Star Clusters in Evolving Galaxies Florent Renaud Department of Astronomy and Theoretical Physics, Lund Observatory, Box 43, SE-221 00 Lund, Sweden Department of Physics, University of Surrey, Guildford, GU2 7XH, UK Abstract Their ubiquity and extreme densities make star clusters probes of prime importance of galaxy evolution. Old globular clusters keep imprints of the physical conditions of their assembly in the early Universe, and younger stellar objects, observationally resolved, tell us about the mechanisms at stake in their formation. Yet, we still do not understand 5 the diversity involved: why is star cluster formation limited to 10 M objects in the Milky Way, while some dwarf galaxies like NGC 1705 are able to produce clusters 10 times more massive? Why do dwarfs generally host a higher specific frequency of clusters than larger galaxies? How to connect the present-day, often resolved, stellar systems to the formation of globular clusters at high redshift? And how do these links depend on the galactic and cosmological environments of these clusters? In this review, I present recent advances on star cluster formation and evolution, in galactic and cosmological context. The emphasis is put on the theory, formation scenarios and the effects of the environment on the evolution of the global properties of clusters. A few open questions are identified. I Introduction 2 5.5 Galactic centre . 13 1 Outline, framework and objectives 2 6 Young massive clusters in interacting galax- ies 14 2 A multi-scale and multi-physics topic 3 6.1 Nuclear starburst . 15 3 What is a star cluster? 3 6.2 Cloud-cloud collisions, shocks . 15 3.1 Bound and part of a galaxy? . .3 6.3 Tidal and turbulent compression . 15 3.2 Small and compact? . .5 3.3 Dark matter-free? . .5 7 In gas-rich, clumpy galaxies 16 3.4 Relaxed? . .5 3.5 Hosting a simple population? . .6 8 Globular clusters: formation at high redshift 17 3.6 Is there a definition? . .6 8.1 Uncertainties on the ages, and bi- modalities . 17 4 Cluster mass function 6 8.2 Formation in dark matter halos . 18 8.3 Formation in wet mergers . 18 8.4 Multiphase collapse . 18 II Formation 8 8.5 In situ formation and accretion . 19 5 Resolved star formation, hints from local 9 Nuclear clusters and their connection with arXiv:1801.04278v1 [astro-ph.GA] 12 Jan 2018 galaxies 8 ultra-compact dwarf galaxies 19 5.1 Molecular clouds, star formation and 9.1 Two and a half formation scenarios . 20 feedback . .8 5.2 The role of the environment . 10 9.2 Ultra compact dwarf galaxies . 20 5.3 Arms and inter-arm regions . 12 5.4 Cloud-cloud collisions, tips of the bar . 13 III Evolution 21 Email address: [email protected] (Florent Renaud) 10 Collisional systems 21 Preprint submitted to New Astronomy Reviews January 16, 2018 11 Modelling dense stellar systems 22 fade. There is now a strong need to merge the two 11.1 A numerical challenge . 22 and build a more holistic picture of star clusters within 11.2 Accounting for the environment . 24 their galactic and cosmological environments. How- ever, bridging the gap between previously distinct fields 12 Dynamical friction 24 of research is a demanding task. With this review, I aim to draw a picture of our current knowledge and under- 13 Adiabatic, secular tides 25 standing of this topic, by focussing on the multi-scale 13.1 Tidal radii and Jacobi surface . 25 and multi-physics aspects of the question and the cou- 13.2 Potential escapers and kinematics in the pling between the two sides of this coin. This fields outer regions . 26 being vast, technical aspects and details on the results 13.3 Stellar streams . 28 presented here are often skipped, and I strongly encour- 13.4 Evolution in a fixed, isolated galaxy . 29 age the reader to consult the studies mentioned and the 13.4.1 Constant tides: circular orbits . 30 references therein. This contribution could not be more 13.4.2 Time-varying tides: the exam- than a mere starting point to explore a field too rich and ple of eccentric orbits . 31 diverse to make an exhaustive review of it. 13.4.3 In non-axisymmetric, barred The focus being on the link between the clusters and potentials . 32 their galactic and cosmological context, it does not ad- dress the topics of internal cluster physics and their stel- 14 Tidal shocks 32 lar populations in details, nor the state of the art on the 14.1 Disc crossing . 32 observational side of the subject. I encourage the reader 14.2 Passages of spiral arms . 33 to explore complementary reviews on these topics, in 14.3 High speed encounters with clouds . 33 particular in 15 Evolution in cosmological context 35 • Naab and Ostriker (2017): galaxy formation 15.1 Adiabatic growth . 35 15.2 Accretion of satellite galaxies . 35 • Hennebelle and Falgarone (2012): turbulence of 15.3 Interacting galaxies and major mergers . 36 the interstellar medium 15.4 Full cosmological context . 36 • Krumholz (2014): star formation • IV Open questions 37 Brodie and Strader (2006): formation of extra- galactic clusters, mainly from an observational per- 16 Are YMCs young globular clusters? 37 spective • Charbonnel (2016): multiple stellar populations 17 Zone of avoidance 39 • Portegies Zwart et al. (2010) and Adamo and Bas- 18 Maximum cluster mass and star formation tian (2015): young massive clusters rate 39 • Heggie and Hut (2003) and Vesperini (2010): in- 19 The halo mass - cluster mass relation 40 ternal dynamics of clusters 20 The role of globular clusters in reionization 42 • Aarseth (2003): N-body simulations of clusters. 21 And many more ... 43 The interested reader could also compare our current understanding of this field with the challenges identified more than a decade ago by Davies et al. (2006), and Part I even confront the timeline they proposed for progress in each domain to what actually happened... Introduction In this introduction, I set the stage for this review, list a few possible definitions of star clusters, and highlight 1. Outline, framework and objectives connections with dwarf galaxies. The second part ad- dresses our theoretical understanding of star cluster for- Over the last years, the boundary between the fields mation in different galactic environments, in the Milky of galaxy formation and stellar populations started to Way, in interactions and mergers, in the local Universe, 2 at high redshift etc. The main focus of this part is the to propose holistic theories. Yet, significant progresses physical phenomena responsible for the accumulation on individual concepts have been made in the last few of star forming dense gas, and the first Myr of the re- decades, and coupling several aspects together is now sulting stars clusters, until they become gas-free. I also routinely achieved in theories, simulations and interpre- propose short incursions in the neighbour topics of nu- tation of observations. By focussing on the interactions clear clusters and ultra-compact dwarf galaxies. The between clusters and their galactic context, I will high- third part concerns the evolution of gas-free clusters, fo- light here some of these progresses and pin down a few cussing on the effects of the galactic and cosmological possible directions for future research. environment but leaving aside most of the cluster inter- nal physics. I address here the processes modifying the orbits of clusters, like dynamical friction, and the tidal 3. What is a star cluster? effects (adiabatic and impulsive) that alter their proper- ties. Finally, I identify in the last part a few open ques- This section gives the general tone of this review: tions on these topics, the state of the art and why they asking a simple question and showing that the complex- still keep us puzzled. ity of the problem still causes a (frustrating but exciting) lack of definite answer. 2. A multi-scale and multi-physics topic Until about a decade ago, star clusters in general and globulars in particular were considered as simple Many introductions of papers and proposals about (and sometimes bland) objects, made of gravitationally star clusters would tell you they are the building blocks bound stars sharing a common origin. However, the im- of galaxies, that most if not all stars form in clusters provements in observational resources and techniques and that globular clusters have witnessed all steps in the allowing us to deeper probe these objects and study the evolution of their host. Yet, the formation and evolu- composition of their stars, and this in an always widen- tion of star clusters remains a poorly known topic. The ing range of environments, have revealed a much more reason for this situation probably lies in the multi-scale complex picture. Up to the point that, today, there is and multi-physics nature of the field. Star clusters form no clear definition of what a star cluster is. More than in dense gas clouds, of which assembly is triggered, just semantics (or our urge to sort the Universe), the set and regulated by galactic-scale hydrodynamics, it- underlying question is to establish whether star clusters self influenced by the inter-galactic and cosmological and galaxies follow comparable physical formation pro- environment. Once formed, stars in clusters alter the cesses, and to which extend parallels can be drawn be- morphology, energy and chemistry of their nurseries tween theses classes of objects. through stellar feedback. Details on the injection of feedback are set by stellar evolution and depends on the clustering of star formation, the presence of binary and 3.1. Bound and part of a galaxy? multiple stars, the metallicity etc.