2012 Arizona Legislative Scorecard -- (28th annual scorecard from AFP/AFT) Americans for Prosperity 2011 Arizona Legislative Scorecard November 21, 2012 Semi-Final Edition, Pending Results of a Special Session on the AZ ObamaCare Exchange -- www.aztaxpayers.org 2012 Prior Years 2005 - 2011 Cumulative Old New S/H Legislator -- 2012 Score 2012 Designation 11 10 09 08 07 06 05 Avg. Designation R/D LD LD Sen. Andy Biggs 82 Champion of the Taxpayer 99 82 61 96 94 72 84 84 Champion of the Taxpayer R 22 12 Sen. Judy M. Burges 82 Champion of the Taxpayer 77 86 74 85 82 74 86 81 Champion of the Taxpayer R 4 22 Sen. Lori Klein 82 Champion of the Taxpayer 95 88 Champion of the Taxpayer R 6 1 Sen. Gail Griffin 80 Champion of the Taxpayer 95 87 Champion of the Taxpayer R 25 14 Sen. Steve Smith 79 Friend of the Taxpayer 95 87 Champion of the Taxpayer R 23 11 Sen. Ron Gould 77 Friend of the Taxpayer 99 84 70 96 97 90 89 88 Champion of the Taxpayer R 3 NA Sen. Rick Murphy 74 Friend of the Taxpayer 94 49 74 82 82 67 84 76 Friend of the Taxpayer R 9 21 Sen. Sylvia Allen 74 Friend of the Taxpayer 94 48 90 98 81 Champion of the Taxpayer R 5 NA Sen. Nancy K. Barto 73 Friend of the Taxpayer 93 42 73 80 77 67 72 Friend of the Taxpayer R 7 15 Sen. Don Shooter 72 Friend of the Taxpayer 93 82 Champion of the Taxpayer R 24 13 Sen. Frank Antenori 71 Friend of the Taxpayer 92 77 72 78 Friend of the Taxpayer R 30 10 Rep. John Kavanagh 71 Friend of the Taxpayer 75 83 74 89 80 79 Friend of the Taxpayer R 8 23 Rep. Debbie Lesko 70 Friend of the Taxpayer 75 49 72 67 Not Bad R 9 21 Rep. John Fillmore 70 Friend of the Taxpayer 76 73 Friend of the Taxpayer R 23 16 Rep. Jack W. Harper 69 Not Bad 77 82 89 89 71 87 86 81 Champion of the Taxpayer R 4 NA Rep. Phil Lovas 69 Not Bad 69 Not Bad R 4 22 Rep. Carl Seel 68 Not Bad 76 83 73 75 Friend of the Taxpayer R 6 20 Rep. Rick Gray 68 Not Bad 76 72 Friend of the Taxpayer R 9 21 2012 Prior Years 2005 - 2011 Cumulative Old New S/H Legislator -- 2012 Score 2012 Designation 11 10 09 08 07 06 05 Avg. Designation R/D LD LD Sen. Michele Reagan 68 Not Bad 93 41 71 36 62 58 63 61 Not Bad R 8 23 Rep. David B. Smith 67 Not Bad 76 74 72 Friend of the Taxpayer R 7 15 Rep. Vic Williams 61 Not Bad 72 43 71 62 Not Bad R 26 NA Rep. Chester Crandell 60 Not Bad 73 66 Not Bad R 5 6 Rep. Brenda Barton 60 Not Bad 73 66 Not Bad R 5 6 Rep. Peggy Judd 59 Needs Improvement 71 65 Not Bad R 25 NA Sen. Steve Pierce 59 Needs Improvement 94 44 88 71 Friend of the Taxpayer R 1 1 Rep. Tom Forese 59 Needs Improvement 76 67 Not Bad R 21 17 Rep. Eddie Farnsworth 58 Needs Improvement 80 93 85 71 83 78 Friend of the Taxpayer R 22 12 Sen. Al Melvin 58 Needs Improvement 93 41 86 70 Friend of the Taxpayer R 26 11 Sen. Adam Driggs 58 Needs Improvement 94 79 73 79 70 75 Friend of the Taxpayer R 11 28 Sen. Steven Yarbrough 58 Needs Improvement 93 42 72 84 75 63 69 70 Friend of the Taxpayer R 21 17 Sen. John McComish 58 Needs Improvement 84 42 71 77 59 56 63 64 Not Bad R 20 18 Rep. Steve Montenegro 57 Needs Improvement 76 84 74 73 Friend of the Taxpayer R 12 13 Rep. Karen Fann 57 Needs Improvement 74 65 Not Bad R 1 1 Rep. Michelle Ugenti 56 Needs Improvement 75 66 Not Bad R 8 23 Rep. David W. Stevens 56 Needs Improvement 75 44 74 62 Not Bad R 25 14 Rep. Justin Olson 55 Needs Improvement 75 65 Not Bad R 19 25 Rep. David Gowan 54 Needs Improvement 75 80 74 71 Friend of the Taxpayer R 30 14 Rep. Justin Pierce 52 Needs Improvement 52 Needs Improvement R 19 25 Sen. John B. Nelson 52 Needs Improvement 93 43 87 75 38 59 65 64 Not Bad R 12 NA Rep. Jeff Dial 51 Needs Improvement 75 63 Not Bad R 20 18 Rep. Jerry Weiers 51 Needs Improvement 73 80 72 81 73 60 76 71 Friend of the Taxpayer R 12 NA Rep. Steve Court 50 Needs Improvement 75 46 69 60 Not Bad R 18 NA Sen. Linda Gray 50 Needs Improvement 88 41 66 74 64 68 71 65 Not Bad R 10 NA Rep. J.D. Mesnard 50 Needs Improvement 75 62 Not Bad R 21 17 Rep. Andy Tobin 49 Friend of Big Government 73 41 71 75 41 58 Needs Improvement R 1 1 Rep. Amanda Reeve 49 Friend of Big Government 75 70 64 Not Bad R 6 28 Rep. Kimberly Yee 49 Friend of Big Government 75 62 Not Bad R 10 20 Rep. Jim Weiers 48 Friend of Big Government 73 48 67 80 60 62 78 64 Not Bad R 10 NA 2012 Prior Years 2005 - 2011 Cumulative Old New S/H Legislator -- 2012 Score 2012 Designation 11 10 09 08 07 06 05 Avg. Designation R/D LD LD Rep. Doris Goodale 48 Friend of Big Government 52 42 72 53 Needs Improvement R 3 5 Rep. Bob Robson 47 Friend of Big Government 65 77 58 59 72 63 Not Bad R 20 18 Rep. Kate Brophy McGee 46 Friend of Big Government 57 52 Needs Improvement R 11 28 Rep. Heather Carter 46 Friend of Big Government 65 55 Needs Improvement R 7 15 Rep. Terri Proud 45 Friend of Big Government 75 60 Not Bad R 26 NA Sen. Rich Crandall 44 Friend of Big Government 84 44 70 76 60 63 Not Bad R 19 16 Rep. Ted Vogt 44 Friend of Big Government 75 64 61 Not Bad R 30 10 Rep. Frank Pratt 44 Friend of Big Government 75 40 71 57 Needs Improvement R 23 8 Rep. Nancy McLain 43 Friend of Big Government 54 46 72 82 65 56 67 61 Not Bad R 3 5 Rep. Steve Urie 43 Friend of Big Government 57 50 Needs Improvement R 22 NA Sen. Jerry Lewis 42 Friend of Big Government 42 Friend of Big Government R 18 26 Gov. Jan Brewer 40 Friend of Big Government 40 42 43 41 Friend of Big Government R AZ AZ Rep. Russell L. Jones 36 Friend of Big Government 55 39 70 46 65 52 Needs Improvement R 24 13 Rep. Cecil P. Ash 29 Champ. of Big Government 54 44 72 50 Needs Improvement R 18 NA Rep. Ben Arredondo 18 Champ. of Big Government 14 16 Champ. of Big Government D 17 NA Rep. Eric Meyer 18 Champ. of Big Government 16 8 31 18 Champ. of Big Government D 11 28 Rep. Ed Ableser 18 Champ. of Big Government 25 8 12 5 17 16 14 Champ. of Big Government D 17 26 Rep. Lynne Pancrazi 18 Champ. of Big Government 14 10 30 5 18 16 Champ. of Big Government D 24 4 Sen. Jack Jackson, Jr. 17 Champ. of Big Government 9 13 Champ. of Big Government D 2 7 Rep. Chad Campbell 16 Champ. of Big Government 25 6 15 5 34 17 Champ. of Big Government D 14 24 Rep. Matt Heinz 16 Champ. of Big Government 26 9 38 22 Champ. of Big Government D 29 NA Rep. Steve Farley 16 Champ. of Big Government 25 4 25 3 14 15 Champ. of Big Government D 28 9 Sen. Steve Gallardo 15 Champ. of Big Government 10 5 17 23 16 14 Champ. of Big Government D 13 29 Sen. Leah Landrum 15 Champ. of Big Government 12 6 17 42 45 11 21 21 Champ. of Big Government D 16 27 Sen. David Schapira 15 Champ. of Big Government 10 4 13 5 35 14 Champ. of Big Government D 17 NA Rep. Tom Chabin 15 Champ. of Big Government 16 5 25 6 13 Champ. of Big Government D 2 6 Sen. David Lujan 15 Champ. of Big Government 7 24 3 38 22 15 18 Champ. of Big Government D 15 NA 2012 Prior Years 2005 - 2011 Cumulative Old New S/H Legislator -- 2012 Score 2012 Designation 11 10 09 08 07 06 05 Avg. Designation R/D LD LD Rep. Ruben Gallego 14 Champ. of Big Government 19 17 Champ. of Big Government D 16 27 Rep. Anna Tovar 14 Champ. of Big Government 14 6 36 5 17 15 Champ. of Big Government D 13 19 Sen. Robert Meza 14 Champ. of Big Government 11 8 30 5 36 22 30 19 Champ. of Big Government D 14 30 Rep. Catherine Miranda 13 Champ. of Big Government 16 15 Champ. of Big Government D 16 27 Rep. Martin J. Quezada 13 Champ. of Big Government 13 Champ. of Big Government D 13 29 Sen. Paula Aboud 13 Champ. of Big Government 10 5 22 17 43 11 17 Champ.