Revista Chilena de Historia Natural 64: 399-412, 1991 Comparative ecology of temperate rainforests of the Americas along analogous climatic gradients Ecologfa comparativa de los bosques lluviosos templados de Norte y Sudamerica a lo largo de gradientes climaticos analogos PAUL B. ALABACK U.S. Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station Post Office Box 20909, Juneau, AK 99802 USA. (Fax: 907-586-7848) ABSTRACT A definition for temperate rainforest and its applications to world forest type distribution is presented. Southern Chile and the Pacific coast of North America are the largest expanses of temperate rainforest. Although both regions have important similarities in climate, dramatic differences in the species composition of flora and fauna are evident. An- alogous forest types occur at similar levels of summer rainfall in both zones. In Chile sea-level glaciers and associated subantarctic vegetation types begin at 10-15 degrees lower latitude than in North America. Biomass accumulations achieve world record status in coniferous forest types in both regions, although conifer forest types are rare in Chile. Structure and composition of forests in both zones reflect chronic disturbance by wind and rain, and periodic catastrophic dis- turbance by intense storms, landslides, or vulcanism. Ecological analogs exist for many common plant species. Detailed comparative studies are needed between the principal rainforest regions of the world to more clearly identify how biogeographical, climatic and historical factors have influenced evolution of forest structure and function. The prospect of global climatic change also underscores the need for comparative data on ecosystem processes along analogous climatic gradients, especially at high latitudes where the most pronounced changes are expected to occur. Key words: Temperate rainforests, climate, biogeography, plant ecology, Alaska, Nothofagus, Picea. RESUMEN Se presenta una definicion de bosque lluvioso templado y su aplicaci6n a Ia distribucion geografica mundial de bosques. El sur de Chile y Ia costa noroeste de Norteamerica tienen las áreas de bosques lluviosos templados más grandes en todo el mundo. Ambas regiones son semejantes en clima, pero son muy diferentes en cuanto a Ia composicion de especies de plantas y animales. En ambas regiones los tipos de bosques analogos están en lugares que reciben Ia misma cantidad de lluvias durante el verano. En Chile, los glaciares adyacentes a! mar, y Ia mayorfa de los tipos de bosques análogos comienzan 10-15 grados de latitud antes que en Norteamerica. La acumulacion de biomasa más alta de todo el mundo ocurre en bosques de coniferas de ambas regiones, aunque los bosques de coniferas son escasos en Chile. La estructura y composicion de los bosques de ambas regiones son una funci6n de perturbaciones frecuentes causadas por vientos y lluvias y de perturbaciones más raras causadas por tempestades fuertes, derrumbes, avalanchas, o volcanismo. Exis- ten análogos ecologicos para muchas especies de plantas en ambas regiones. Estudios comparativos de bosques lluviosos del mundo son necesarios para entender cómo Ia biogeografia, el clima y Ia historia han influido Ia evolucion del funcionamiento y estructura de estos bosques. La posibilidad de cambios en el clima en un futuro proximo también subraya Ia necesidad de obtener datos comparativos sobre los procesos de eco- sistemas a lo largo de gradientes análogos de clima, sobre todo a altas latitudes, en donde se producirian los cambios más significativos de clima y de funcion ecologica. Palabras claves: Bosques lluviosos, clima, biogeografia, Nothofagus, Picea, ecologia, Alaska. INTRODUCTION and management throughout their geo- graphic range. They include some of the The term temperate rainforest has been longest-lived and massive tree species as applied to a broad range of forest types well as the largest remaining virgin land- in both popular and scientific publications. scapes outside of the tropics (Franklin These forests have been the focus of in- & Warring 1980, Veblen et al. 1976). tense public debate on both conservation They also occur at high latitudes where their sensitivity tc and history of rapid climatic change make them ideal subjects (Received 23 March 1990.) for monitoring global climatic change. 400 ALABACK Many critical scientific questions relating to a common vegetational history. A close landscape level processes may be best examination of sites with a temperate studied in temperate rainforests since their rainforest climate located at the far comers fauna and landscapes are more intact than of the earth where vegetation evolved in most other ecosystem types. Important more or less independently might provide decisions on conservation and management some unique insights as to how climate options for these pristine ecosystems influences forest evolution and function. will also require that we understand in Consideration of the disturbance regimes much greater detail how temperate rain- and functional characteristics of these forests respond to both logging and cli- disparate forest types are also needed to matic pertubations. determine what adaptations to the rain- Research emphasis has been much dif- forest environment are shared between ferent in temperate rainforests of the these floristically distinct locales. In par- northern and southern hemispheres. In ticulari would like to ask the question how the northern hemisphere much attention do the two largest temperate rainforests has been paid to the relation of structure regions in the world compare; and to what to function and of the unique attributes degree do historical factors influence pre- of "old-growth" forests (Alaback & Juday sent day ecosystem functioning, as we 1989, Franklin et al. 1981, Graham & Cro- understand them, and what are the research mack 1982, McKee et a/. 1982, Spies opportunities for comparative studies in eta/. 1988, Spies & Franklin 1988, Waring this forest zone? & Franklin 1979). Succession research has focused on post-logging, fire and A definition for temperate rainforest wind caused disturbances (e.g. Alaback 1982, Cline et a/. 1980, Halpern 1989, The term temperate rainforest is not new Harcombe 1986, Kellman 1969) although to ecology, but has been applied to a range some work has been done on revegetation of vegetative types throughout the world following mass movements and vulcanism (Alaback & Juday 1989, de Laubenfels (Dale 1989, Miles & Swanson 1986, Smith 1975, Koppen 1918, Kuchler 1949, Veblen & Commandeur 1986) and fluvial dynamics et a/. 1983, Webb 1978). One of the most (Fonda 1974, McKee et a/. 1982). Much distinctive features of rainforest climate is of the classic work on post-glacial succes- cool summers and wet weather year around. sion was conducted in the northern tem- An ecological consequence of this unique perate rainforest zone of Southeast Alaska climate is frequent disturbance by wind, (Cooper 1937, Crocker & Major 1955, and the lack of fire as an important factor Reinersetal. 1971). in forest dynamics. In the southern hemi- In southern Chile research has focused sphere lightning caused fires appear to be on gap dynamics of old-growth forests rare events (Veblen eta/. 1983, Wardle et and succession following mass movement al. 1983). Throughout the northern hemi- events (e.g. Armesto & Figueroa 1987, sphere fire plays a key role, either as a Veblen 1989, Veblen eta/. 1981). Little infrequent catastrophic event in humid work has been done on post-glacial suc- regions, or as a chronic event in drier cession, and on the relation of forest climates. Only in the coastal rainforest structure to function (Kunkel 1955, Ve- is fire of minor importance (Harris & blen 1982, Weinberger 1974, Young 1972). Farr 1974). Although many sites spread throughout Rainforests are difficult to distinguish the temperate zone are commonly referred floristically or physiognomically from relat- to as temperate rainforests there have been ed forest types (Cockayne 1971, de Lau- few attempts to compare the ecological benfels 1975, Webb 1968, 1978). The up- characteristics of these widely scattered per canopy is often composed of a large forests. Most comparisons have been made number of species with few in a position of temperate rainforests with climatically of dominance, and trees form clumped disparate environments, or of forests with patterns reflecting gap-phase disturbance COMPARISON OF TEMPERATE RAINFORESTS 401 regimes (Armesto et a/. 1986). Epiphytes Cloudforests may be less productive and are often associated with rainforests, but shorter in stature than corresponding high they also frequent timberline and arctic latitude rainforests because of their expo- environments with a high frequency of sure to winds at the high elevations in which fog. they typically occur (e.g. Howard 1969, De Laubenfels (197 5) has proposed pre- Byer & Weaver 1977). sence of a dense and continuous under- Many phytogeographers have distinguish- story layer and the absence of annual ed the needle-leaved forests of the northern herbaceous plants as key factors distin- hemisphere from the evergreen broad- guishing rainforests from seasonal forests. leaved forests of the southern hemisphere, Understory plants in many mesophytic implying they are ecologically distinct temperate forests, however, are light limit- entities. Although it is generally true that ed so that their relative abundanc~ may the northern hemisphere forests have reflect more the structure and disturbance cooler winters and that conifers are