MAN OR MONSTER? : THE TRIAL OF A KHMER ROUGE TORTURER PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Alexander Laban Hinton | 360 pages | 08 Nov 2016 | Duke University Press | 9780822362739 | English | North Carolina, United States Man or Monster? : The Trial of a Khmer Rouge Torturer PDF Book Trial based on civil rather than common law, includes Act of Prosecution, Witnesses' Testimonies, Investigation reports on crimes committed against various segments of society; Indictment; Statements by foreign jurists; Pleadings for and against the defendants; Judgement. Bryan, Mekong Review. What do these messages say? They listened intently as the closing order was read, tracing out Duch's path to S and the brutalities that took place there. Man or Monster? Remember me on this computer. Download PDF here. The sentencing lends weight to the monster image of Duch in public opinion. Throughout the book it nevertheless becomes clear that reality is more complex than this good and bad binary. Archived from the original on In addition to the five-judge Trial Chamber overseeing Duch's hearing, the ECCC has a five-person Pre-Trial Chamber and a seven-person Supreme Court Chamber SCC , each of which has a majority of Cambodian judges but requires for a decision a supermajority that includes the vote of at least one international judge. He had been waiting years for this trial to begin. Unidentified prisoner, S Over the course of , the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia eccc , more colloquially referred to as the Khmer Rouge Tribunal, held seventy-seven sessions that included the testimony of thirty-five witnesses and twenty-two victims. Man or Monster shows how globalized views of justice and human rights impact on the Cambodian experience. Chum Mey had been spared because he was a mechanic and could fix generators on the compound. It is comparative if often inflected through the lens of the Cambodian genocide, where I long conducted ethnographic fieldwork. The trial was to begin and end in controversy. I gave expert testimony at the Khmer Rouge tribunal in Cambodia in early around the time Donald Trump was becoming the front-runner in the Republican primaries — despite his inflammatory speech and white power support. The text in the signs at Tuol Sleng are here reproduced verbatim, without correct- ing the English-language errors. In addition, there are Cambodian and international co-investigative judges, and civil parties and defendants may select Cambodian and, if they wish, international lawyers. It will also be of use to those considering the very work we do as social scientists; how what we do is intimately involved in the frames of how others come to understand particular places, people, and events. This theme of atrocity is amplified in ground-floor rooms of Building A, where another sign explains that S used them for torture and interrogation. In Man or Monster? Mekong Dreaming. What has been the subject of your primary research focus? While this term is fairly elastic, it connotes membership in the global community, with an accompa- nying worldly perspective and commitment to a set of transnational rights, duties, and obligations. Duch, the commandant of S, insisted on adherence to a set of rules and instructions for torture. The Trial of a Khmer Rouge Torturer introduction. Duch was separated from the people sitting in the front row of the gallery by just half a dozen meters and the protective glass wall. This structure also reflects my experience of the Duch trial, which often seemed like a performance, and resonates with the importance of the oral tradition in Cambodia, where the Khmer Rouge past is often recollected through narrative and story. Man or Monster? This word was often used to describe Duch. They detained Duch less than two weeks later, eventually charging him with "crimes against humanity" and "grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions. For many years, visitors could see bloodstains on the white-and-tan checkerboard floor. Duch differs from the others in that after the fall of DK he lived a normal life and distanced himself from the top leaders. This time I notice a single credit line at the bottom of the page, in a tiny, barely legible font. Tens of thousands of people likely perished during this initial phase of forced evacuations and executions. Hinton succeeds beautifully in drawing the reader into a confrontation with our own articulations and redactions of the world around us. Day 4, 51; Khmer, Classification: lcc kz August Learn how and when to remove this template message. Latinx Art. Through an examination of post Thai cinema and video art Arnika Fuhrmann shows how vernacular Buddhist tenets, stories, and images combine with sexual Over the years they have also periodically returned to Tuol Sleng. Add links. Susanne Knittel and Zachary Goldberg, eds. Man or Monster? : The Trial of a Khmer Rouge Torturer Writer In the case of the ECCC, three key documents delineate the court's mandate, jurisdiction, composition, and applicable laws. These three works represent a sustained effort to understand and explain genocide. In , Hinton was awarded the Robert B. Duch speaking at S meeting. Yet it is not these prescriptions that leave the most lasting impression. Victims and Perpetrators? One look tells the story. Genocide Studies and Prevention 13 3 : The Gate. S was under the direct leadership of Duch, a former mathematics teacher who joined the Communist movement in , later to become known as the Khmer Rouge. Man or Monster? Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. The revolution was not the last time he would change it. Read the Introduction. They listened intently as the closing order was read, tracing out Duch's path to S and the brutalities that took place there. In many cases, the Cambodian case is depicted as a particular example of the universal category of crimes against humanity, a point emphasized by noting the link to other cases of mass human rights violations. Clearly, there are multiple dynamics involved in the genocidal process, ranging from socioeconomic upheaval to structural constraint. As a result, most former Khmer Rouge cadre, including by implication many PRK officials, were said to be not ultimately responsible for the DK vio- lence and suffering. This book will become standard reading for anyone studying the portrayal of perpetrators during post-conflict justice processes. M46 Kroch Asia Library. Request a desk or exam copy. Some visitors to the museum would recognize Duch as the Khmer Rouge cadre who ran a secret security prison, S Security Office 21 , at the site from to New York: Oxford University Press. Rutgers University Press. Retrieved Subjects: Asia Studies. Jackson, Jr. Judge Lavergne was the first person afforded the opportunity to directly question Duch during the trial proceedings. There is almost no explanatory text. This structure also reflects my experience of the Duch trial, which often seemed like a performance, and resonates with the importance of the oral tradition in Cambodia, where the Khmer Rouge past is often recollected through narrative and story. As the ranks and territorial control of the Khmer Rouge rapidly increased in the early s, Duch was running M prison and developing methods of inter- rogation he would bring to S The faces of some prisoners are swollen and bruised. Man or Monster? : The Trial of a Khmer Rouge Torturer Reviews What prompted you to begin a project focused on the US? The most approachable way that these frames are introduced is through the idea of graffiti. Are there any specific challenges to working in the US either personal or in terms of the content of the research? Prisoners were executed on site. I have done very bad things before in my life. More specifically, they sought to eliminate corrupting in- fluences from the past by banning nonrevolutionary art and styles, destroying and damaging temples, curtailing media and communication, ending traditional holidays and rituals, separating family members, homogenizing clothing, and eliminating private property, including photos and other mementos. One weekend that November, my father decided to take me to see a newly released film at the local cineplex. Flowing text, Google-generated PDF. The Conversation, October Gordon Longmuir, Pacific Affairs. The flags of the UN and Cambodia were affixed to the left and right sides of the wall, respectively. The meaning is redacted to those who speak only English, remaining as an uncanny presence on the photo. This hybrid court deals with those most responsible for the genocide committed during the Democratic Kampuchea DK period of Khmer Rouge rule in Cambodia, which led to an estimated two million deaths. In Duch stood trial for these crimes against humanity. These techniques reinforce the attempt to disrupt the black and white thinking that is inherent in transitional justice, showing how taken for granted truths are in reality framed by leaving out inconvenient aspects. And, will they, like Pol Pot who died in April and Ta Mok July , die before they face justice or will they be tried for genocide and crimes against humanity? Duch made this apology on March 31, , the second day of his trial, while standing in the court's horseshoe-shaped dock. In , Duch was sentenced to 35 years in prison, reduced by 11 years for time served and a further 5 years for what the court found to be illegal detention, leaving an actual sentence of 19 years. Issue 13, Vol 3. Throughout the book it nevertheless becomes clear that reality is more complex than this good and bad binary. Day 4, 49; Khmer, Most are set in checkerboard panels, a panorama of suffer- ing and humanity. Unlike Alexander Hinton, author of the two books under consideration here, I was not able to concentrate my work around the unimaginably complicated tragedies labeled genocide.