DOCUMENT 5.4.8C 8C Results of Step 1 Appraisal of Change to Setting National Grid (Richborough Connection Project) Order Regulation (5)(2)(a) of the Infrastructure Planning (Applications: Prescribed Forms and Procedure) Regulations 2009 and TEN-E Regulation EU347/2013 Application Ref: EN020017 January 2016 Page intentionally blank Richborough Connection Project Volume 5 5.4 Environmental Statement Appendices 5.4.8C Results of Step 1 Appraisal of Change to Setting National Grid National Grid House Warwick Technology Park Gallows Hill Warwick CV34 6DA Final January 2016 Page intentionally blank Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C Document Control Document Properties Organisation Amec Foster Wheeler Author John Mabbitt Approved by Sean Steadman Title Appendix 8C Results of Step 1 Appraisal of Change to Setting Document Reference 5.4.8C Version History Date Version Status Description/Changes 04/01/16 1 Final 1st Issue Final January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C Page intentionally blank Final January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C Table of Contents 1. INTRODUCTION 1 2. STEP 1 ASSESSMENT FOR SECTION A 3 3. STEP 1 ASSESSMENT FOR SECTION B 97 4. STEP 1 ASSESSMENT FOR SECTION C 123 5. STEP 1 ASSESSMENT FOR SECTION D 125 Final i January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C Page intentionally blank Final ii January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C 1. INTRODUCTION This appendix presents the results of the appraisal of heritage assets potentially subject to loss of significance as a result of change to setting caused by the proposed development discussed in Section 8.7 of Volume 5, Document 5.2. This appraisal considered all designated heritage assets within the study area defined at the Connection Options Report (COR) stage (see Chapter 2 of Volume 5, Document 5.2). Where the potential for harm to significance to arise as a result of change to setting, the relevant heritage asset(s) has been considered at Section 8.10 of Volume 5, Document 5.2. For ease of reference, the results are presented by route sections A to D, and assets and asset groups considered in detail in the ES are presented first. The nature of change to settings means that the results of this appraisal are a matter of professional judgement, although in this case, the proposed scope of assessment set out at scoping has been modified in the light of consultation responses from the relevant prescribed consultees and the public. These consultations are detailed at Section 8.4 of Volume 5, Document 5.2. Final 1 January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C Page intentionally blank Final 2 January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C 2. STEP 1 ASSESSMENT FOR SECTION A Table 8C.2.1 Section A List Entry Name Potential Rationale/ES Assessment for harm Designated Heritage Assets in Canterbury World Heritage Site and Buffer Zone and Dane John Gardens Designated Park and Garden Canterbury World Heritage Yes Negligible - Proposed overhead line would be visible as a distant background element in views from the Site and Buffer Zone tower of Christchurch cathedral and would be present in some minor and distant views of the cathedral which are heavily filtered by intervening development and planting. Canterbury City Conservation No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Area Negligible – proposed overhead line would be visible only in very distant and heavily filtered views from Dane John Gardens Yes single point in the designated gardens. 1003780 Dane John Mound and Roman Negligible – proposed overhead line would be visible only in very distant and heavily filtered views from and Medieval remains in Dane Yes single point in the designated gardens. John Garden 1005163 St George's Church tower No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1005164 The Guildhall No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1005160 Roman site, Butchery Lane No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1003554 Canterbury city walls No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Tower of St Magdalene's 1005189 No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Church Final 3 January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C List Entry Name Potential Rationale/ES Assessment for harm 1016844 St Augustine's Abbey No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Christchurch Priory and 1004195 No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Archbishop's Palace 1065775 1, St Radigund Street No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085018 3-9, Guildhall Street No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085019 17 and 18, Guildhall Street No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085040 9-11, Church Street No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085041 13-15, Church Street No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085042 16 and 17 Church Street (see No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. details for further address information) 1085055 The Little House No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085056 2a, Duck Lane No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085062 Cloister to Christchurch No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Cathedral 1085063 Chapter House to No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Christchurch Cathedral 1085064 Dark Entry No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Final 4 January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C List Entry Name Potential Rationale/ES Assessment for harm 1085065 Prior's Chapel No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085066 The Archbishop's Palace or No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. The Old Palace 1085067 Sundial in front garden of No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Archbishop's Palace 1085068 Wall to left of Archbishop's No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Palace 1085069 2, The Cathedral Precincts No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085070 3, The Cathedral Precincts No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085071 5, The Cathedral Precincts No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085072 6 and 7, The Cathedral No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Precincts 1085073 11a and 11b, The Cathedral No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Precincts (see details for further address information) 1085074 Wall on South and North side No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. of Kent Memorial Garden 1085075 Wall on South and East side of No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. no 16 (Meister Omers) and forming the West wall of the Memorial Gardens 1085076 17, The Cathedral Precincts No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Final 5 January 2016 Richborough Connection Project – Volume 5, Document 5.4, Appendix 8C List Entry Name Potential Rationale/ES Assessment for harm 1085077 Wall between no 18 and the No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Cathedral 1085078 22-26, The Cathedral No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Precincts 1085079 Pilgrims entry or Pentise No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. attached to number 29 1085080 Wall and Gatepiers between No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. nos 28 and 29 1085081 Library of King's School No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. 1085082 Remains of Cellarer's Hall in No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings and planting. Archbishop's Palace Garden 1085083 1, Butchery Lane No Visibility to proposed overhead line would be precluded by intervening buildings