INTERNET FOR ALL Proceedings of the Third Internet Governance Forum Hyderabad, India 3-6 December 2008 Edited by Don MacLean Файл загружен с http://www.ifap.ru General Table of Contents Message by Sha Zukang, Under-Secretary-General, United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UNDESA) ……………………..i Introduction……………………………………………………………...……….ii Preface ......................................................................................................... 1 Setting the Scene ....................................................................................... 5 Opening Ceremony, 3 December 2008.....................................................6 Opening Session, 3 December 2008.......................................................16 Part 1 – Reaching the Next Billion.............................................................. 34 Chairman’s Summary of the Main Sessions..........................................35 Panel Discussion on Realizing a Multilingual Internet .........................39 Panel Discussion on Access...................................................................50 Open Dialogue on Reaching the Next Billion ........................................67 Reports of Workshops, Best Practice Forums, Open Forums and Dynamic Coalitions ..................................................................................84 Part 2 – Promoting Cyber-security and Trust ........................................... 117 Chairman’s Summary of Main Sessions ..............................................118 Panel Discussion on Dimensions of Cyber-security and Cyber-crime ..................................................................................................................125 Panel Discussion on Fostering Security, Privacy and Openness .....143 Open Dialogue on Promoting Cyber-security and Trust ....................159 Internet for All 04 July 2009 Reports of Workshops, Best Practice Forums and Dynamic Coalitions ..................................................................................................................179 Part 3 – Managing Critical Internet Resources......................................... 206 Chairman’s Summary of the Main Sessions........................................207 Panel Discussion on the Transition from IPv4 to IPv6 .......................213 Panel Discussion on Global, Regional and National Arrangements for Internet Governance...............................................................................229 Open Dialogue on Managing Critical Internet Resources ..................245 Reports of Workshops, Best Practice Forums, Open Forums and Dynamic Coalitions ................................................................................271 Part 4 – Future Challenges and Next Steps............................................. 291 Chairman’s Summary of Main Sessions ..............................................292 Panel Discussion on Emerging Issues.................................................298 Open Dialogue on Taking Stock and the Way Forward......................326 Reports of Workshops, Best Practice Forums, Open Forums and Dynamic Coalitions ................................................................................354 Wrapping Up ........................................................................................... 384 Closing Ceremony, 6 December 2008 ..................................................385 Postscript................................................................................................ 397 2 Internet for All 04 July 2009 Detailed Table of Contents Message by Sha Zukang, Under-Secretary-General, United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UNDESA) ……………………..i The Second IGF book- Markus Kummer ...…………………………….…...…ii The Third IGF:A Further Step from Process to Performance- Nitin Desai.. iv Editor's introduction - Don MacLean…………………………………………..vi Editorial Approach…………………………………………………………….…vi Observations on the Proceedings …………………………………………....vviiii Preface ......................................................................................................... 1 Setting the Scene ......................................................................................... 5 Opening Ceremony, 3 December 2008........................................................6 Opening Session, 3 December 2008 .........................................................16 Part 1 – Reaching the Next Billion.............................................................. 34 Chairman’s Summary of the Main Sessions ..............................................35 Panel on Realizing a Multilingual Internet ..................................................35 Panel on Access: Reaching the Next Billion ..............................................36 Open Dialogue Session..............................................................................37 Panel Discussion on Realizing a Multilingual Internet................................39 Introductory Remarks .................................................................................39 Presentations by the Panelists ...................................................................41 Discussion ..................................................................................................47 Panel Discussion on Access ......................................................................50 Introductory Remarks .................................................................................50 Presentations by the Panelists ...................................................................51 1 Internet for All 04 July 2009 Discussion ..................................................................................................60 Open Dialogue on Reaching the Next Billion .............................................67 Introductory Remarks .................................................................................67 Reports from the Panel Sessions...............................................................68 Discussion ..................................................................................................71 Reports of Workshops, Best Practice Forums, Open Forums and Dynamic Coalitions....................................................................................................84 Realizing a Multilingual Internet .................................................................84 WS 4: Internationalized Domain Names ....................................................84 Dynamic Coalition for Linguistic Diversity ..................................................84 Access........................................................................................................86 WS 2: Challenges Facing Internet Operators in Developing Countries .....86 WS 7: Low-Cost Sustainability Access.......................................................90 WS 9: Including Accessibility and Human Factors in the Universalization of the Internet .................................................................................................93 WS 20: Governance for Gatekeepers ........................................................95 Dynamic Coalition on Accessibility and Disability ......................................97 Content.......................................................................................................98 WS 16: Digital Content Strategies and Policies .........................................98 WS 21: Knowledge as a Global Public Good .............................................99 WS 23: Overcoming Obstacles to Effective Digital Education ...................99 WS 25: Digital Identifiers and IPRs ..........................................................100 BPF 68: Enhanced Internet-Enabled Access and Use of Public Sector Information................................................................................................101 Dynamic Coalition on Freedom of Expression and Freedom of the Media on the Internet ..........................................................................................102 Development and Capacity Building ........................................................103 2 Internet for All 04 July 2009 WS 49: A Development Agenda for Internet Governance: From Principle to Practice.....................................................................................................103 WS 56: The Role of Internet Exchange Points in Creating Internet Capacity and Bringing Autonomy to Developing Nations........................................106 WS 58: Network Neutrality Issues and Implications for Development .....108 WS 60: Capacity Building for Web 2.0 .....................................................111 BPF 62: Internet Governance Capacity Building......................................112 BPF 64: Turkey: A Nation Transforming to Information Society...............115 Part 2 – Promoting Cyber-security and Trust ........................................... 117 Chairman’s Summary of Main Sessions ..................................................118 Dimensions of Cyber-security and Cyber-crime.......................................118 Fostering Security, Privacy and Openness ..............................................120 Open Dialogue Session............................................................................122 Panel Discussion on Dimensions of Cyber-security and Cyber-crime .....125 Introductory Remarks ...............................................................................125 Presentations