LISTING OF CITATIONS - ABERDEEN CITY VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE Hearing on 27th June 2018 at 10.00 am in Committee Room 3, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 1 84240/58743 CAFE TEJJ BUSINESS SOLUTIONS LTD T 13,500 13,500 SMITHFIELD ROAD T/A CAFE CREO ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 2 2526/53061 RESTAURANT NOOR AHMED T 58,000 58,000 13 ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 3 2529/54629 RESTAURANT PREMIER TANDOORI LTD O 41,500 41,500 19 ROSE STREET ABERDEEN 4 2529/56061 RESTAURANT PREMIER TANDOORI LTD O 41,500 41,500 19 ROSE STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 5 2657/59033 CAFE PATTERSONS OF ABERDEEN P 24,250 24,250 464 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 6 2664/59076 SHOP NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD P 19,250 19,250 478 UNION STREET PER A C MORRISON & RICHARDS ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 7 2664/62680 SHOP JOHNSONS APPARELMASTER LTD O 19,250 19,250 478 UNION STREET ABERDEEN G L HEARN LIMITED A 8 2668/59075 OFFICE NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD P 49,000 49,000 484 UNION STREET PER A C MORRISON & RICHARDS ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 9 2669/55969 SUPERMARKET SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD T 75,000 75,000 SAINSBURYS LOCAL PER G L HEARN 492 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A 10 2670/58886 CAFE STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD T 40,500 40,500 496 UNION STREET C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 11 2679/63766 SHOP BLACK & LIZARS LTD P 27,250 27,250 510 UNION STREET ABERDEEN J & E SHEPHERD A 12 33185/54643 RESTAURANT MARK CAVANAGH T 18,000 18,000 28 ADELPHI ABERDEEN 13 39276/54966 RESTAURANT THE RESTAURANT GROUP T 82,500 82,500 UNIT 2 T/A CHIQUITO'S QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK PER GERALD EVE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 16/03/2018 Page 1 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 14 39276/62723 RESTAURANT PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED P 82,500 82,500 UNIT 2 QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 15 80932/53427 RESTAURANT TRAGUS GROUP T 79,000 79,000 UNIT 6 PROPERTY DEPARTMENT QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 16 80932/62727 RESTAURANT PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED P 79,000 79,000 UNIT 6 QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 17 38161/62728 RESTAURANT PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED P 56,000 56,000 UNIT 7 QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 18 37010/53024 RESTAURANT THE RESTAURANT GROUP T 85,000 85,000 UNIT 5 T/A FRANKIE & BENNY'S QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK PER GERALD EVE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 19 37010/62726 RESTAURANT PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED P 85,000 85,000 UNIT 5 QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 20 37009/58270 RESTAURANT PIZZA HUT (UK) LTD T 75,000 75,000 UNIT 4 QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN DALTON WARNER DAVIS A 21 37009/62724 RESTAURANT PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED P 75,000 75,000 UNIT 4 QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 22 37008/53448 RESTAURANT TGI FRIDAYS UK LTD T 110,000 110,000 UNIT 3 QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 23 37008/62725 RESTAURANT PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED P 110,000 110,000 UNIT 3 QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 24 3955/56442 SHOP DUNASKIN PROPERTIES LTD P 18,000 18,000 17 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 25 3955/61775 SHOP MARTIN THE NEWSAGENT LTD T 18,000 18,000 17 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 26 3957/64112 SHOP VISIT SCOTLAND T 29,750 29,750 23 UNION STREET PER MARGARET CRAWFORD ABERDEEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A 27 3958/64191 SHOP ELINOR J ANDERSON P 32,500 32,500 25 UNION STREET PER PETERKINS ABERDEEN BURNETT & REID A 16/03/2018 Page 2 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 28 3959/62713 SHOP INSTANT CASH LOANS LTD T 24,500 24,500 27 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 29 3961/54630 SHOP M C LEISURE LTD P 23,000 23,000 31 UNION STREET PER A B ROBB ABERDEEN A B ROBB A 30 3961/58556 SHOP BRITISH HEART FOUNDATION T 23,000 23,000 31 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 31 3962/58559 SHOP AMPLIFON LIMITED T 26,750 26,750 33 UNION STREET ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 32 3976/55492 SHOP POUNDSTRETCHER PROPERTIES LIMITED T 68,500 68,500 43 UNION STREET ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 33 3976/63687 SHOP PRESTIGIC HOLDINGS LIMITED P 68,500 68,500 43 UNION STREET RETIREMENT BENEFITS SCHEME ABERDEEN PER SAM TRUSTEES LIMITED RYDEN LLP A 34 30225/58332 SHOP FIRST ABERDEEN LTD T 25,000 25,000 47 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GVA A 35 30225/59074 SHOP NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD P 25,000 25,000 47 UNION STREET PER A C MORRISON & RICHARDS ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 36 4009/56408 SHOP SCOTTISH MIDLAND CO-OP T 33,500 33,500 49 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 37 4009/61916 SHOP DONGEM SUPPLIES LTD P 33,500 33,500 49 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 38 87635/53067 SHOP CCHG LTD T 27,500 27,500 51 UNION STREET T/A VAPORIZED ABERDEEN CARNDEARG CONSULTANTS T/A PCA A 39 87635/55683 SHOP FLOWER OF SCOTLAND LTD P 27,500 27,500 51 UNION STREET ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 40 86487/53464 BETTING OFFICE PADDY POWER BOOKMAKERS T 33,000 33,000 53 UNION STREET ABERDEEN GRIFFIN WEBSTER PARTNERSHIP A 41 4011/56500 SHOP GREGGS PLC T 46,000 46,000 55 UNION STREET T/A BAKERS OVEN NORTH ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 16/03/2018 Page 3 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 42 52545/56111 SHOP SPORTSDIRECT.COM RETAIL LTD T 275,000 275,000 57 UNION STREET ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A 43 53996/53046 SHOP POUNDLAND LTD T 156,000 156,000 57 UNION STREET PER GERALD EVE ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 44 54222/52992 RESTAURANT MATTHEW NG & AMY NG P 18,500 18,500 136 CAUSEWAYEND ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 45 54222/56123 RESTAURANT FIRST CLASS DINING LTD T 18,500 18,500 136 CAUSEWAYEND T/A MANCHURIAN ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 46 53463/56035 SUPERMARKET MATTHEW NG & AMY NG P 46,000 46,000 138 CAUSEWAYEND ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 47 4598/53032 RESTAURANT PIZZA EXPRESS (RESTAURANTS) LTD T 33,250 33,250 CABERSTONE HOUSE 47 BELMONT STREET ABERDEEN GERALD EVE LLP A 48 4625/59247 CAFE ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL P 33,000 33,000 24 BELMONT STREET PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 49 38479/55462 RESTAURANT NANDO'S CHICKENLAND LIMITED T 63,500 63,500 UNIT 10 THE ACADEMY BELMONT STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN 50 38745/62092 SHOP JACK WILLS LTD T 57,000 57,000 UNIT 13 THE ACADEMY BELMONT STREET WYMRE A ABERDEEN 51 38481/53037 SHOP COSTA LTD T 15,000 15,000 UNIT 15 THE ACADEMY BELMONT STREET GERALD EVE LLP A ABERDEEN 52 31127/64096 SHOP MR PRETZEL (UK) RETAIL LTD T 29,750 29,750 UNIT 1 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN CVS A 53 31127/64663 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 29,750 29,750 UNIT 1 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 54 31128/58251 SHOP VODAFONE LIMITED T 90,000 90,000 UNIT 2 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A 55 31128/64664 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 90,000 90,000 UNIT 2 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 16/03/2018 Page 4 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 56 31130/59065 SHOP TELEFONICA UK LTD T 118,000 118,000 UNIT 3 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN CLUTTONS LLP A 57 31130/64665 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 118,000 118,000 UNIT 3 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 58 31133/63170 SHOP THE CARPHONE WAREHOUSE T 134,000 134,000 UNIT 4 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN G L HEARN LIMITED A 59 31133/64666 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 134,000 134,000 UNIT 4 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 60 31211/56039 SHOP MONSOON ACCESSORIZE LTD T 264,000 264,000 UNIT 5 & 33 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN CBRE LTD A 61 31211/64667 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 264,000 264,000 UNIT 5 & 33 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 62 31135/56436 SHOP CHISHOLM & HUNTER T 135,000 135,000 UNIT 6 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A 63 31135/64668 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 135,000 135,000 UNIT 6 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 64 31136/62361 SHOP ARCADIA GROUP PLC T 138,000 138,000 UNIT 7 T/A WALLIS FASHION GROUP LTD BON ACCORD CENTRE PER SGP PROPERTY SERVICES LTD ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 65 31136/64669 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 138,000 138,000 UNIT 7 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 66 31137/55896 SHOP SWAROVSKI UK LTD T 111,000 111,000 UNIT 8 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN JONES LANG LASALLE A 67 31137/64670 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 111,000 111,000 UNIT 8 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 68 31138/64671 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 210,000 210,000 UNIT 9 & 10 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 69 31816/61843 SHOP KURT GEIGER T 122,000 122,000 UNIT 11 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 16/03/2018 Page 5 of 45 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 70 31816/64672 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 122,000 122,000 UNIT 11 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 71 33773/64125 SHOP TGFS (THE GOOD FOOD SHOP) LTD T 30,750 30,750 UNIT 12A BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN MONTAGU EVANS A 72 33773/64674 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 30,750 30,750 UNIT 12A BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 73 33506/62509 SHOP RADLEY & CO T 58,000 58,000 UNIT 13 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN FREDERICK HOLT & COMPANY A 74 33506/64675 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD P 58,000 58,000 UNIT 13 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN ERIC YOUNG & CO A 75 33531/63779 SHOP JOJO MAMAN BEBE LIMITED T 57,500 57,500 UNIT 14 BON ACCORD CENTRE ABERDEEN F G BURNETT LTD A 76 33531/64676 SHOP ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE