ANSWER TO JOB: THE COLLECTED WORKS OF C. G. JUNG VOLUME 11 PDF, EPUB, EBOOK C. G. Jung,R. F. C. Hull,Sonu Shamdasani | 152 pages | 14 Nov 2010 | Princeton University Press | 9780691150475 | English | New Jersey, United States Answer to Job: The Collected Works of C. G. Jung Volume 11 PDF Book The Book of Job coincides, Jung further argues, with a body of Hebrew wisdom writing that describes a feminine force called Sophia, who supplements the excessively masculine deity with a feminine counterpart. At a brief pages, you can finish it in less than a week. Carl Gustav Jung. Irrespective of the mechanics of his writing, the suggestions and indeed proposals presented here are profound, deeply unsettling to my Catholic education, and fascinating to consider. Close X. In the crucifixion, we find the "answer to Job" of Jung's title: "God experiences what it is to be a mortal man and drinks to the dregs what he made his faithful servant Job suffer. What event made God bless Job after elongated suffering and was the blessing intended to erase the pain already taken place? Large heapings of apocrypha serve to further muddy things, wherein Jung seems convinced his reader or followers will accept Sophia as God's queen, Lilith as Seth's mother, the Virgin Mary as an incarnation of Sophia, and many, many other staples of New Age, Kabbalah-drenched Christianity. Pictures of Nothing Kirk Varnedoe. Jung also concludes with some critique on Protestantism, and offers his commentary on Catholicism's "Assumption" Jung also drops in some beautiful little prose diamonds here and there. Product details Format Paperback pages Dimensions x x He conjectures that the John of the epistles was compelled by his station to live an extremely selfless and loving life, as he felt to be his calling as a Christian, but that a lack of engagement with his own darker aspects coupled with a general lack of self-awareness relegated the negative impulses within him to the realm of the unconscious, where they burst forth into consciousness as a dark vision of the apocalypse. Show less Show more Advertising ON OFF We use cookies to serve you certain types of ads , including ads relevant to your interests on Book Depository and to work with approved third parties in the process of delivering ad content, including ads relevant to your interests, to measure the effectiveness of their ads, and to perform services on behalf of Book Depository. For Kierkegaard, several Rashoman-like retellings of the story eventually yield to furious, brooding analysis in the face of the absurdity: A father willing to kill his son for his faith. Consider changing the search query. His answer to the ultimate question of suffering is worthy of anyone's time, believer or not. What exists in the pleroma as an eternal process appears in time as an aperiodic sequence, that is to say, it is repeated many times in an irregular pattern. I thought that Rogers was tangential in his writing but this is even worse. The evil part of the psyche remains un-integrated, which means that it will continue to express itself in destructively unconscious ways. Psychology of the Unconscious C. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. I don't know, whiskey? Apr 05, Jim rated it really liked it. On the other hand, there is the New Agey side of Jung. Something of the kind must have happened to Yahweh. Free Shipping in the US on over 5 million books in stock. He typifies God as wrathful, unreliable, injust, and cruel. In contrast to the story of Eden, Jung does not feel that people in the book of Job are guilty of an "original sin" and that, instead, good and evil exist on a higher plane of duality, that mankind has innocently inherited. Carl Jung doesn't concern himself with the truth or non-truth of biblical events and nor does he see that as important. What if Jung is a bit of a chivalric sexist and overrates the beneficence of what he calls "the feminine"? It was when God finally discovered this, according to Jung, that he began to move toward humanity in an effort that would culminate in the incarnation. Enlarge cover. Return to Book Page. Testament of Job. In the Book of Job, Yahweh is easily manipulated by Satan, his shadow side, into testing Job's faith with an outpouring of persecution and torment. I'm surprised that Jung didn't believe the biblical text that it was Lucifer who brought suffering onto Job. Nevertheless, Jung presents a fascinating notion of a many-sided god who seeks to compensate for his Old Testament extremes by continuously incarnating himself in Jesus, the Holy Ghost, and in Jung's mind, many other characters, including, if you read long enough, you and I. Help support the institute by donating or becoming a Friend of the Institute today! Fortunately, with that bible, he's got plenty of opportunity to write great footnotes. Our idea of God is, in a sense, our self-concept. I kept waiting for Jung to offer me a rope to pull me out of the mire that was his discursive monologue, yet on and on he continued muttering to himself. I say that I have not totally understood the main thesis, and for that, I shall read it again. Jung considers the Book of Job a landmark development in the "divine drama," for the first time contemplating criticism of God Gotteskritik. Answer to Job: The Collected Works of C. G. Jung Volume 11 Writer Cain and Abel, Jacob and Esau, correspond to this prototype, and so, in all ages and in all parts of the world, does the motif of the hostile brothers, which in innumerable modern variants still causes dissension in families and keeps the psychotherapist busy. Note however that the end of a story is not the end of its lifeworld, but simply the point at which its author reached satisfaction with regards to tying threads he considered of particular import. Title Answer to Job: From Vol. This rejection of Freud's biological determinism is probably what Deleuze and Guattari had in mind when they observed in passing in A Thousand Plateaus that "Jung is in any event profounder than Freud. The entire point of the Christian doctrine is that the will and mind of God stands aside from human comprehension. Learn about new offers and get more deals by joining our newsletter. This could not go unnoticed by man, consciously or not. Every word, paragraph, and chapter opens a space for events to unfold by creating a precedent for future developments. Jung outlines a process of psychological evolution the biblical god progressed through starting with illustrating the suppressed shadow side of the manic old testament deity. Jung, however, has chosen a parable with considerably fewer hand-holds. Though they loved him, the ancient Hebrews were genuinely afraid of this deity. Donations can be made online or by check and are tax-deductible. Now, under fire, Job's faithfulness is tried and proven again. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it. It is clear that Jung reads Job through at least two paradigms, that of Christianity and that of his analytical psychology. Nevertheless, Jung presents a fascinating notion of a many-sided god who seeks to compensate for his Old Testament extremes by continuously incarnating himself in Jesus, the Holy Ghost, and in Jung's mind, many other characters, including, if you read long enough, you and I. Answer to Job. Feb 21, Jake rated it really liked it. Satan was banished from heaven and God incarnated as purely good, through a virgin birth , into the sinless redeemer Jesus Christ. The turning point for this deity's evolution seemed to be his unjust treatment of the faithful servant Job. There is a major contradiction within God, a shadow side to God. Testament of Job. Scripture has it that Lucifer brought misfortune to goad Job into rebellion. I am not a theologian or even a psychoanalyst he was the latter, but his deep knowledge about the Bible and archetypes in other religions and bold interpretations of the passages deserve him both titles , but I feel this book completes my quest for many doubt-causing answers that I was left with after havin A book that shattered my faith, while at the same time soothed my psyche. Jung has never pursued the "psychology of religion" apart from general psychology. These cookies are necessary to provide our site and services and therefore cannot be disabled. Fortunately, with that bible, he's got plenty of opportunity to write great footnotes. Analyst Training Program Internship Program. Original Title. What event made God bless Job after elongated suffering and was the blessing intended to erase the pain already taken place? Answer to Job: The Collected Works of C. G. Jung Volume 11 Reviews Jung claims that God once was in a state of unconsciousness and was prodded by Lucifer, who was inclined to make use of God's omniscience, into acting unfairly with Job. Testament of Job. We may be in less risk of thermonuclear annihilation than in Jung's time, but it's hard to deny that American, and perhaps international politics, is in a death spiral of self-devouring self-righteousness and hypertrophic "identities" that accuse all the evils of the world on others. How could a "good" god subject an honest man to such a troubled life? Quotes from Answer to Job. His chapter-by- chapter progression from historical regurgitation marching further into apocalyptical projection felt clunky at moments, yet that may also be the result of me biting into it one chapter at a time.