Draft version July 3, 2018 Preprint typeset using LATEX style AASTeX6 v. 1.0 SETI WITH GAIA: THE OBSERVATIONAL SIGNATURES OF NEARLY COMPLETE DYSON SPHERES Erik Zackrisson1∗, Andreas J. Korn1, Ansgar Wehrhahn1 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Uppsala University, Box 515, SE-751 20 Uppsala, Sweden Johannes Reiter2 University of Heidelberg, Germany ∗ E-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT A star enshrouded in a Dyson sphere with high covering fraction may manifest itself as an optically subluminous object with a spectrophotometric distance estimate significantly in excess of its parallax distance. Using this criterion, the Gaia mission will in coming years allow for Dyson-sphere searches that are complementary to searches based on waste-heat signatures at infrared wavelengths. A limited search of this type is also possible at the current time, by combining Gaia parallax distances with spectrophotometric distances from ground-based surveys. Here, we discuss the merits and shortcom- ings of this technique and carry out a limited search for Dyson-sphere candidates in the sample of stars common to Gaia Data Release 1 and RAVE Data Release 5. We find that a small fraction of stars indeed display distance discrepancies of the type expected for nearly complete Dyson spheres. To shed light on the properties of objects in this outlier population, we present follow-up high-resolution spectroscopy for one of these stars, the late F-type dwarf TYC 6111-1162-1. The spectrophotometric distance of this object is about twice that derived from its Gaia parallax, and there is no detectable infrared excess. While our analysis largely confirms the stellar parameters and the spectrophotometric distance inferred by RAVE, a plausible explanation for the discrepant distance estimates of this object is that the astrometric solution has been compromised by an unseen binary companion, possibly a rather massive white dwarf (≈ 1 M⊙). This scenario can be further tested through upcoming Gaia data releases. Keywords: Extraterrestrial intelligence – stars: distances – methods: data analysis – methods: spec- troscopy – dust, extinction – stars: individual (TYC 6111-1162-1) 1. INTRODUCTION posed uses for the collected energy include supercom- By constructing a Dyson sphere (Dyson 1960) out of puting, vessel propulsion, the powering of artificial habi- material from dismantled planets, extremely advanced tats and long-range communication (e.g. Suffern 1977; Sandberg 1999; Arnold 2005; Armstrong & Sandberg arXiv:1804.08351v2 [astro-ph.SR] 1 Jul 2018 civilizations could in principle tap into a significant frac- tion of the radiation power of their host star, thereby 2013). climbing the Kardashev scale towards type II status In the field of Searching for Extraterrestrial Intel- (Kardashev 1964). The Dyson sphere is typically not en- ligence (SETI), a number of searches for individual visioned as a solid shell, but rather as a dense, spherical Dyson spheres have already been carried out, with- swarm or shroud of absorbing satellites, with each satel- out unraveling any compelling evidence for such struc- lite absorbing a small fraction of the stellar radiation. tures in the Milky Way (Slysh 1985; Timofeev et al. Less ambitious astro-engineering designs, where sparse 2000; Jugaku & Nishimura 2004; Carrigan 2009). Simi- swarms, rings or single large shades are built around lar searches for civilizations engaging in galaxy-spanning both stars and stellar remnants have also been consid- or even intergalactic colonization powered by Dyson ered (e.g. Suffern 1977; Wright et al. 2014a; Osmanov sphere technology have also failed to turn up any 2016; Wright et al. 2016), and the time to build a small- tell-tale signatures of this type of astro-engineering scale megastructure of this type has been estimated at as (Annis 1999; Wright et al. 2014b,a; Griffith et al. 2015; little as ∼ 102 yr (Armstrong & Sandberg 2013). Pro- Zackrisson et al. 2015; Garrett 2015; Olson 2017). De- pending on the sizes and distribution of the obscuring 2 Zackrisson et al. satellites, these structures may give rise to conspicu- /far-infrared excess through a comparison of predicted ous temporal variations in the apparent brightness of and observed fluxes at mid/far-IR wavelengths from in- the affected star (e.g. Arnold 2005; Wright et al. 2016; frared telescopes like WISE, IRAS, Spitzer, Akari and Osmanov 2016). However, most searches so far have fo- Herschel. cused on the overall, long-term changes in the spectral In section 2, we describe the method and its limita- energy distribution of the star that the satellites may tions. In section 3 we apply this method to the ≈ 2×105 induce. stars in common between Gaia DR1 and RAVE DR5 Following the AGENT formalism of Wright et al. in search of objects with signatures that match those (2014a), the energy budget of a Dyson sphere can be expected for partial Dyson spheres with high covering described as: fractions. As an example of the type of object that is α + ǫ = γ + ν, (1) identified by this method, we discuss the properties of TYC 6111-1162-1 in section 4, and present follow-up ob- where α represents the radiation energy collected by servations to confirm the stellar parameters derived by the Dyson sphere, ǫ the energy produced by other RAVE. Section 5 discusses the prospects of applying the means, γ the thermal waste heat and ν the energy lost method to much larger data sets in the future. Section 6 through non-photonic means (e.g. neutrinos, gravita- summarizes our findings. tional waves). Under the assumption that the collected starlight overwhelms all other forms of energy generated 2. DISCREPANCIES BETWEEN and that non-thermal losses are negligible, equation (1) SPECTROPHOTOMETRIC AND PARALLAX simplifies to α ≈ γ. In observational terms, even a minor DISTANCES FOR PARTIAL DYSON SPHERES fraction of collected starlight can then generate a very Through the use of stellar-atmosphere modeling and pronounced infrared excess in the spectral energy distri- theoretical stellar isochrones in conjunction with ob- bution of the star, as long as the Dyson sphere operates served photometric fluxes and spectroscopic data at at a temperature in the 50–1000K range. Consequently, optical/near-infrared wavelength, it is possible to ac- most Dyson-sphere searches have focused on detecting curately determine stellar parameters, dust-attenuation this infrared signature. However, in case where losses factors and spectrophotometric distances Dspec, or con- due to non-thermal photons are significant (i.e. where ν versely spectrophotometric parallaxes πspec, for various is non-negligible), where the energy is somehow stored types of stars (e.g Binney et al. 2014). This procedure rather than radiated away or where the waste heat radi- basically assumes that once the observed optical flux ation is anisotropic (and not emitted in our direction), fopt has been corrected for dust, the relation between the infrared signature may be weaker than usually as- the intrinsic optical luminosity Lopt and its spectropho- sumed. Here, we outline a method to search for partial tometric distance is: Dyson spheres with weak or even absent waste heat sig- Lopt natures. Fopt = , (2) 4πD2 Since a star surrounded by a partial Dyson sphere with spec large (but non-unity) covering fraction is expected to ap- which implies pear unusually faint for its type at optical/near-infrared 1/2 Lopt wavelengths, its spectrophotometric distance is expected Dspec = (3) to be overestimated. A trigonometric parallax measure- 4πFopt ment, as provided by Hipparcos or Gaia would, on the However, consider a star enshrouded by a Dyson sphere other hand, still be able to provide an accurate dis- which covers a fraction fcov of the stellar surface tance estimate. Hence, it should be possible single out area. If this obscuring structure blocks the emerging tentative Dyson-sphere candidates by comparing paral- optical/near-IR light like a grey absorber (i.e. all wave- lax distances to their spectrophotometric counterparts. lengths throughout this interval are equally affected), With future Gaia data releases, both distance estimates the only impact on the observed flux would be a general can be obtained from Gaia data, but even with Gaia dimming, whereas the detailed shape of the spectrum at Data Release (DR) 1 (Gaia Collaboration et al. 2016) it these wavelengths would be unaffected. The true dis- is possible to carry out a search of this kind by com- tance would then be given by D′: bining the parallax distances provided by the Tycho- L (1 − f ) 1/2 Gaia Astrometric Solution (TGAS) with spectrophoto- D′ = opt cov . (4) metric distances from ground-based surveys like the Ra- 4πFopt dial Velocity Experiment (RAVE; Kunder et al. 2017) Combining eqs. 3 and 4, we get: or GALAH (Martell et al. 2017). Candidates for Dyson ′ 1/2 spheres identified this way can also be tested for mid- D = Dspec(1 − fcov) (5) SETI with Gaia 3 Figure 1. Distribution of fcov for a) the whole Gaia DR1-RAVE DR5 sample; b) the subset of the Gaia DR1-RAVE DR5 sample with the smallest parallax errors (trigonometric parallax error ≤ 10%, spectroscopic parallax error ≤ 20%). Hence, for a Dyson sphere which obscures a fraction spectrophotometric fit also allows for a prediction of the 1 > fcov > 0 of the intrinsic optical radiation, the intrinsic stellar flux at infrared wavelengths that can true distance D′ would be smaller than that inferred by be directly compared to observed fluxes with mid/far- standard spectrophotometric distance-estimation tech- infrared survey data in search of any potential infrared niques. Even in this case, a measurement of the trigono- excess. metric parallax distance Dtrig should still be able to re- It should be noted that the covering fraction fcov used trieve the true distance, since this technique is not di- in the above formalism does not need to represent the rectly affected by the brightness of the star.