z(ol7 Session Additional Docurnents include: *Business Report * Roll Catt(attendance) *Standing Committee Reportsr *Table Billsr Fiscal reports etc. *Roll Call Yotes , *Witness Statements *Inforrnational items *Visitor Registrations *Any other Documents; -Petitions if any? -Any and all material handed in after the meeting end. lVf ontaxra, Ilistorica,l Societ5r A.rchirzes 22511[. FR.oloergts Ilelena lUflF Sgrt6 2O-12(Of z.oL|Z Legisla,tirze Scann ere Strsie IIa,rnlltorr BUSINESS REPORT MONTANA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 65th LEGISLATURE - REGULAR SESSION HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE Date: Friday, January 20,2017 Time: 8:00 AM Place: Capitol Room:137 BILLS and RESOLUTIONS HEARD: HB 147 - Requiring search warrant for gov access to electronic devices - Rep. Daniel Zolnikov HB 148 - Generally revise privacy laws - Rep. Daniel Zolnikov HB 149 - Revise privacy laws regarding license plate scanners - Rep. Daniel Zolnikov EXECUTIVE ACTION TAKEN: HB 129 - Tabled HB 194 - Do Pass HB 206 - Tabled HB 217 - Do Pass Comments: .'ffi,",'#1?.,1#i, Winn &'r -r h{ {) N :r A hI.&\ Fjt,m u $.}q ffi F' R lri p R m $ mN_T Air \r ri s JUDICIARY COMMITTM tl ROLL CALL DATE: I lto tt7 NAlv{E PRESENT ABSIENT/IEXC]LNSED rl REP. SETH BERGLEE. VICE CHAIR \t r REP. VIRGINIA COURT, VICE CHAIR ,// REP. KATHY KELKER ,l r REP. BOB BROWN REP. BARRY USHER r/t REP. DALE MORTENSEN \/, REP. JENNY ECK Vt REP. LAURIE BISHOP REP. ELLIE HILL SMITH t/ REP. NATE MCCONNELL J/ REP. KIRK WAGONER \// REP. MATT REGIER V REP. BILL HARRIS REP. LOLA SHELDON-GALLOWAY REP. THERESA MANZELLA REP. CASEY KNUDSEN REP. ZAC PERRY REP. SHANE MORIGEAU REP. ALAN DOANE. CHAIR t/ 19 N4E]\48]ERS S:\2017 House Session\Committees\SecretariesV udicia ry\Roll Call.docx HOUSE STANDING COMMITTEE REPORT Ianuary 20,2017 Page I of I Mr. Speaker: We, your committee on Judiciary recommend that House BillzlT (first reading copy -- white) do pass. Signed: Representative - END. Committee Vote: Yes 19, No 0 Fiscal Note Required _ H80217002SC. hts $^) lliso A$4 o l4't1 HOUSE STANDING COMMITTEE REPORT Ianuary 20,2017 Page 1 of 1 Mr. Speaker: We, your committee on Judiciary recommend that House Bill 194 (first reading copy -- white) do pass. Representative A -END- COMMITTEE FILE COPY BILL TABLED NOTICE HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE The HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE TABLED HB 129 - Revising laws related to privacy in communications - Rep.Ellie Hill Smith HB 206 - Revise laws regarding crimes - Rep. DanielZolnikov by motion, on Friday, January 20,20'17 (PLEASE USE THIS ACTION DATE lN LAWS BILL STATUS). (For the Committee) (For the Chief Clerk of the House) lz,su !2" _ (Time) (Date) January 20, 2017 (12.40pm) Sara Fleming, Secretary Phone. 444-4709 ,Wr:, r #fp','#k W,*.,{tw ,h{,mNTAtdA x{mti$Ii mtr RnpRH$K} TATT\r1HS JUDICIARY COMMITTEE ROLL CALL VOTE ( / / BILL NUMBER VV' DADN'- f lv-ofz MOTION NAN,{E AYE Nq PROXY REP. SETH BERGLEE. VICE CHAIR (, REP. VIRGINIA COURT. VICE CHAIR V REP. KATHY KELKER \, REP. BOB BROWN ,// REP. BARRY USHER v, REP. DALE MORTENSEN v REP. JENNY ECK t/r REP. LAURIE BISHOP J, REP. ELLIE HILL-SMITH rlr REP. NATE MCCONNELL ,/ r REP. KIRK WAGONER tl,, REP. MAT:I REGIER ,/r REP. BILL HARRIS \f/ REP. LOLA SHELDON-GALLOWAY v REP. THERESA MANZELLA Jr REP. CASEY KNUDSEN REP. ZAC PERRY \lr REP. SHANE MORIGEAU r/ REP. ALAN DOANE, CHAIR V 19 N4EN,{tsERS S:\2017 House Session\Committees\Secretaries!udiciary\Roll CallVote.docx (#,rm&pt ,'W ,';#r)p .Wy hSffi N:f ANA Hffi ]l-i$T:r, SF RnpRK$nN-:fATT VH$ JUDICIARY COMMITTEE ROLL CALL VOTE BILL NUMBER MOTION NAN4E AYzE NO PROXY REP. SETH BERGLEE, VICE CHAIR REP. VIRGINIA COURT. VICE CHAIR v, REP. KATHY KELKER ,r/ REP. BOB BROWN ,/r REP. BARRY USHER t/t REP. DALE MORTENSEN \/ REP. JENNY ECK REP. LAURIE BISHOP ../ REP. ELLIE HILL-SMITH J REP. NATE MCCONNELL ,/ REP. KIRK WAGONER JI REP. MATT REGIER V REP. BILL HARRIS r{ REP. LOLA SHELDON-GALLOWAY REP. THERESA MANZELLA Vz REP. CASEY KNUDSEN ,, l REP. ZAC PERRY JI REP. SHANE MORIGEAU V REP. ALAN DOANE. CHAIR 19 Iv{EN,{IEER-S S:\2017 House Session\Committees\Secretaries!udiciary\Roll Call Vote.docx ,''ffi'. ,#1,p' ,t$g Yirmtnw t\{mhT:rANA H#ti$K mF RHpKmsniNTATl\' ti$ JUDICIARY COMMITTEE ROLL CALL VOTE BrLL NUMBE " LLbll\ oo* t fz-o /tF MOTION NAN{E AYE NO PROXY REP. SETH BERGLEE. VICE CHAIR J REP. VIRGINIA COURT, VICE CHAIR J, REP. KATHY KELKER rl REP. BOB BROWN ,/. REP. BARRY USHER d, REP. DALE MORTENSEN J REP. JENNY ECK ,[, REP. LAURIE BISHOP {, REP. ELLIE HILL-SMITH x/, REP. NATE MCCONNELL REP. KIRK WAGONER J REP. MATT REGIER J, REP. BILL HARRIS V REP. LOLA SHELDON-GALLOWAY ,r/ REP. THERESA MANZELLA J REP. CASEY KNUDSEN J REP. ZAC PERRY J, REP. SHANE MORIGEAU J REP. ALAN DOANE. CHAIR J 19 N{EN{tsER:S S:\2017 House Session\Committees\Secretaries!udiciary\Roll Call Vote.docx MONTANA House of Representatives Visitors Register HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE Friday, January 20,2017 HB 1 47 - Requiring search warrant for gov access to electronic devices Sponsor: Rep. Daniel Zolnikov PLEASE PRINT Name Representing Support Oppose Info D^u^" Ufr//,,^" A/t Df .V Jou.- [,.^ {vl+. L.'b,o-, A rsul''^l; ,^ )< u,rv\ Hlinnrate UtlbLka5.y Mf \i.wn' I<;-A^ - Y \Y K- 5s., At,LV Y \ r;tYv F inlcv mr! trt X il /* P- /n-u^)r t'nlr Cc./-= V (/ fYlik- -q- e rr1-rr Isif ,.\ Ml Pp /4rt"nfil ,' M/ c'>n hd d rntrAz U;/ t/*Zn fl ft\T \ Please leave prepared testimony with Secretary. Witness Statement forms are available if you care to submit written testimony. MONTANA House of Representatives Visitors Register HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE Friday, January 20,2017 HB 148 - Generally revise privacy laws Sponsor. Rep. Daniel Zolnikov PLEASE PRINT Name Representing Support Oppose Info 5L (rss\ Aclu ,k Nc/^-I-,1t4 UiWart"." AA:a l-ib \r^)r\ kqn X \\_ J -- r n ,' ', I r --\ou^ l-. ^^ /Vl -1 Lth'u^4 /tSSd(,^f, \ e til nnz, n4an4k'l /{)cA,4 lAie)A /t//PAl x I'U fr0-,/ /or,/on illtrw \ Please leave prepared testimony with Secretary. Witness Statement forms are availatrle if you care to submit written testimony. MONTANA House of Representatives Visitors Register HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE Friday, January 20,2017 HB 149 - Revise privacy laws regarding license plate scanners Sponsor: Rep. Daniel Zolnikov PLEASE PRINT Name Representing Support Oppose lnfo St< ( o:Sl At t^U X /-1Tgcr; /Dc-= X // ),s I . /1 r n-^) ,vt/t ,x -;-,on,J,- ' /,,t; l, / Gif \< Wfurat, " dzrl Aj;t, n.4 d /ri$.dA rne9t X Sl.rr*{d*r- mLal K 6 ( \ Please leave prepared testimony with Secretary. Witness Statement forms are available if you care to submit written testimony. January 20,2017 Honorable Alan Doane Chairman, House judiciary Committee Capital Building Helena MT RE: HB 230 Thank you for the great hearing on HB 230 {requiring costs paid to detention centers be based on actual costs) on Thursday, January 19. I wish to provide the committee with a little information to clarify some of the answers that were given by me and the sheriffs during the hearing. The actualcosts of running a detention facility vary between counties. Due to varying levels of operational costs, some county facilities incur daily costs below the 569 cap whiie others exceed the cap. I have attached a chart that displays the cost each county incurs per inmate per day. To illustrate the actualimpact of the $69 cap, referto column G which was the most recent contract year before the cap was implemented in 2015. in calculatingthe coststo local propertytax payers, we used the same projected bed numbers provided in column G. A large majority of inmates awaiting beds in State facilities are housed in the urban counties. This information is acquired frorn severaldata sources. The actual price information comes from 2015 contract rates. Columns B and C are from the Department of co rrections. A committee member asked how the state can be assured costs will not become excessive. While it is true that we are asking for actual costs with no cap, any question about the propriety of the costs claimedbythecountiesisaddressedbyauditlanguageonpage3ofthebill, linesTand8. Theseclauses refer to current statute providing for auditing of localgovernment and political subdivisions. Of the 4L county facilities in Montana capable of holding inmates on a long term basis, 24 have signed a Department of Corrections ( DoC)contract, 15 have not signed the contract,and2 do not take DoC inmates. A county will often consider several factors when deciding whether or not to accept inmates. This includes, available staff, transportation requirements of the inmate, medical needs of the inmate, and family considerations of the inmate. Another committee member raised a question regarding revenue from inmate phone calls. Phone charges are paid either with prepaid phone cards or by the recipient of the call. Any revenue brought in through phone services is placed in an account for the benefit of the inmates and pays for things like television, recreation equipment, etc. Again, thanl< you for yourtime and a good hearing. lf you have other questions please feelfree to contact me at 406.461,.1314. Regards: 31 51o.*r-_\- David A. Galt Department of Corrections 2015 county jail hold budget Current Most Daily Recent Projected Costs Bed Days Co ntract Bed days times annual Ca pped times rate (201s) rate D iffe re n ce Beds q141 ??,q Aarr rn- r; Anaconda 2,047 $69.00 576.ss frJvrvJJ.vl 51,s,454.43 <) 1 -7 A-7 11 Beaverhead 51J $67.00 521.,767 567.00 tLLt.