THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.SATHYANARAYANAN JUDGMENT TO BE DELIVERED ON FRIDAY THE 29TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2013 AT 2.05 P.M. ( Sitting in His Lordship's Chambers ) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------------ FOR JUDGMENT ~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1. CRP NPD.1215/2005 M/S.PL.NARAYANAN M/S.T.D.VASU S.MAHENDRAN FOR RESPONDENT 2. CRP.109/2007 M/S.A.MUTHUKUMAR M/S.S.SOUNTHAR P.NARESH KUMAR B.JAWAHAR FOR RESPTS. 3. CRP.2043/2007 M/S.R.SUBRAMANIAN CRP.2043/2007 B.RAVI ------------------------------ S.S.RAGHAVAN RR2 TO 11 - GIVEN UP M/S S.JAYAKUMAR G.SRIDHAR FOR R1 For Stay MP.1/2007 M/S.R.SUBRAMANIAN B.RAVI S.S.RAGHAVAN CRP.2044/2007 M/S.R.SUBRAMANIAN CRP.2044/2007 B.RAVI -------------------------- S.S.RAGHAVAN M/S K.MANI V.V.KRISHNAMURTHY K.NAGARAJAN FOR R11 M/S M.BALASUBRAMANIAN S.LOKAIAH M.VENKATESH FOR R1 RR2 TO 10 - GIVEN UP ***************(CONCLUDED)*************** MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE C. S. KARNAN JUDGMENT TO BE DELIVERED ON FRIDAY THE 29TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2013 COURT NO. 11 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ------- FOR JUDGMENT ~~~~~~~~~~~~ JUDGMENT WAS RESERVED DURING HIS LORDSHIP'S SITTING IN THE PRINCIPAL BENCH ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1. WP.44603/2002 M/S.P.CHANDRASEKARAN AGP(W) FOR R1 (LABOUR) M/S.N.BALASUBRAMANIAM M.S.S.VENKATRAMAN FOR R2 ***************( Concluded )*************** LOK ADALAT - I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ PRESIDED OVER BY THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE A.RAMAMURTHI (Retd.) TO BE HEARD ON FRIDAY THE 29th DAY OF NOVEMBER 2013 AT 11.00 A.M. I FLOOR, ANNEXE BUILDING, HIGH COURT ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------- NOTICE CASES ~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1. CMA.2580/2005 SETC LTD SURESH CHAND OP.3972/1998 CHENNAI-2 JYOTISHI ADDL DIST AND ------------- ---------------- SESSION COURT M/S.M.KRISHNAMOORTHY FTC 2 CHENNAI R.THIRUNAVUKARASU 2. CMA.SR.71321/2012 SETC CHENNAI 1.LATHA AND 2 OTHERS OP.161/2008 2.CHINNAPONNU CJM VILLUPURAM -------------------- --------------------- AND MR.K.J.SIVAKUMAR MP.1/2013 3. CMA.SR.18673/2013 TNSETC NANMARAN OP.222/2011 CHENNAI CHEYYAR TOWN SUB COURT, -------- ----------------- CHEYYAR MR.A.BABU ADJOURNED CASES ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 4. SA.220/2009 ANANDAYEE KALA AND 3 OTHERS AS.107/2006 AND 2 OTHERS PRL. DIST. COURT R.KANAGAMBAL SALEM AND 7 OTHERS ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ AND M/S. MUTHUMANI DORAISAMI M/S. R.EZHILARASAN KANDAVADIVEL DORAISAMI A.K.BALAJI SA.226/2009 M.KATHIRVEL FOR R1 TO R8 AS.190/2006 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ADDL. SUB COURT R.THAMARAI SELVAM SALEM M.GEETHA 5. SA.81/2012 S.JAYARAMAN M.S.GURUMURTHY AS.189/2009 V ADDL. COURT ----------------- --------------- CITY CIVIL COURT M/S G.SUGUMARAN M/S N.KARTHIKEYAN CHENNAI PREMAVATHI SUGUMARAN S.KASTHURIBAI 6. SA.412/2012 MARUDHAVAN SELVANAYAKAM AS.4/2010 ----------- -------------- ( ADDL SUB COURT M/S.S.SOUNTHAR M/S.A.MUTHUKUMAR MAYILADUTHURAI) B.JAWAHAR P.NARESH KUMAR 7. SA.470/2012 P.N.CHINNASAMY MANISEKAR AND 4 OTHERS AS.3/2011 -------------- ---------------------- (FTC II GOBI) M/S.S.PARTHASARATHY M/S.I.C.VASUDEVAN V.C.AJEETH KUMAR R.NIRAMALA 8. AS.472/2012 ANNAKODI A.NATARAJAN AND 5 OTHERS AS.54/2011 ----------- ------------------------- (ADDL SUB COURT M/S.V.S.KESAVAN M/S.SARAVABHAUMAN ASSOCIATES I ERODE) B.SINGARAVELU 9. SA.476/2012 A.DHARMARAJ A.KALIMUTHU AS.15/2008 AND ANOTHER 10. SA.481/2012 ARJUNAN ANUSUYA AS.34/2011 AND ANOTHER (SUB COURT ------------- ----------- NAGAPATTINAM) M/S.S.SOUNTHAR M/S.V.CHANDRASEKARAN 11. SA.778/2012 MANI @ RAVICHANDARAN R.P.RAJENDRAKUMAR, ERODE AS.92/2011 -------------------- ------------------------ I ADDL.SUB M/S.N.MANOKARAN M/S.S.T.S.MURTHI COURT, ERODE A.SULOCHANA R.NALLIYAPPAN FOR RESPDT. 12. SA.823/2012 ABDUL WAHAB RASIA BEGUM AND 6 OTHERS AS.26/2008 ---------------- ------------------------ PRL.DIST.COURT M/S.V.BHARATHIDASAN THIRUVARUR P.T.RAMADEVI. 13. SA.1016/2012 S.T.RAMASAMY AND ANOTHER S.T.THIMMAIYAN AND 2 OTHERS AS.39/2008 ------------------------ II ADDL.SUB M/S.B.SOUNDARAPANDIAN COURT COIMBATORE B.SRINIVASAN. 14. SA.1211/2012 SRI ANJANEYA SRI RAGHAVENDRA R.MOHANASUNDARAM @ BALU AS.46/2011 SWAMY THIRUKKOVIL REP BY ITS AND 3 OTHERS I ADDL.SUB MANAGING TRUSTEE ------------------------ COURT, ERODE SMT.KUPPULAKSHMI, ERODE M/S.P.VALLIAPPAN ---------------------------- S.M.S.SHRIRAMNARAYANAN FOR R1 M/S.A.K.KUMARASAMY S.KAITHAMALAI KUMARAN 15. CS.46/2013 MRS. R.SAKUNTHALA MR. SHANMUGAM AND AND 4 OTHERS OA.93/2013 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ O.PADMAPRAKASH G.VENKATESAN G.MOHAN 16. CS.631/2012 TMT. SASIKALA MR. T.SURESH OA.822/2012 AND 7 OTHERS AND ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ OA.823/2012 M/S. R.RAMANLAL MRS. UMASHANKAR P.LAKSHMIKANTHAN FOR D3 17. CMA.SR.91289/2012 THE M.D. K.NANDAKUMARI - R1 OP.80/2008 S.E.T.C. R.NITHYANANDAM - R2 C.J.M. R.VASANTHAMALA - R3 VILLUPURAM R.DHANALAKSHMI - R4 R.MURUGANANDAM - R5 R.RAMU - R6 R.LAKSHMANAN - R7 AND ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ MP.1/2013 MR. K.I.SIVAKUMAR 18. CMA.1496/2011 ROYAL SUNDRAM ALLIANCE PRAKASH OP.10/2006 INS.CO.LTD. ADDL.SUB.COURT, ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ CHENGALPATTU MR.S.MANOHAR M/S.K.S.SIVAKUMAR AND S.SANKARALINGAM MP.1/2011 19. CMA.45/2012 G.LAKSHMI ICICI LOMBARD OP.3467/2007 ------------- GENERAL INS.,CO., CHIEF SMALL CAUSES M/S.N.M.MUTHURAJAN LTD., CHENNAI COURT, CHENNAI R.KALAI ARASAN CMA.46/2012 G.INDIRA (SINCE DIED) ICICI LOMBARD OP.3468/2007 R.SARASWATHI GENERAL INS.,CO., CHIEF SMALL CAUSES AND 3 OTHERS LTD., CHENNAI COURT CHENNAI CHENNAI --------------------- ------------------- M/S.N.M.MUTHURAJAN M/S.K.S.NARASIMHAN R.KALAI ARASAN FOR R2 20. CMA.1173/2012 K.CHANDRASEKARAN MANICKA PUSHPARAJAN OP.5372/2005 AND III RD IFFCO TOKIO GENERAL SMALL CAUSES COURT INSURANCE CO. LTD. CHENNAI CHENNAI --------------------------- ----------------------------- M/S.K.VARADHA KAMARAJ MR.N.VIJAYARAGHAVAN FOR R2 21. CMA. 1012/2011 MATHALAIMARY J. SURESH BABU AND OP. 406/2009 AND 4 OTHERS AND PRL DIST COURT IFFCO - TOKIO GENERAL DHARMAPURI CO LTD, COIMBATORE --------------- ----------------- M/S. M. SELVAM M/S.A.JAGANATHAN P. MALLIGA (VAK. NOT FILED) M. SATHYAN 22. SA.394/2012 ALAMELU MAYARANTHA SWAMY TEMPLE AS.20/2011 AND 4 OTHERS DIST COURT --------- ------------------------- NAGAPATTINAM M/S.K.M.VIJAYAN M/S.A.MUTHUKUMAR ASSOCIATES V.SUNDAR 23. WP.10071/2006 TNSTC LTD.REP BY ITS P.MANIMARAN AND ANOTHER MANAGING DIRECTOR SALEM ----------------------- ------------------------ MR.L.G.SAHADEVAN G.PURUSHOTHAMAN M/S.M.RAVIBHARATHI J.KUMARA VIJAYAN 24. WP.10527/2006 TNSTC LTD.VILLUPURAM K.JAYARAJ AND ANOTHER DIVISION REP BY ITS ---------------------- MANAGING DIRECTOR MR.C.MANOHAR FOR R2 ----------------------- MR.L.G.SAHADEVAN FOR REPORTING SETTLEMENT ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 25. AS.225/2011 P.PALANISAMY N.KOUSALYA OS.565/2006 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ III ADDL.DIST.COURT, M/S.CHITRA SAMPATH D.KRISHNAKUMAR FTC COURT-III T.S.BASKARAN COIMBATORE AND AS.226/2011 P.PALANISAMY KOUSALYA AND ANOTHER OS.95/2009 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ADDL.DIST.COURT, M/S.CHITRA SAMPATH D.KRISHNAKUMAR FTC-III, COIMBATORE T.S.BASKARAN *****************(CONCLUDED)***************** LOK ADALAT - II ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ PRESIDED OVER BY THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P.THANGAVEL (Retd.) TO BE HEARD ON FRIDAY THE 29th DAY OF NOVEMBER 2013 AT 11.00 A.M. I FLOOR, ANNEXE BUILDING, HIGH COURT ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------- NOTICE CASES ~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1. CRL.RC.1223/2010 M/S.V.SAIRAM G.VANITHA AND ANOTHER K.MAGESH 2. CRL.RC.1527/2012 M/S.P.MANI M/S.A.ARASUGANESAN V.MURALI A.BAKKIYARAJ 3. CRL.RC.1550/2012 M/S.S.DAVIS ELNAGOVAN M/S.C.PRABAKARAN C.SIVAPRABHU E.RAMADEVI ADJOURNED CASES ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 4. WP.7126/2006 THE BLOCK DEVELOPMENT R.GANDHI AND ANOTHER OFFICER THANDARAMPET PANCHAYAT UNION ------------------------- ------------------------ R. VIJAYA KUMAR VAK. NOT FILED 5. CRL.RC.1470/2012 A.U.JAMBU P.R.BALAJI CA.234/2012 ------------------- -------------------- V ADDL. DISTRICT M/S H.RAJASEKAR M/S T.MURUGAMANICKAM AND SESSIONS A.M.RAHAMATH ALI ZEENATH BEGUM COURT,CBE 6. CP.152/2006 M/S.S.SULOCHANA AND M/S. STERLING TREE MAGNUM 6 OTHERS INDIA (PVT) LTD., ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ M/S.S.KARTHIKEYAN M/S. IYER AND THOMAS M.MURTHY KARTHIK SESHADRI ELIZABETH SESHADRI 7. SA.835/2010 KALPAKA TRANSPORT UNITED INDIA AS.131/2004 CUTTACK INSURANCE CO.LTD., PRL.DJ. CHENNAI -14 - R1 CBE RAJALAKSHMI PAPER MILIS AND LTD., MADATHUKULAM - R2 -------------------- ----------------------- AND M/S.MURTHI AND VASAN M/S.T.RAVIDCHANDRAN MP.1/2010 I.MALAR 8. SA.1447/2010 SUSEELA GNANASEKARAN -R1 AS.4/2006 AND ANOTHER CHANDRA - R2 FTC CUDDALORE ------------- ---------------------- AND M/S.R.GUNARAJ M/S.D.RAVICHANDRA D.BHASKAR P.SANTHA MANJULA BHASKAR MP.1/2010 9. SA.720/2010 T.KALYANASUNDARAM S.ARUMUGANICKAR AS.11/2006 ------------------ ------------------ II ADDL.DJ, M/S.R.SUBRAMANIAM M/S.T.P.MANOHARAN PONDY M.SUDHAKAR AND MP.1/2010 10. CMA.198/2012 V.VASANTHA AND ANOTHER ROYAL SUNDARAM OP.3097/2007 ALLIANCE INS., CHIEF SMALL CAUSES CO.LTD., CHENNAI COURT, CHENNAI ------------------------ ----------------- M/S.N.M.MUTHURAJAN M/S.N.VIJAYARAGAVAN R.KALAI ARASAN 11. CMA.2280/2012 A.KUMARAVEL ROYAL SUNDARAM OP.3865/2009 ALLIANCE INS., VI SMALL CAUSES ------------- CO.LTD., COURT,CHENNAI M/S.M.SWAMIKKANNU ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ P.T.SALIM FATHIMA VAK. NOT FILED ADJOURNED CASES ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 12. SA.50/2012 KANNAMMA P.SAGUNTHALA AS.69/2010 AND ANOTHER ERODE PRL.DIST.