Wv Lrs Urnau Uhrjt U,Hc ,Tu Uhbc ,T Vumh Rat Ignk Uh,Gsh Hf E E M M M M

Wv Lrs Urnau Uhrjt U,Hc ,Tu Uhbc ,T Vumh Rat Ignk Uh,Gsh Hf E E M M M M

e e e e s s s s A SERIES IN HALACHA t"yhka skparhv lurc r"vun ,tn n n n n e e ,nab hukhgk e e xyhhv sbkchke lurc ohhj ,ryg kkuf atr LIVING A “TORAH” DAY LIVING A “TORAH” DAY p p TO SUBSCRIBE p p x x ovrct wr x x e e e e are the same. In Igros Moshe (1) , he says that the issur is only if one AND RECEIVE THIS ktuna ;xuh "okuf sdbf vru, sunk,u" - The Greatest Mitzvah of All (149) O O TORAH SHEET WEEKLY. O O Teaching a Gentile Torah. In our society a number of modern intends to give the knowledge over to a gentile, but if one is R R wr ic rykt R R E E E E Z Z WWW.TORAHTAVLIN.ORG k"z whcuy Z Z day dilemmas have come up regarding teaching Torah to gentiles. targeting Yidden and gentiles happen to listen, it is not prohibited. t t t t a a OR SEND AN EMAIL TO tahr u,hgru a a l l l l Case One: College Campus Classes. People who organize He compares this to the issur of teaching an eved (slave) Torah and e e wr ,c kjr e e o o TORAHTAVLIN@ Monsey o o r r ovrct r r still the Sages spoke freely in front of Tevi (famous slave of s s kiruv classes for Jewish students on college campuses have s s i i YAHOO.COM Edition i i Y Y v"g vnka Y Y Rabban Gamliel ) (2) . In Mishna Halachos (3) , R’ Menashe Klein z z z z posed the following question: Even though they target Jewish t t t t e e e e r r r r students, they have no way to stop gentile students from entering bases this psak on the many Rishonim who wrote seforim in E E E E n n n n i i i i their classrooms. This happens often and they have asked if they Arabic even though this enabled gentiles to learn Torah concepts. s s s s o o o o Lifnei Iver. R’ Moshe in that second teshuva explains and proves h h h h can continue their class when a gentile enters to listen. s s s s u u u u r r r r Case Two: Children Without Yichus in Classrooms. Certain that Lifnei Iver is only if one interacts with the one who will G G G G d d stumble and sin. However, if one does his own justified activity d d schools that have frum teachers teaching, have students whose n n n n a a 10:02 - t"rdvkqvkhp, inz ;ux | 9:13 - t"rdv q gna ,thre inz | 8:37 - t"n q gna ,thre inz | 4:19 - ,ca ,urb ,eksv a a mothers went through worthless Conservative or Reform and the other finds a way to sin from it, this is not Lifnei Iver. s s s s o o 5:49 - o, ubhcrk q f"vtm | 5:27 - ohcfufv ,tm e"amun | 4:37 - asue ,ca vnjv ,ghea | 12:11 - vkusd vjbn ,khp,k inz o o n n n n oreyofcourtesy myzmanim.com conversions. Those children are not Jewish and are sitting in the u u *********************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************************** u u g g g g A A A A class with Jewish children who are being taught Torah . Is the - Nidah 23a , , , , lhjd tku lhjhd hshk trhz wrk vhnrh hcr uthcv itf sg m m obhnzvk ovhkt ouek tk ,uchxu ohngy hbhn kf uk vhva ,urnk ovrct m m i i i i Rashi d d d d teacher allowed to teach Torah in such a case? explains that R’ Yirmiyah tried numerous times to make R’ Zeira m m wv tca vbhfav hbp ,kce gmntc vhv hrv hf 'o,ueavku okhftvk o,raku m m a a a a l l l l Case Three: At a Family Pesach Seder. A Baal Teshuva laugh but was unsuccessful. This is due to the halacha ostk ruxt" e e kf ogu 'vhryp tbnjrs wxubtw uvhrv vkuju 'u,khnk hahkav ouhc uhkjn ureck wv lrs urnau uhrjt u,hc ,tu uhbc ,t vumh rat ignk uh,gsh hf e e M M M M f f Yeshiva R’ Moshe Feinstein zt”l ,t kcek .tu vbhfav hbpn ucaun ouenn ,uzhrzc oe tkt kmg,b tk vz ,uzhrz lu,n wv ,sucg - (yh-jh) wypanu vesm ,uagk f f student once asked the "euja uhp tknha, and R’ Zeira was very stringent with this. o o o o s s s s following question: He is returning home for Pesach and will The ,uhj ."rvn writes, a few times in Shas we see R’ Yirmiyah trying e e aka hrvnw :vrak vum ohcu,fv lanvcu 'wudu o,trek .rhu trhuw a"nf 'uhjrut rat ignk 'uh,gsh vnku /urhfnu ugsuhu ukmt ucren ostv ,t ccjnvaw :h"art e e i i i i l l l l i i i i lead the Seder in his home, explaining things to his family and unsuccessfully to make R’ Zeira laugh. Once R’ Yirmiyah was m m /wovrct .r recv$ktuw o,rak unmgc rvhn cuau (z euxp) w,kx jne ohtx vfuz 'ubhct ovrct vnutv hct /f"g whfrs runak hkg uhbc ,t vumn tuva hpk vumh m m a a a a f f f f relatives. One non-religious relative will have a non-Jewish excessively cheerful in front of R’ Zeira (:k ,ufrc) and R’ Zeira quoted s s fh,a vshegc ot ,uumnk u,nsevu u,nfav kg ohtkn ,utren ubtmn if od tkt 'uh,uumn ,t runah rat sckc uz tka uhkg gsuh hf uhkg shgn v"cevu s s p p p p l l l l e e Seder k"r Haggada Torah recc ovrct ofahuw :lf rjt shnu whbbvw rntu vbg vshegv kg wv huuhm og 'ypanu vesm ,uagk wv lrs ,t runak uhrjt uh,urus ,tu uhbc ,t lbjhu shngh e e spouse at the , . Can he explain the and to him: "r,In vhvh cmg kfc" (df:sh hkan) - “in all sorrow, there is profit.” h h h h y y y y l l - vntv ic ,t ardha vra vrnta ,gc ifu (d cf erp) wurunj ,t acjhu hbhgc rahvu cuyv vagh ot ostu ost kf hshc vhumn vrhjcv hrv 'thauev ,ktab l l concepts to the Jews at the table, when the gentile will hear? Another time (:df c"c) R’ Yirmiyah asked such a farfetched question to p p p p m m m m i i v"cev uk rnt vbc ejmh og arh tk hf ejmn u,ut v,tra rjtk ktgnah tuc ory sug ubhct ovrct kg vru, vshgn lhtv if otu 'lphvv ouka xj ut 'oav i i Case Four: Publicizing Torah in Mass Media. Around 60 years elicit a smile, that he was actually asked to leave the Beis Medrash ! s s s s t t t t a a ojk jehu recc ovrct ofahuw shn wvkuec gna vra lhkt rnt, rat kfw lrs ,t urnah ignk uh,urus hrusu uh,urus ,tu uhbc ,t vumh ifta 'okugk ejmh ubc a a ago, a famous Talmid Chacham began saying a Daf Yomi shiur rbk lurg asks, if it is assur to fill one’s mouth with laughter, why wasn’t h h h h t t t t y y ratf hf /(sh tf erp) wvjkahu skhv ,tu vnfa kg oa rdv kt i,hu ohn ,nju lt ',uagvk sh,ga vn kf gsuh atrn ,urusv true wva yuap rcsva odv 'wv y y on the radio. His intention was for Yidden to listen and learn, but of R’ Yirmiyah shpen? He answers that the rvuz says (also brought in t t t t i i i i r r r r a a hn ,t cvuta vkdnu vtrn tuv vjnacu ,uzhrzc ,uumnv ,t vaug ostv /kfav rxun ubnn snkb ignk ,tz c,fbu ,hjmb thv vru,v a a course gentiles could and would listen. The question was asked v"p ,ufrc 'vbuh ubhcr) that euja is permitted in vru, hrcs. R’ Zeira h h h h c c vumnv ouhe inzk vpmnu ih,nn ,g kfcu shn uvaug if kgu u,uagk uvuuma 'ejmh ,shk kg ohftknv ,ruac osue ,tzv vbugcu ,gc vbvs 'vtrb ,tz cahk c c however was makpid even during this time. says similarly that e e t"cyhr e e whether this is permitted. There are two parts to the question - h h h h T T ostvaf if tk at hparcu ,ucvk,vc unhhen vumnv ,g tcafu vzg veua,c ohrfhb uhva hpk 'wv lrs ,t runak u,hc ,t ovrct vumh ratw ,t trucv gsh rcf T T Gemara - - we often see in the we open with "t,ujhscs t,khn" but R’ - - whether one has transgressed the issur of teaching a gentile Torah m m tuv kuga vnf vtrn sa utpfa hnf ,ukmgcu ,ushcfc uhkg chujnv ,t vaug rutc ubgnk uapb ,t rxn rat sckn 'ohdkpun oav ,cvt hbnhx ovrct kmt m m Zeira was trnujk dvub and that is what Rashi means when he said wru" o o o o and if this is also “Lifnei Iver” by causing a gentile to do what he c c c c . s s ubhct ovrctu /ann vhpfc o,ut vaug lfhpk vuuymb vhv tka htukvu ukhcac urcgc lkvu srpbu 'ohbu,j,c u,ueukt ,t oxrpa iuatrv vhv tuv ;tu 'ohsaf s s "hpy rhnjn trhz.

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    2 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us