eTropic 16.2 (2017): ‘Bold Women Write Back’ Special Issue | 94 Reading Three Stories of Palm Island Leigh Dale University of Wollongong Abstract After briefly introducing Palm Island and its history as a place of punishment for Indigenous people, this essay looks at how readers respond to three books about Palm: Thea Astley’s The Multiple Effects of Rainshadow (1996), Chloe Hooper’s The Tall Man (2008), and Cathy McLennan’s Saltwater (2016). Using reviews posted by contributors to Goodreads, I investigate the colocation of terms which recur in positive reviews, in search of a specific form of reading, described here as “absorption.” Against the publishing and broader cultural conventions which differentiate fiction from non-fiction, the evidence shows that readers who describe themselves as having become absorbed tend also to praise these books for their truth, regardless of genre. The essay proposes some points of reference for thinking about the reading experience, and concludes by briefly noting the limits of using of genre in marketing, reviewing, and studying books. The essay is built on an awareness of the radical imbalance in the distribution of literacy in the region these books depict. The mainly Aboriginal “settlement” of Palm Island was “established” in 1918, after a cyclone on 10 March that year smashed apart a similar community at Hull River (near Mission Beach). Some in Queensland, notably then “Protector” J.D. Bleakley, had wanted an island prison for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and ensured land was set aside in 1914 (Watson, 2010, p. 32). The cyclone and its aftermath accelerated the decision: those at Hull River who had not been killed (or just disappeared) were forcibly rounded up and sent to Palm. Strangely enough, this meant that some were returning home (Watson, 2010, p. 35), “most of the people” on Palm Island having been “removed to Hull River settlement” in 1912.1 Between 1918 and 1972, there were almost 4,000 such “removals,” mainly from Queensland, but also from the Northern Territory and the Torres Strait: “Fear of being removed to Palm Island, from which there was little chance of escape, were passed down through generations of Indigenous people in Queensland” (Watson, 2010, p. 38, 36). For those who had always been there, the history of kidnapping and exile from Palm had begun even earlier, in 1883, when eight men and women were seized and forced to become 1 “Establishment of Palm Island,” corflute poster, Indigenous Knowledge Centre, Palm Island, Queensland. I thank the IKC for permission to take notes from these sources. eTropic 16.2 (2017): ‘Bold Women Write Back’ Special Issue | 95 performers in Barnum, Bailey and Hutchinson’s “Greatest Show on Earth” (Watson, 2010, p. 29).2 Historian Henry Reynolds, a long-time resident of nearby regional centre Townsville, has called it “an island Siberia”: “If you had set out to create a community with problems, if that had been your specific intention, you couldn’t have done better than the Queensland government did, inadvertently, on Palm Island” (Special Broadcasting Service, 1993). Yet, as Watson is at pains to point out, Palm Island is also one of Australia’s largest Indigenous communities (see also Hooper, 2008, p. 12); for many people, it is home. The three books I discuss here consider life on Palm Island in the context of its twentieth- century history, as prison, naval base, mission, administrative showpiece, and holiday resort, as well as being home to Indigenous people from 57 different cultural and linguistic backgrounds.3 The first of these books is a novel by Thea Astley, one of Australia’s most famous writers. The Multiple Effects of Rainshadow (Astley, 1996) was shortlisted for the Miles Franklin Award, perhaps Australia’s most prestigious literary prize, in 1997, and won the Age newspaper’s Book of the Year. The title refers literally to the “rainshadow” that affects the Townsville region (Healy, 2016).4 But “rainshadow” is also a metaphor: shadows get longer, they shift, they deepen and make it hard to see; violence leaves “shadows” in hearts and minds and voices. The violence Astley writes about is based on two events, one in 1930, the second in 1957. In 1930 Robert Curry (sometimes Currie), a former army officer who was superintendent of the settlement, killed then incinerated his children, blew up some buildings and a boat, shot and wounded the island’s doctor and the doctor’s wife, then was himself shot and died, events described in detail in a series of stories in the Townsville Daily Bulletin.5 In 1957, a strike by Indigenous residents—who kept the settlement immaculate, and produced its food—was broken when a police contingent smashed down doors and took seven strikers away in chains, afterwards exiling them and their families to other “settlements” across Queensland.6 Like the shadows of a moving object, violence and exile pivot and spin: exiled 2 “1918 Hull River Removals,” corflute poster, Indigenous Knowledge Centre, Palm Island, Queensland. Another poster (among 33 depicting the history of the island) shows a picture of eight Aboriginal women and men posing for a photograph in a San Francisco studio in 1892. 3 Elsewhere this figure is given as 40; it derives from the “national survey” conducted in 1938 and 1939 by Norman Tindale and Joseph Birdsell, which aimed to collect genealogies from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples living on missions and “settlements” (or reserves, effectively, open air prisons) across Australia. Information from corflute posters, Indigenous Knowledge Centre, Palm Island. 4 I thank Mary Vernon for bringing this to my attention, by explaining the weather patterns and geography of the region. 5 See “Palm Island Sensation” (1930), and “The Palm Island Tragedy a Terrible Affair” (1930). Subsequent stories give details on the violence that had already occurred, as part of the coverage of the Inquiry into the killings by Curry (February), the arrest and charging of several persons in relation to Curry’s death (April), their trials (June), and the collapse of the charges (August), all from the National Library of Australia’s Australian Newspaper Database, http://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/ (search “Robert Curry”). Astley clearly had read these news stories, and/or Joanne Watson’s 1993 PhD (Watson, 1993); see also “The 1930 Rampage: ‘As Straight as a Gun Barrel’ “ (Watson, 2010, pp. 55– 75). 6 Descriptions of these events, along with photographs that confirm that the “settlement” had a military neatness, gardens and carefully swept dirt streets marked out by rows of lime-washed rocks, are in the corflute posters at the Island’s Indigenous Knowledge Centre. eTropic 16.2 (2017): ‘Bold Women Write Back’ Special Issue | 96 to, exiled from Palm, Indigenous people are blamed for violence they have usually been victims of. Thea Astley shows her characters struggling with history, how to remember it. Her character Mr Vine, an English teacher, writes about the problem in a letter to a former student, Normie Cooktown, whose consciousness is the narrative centre of the novel: There was a time, Vine wrote, I felt deeply about something—someone, actually— and I put that down, all of it, as if it were fiction. Oh, I can’t tell you the pain and hurt of the reality. But after it was written, and the years had passed, I found I couldn’t even remember the faces—the face, to tell the truth—or the words or the events. Not with any clarity, that is. It was as if the whole of that period had lost its reality and become absorbed as fiction and was as fragile and unmemorable as most fiction is. It had ceased to exist. (Astley, 1996, pp. 284–85) I don’t think Astley herself believed fiction is “fragile and unmemorable”—after all, she spent a lot of her life writing it—but I do think she wanted readers to think about how stories can be made to continue, and to resonate, rather than fray and fall apart, becoming illegible. She does that in this novel: helps us to remember, and make us think about memory, by writing fiction. And she uses the word “absorption” to describe the way in which stories become integrated into our bodies, our ways of thinking and speaking. For most people, a well-told story is a better mnemonic or memory tool than a list of facts, but Normie Cooktown is sceptical about what he calls “ ‘Fuckin’ fiction!’ ”: “ ‘Fuckin’ fiction!’ Normie said aloud and bitterly, looking around the crowded shanty he shared with his family, four of them in a room twelve by ten’ (Astley, 1996, p. 285). But if he’s cynical about novels, Normie also realises he has been made stronger by a literary education he hated getting because of his classmates’ racism (pp. 179–80): “It done somethin, his eldest brother Manny said. You can talk to the bastards now. You ain’t scared” (p. 285). Those “bastards” are white people; Bill Congoo, one of the men exiled from Palm Island as a consequence of the strike in 1957, says of the supervisor whose authority he and others were protesting, “he was a Bastard” (Untitled Poster, n.d.). Like The Multiple Effects of Rainshadow (1996), Chloe Hooper’s The Tall Man (2008) deals with a white inhabitant of Palm Island with authority over the community. Senior sergeant Chris Hurley became the first serving police officer in Queensland to be charged with murder, after the death of a Palm Island resident in custody in 2004. Hooper describes the leadup to the death and the aftermath, including the reaction of Palm Island residents to the news that an initial inquiry had found Hurley innocent of any wrong-doing.