Indigenous Research Within the Discipline of Geography: an Evaluation of Three Decades of Graduate Thesis Research in Canada

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`!&-,$),1'! 1/'*'*!GMNO!F,*1'-*!1/'*'*a!ONZ!$(.1(-,4!1/'*'*J!1/-()&/!,!X'70(-$!*',-./!(5!1/'*%*!1%14'*!,#$! ,I*1-,.1*!%#!B-(L)'*1!,#$!1/'!@/'*'*!;,#,$,!B(-1,4!(5!1/'!b%I-,-7!,#$!9-./%:'*!;,#,$,! Gb9;JU!D%#$%#&*!-':',4'$!,#!%#.-',*'!(:'-!1%='!%#!-'*',-./!1(3%.*!1/,1!%#:(4:'$\%=3,.1'$! "#$%&'#()*!3'(34'*U!911'#1%(#!1(!.4%=,1'!./,#&'!,#$!5(($!*'.)-%17!/,*!%#.-',*%#&47!$(=%#,1'$!,*! ,!-'*',-./!1/'='!(:'-!1/'!3,*1!$'.,$'U!L),4%1,1%:'!,#,47*%*!(5!1/'!1/'*'*!0,*!.(#$).1'$!I,*'$!(#! ,#!,**'**='#1!(5!5()-!%#$%.,1(-*8!OJ!,.X#(04'$&'='#1!(5!"#$%&'#()*!3,-1%.%3,#1*!,#$! .(==)#%1%'*a!MJ!%#.4)*%(#!(5!1-,$%1%(#,4!"#$%&'#()*!X#(04'$&'a!_J!,334%.,1%(#!(5!3,-1%.%3,1(-7! ='1/($*a!,#$!cJ!I'#'5%1*!(5!-'*',-./!1(!1/'!.(==)#%17U!D%#$%#&*!-':',4!,!3(*%1%:'!1-'#$!5(-!',./! (5!1/'!%#$%.,1(-*!(:'-!1%='U!d(0':'-A!=)./!-'=,%#*!1(!I'!$(#'!1(!,$:,#.'!$'.(4(#%[,1%(#!0%1/%#! 1/'!$%*.%34%#'U! ! ! !! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! & & ! %%%! @2A%0B#/*5/$/%.-& ! @(!I'&%#!0%1/A!"!0()4$!4%X'!1(!,.X#(04'$&'!1/'!Y,#%'#eX'/f8X,!R,1%(#!,*!1/'!.)*1($%,#*! (5!1/'!4,#$*!,#$!0,1'-*!(#!0/%./!;(#.(-$%,!H#%:'-*%17!%*!4(.,1'$A!,#$!0/'-'!1/%*!-'*',-./!I'&,#U! <%#.'!"!=(:'$!1(!1/'!0'*1!.(,*1!,51'-!5%#%*/%#&!=7!.()-*'*A!,#$!=(*1!(5!1/%*!*1)$7!0,*!.(#$).1'$! 0/%4*1!-'*%$%#&!(#!S,#.():'-!"*4,#$A!>;A!"!,4*(!,.X#(04'$&'!1/,1!"!4%:'!,#$!0(-X!,*!,#!)#%#:%1'$! &)'*1!(#!1/'!1-,$%1%(#,4A!)#.'$'$!1'--%1(-%'*!(5!1/'!<#)#'7=)V0!B'(34'!,#$!1/'!<1[g)=%#)*! B'(34'U!9$$%1%(#,447A!"!0()4$!4%X'!1(!,.X#(04'$&'!,44!D%-*1!R,1%(#*A!"#)%1A!,#$!FK1%*!3'(34'*!%#! ;,#,$,A!,#$!"#$%&'#()*!.(==)#%1%'*!%#!(1/'-!.()#1-%'*A!(#!0/(*'!4,#$*!1/'!&-,$),1'!*1)$%'*! 'V,=%#'$!%#!1/%*!-'*',-./!0'-'!.(#$).1'$U!2'*3%1'!,!4'&,.7!(5!'V1-,.1%:'!-'*',-./!.(#$).1'$!I7! ()1*%$'-*!%#!=,#7!"#$%&'#()*!.(==)#%1%'*A!0%1/()1!1/'%-!,..'31,#.'A!&)%$,#.'A!*)33(-1A!,#$! /(*3%1,4%17!1/'!:,*1!=,h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b%I-,-7A!5(-!/%*!,**%*1,#.'!%#!=7!-'*',-./A!,#$!i'##%5'-!<-'7A!()-!6-,$),1'!B-(&-,=!9**%*1,#1A!5(-! /'-!.(#1%#)()*!*)33(-1!1/-()&/()1!=7!$'&-''U! !"!0()4$!4%X'!1(!,.X#(04'$&'!1/'!)#.(#$%1%(#,4!*)33(-1!,#$!4(:'!1/,1!=7!4,1'!=(1/'-! 3-(:%$'$!='!,44!1/'*'!7',-*!1(!.(=34'1'!=7!$'&-''U!"1!%*!'V1-'='47!)#5(-1)#,1'!1/,1!$)'!1(!/'-! 1-,&%.!3,**%#&!$)-%#&!1/'!)#h)*1!$(0#%#&!(5!54%&/1!B<!jZM!(#!i,#),-7!^A!MNMN!%#!@'/-,#!*/'!%*!#(! 4(#&'-!3/7*%.,447!,=(#&*1!)*!1(!0%1#'**!1/'!$,7!"!5%#,447!.(=34'1'!1/%*!$'&-''U!"!,=!.'-1,%#!/'-! *3%-%1!0%44!I'!0%1/!='!1(!*)33(-1!='!$)-%#&!=7!$'5'#*'!,*!0'44U!! "!0()4$!4%X'!1(!,.X#(04'$&'!1/'!%--'34,.',I4'!3-'*'#.'!(5!=7!*(#A!Y,7/,#A!0/(!0,*!I(-#! -%&/1!,51'-!"!I'&,#!1/%*!,.,$'=%.!h()-#'7A!0/%./!=(1%:,1'$!='!1(!5%#,447!.(=34'1'!1/%*!$'&-''A! '*3'.%,447!,51'-!1/'!1-,&%.!3,**%#&!(5!=7!=(1/'-!4,*1!7',-U!"!,=!,4*(!:'-7!&-,1'5)4!1(!/%*!=(1/'-A! b%47!d,#A!0/(!$'*3%1'!()-!*'3,-,1%(#!$)-%#&!1/'!4,*1!7',-A!.(#1%#)'$!0%1/!/'-!%#:,4),I4'!*)33(-1! ,#$!,**%*1,#.'!1/-()&/()1!=7!$'&-''U!!! b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kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkO]! ! 4+"67&D8!R)=I'-!(5!=,*1'-e*!,#$!$(.1(-,4!1/'*'*!3'-!7',-kkkkkkkkkkkkkUMO! ! 4+"67&E8!;/,#&'*!%#!#)=I'-!(5!1/'*'*!5(-!Z!$%55'-'#1!*)I?.,1'&(-%'*!GZ?7',-!,&&-'&,1'*J!kUMM! ! 4+"67&F8!9:'-,&'!1(1,4!-,1%#&*!GZ?7',-!,&&-'&,1'*J!kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkUMc! ! 4+"67&G8!9:'-,&'!-,1%#&*!5(-!,.X#(04'$&='#1!*'.1%(#!GZ?7',-!,&&-'&,1'*J!kkkkkkUUUMZ! ! 4+"67&H8!9:'-,&'!-,1%#&*!5(-!1/'!%#.4)*%(#!(5!"#$%&'#()*!X#(04'$&'!GZ?7',-!,&&-'&,1'*J!kM`! ! 4+"67&I8!9:'-,&'!-,1%#&*!5(-!3,-1%.%3,1(-7!,33-(,./'*!GZ?7',-!,&&-'&,1'*J!kkkkkkkMj! ! ! ! J7"+.&C8!R)=I'-!(5!1(1,4!1/'*'*!I7!)#%:'-*%1%'*kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkUMN! ! J7"+.&D8!@/'=,1%.!I-',X$(0#!(5!1(1,4!#)=I'-!(5!*)I?.,1'&(-%'*kkkkkkkkkkkUMM! ! J7"+.&E8!@(1,4!#)=I'-!(5!*1)$%'*!5(.)*'$!(#!',./!"#$%&'#()*!&-()3kkkkkkkkkkMc! ! ! ,"6&C8!2%*1-%I)1%(#!(5!1(1,4!#)=I'-!(5!1/'*'*!I7!3-(:%#.'\1'--%1(-7kkkkkkkkkkUM_! ! ! ! ! ! ( ( ( ( ( ! :%%! )*#$(+,(!""%02*&$*+3#( & & & J@4kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkUU;,#,$%,#!9**(.%,1%(#!(5!6'(&-,3/'-*!

Indigenous Research Within the Discipline of Geography: an Evaluation of Three Decades of Graduate Thesis Research in Canada

Details

Download

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

Support