Noname manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) Solar structure and evolution Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard Received: date / Accepted: date Abstract The Sun provides a critical benchmark for the general study of stellar structure and evolution. Also, knowledge about the internal properties of the Sun is important for the understanding of solar atmospheric phenom- ena, including the solar magnetic cycle. Here I provide a brief overview of the theory of stellar structure and evolution, including the physical processes and parameters that are involved. This is followed by a discussion of solar evolu- tion, extending from the birth to the latest stages. As a background for the interpretation of observations related to the solar interior I provide a rather extensive analysis of the sensitivity of solar models to the assumptions under- lying their calculation. I then discuss the detailed information about the solar interior that has become available through helioseismic investigations and the detection of solar neutrinos, with further constraints provided by the observed abundances of the lightest elements. Revisions in the determination of the so- lar surface abundances have led to increased discrepancies, discussed in some detail, between the observational inferences and solar models. I finally briefly address the relation of the Sun to other similar stars and the prospects for asteroseismic investigations of stellar structure and evolution. Keywords Stellar structure – Stellar evolution – Solar evolution – Solar interior J. Christensen-Dalsgaard Stellar Astrophysics Centre, and Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University, arXiv:2007.06488v2 [astro-ph.SR] 14 May 2021 Ny Munkegade, 8000 Aarhus C, Denmark E-mail: [email protected] Orchid: 0000-0001-5137-0966 2 Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard Dedicated to the memory of the late Professor Michael J. Thompson, who tragically passed away in October 2018. His great understanding of the Sun and the helioseismic techniques used to probe its properties, shared through our collaboration over two decades, is an essential basis for the work presented here. Contents 1 Introduction...................................... 3 2 ModellingtheSun ................................... 7 2.1 Basicsofstellarmodelling . ..... 7 2.2 BasicpropertiesoftheSun . ... 10 2.3 Microphysics .................................... 13 2.3.1 Equationofstate.............................. 14 2.3.2 Opacity ................................... 21 2.3.3 Energygeneration . .. .. .. 24 2.3.4 Diffusionandsettling . 29 2.4 Thenear-surfacelayer . ... 33 2.5 Treatmentofconvection . ... 36 2.6 Calibrationofsolarmodels . .... 43 3 TheevolutionoftheSun.............................. ... 45 3.1 Pre-main-sequenceevolution. ...... 46 3.2 Main-sequenceevolution . .... 50 3.3 Lateevolutionarystages . .... 54 4 ‘Standard’solarmodels ............................. .... 55 4.1 ModelS....................................... 56 4.2 Sensitivity of the model to changes in physics or parameters.......... 57 5 Testsofsolarmodels................................ ... 78 5.1 Helioseismictestsofsolarstructure . ......... 79 5.1.1 Propertiesofsolaroscillations. ...... 79 5.1.2 Investigations of the structure and physics of the solar interior . 84 5.1.3 Specific aspects of the solar interior . ..... 95 5.1.4 Investigations of solar internal rotation . ......... 98 5.1.5 Temporal changes of the solar interior . ..... 102 5.2 Solarneutrinoresults. .... 104 5.2.1 Problemswithsolarmodels? . 106 5.2.2 Revision of neutrino physics: neutrino oscillations ............ 111 5.3 Abundances of light elements . .... 116 6 Thesolarabundanceproblem . .... 118 6.1 Revisions to the inferred solar composition . .......... 119 6.2 Effects on solar models of the revised composition . ......... 122 6.3 Are the revised abundances correct? . ...... 130 6.4 Possible corrections to the solar models . ........ 132 6.5 Effectsofaccretionormassloss. ..... 138 7 Towardsthedistantstars . .. .. .. .... 142 7.1 Solartwins ..................................... 147 7.2 Asteroseismology ................................ 149 8 Concludingremarks ................................. 153 A Numericalaccuracy ................................. 155 Solar structure and evolution 3 1 Introduction The study of stellar properties and stellar evolution plays a central role in astrophysics. Observations of stars determine the chemical composition, age and distance of the varied components of the Milky Way Galaxy and hence form the basis for studies of Galactic evolution. Stellar abundances and their evolution, particularly for lithium, are also a crucial component of the study of Big-Bang nucleosynthesis. Understanding of the pulsational properties of Cepheids underlies their use as distance indicators and hence the basic unit of distance measurement in the Universe. The detailed properties of supernovae are important for the study of element nucleosynthesis, while supernovae of Type Ia are crucial for determining the large-scale properties of the Universe, including the evidence for a dominant component of ‘dark energy’. In all these cases an accurate understanding, and modelling, of stellar interiors and their evolution is required for reliable results. Modelling stellar evolution depends on a detailed treatment of the physics of stellar interiors. Insofar as the star is regarded as nearly spherically sym- metric the basic equations of stellar equilibrium are relatively straightforward (see Sect. 2.1), but the detailed properties, often referred to as microphysics, of matter in a star are extremely complex, yet of major importance to the modelling. This includes the thermodynamical properties, as specified by the equation of state, the interaction between matter and radiation described by the opacity, the nuclear processes generating energy and causing the evolution of the element composition, and the diffusion and settling of elements. Equally important are potential hydrodynamical processes caused by various instabil- ities which may contribute to the transport of energy and material, hence causing partial or full mixing of given regions in a star. It is obvious that sufficiently detailed observations of stellar properties, and comparison with models, may provide a possibility for testing the physics used in the model calculation, hence allowing investigations of physical processes far beyond the conditions that can be reached in a terrestrial laboratory. Amongst stars, the Sun obviously plays a very special role, both to our daily life and as an astrophysical object. Its proximity allows very precise, and probably accurate, determination of its global parameters, as well as extremely detailed investigations of phenomena in the solar atmosphere, compared with other stars. Indications are that the Sun is typical for its mass and age (e.g., Gustafsson 1998; Robles et al. 2008; Strugarek et al. 2017),1 although a de- tailed analysis by Reinhold et al. (2020) of photometric variability observed with the Kepler spacecraft indicated that solar magnetic activity may be rather low compared with solar-like stars. Also, conditions in the solar interior are relatively benign, providing some hope that reasonably realistic modelling can be carried out. Thus it is an ideal case for investigations of stellar structure 1 However, subtle and potentially very interesting differences have been found between the solar surface composition and the composition of similar stars; see Sect. 7.1, in particular Fig. 64. 4 Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard and evolution. Interestingly, there still remain very significant discrepancies between the observed properties of the Sun and solar models. A good overview of the development of the study of stellar structure and evolution was provided by Tassoul and Tassoul (2004). Also, Shaviv (2009) gave an excellent wide-ranging and deep description of the evolution of the field, including an extensive discussion of the relevant observational basis, the underlying physics, and related aspects, such as the early tension between es- timates of the age of the Earth and the Sun. The application of physics to the understanding of stellar interiors developed from the middle of the 19th century. The first derivation of stellar models based on mechanical equilibrium was carried out by Lane (1870).2 Further development of the theory of such models, summarized in an extensive bibliographical note by Chandrasekhar (1939), was carried out by Ritter, Lord Kelvin and others, culminating in the monograph by Emden (1907). These models were based on the condition of hydrostatic equilibrium, combined with a simplified, so-called polytropic, equation of state. Major advances came with the application of the theory of radiative transfer, and quantum-mechanical calculations of atomic absorption coefficients, to the energy transport in stellar interiors. This allowed theo- retical estimates to be made of the relation between the stellar mass and luminosity, even without detailed knowledge about the stellar energy sources (for a masterly discussion of these developments, see Eddington 1926). Fur- ther investigations of the properties of stellar opacity led to the conclusion that stellar matter was dominated by hydrogen (Str¨omgren 1932, 1933), in agreement with the detailed determination of the composition of the solar photosphere by Russell (1929), as well as with the analysis of a broad range of stars by Uns¨old (1931). Although stellar modelling had proceeded up to this point without any definite information about the sources