63(&,$/,668( *OURNALOF7ORLD 3YSTEMS2ESEARCH &%343#(2)&4&/2 )--!.5%, 7!,,%234%).0!24) 05",)3(%$5.$%24(%30/.3/23()0/&4(% #%.4%2&/2',/"!, ).4%2.!4)/.!, 2%')/.!,345$)%3!.$4(%$)6)3)/./& 3/#)!,3#)%.#%3!44(%5.)6%23)49/& #!,)&/2.)! 3!.4!#25: 92/80(;,180%(56800(5)$// KWWSMZVUXFUHGX Journal of World-Systems Research iii. world-systems: historical Vol. xi Number 2 Summer/Fall2000 Amiya Kumar Bagchi The Past and the Future of the Developmental State 398 freehttp://jwsr.ucr.edu/ e-journal 444 Special Issue: Silviu Brucan The Hard-Earned Integration of the East in the Festschrift for Immanuel Wallerstein – Part I World Economic System Edited By Giovanni Arrighi & Walter L. Goldfrank Theotônio dos Santos World Economic System: On the Genesis of a 456 Contents Concept Giovanni Arrighi & Preface viii Harriet Friedmann What on Earth is the Modern World-System? 480 Walter L. Goldfrank Foodgetting and Territory in the Modern Era and Beyond Walter L. Goldfrank Paradigm Regained? The Rules Of Wallerstein’s 150 World-System Method Henryk Samsonowicz The Rise and Fall of ‘The World of Economy’: 518 Eastern Europe in 9th–12th Centuries i. general issues Nicoletta Stame Household and Small Business Across 526 Albert J. Bergesen The Columbia Social Essayists 198 the Disciplines Andre Gunder Frank Immanuel and Me With-Out Hyphen 216 Peter J. Taylor Havens and Cages: Reinventing States and 544 Households in the Modern World-System William G. Martin Still Partners and Still Dissident After All These 234 Years? Wallerstein, World Revolutions and the World-Systems Perspective available for download winter 2000 Göran Therborn Time, Space, and Their Knowledge: The Times and 266 Festschrift for Immanuel Wallerstein – Part II Place of the World and Other Systems Edited By Giovanni Arrighi & Walter L. Goldfrank Contributors ii. colonialism & nationalism iv. world-systems: contemporary v. structures of knowledge Anouar Abdel-Malek Carlos Antonio Aguirre Rojas Anna Davin Flight to the Centre: Winnie Gonley, 1930s 286 Samir Amin Roberto Briceño-León & Colonial Cosmopolita Orlando Fals Borda Heinz R. Sonntag Jonathan Friedman Catherine Coquery-Vidrovitch Michael Hechter Nationalism and Rationality 308 Pablo González Casanova Pierre Dockès Philip McMichael John Galtung Daniel Singer Richard E. Lee Ramkrishna Mukherjee Caste in Itself, Caste and Class, or Caste in Class 332 Te ivo Te ivainen Su-Hoon Lee Claudia von Werlhof Orlando Lentini Aníbal Quijano Colonialidad del Poder y Clasifi cacion Social 342 Ilya Prigogine Ari Sitas B. Verhaegen Wallerstein: L’Afrique et le monde: une vision 388 Boaventura de Sousa Santos José María Tortosa provocante au carrefour de l’histoire et de la Alain Touraine sociologie JWSR Editorial Policy Journal of World-Systems Research The main editorial goal of the Journal of World-Systems Research is to develop and http://jwsr.ucr.edu/ [email protected] disseminate scholarly research on topics that are relevant to the analysis of world- systems. We especially want to include works that proceed from several different theoretical stances and disciplines. These include, but are not limited to, civilizationists, Editor Walter L. Goldfrank evolutionary approaches, international political economy, comparative, historical and cultural analysis. We seek the work of political scientists, historians, sociologists, Assistant Editor Eric W. Titolo ethnographers, archaeologists, economists and geographers. Book Review Editor Joya Misra We especially encourage works that take theory seriously by confronting problems of conceptualization and making defi nitions of concepts explicit, by formulating hypotheses, Publication Services Global Hegemonics and Cover Art www.globalhegemonics.com constructing axiomatic theories and causal models. Theoretical research programs that combine theory construction with comparative research are badly needed to take the Guest Publishing Ben Brewer world-systems approach beyond the stage of a perspective. Assistants Ho-fung Hung We also want to encourage the application of comparative, quantititave and network- analytic methods to world-systems research, though we will certainly also publish pieces Editorial Board Janet Abu-Lughod David Kowalewski that do not use these methods. Any empirical study that is deemed relevant to world- Albert Bergesen Su Hoon Lee systems analysis may be published even if it uses a very different conceptual framework. Volker Bornschier Alejandro Portes Terry Boswell Beverly Silver And fi nally we also want to publish discussions of future trajectories and options for the Christopher Chase-Dunn Cornelius Terlouw modern world-system and considerations of what can be done to create a more humane, Carl Dassbach William R. Thompson peaceful and just world society. Jonathan Friedman Michael Timberlake Andre Gunder Frank David A. Smith The purposes of JWSR are: Thomas D. Hall David Wilkinson to produce a high quality publication of world-systems research articles; to publish quantitative and comparative research on world-systems; to publish works of theory Associate Editors Syed Farid Alatas Katherine Moseley construction and codifi cation of causal propositions; to publish data sets in connection Giovanni Arrighi Thomas Schott with articles; to publish reviews of books relevant to world-systems studies; and to Peter Evans Peter J. Taylor encourage authors to use the hypermedia advantages of electronic publication to present Gary Feinman Immanuel Wallerstein their research results. Harriet Friedmann Dale Wimberley Edward Kick Governance: Robert J.S. Ross JWSR is a self-published refereed journal under the control of the Editor and the John W. Meyer Editorial Board. The Associate Editors are consultants who help to procure and evaluate Patrick McGowan articles for publication. George Modelski Copyright Policy The Journal of World-Systems Research (JWSR) (issn 1076-156x) is currently published The contents of JWSR are for use by scholars and researchers and cannot be copied for quarterly under the sponsorship of the Center for Global, International & Regional commercial purposes. Authors retain the full copyrights to their papers. Permissions to Studies, and the Division of Social Sciences at the University of California, Santa reprint must be obtained from the authors. Authors are asked to cite the JWSR versions Cruz. Additional funding for Vol VI, Number 2 provided by Global Hegemonics of their papers if related versions are published elsewhere. The Editor of JWSR reserves and the Program in Comparative International Development in the Department of the right to reproduce articles in future hard copy, protable document format (PDF), or Sociology at Johns Hopkins University. HTML editions of JWSR. To I W Preface ublication of a festschrift should be an occasion for refl ection, for apprecia- Ption, and for hope: refl ection on an unusually signifi cant career, apprecia- tion for opening paths that contributors and others have followed, hope for the honoree’s well-being in the years that remain. Many far-fl ung colleagues and friends were invited to participate in this publication, and most were able to accept; so many, in fact, that the impossibility of an old-fashioned book quickly became apparent to us. At the other extreme was the example of the open web- site through which Noam Chomsky was honored on the recent occasion of his seventieth birthday. Thus we were happy to hit upon the present alterna- tive, a special macro “double double” issue of the on-line Journal of World-Systems Research —itself an important institutional by-product of Immanuel Waller- stein’s lifework. “Double double:” half the contents will appear in this jumbo summer/fall issue (VI, 2) and half in the fall/winter (VI, 3); each of the two numbers is twice normal size. We hope that our readers will agree that “macro” is indeed appropriate in this instance. As adumbrated in the introduction that follows, it is convenient to divide Wallerstein’s scholarly career into three overlapping temporalities: Africa and colonialism/nationalism; the modern world-system; social science and the structures of knowledge. We have organized this festschrift around this scheme, such that VI, 2 contains the introduction, three general essays, fi ve contri- butions with a colonial/national thematic, and eight dealing with historical aspects of the modern world-system. The subsequent double issue, to appear in the Winter, includes nine contributions focussed on contemporary global mat- ters and thirteen on questions of social science concepts and methods. As we salute Prof. Wallerstein at 70, we know that he joins us in thanking those who helped make this publication possible: Donna Devoist of the Fer- nand Braudel Center at Binghamton University; Christopher Chase-Dunn, founding editor of JWSR; Ben Brewer and Ho-Fung Hung at Johns Hopkins University; and Eric Titolo at Binghamton University and the University of California, Santa Cruz. G. Arrighi & W. Goldfrank, Special Issue Editors journal of world-systems research, vi, 2, summer/fall 2000, viii Special Issue: Festchrift for Immanuel Wallerstein – Part I http://jwsr.ucr.edu/ issn 1076-156x © 2000 Giovanni Arrighi & Walter L. Goldfrank viii Paradigm Regained? The Rules Of Wallerstein’s World-System Method* Walter L. Goldfrank he last third of the twentieth century was ushered in by a set of Tevents—wars, rebellions, fi nally economic crisis—that dealt a crush- ing blow to the previously dominant paradigm in U.S. social science, the structural-functionalist modernizationism elaborated by Talcott Parsons