04/12/2012 SUPPLEMENTARY LIST SUPPLEMENTARY LIST FOR TODAY IN CONTINUATION OF THE ADVANCE LIST ALREADY CIRCULATED. THE WEBSITE OF DELHI HIGH COURT IS www.delhihighcourt.nic.in INDEX PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENTS----------> J-1 TO J-2 REGULAR MATTERS --------------------> R-1 TO R-35 FINAL MATTERS (ORIGINAL SIDE) ------> F-1 TO F-11 ADVANCE LIST------------------------> 1 TO 78 APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)-> 79 TO 88 (FIRST PART) APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)-> 89 TO 96 (SECOND PART) COMPANY ----------------------------> 97 TO 98 SECOND SUPPLEMENTARY----------------> 99 TO 106 ORIGINAL SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY I)-----> 107 TO 114 THIRD SUPPLEMENTARY-----------------> -- TO -- NOTES 1. Following directions are issued by Hon'ble DB-II in urgent mentioning matters w.e.f. 14.10.2011: i) No urgent mentioning shall be entertained, except at 10.30 A.M. ii)Urgent mentioning shall be entertained only in respect of matters of Detention and Personal Liberty and matters which cannot brook delay till the normal next day of listing. It has further been directed by Hon'ble DB-II that urgent mentioning shall be entertained only in such cases which are accompanied by duly filled in “Form For Urgent (Mentioning) Cases For Listing/Accommodation” in duplicate. Such forms can be obtained from window No. 4 of the Filing Counter with effect from 24th November 2011. A Specimen of the form is available on the website under the heading “Download”. DELETIONS 1. CM 4907/2012 in LPA 190/2010 listed before Hon'ble DB-I at item No.26 is deleted as CM 4907/2012 is wrongly shown in the Cause list. 2. MAT.APP. 67/2012 listed before Hon'ble Ms. Justice Veena Birbal at item No.23 is deleted as the same is returned to Filing Counter for removal of office objections. 3. MAC.APP. 877/2012 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice G.P.Mittal at item No.16 is deleted as the same is fixed for 08.01.2012 before Registrar(Original). NOMINATED/STANDING COUNSEL BAR COUNCIL OF INDIA MR. ASHISH AGGARWAL OFF.: B-29, SAGAR APARTMENTS 6, TILAK MARG, NEW DELHI-110001 PH.: 23071060, 23389195 MOB.: 9810077771, 9717077771 CIRCULAR In continuation of Circular bearing F.No. 365/e-court/Comp./DHC/No. 545 dated 03.08.2012, all concerned are hereby informed that the facility of providing digitized data of the cases(except the orders part) to the Advocates appearing in e-Courts, free of charge is further extended till 31st March 2013. All concerned are requested to submit their application for supply of digital copy of the cases pending in the e-Courts of Delhi High Court in the set format alongwith the CDs/DVDs to the Court Master of the Court where the matter is listed for hearing who in turn will forward the same to the Portfolio Department. The CDs/DVDs containing the digital data can be collected from the concerned Court Masters. Only those Advocates who have already filed the Vakalatnama will be entitled to apply for the digital copy. REGISTRAR[LISTING] 04.12.2012 J-1 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENTS (APPLT. JURISDICTION) COURT NO. 1 (DIVISION BENCH-1) HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW AT 10:30 AM 1. LPA 705/2012 SUDESH SOLANKI N.S. DALAL CM APPL.18030/2012 VS. DELHI DEVELOPMENT DEVESH PRATAP SINGH AUTHORITY PAWAN MATHUR 2. LPA 872/2010 SHARP KABUSHIKI KAISHA AKHIL SIBAL CM APPL. 21976/2010 VS. SUNIL GROVER A.A. MOHAN & ORS SUSHANT SINGH P.C. ARYA GEETIKA KAPUR GEETA LUTHRA HARI NARAYAN TAKKAR ASHLY CHERIAN 3. LPA 751/2012 BHAGIRATH CHAUDRI RICHA KAPOOR (DECD.) THR. LRs. SANGEETA CHANDRA VS. DELHI DVELOPMENT AUTHORITY 4. LPA 739/2012 VENKATESHWAR EDUCATION RAJIV NAYAR CM APPL.18965/2012 & MEDICAL SOCIETY (REGD.) GAURAV MITRA CM APPL.18966/2012 VS. DELHI DEVELOPMENT SAURABH SETH CM APPL.18967/2012 AUTHORITY SHIVASHANKAR PANICKER VINEET KUMAR SAMREEN SHOBHANA TAKIAR COURT NO. 4 (DIVISION BENCH-4) HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP NANDRAJOG HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN SINGH AT 10:30 AM 1. RFA(OS) 40/2011 M/S RUBFILA INTERNATIONAL V. MOHANA LTD. ARUN BIRBAL VS. ALOK GUPTA 2. RFA(OS) 110/2011 AJIT SINGH GILL & ORS S.M. HASHMI VS. ARVIND KHOSLA & ORS P.K. AGARWAL GURVINDER SINGH 04.12.2012 J-2 PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENTS (APPLT. JURISDICTION) COURT NO. 34 EXTENSION BLOCK (SECOND FLOOR) HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.V.EASWAR AT 2:15PM 1.W.P(C)14076/2009 MEINHARDT SINGAPORE PTE LTD C.S.AGGARWAL VS. ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF PRAKASH KUMAR INCOME TAX,CIRCLE 3(1) SANJEEV SABHARWAL INTERNATIONAL TAXATION PUNEET GUPTA NEW DELHI 2.W.P(C)14077/2009 MEINHARDT SINGAPORE PTE LTD C.S.AGGARWAL VS. ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF PRAKASH KUMAR INCOME TAX,CIRCLE 3(1) SANJEEV SABHARWAL INTERNATIONAL TAXATION PUNEET GUPTA NEW DELHI 3.W.P(C)14085/2009 MEINHARDT SINGAPORE PTE LTD C.S.AGGARWAL VS. ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF PRAKASH KUMAR INCOME TAX,CIRCLE 3(1) SANJEEV SABHARWAL INTERNATIONAL TAXATION PUNEET GUPTA NEW DELHI 4.W.P(C)14096/2009 MEINHARDT SINGAPORE PTE LTD C.S.AGGARWAL VS. ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF PRAKASH KUMAR INCOME TAX,CIRCLE 3(1) SANJEEV SABHARWAL INTERNATIONAL TAXATION PUNEET GUPTA NEW DELHI COURT NO. 30 EXTENSION BLOCK (FIRST FLOOR) HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.K. PATHAK AT 10:30 AM 1. CRL.A. 270/2012 CHUNMAN @ AKASH RAVI CHATURVEDI VS. STATE OF NCT FIZANI HUSSAIN OF DELHI HIGH COURT OF DELHI 03RD DECEMBER, 2012 REGISTRAR (LISTING) 04.12.2012 R- 1 ( Regular Matters) 04.12.2012 REGULAR MATTERS COURT NO. 1 (DIVISION BENCH-1) HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW [NOTE I: COUNSELS ARE REQUESTED TO PAGINATE THEIR FILES IN CONFORMITY WITH THE COURT FILE IN ADVANCE]. NOTE II: COUNSELS ARE REQUESTED TO PROVIDE LIST OF BOOKS/ACTS ON WHICH THEY ARE RELYING IN ADVANCE]. NOTE III: IN REGULAR MATTERS & FINAL HEARING MATTERS , THE PARTIES SHOULD KEEP READY,SHORT SYNOPSIS RUNNING INTO NOT MORE THAN 3 PAGES EACH. NOTE IV: PART-II WILL BE TAKEN UP ON THURSDAY ONLY.] PART-I REGULAR MATTERS NO.2,36,40,45,46----DISPOSED OF NO.43 .LPA 135/2008,NO.44 .LPA 151/2008---FOR 11.12.12 IN ANMM NO.47. LPA 511/2010----FOR 28.1.13 IN ANMM 1 . LPA 190/2010 SESAME FOODS PVT LTD ANUBHAV SINGHVI,ATUL CM APPL. 4907/2010 Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS NANDA,MUKESH ANAND,ARVIND NO.1/SUB TO O/N PH KUMAR,RUCHI KAUSHIK,SATISH AGGARWAL 3. LPA 169/2012 UNION OF INDIA AND ORS ASHWANI BHARDWAJ,V LAKSHMI NO.1 Vs. COMPETITION COMMISSION OF KUMARAN INDIA AND ORS 4 . W.P.(C) 859/2008------| G.D.BUILDTECH P.LTD. J.K.MITTAL,MUKESH ANAND TOP Vs. UOI TAX/VIRES | 5 . W.P.(C) 1342/2008 | YFC PROJECTS P.LTD. J.K.MITTAL, ZEBA TOP Vs. UOI KHAN, MUKESH ANAND, TAX/VIRES | SUNIL UPADHYAY 6 . W.P.(C) 4116/2008 | VISTAR CONSTRUCTIONS (P) LTD J.K.MITTAL AND CO.,MUKESH TOP Vs. U.O.I ANAND,SONIA MATHUR TAX/VIRES | 7 . W.P.(C) 822/2008 | G.D.BUILDERS J.K.MITTAL,SONIA SHARMA,H.C. VIRES/ TOP | Vs. UOI AND ANR BHATIA,MUKESH ANAND 8 . W.P.(C) 6058/2008 | SKYLINE ENGINEERING CONTRACTS VINEET BHATIA,ANJANA GOSAIN CM APPL. 11712/2008 | (INDIA) LTD. CM APPL. 8236/2010 | Vs. U.O.I AND ORS TOP TAX/VIRES | 9 . W.P.(C) 72/2009 | M/S DLF LAING O' ROURKE V. LAKSHMI KUMARAN,MUKESH TOP (INDIA) LTD. ANAND,SONIA MATHUR | Vs. UOI AND OTHERS 10. W.P.(C) 663/2009 | M/S POOJA MARBLES V. LAKSHMI KUMARAN,SONIA TOP Vs. UOI AND ORS SHARMA,MUKESH ANAND 11. W.P.(C) 685/2009 | WIG BROTHERS CONSTRUCTION V. LAKSHMI KUMARAN,MUKESH TOP PVT. LTD. ANAND,HC BHATIA,SONIA SHARMA | Vs. UOI AND ORS. 12. W.P.(C) 7672/2009 | JAI JAI RAM SINGH V.LAKSHI KUMARAN,SONIA TOP Vs. UOI AND ORS. SHARMA,MUKESH ANAND 13. W.P.(C) 10831/2009 | WIG BROTHERS CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD. V.LAKSHMI KUMARAN,MUKESH TOP Vs. UOI AND ORS. ANAND,SONIA SHARMA 14. W.P.(C) 448/2010 | M/S POOJA MARBLES TARUN JAIN,SONIA TOP Vs.UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS MATHUR,MUKESH ANAND 15 .W.P.(C) 5666/2010-----| M/S ALKARMA PUNEET AGARWAL,HC BHATIA, CM APPL. 11155/2010 Vs. UOI AND ORS MUKESH ANAND TOP 04.12.2012 R- 2 ( Regular Matters) 16 .W.P.(C) 4107/2008-----| G.D.BUILDERS J.K.MITTAL AND CO.,MUKESH TOP Vs. UOI AND ANR. ANAND,HC BHATIA TAX | 17 .W.P.(C) 10226/2009 | RAJ FURNITURE S.K. SARWAL,MUKESH ANAND TOP Vs. UOI TAX/VIRES | 18 .W.P.(C) 4127/2008 | CLARION PROPERTIES LTD. J.K.MITTAL AND CO.,HC BHATIA, TOP Vs. UOI AND ORS. MUKESH ANAND,SONIA SHARMA 19 .W.P.(C) 4658/2008 | VIPUL LIMITED J.K.MITTAL,HC BHATIA, TOP Vs. UOI AND ANR SONIA SHARMA 20 .W.P.(C) 5046/2008 | UNITECH LIMITED J.K.MITTAL,SONIA SHARMA,MUKESH TOP Vs. UOI AND ORS ANAND,HC BHATIA 21 .W.P.(C) 6924/2008 | ANS CONSTRUCTIONS LTD J.K.MITTAL,H.C. BHATIA,MUKESH TOP Vs. U.O.I AND ANR ANAND,SONIA SHARMA 22 .W.P.(C) 155/2009 | M/S AHLUWALIA CONTRACTS (I) LTD. S.K. SARWAL,MUKESH ANAND,H.C. TOP Vs. UOI AND ORS. BHATIA 23 .W.P.(C) 401/2009 | SIMPLEX INFRASTRUCTURE LTD. J.K. MITTAL,H.C. TOP Vs. UOI AND ORS. BHATIA,MUKESH ANAND 24 .W.P.(C) 4057/2010 | SIMPLEX INFRASTRUCTURE LTD JK MITTAL,H.C.