Sky localization of space-based gravitational wave detectors Chao Zhang ( 超),1, ∗ Yungui Gong (龚云5),1, y Hang Liu (刘 *),2, z Bin Wang (王斌),3, 2, x and Chunyu Zhang ( %è)1, { 1School of Physics, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, Hubei 430074, China 2School of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China 3Center for Gravitation and Cosmology, Yangzhou University, Yangzhou 225009, China. Localizing the sky position of the gravitational wave source is a key scientific goal for gravita- tional wave observations. Employing the Fisher information matrix approximation, we compute the angular resolutions of LISA and TianQin, two planned space-based gravitational wave detec- tors and examine how detectors' configuration properties, such as the orientation change of the detector plane, heliocentric or geocentric motion and the arm length etc., affect the accuracy of source localization for monochromatic sources at selected values of frequencies. We find that the amplitude modulation due to the annual changing orientation of the detector plane helps LISA get better accuracy in the sky localization and better sky coverage at frequencies below several mHz, and its effect on TianQin is negligible although the orientation of TianQin's detector plane is fixed. At frequencies above roughly 30mHz, TianQin's ability in the sky localization is better than LISA. Further we explore potential space detector networks for fast and accurate localization of the grav- itational wave sources. The LISA-TianQin network has better ability in sky localization for sources with frequencies in the range 1-100 mHz and the network has larger sky coverage for the angular resolution than the individual detector. I. INTRODUCTION all directions within a few seconds to minutes. It requires three or more ground-based GW detectors at widely sep- Since the first gravitational wave (GW) event arated sites to locate GW sources with the method of GW150914 observed by the Laser Interferometer timing triangulation approximation [23{25]. However, Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) Scientific Col- space-based GW detector can measure GWs for months laboration and the Virgo Collaboration [1,2], there have to years, the periodic Doppler shift due to the detector been tens of confirmed GW detections by ground-based motion in space results in amplitude and phase modula- GW observatories [1{13]. The ground-based GW ob- tions of the detected GW signals which encode informa- servatories can measure GWs within frequency range tion about the detector position and the angular position 10 103 Hz only, and are difficult to explore lower fre- of the source. Therefore, a single space-based GW detec- quency− band where a wealth of astrophysical signals re- tor is able to locate the source position. side. The proposed space-based observatories including Like LISA, Taiji is composed of a triangle of three LISA [14, 15], TianQin [16] and Taiji [17] are expected spacecrafts with a larger separation distance in a helio- to detect GWs in the low-frequency regime. centric orbit ahead instead of behind the Earth by about Accurately localizing GW sources is important, since 20◦ [17]. The similarities in configurations construe that the source position is correlated with the physical prop- similar to LISA, Taiji's angular resolution depends simi- erties of the binary star system which are necessary larly on the type of signal and on how much other infor- to understand the formation and evolution of the bi- mation must be extracted. Similarities and complements nary. Moreover, the accurate GW source localization between LISA and Taiji imply that LISA-Taiji network may provide important information about the environ- can effectively help to accurately localize GW sources, ments where such relativistic objects reside. In particu- since the angular resolution measurements for the net- lar, the accurate knowledge of the GW source position work depend on the configuration angle and separation is essential for the follow-up observations of counterparts of the two constellations [26, 27]. The network was es- and the statistical identification of the host galaxy if no timated to improve the angular resolution over 10 times arXiv:2009.03476v3 [astro-ph.IM] 4 May 2021 counterpart is found, so that we can use GWs as stan- than each individual LISA or Taiji detector [28]. dard sirens to explore the universe's expansion history Unlike LISA and Taiji, TianQin has a geocentric or- and understand the problem of Hubble tension [18{22]. bit configuration with three spacecrafts orbiting the One ground-based GW observatory cannot localize Earth and further rotating around the Sun together GW source, since it is sensible to GW signals from nearly with the Earth. The normal vector of TianQin's de- tector plane points to the source RX J0806.3+1527 at ◦ ◦ (θtq = 4:7 ; φtq = 120:5 ). TianQin is slightly more − ∗ chao [email protected] sensitive to GWs with higher frequency than LISA. The y Corresponding author. [email protected] precision of the parameter estimation and the sky lo- z [email protected] calization of equal mass supermassive black hole binary x 5 7 wang [email protected] systems with masses in the range 10 10 M for Tian- { [email protected] Qin was discussed in [29]. It was further− argued that the 2 LISA-TianQin network can improve the sky localization The organization of the paper is as follows. In Sec. II, of Galactic double white dwarf binaries up to 3 orders of we review the FIM method of signal analysis. In Sec. III, magnitude [30], if compared with single TianQin obser- we devise several fiducial detectors to discuss the effects vation. of different factors on the sky localization. The orbits For TianQin, considering its special configuration and for these detectors are presented in the Appendix. Then design, it is important to fully study its angular resolu- in Sec. IV we use these results to analyze the angular tion and uncover its dependencies. It is needed to be resolutions of TianQin, compare the result with LISA clarified in TianQin project how information about the and finally explore the combined LISA-TianQin network. source position encodes in Doppler shift, the translational We present our conclusions and discussions in the last motion of the detector relative to the source, detector's section. changing orientation, the rotation period of spacecrafts II. SIGNAL ANALYSIS and the arm length of the detector. Different from LISA, whose amplitude modulation improves the sky localiza- For a GW signal tion accuracy below 1 mHz [31, 32], the detector plane of TianQin points to a fixed direction so there is no am- X A hij(t) = eijhA(t); (1) plitude modulation in TianQin which is more sensitive A to signals above several mHz. It is interesting to ex- plore how much the sky localization accuracy of TianQin the output in the detector α is is affected in the absence of the amplitude modulation. X A On the other hand, the Doppler modulation becomes Hα(t) = Fα hA(t) +n ^α(t); (2) stronger as the frequency of GWs increases and it has the A equatorial pattern [31{33], it is natural to ask how the where A = +; stands for the plus and cross polariza- Doppler modulation affects the sky localization accuracy A × of TianQin and how to compare it with other space-based tions, eij is the polarization tensor,n ^α(t) is the detector A detectors at frequencies above 10 mHz. Moreover, there noise, the angular response function Fα for the polariza- are other questions to be answered, for example: How tion A is the equatorial pattern affects the sky localization accu- A X ij A racy? Is it possible that TianQin has better sky localiza- Fα = Dα eij; (3) tion accuracy than LISA and Taiji even if it has shorter i;j arm length? Neglecting differences in orbit configura- Dij tions, if we explore the potential TianQin-LISA network, and α is the detector tensor. In GR, there are two po- can it perform better in source localization than Taiji- larizations. For alternative theory of gravity, there may LISA network? We will carefully discuss these issues and exist up to six polarizations [34{42]. In this paper, we present sky maps of angular resolutions for monochro- consider GR only. For equal arm space-based interfero- matic sources to identify the sensitive regions of differ- metric detector with a single round trip light travel, the ent detectors. These discussions are helpful to improve detector tensor for a monochromatic GW with the fre- f ! the detector design. Throughout the work, we will em- quency propagating along the direction ^ is ploy the Fisher information matrix approximation (FIM) ij 1 i j i j to give robust estimation of the sky localization of the Dα = [^uαu^αT (f; u^α !^) v^αv^αT (f; v^α !^)]; (4) 2 · − · source with a high signal to noise ratio (SNR) where the inverse of FIM gives the covariance matrix of the param- whereu ^α andv ^α are the unit vectors along the arms of eters. the detector α, T (f; u^α !^) is [43, 44] · 1 f f f f T (f; u^α w^) = sinc[ (1 u^α !^)] exp[ i (3 +u ^α !^)] + sinc[ (1 +u ^α !^)] exp[ i (1 +u ^α !^)] ; (5) · 2f 2f ∗ − · − 2f ∗ · 2f ∗ · − 2f ∗ · g ∗ sinc(x) = sin x=x, f = c=(2πL) is the transfer frequency where the power spectral density Sn,α(f) satisfies ∗ 1 0 of the detector, c is the speed of light and L is the arm n~α(f)~n (f) = δ(f f )Sn,α. For space-based interfer- h α i 2 − length of the detector. With the signal Hα, we define ometers, the noise power spectral density Sn(f) is [16, 45] SNR as S S −4 2 X x 4 a 10 Hz ρ = (H H ) Sn(f) = + (1 + ): (7) α α L2 (2πf)4L2 f α j 1 (6) X Z 1 = 4 df H (f)H∗(f); For TianQin, the acceleration noise is pSa = S f α α −15 −2 1=2 α 0 n,α( ) 10 m s =Hz , the displacement noise is pSx = 3 using the Parseval's theorem [31, 46], the FIM becomes 24 TianQin 10− LISA X @Hα @Hα 27 Γij = 10− @θ @θ α i j ) 1 10 30 1 − − Z X 4 ∗ = @iHα(f)@jHα(f)df (10) (Hz 33 S f 10− n,α( 0) 0 n α S Z 1 10 36 X 2 ∗ − = @iHα(t)@jHα(t)dt ; Sn,α(f0) −∞ 39 α 10− where θi is the ith parameter and @iHα = @Hα=@θi.