D. 150–650) ....................................................................................................... 23 Pioneer Period (A.D. 650–750) .................................................................................................................. 24 Colonial Period (A.D. 750–950) ................................................................................................................. 24 Sedentary Period (A.D. 950–1150)............................................................................................................. 25 Classic Period (A.D. 1150–1450)................................................................................................................ 26 Protohistoric Period (A.D. 1450–1540) .................................................................................................... 27 Historic Period (A.D. 1540–1950) ............................................................................................................. 29 Survey Methods ................................................................................................................................................ 30 Evaluation Criteria ........................................................................................................................................... 30 Survey Results ................................................................................................................................................... 31 2009 Survey Results .................................................................................................................................... 31 2011 Survey Results .................................................................................................................................... 32 Management Recommendations ................................................................................................................... 32 References ......................................................................................................................................................... 34 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Project location. ................................................................................................................................. 2 Figure 2. Map of properties in the area of potential effect, west of Barraza-Aviation Parkway. ........... 4 Figure 3. Map of properties in the area of potential effect, west of Barraza-Aviation Parkway. ........... 5 Figure 4. Map of properties in the area of potential effect, west of Barraza-Aviation Parkway. ........... 6 Figure 5. Map of properties in the area of potential effect, east of Barraza-Aviation Parkway. ............ 7 Figure 6. Map of previously recorded sites within 1 mile of the current survey area. ........................... 16 Figure 7. Map of previous surveys within 1 mile of the current survey area. ......................................... 20 LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Properties in the Area of Potential Effect, West of Barraza-Aviation Parkway........................ 8 Table 2. Properties in the Area of Potential Effect, East of Barraza-Aviation Parkway ....................... 12 Table 3. Previously Recorded Sites within 1 Mile of the Current Survey Area ...................................... 15 Table 4. Previous Surveys within 1 Mile of the Current Survey Area ...................................................... 17 Tierra Archaeological Report No. 2009-83 ii ABSTRACT PROJECT TITLE: A Class III Cultural Resource Survey for the Proposed Road Improvements along 22nd Street from Park Avenue to Tucson Boulevard ,and along Kino Parkway from Silverlake Road to Warehouse Avenue, in Tucson, Pima County, Arizona LAND STATUS: City of Tucson and private FUNDING SOURCE: Regional Transportation Authority AGENCY: City of Tucson PROJECT DESCRIPTION: A systematic, non-collection, 100-percent pedestrian survey of a 97.11-acre area proposed for the widening of 22nd Street and Kino Parkway. CITY OF TUCSON PROJECT NO.: 09-45 TIERRA PROJECT NO.: 9T6-026 TIERRA REPORT NO.: 2009-83 ASM ACCESSION NO.: 2009-832 PERMIT NO.: Arizona Antiquities Act Blanket Permit No. 2009-014bl FIELD WORK DATES: November 25 and December 7, 2009; March 18, April 12 and 21, and May 16, 2011 PROJECT LOCATION: The project area is located along both sides of 22nd Street between South Park Avenue and Tucson Boulevard; along both sides of Kino Parkway between Silverlake Road and East Warehouse Avenue; along both sides of South Warren Avenue between East 22nd Street and East 21st Street; along South Curtis Avenue between East 20th Street and East 22nd Street; along South Vine Avenue between East Warehouse Avenue and East 22nd Street; along both sides of South Cherry Avenue between 22nd Street and midway between East 24th Street and East 25th Street; along East 23rd Street between South Cherrybell Stravenue and South Neff Street; and along portions of East Fairland Stravenue, South Campbell Avenue, East Willits Way, and East Silverlake Road in the S ½ of Section 17, the S ½ of Section 18, the N ½ of Section 19, and the N ½ of Section 20, Township 14 South, Range 14 East, Gila and Salt River Baseline and Meridian (G&SRB&M), on the Tucson, Arizona (1995), 7.5-minute U.S. Geological Survey quadrangle in Tucson, Pima County, Arizona. Tierra Archaeological Report No. 2009-83 iii NO. OF ACRES SURVEYED: 98 acres (39.66 ha) NO. OF SITES: 0 NO. OF ISOLATED OCCURRENCES: 0 MANAGEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS: No prehistoric archaeological sites or isolated occurrences were identified during this survey. However, many of the structures in the project area are themselves historic in age, dating between 1947 and 1964. Tierra recommends that a Historic Properties Assessment be conducted by qualified architectural historians to study and record the historic architecture and other historic cultural features located within the project area, to evaluate these properties as to their eligibility for listing in the National Register of Historic Places or the State Register of Cultural Properties, and to minimize the impact of the project on these historic cultural resources. The client and all subcontractors are reminded that, in accordance with Section 41-844 of the Arizona Revised Statues (ARS