the national bureau of asian research nbr special report #55 | february 2016 mapping pakistan’s internal dynamics Implications for State Stability and Regional Security By Mumtaz Ahmad, Dipankar Banerjee, Aryaman Bhatnagar, C. Christine Fair, Vanda Felbab-Brown, Husain Haqqani, Mahin Karim, Tariq A. Karim, Vivek Katju, C. Raja Mohan, Matthew J. Nelson, and Jayadeva Ranade cover 2 NBR Board of Directors Charles W. Brady George Davidson Tom Robertson (Chairman) Vice Chairman, M&A, Asia-Pacifc Vice President and Chairman Emeritus HSBC Holdings plc Deputy General Counsel Invesco LLC Microsof Corporation Norman D. Dicks John V. Rindlaub Senior Policy Advisor Gordon Smith (Vice Chairman and Treasurer) Van Ness Feldman LLP Chief Operating Ofcer President, Asia Pacifc Exact Staf, Inc. Wells Fargo Richard J. Ellings President Scott Stoll George F. Russell Jr. NBR Partner (Chairman Emeritus) Ernst & Young LLP Chairman Emeritus R. Michael Gadbaw Russell Investments Distinguished Visiting Fellow David K.Y. Tang Institute of International Economic Law, Managing Partner, Asia Karan Bhatia Georgetown University Law Center K&L Gates LLP Vice President & Senior Counsel International Law & Policy Ryo Kubota Tadataka Yamada General Electric Chairman, President, and CEO Venture Partner Acucela Inc. Frazier Healthcare Dennis Blair Chairman Melody Meyer President Sasakawa Peace Foundation USA Honorary Directors U.S. Navy (Ret.) Chevron Asia Pacifc Exploration and Production Company Maria Livanos Cattaui Chevron Corporation Lawrence W. Clarkson Secretary General (Ret.) Senior Vice President International Chamber of Commerce Pamela S. Passman Te Boeing Company (Ret.) President and CEO William M. Colton Center for Responsible Enterprise Tomas E. Fisher Vice President and Trade (CREATe) Senior Vice President Corporate Strategic Planning Unocal Corporation (Ret.) Exxon Mobil Corporation C. Michael Petters President and Chief Executive Ofcer Joachim Kempin Timothy L. Conlon Huntington Ingalls Industries, Inc. Senior Vice President President and COO Microsof Corporation (Ret.) Viasystems Group, Inc. (Ret.) Kenneth B. Pyle Professor (emeritus); Founding President Clark S. Kinlin University of Washington; NBR President and Chief Executive Ofcer Corning Cable Systems Corning Incorporated NBR Counselors Norman D. Dicks Slade Gorton Joseph Lieberman U.S. House of Representatives (Ret.) U.S. Senate (Ret.) U.S. Senate (Ret.) Tomas B. Fargo U.S. Navy (Ret.) NBR Board of Advisors Michael Armacost Carla A. Hills Sam Nunn Stanford University Hills & Company Nuclear Treat Initiative Nicholas Eberstadt Robert D. Hormats Joseph S. Nye Jr. American Enterprise Institute Kissinger Associates, Inc. Harvard University Karl Eikenberry David Lampton Stanley Palmer Stanford University Johns Hopkins University Marvin & Palmer Associates, Inc. Donald Emmerson Nicholas Lardy Dwight Perkins Stanford University Peterson Institute for International Harvard University Economics Aaron Friedberg Tomas Pickering Princeton University Richard Lawless Te Boeing Company (Ret.) New Magellan Ventures Robert Gilpin Clarine Nardi Riddle Princeton University Chae-Jin Lee Kasowitz, Benson, Torres Claremont McKenna College & Friedman LLP Lee Hamilton Indiana University Kenneth Lieberthal Stanley Roth Brookings Institution Te Boeing Company Stephen Hanson College of William and Mary William J. Lynn, III Sheldon Simon DRS Technologies, Inc. Arizona State University Harry Harding University of Virginia Rajan Menon Ashley Tellis City College of New York Carnegie Endowment for Donald Hellmann International Peace University of Washington Mary Minnick Lion Capital John White Robert J. Herbold Harvard University Te Herbold Group, LLC nbr special report #55 | february 2016 mapping pakistan’s internal dynamics Implications for State Stability and Regional Security Mumtaz Ahmad, Dipankar Banerjee, Aryaman Bhatnagar, C. Christine Fair, Vanda Felbab-Brown, Husain Haqqani, Mahin Karim, Tariq A. Karim, Vivek Katju, C. Raja Mohan, Matthew J. Nelson, and Jayadeva Ranade the national bureau of asian research Te NBR Special Report provides access to current research on special topics conducted by the world’s leading experts in Asian afairs. Te views expressed in these reports are those of the authors and do not necessarily refect the views of other NBR research associates or institutions that support NBR. Te National Bureau of Asian Research is a nonproft, nonpartisan research institution dedicated to informing and strengthening policy. NBR conducts advanced independent research on strategic, political, economic, globalization, health, and energy issues afecting U.S. relations with Asia. Drawing upon an extensive network of the world’s leading specialists and leveraging the latest technology, NBR bridges the academic, business, and policy arenas. Te institution disseminates its research through briefngs, publications, conferences, Congressional testimony, and email forums, and by collaborating with leading institutions worldwide. NBR also provides exceptional internship opportunities to graduate and undergraduate students for the purpose of attracting and training the next generation of Asia specialists. NBR was started in 1989 with a major grant from the Henry M. Jackson Foundation. Funding for NBR’s research and publications comes from foundations, corporations, individuals, the U.S. government, and from NBR itself. NBR does not conduct proprietary or classifed research. Te organization undertakes contract work for government and private-sector organizations only when NBR can maintain the right to publish fndings from such work. To download issues of the NBR Special Report, please visit the NBR website http://www.nbr.org. Tis report may be reproduced for personal use. Otherwise, the NBR Special Report may not be reproduced in full without the written permission of NBR. When information from NBR publications is cited or quoted, please cite the author and Te National Bureau of Asian Research. Tis is the ffy-ffh NBR Special Report. NBR is a tax-exempt, nonproft corporation under I.R.C. Sec. 501(c)(3), qualifed to receive tax-exempt contributions. © 2016 by Te National Bureau of Asian Research. Front cover image: “Keeping watch at Baine Baba Ziarat” by Al Jazeera English, used under a creative commons attribution-share-alike 2.0 license. For further information about NBR, contact: Te National Bureau of Asian Research 1414 NE 42nd Street, Suite 300 Seattle, Washington 98105 206-632-7370 Phone 206-632-7487 Fax [email protected] E-mail http://www.nbr.org nbr special report #55 | february 2016 mapping pakistan’s internal dynamics Implications for State Stability and Regional Security TABLE OF CONTENTS Mapping Pakistan’s Internal Dynamics: Implications for State Stability and 1 Regional Security Mahin Karim Mapping Pakistan’s Internal Dynamics Mapping Pakistan’s Political Superstructure 11 Mumtaz Ahmad Pakistan’s Internal Security Environment 33 C. Christine Fair Informal Agencies of Infuence in Pakistan: 59 Te Interdependence of Social, Religious, and Political Trends Matthew J. Nelson Assessing Pakistan’s Geopolitical Environment India-Pakistan Relations and Regional Stability 79 Aryaman Bhatnagar and C. Raja Mohan Pakistan’s Relations with China and Implications for Regional Stability 99 Jayadeva Ranade Pakistan’s Relations with Iran and the Implications for Regional Stability 111 Tariq A. Karim Pakistan’s Relations with Afghanistan and Implications for Regional Politics 123 Vanda Felbab-Brown Pakistan and the Treat of Global Jihadism: Implications for Regional Security 141 Husain Haqqani Pakistan’s Nuclear Proliferation and Its Impact on International and 155 Regional Security Dipankar Banerjee Conclusion Pakistan’s Complex Security Dynamics: Conclusions and Outlook 167 Vivek Katju the national bureau of asian research nbr special report #55 | february 2016 Mapping Pakistan’s Internal Dynamics: Implications for State Stability and Regional Security Mahin Karim MAHIN KARIM is Senior Associate for Political and Security Afairs at the National Bureau of Asian Research (NBR) and Research Director for the project “Mapping Pakistan’s Internal Dynamics: Implications for State Stability and Regional Security.” She can be reached at <[email protected]>. 1 his NBR Special Report is the culmination of a two-year research project by the National Bureau of Asian Research (NBR) that sought to analyze Pakistan’s internal security landscape and external geopolitical environment. Funded with generous support from the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, the project convened an international teamT of experts to author the essays presented in this report. Tese essays were informed by a series of workshops and briefngs held in New Delhi and Washington, D.C., in partnership with the Observer Research Foundation. Project Rationale Pakistan today represents one of the world’s most signifcant and vexing geopolitical challenges. Its geographic position at the nexus of the Middle East and Asia, its nuclear stockpile, and the strength and determination of domestic extremist groups make Pakistan’s future course a top geopolitical priority for the United States. Looming instability inside Pakistan profoundly threatens U.S. interests in regional stability, nonproliferation of weapons of mass destruction, and the eradication of extremism. An unstable Pakistan—a state that is riven by internal factionalization and radicalization, possesses a nuclear stockpile that may not be secure from terrorist groups, and fnds its very existence as