TIFR/TH/20-32, CERN-TH-2020-145 Low Mass Black Holes from Dark Core Collapse Basudeb Dasgupta ID ,1, ∗ Ranjan Laha ID ,2, 3, y and Anupam Ray ID 1, z 1Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Homi Bhabha Road, Mumbai 400005, India 2Theoretical Physics Department, CERN, 1211 Geneva, Switzerland 3Centre for High Energy Physics, Indian Institute of Science, C. V. Raman Avenue, Bengaluru 560012, India (Dated: April 9, 2021) Unusual masses of black holes being discovered by gravitational wave experiments pose funda- mental questions about the origin of these black holes. Black holes with masses smaller than the Chandrasekhar limit ≈ 1:4 M are essentially impossible to produce through stellar evolution. We propose a new channel for production of low mass black holes: stellar objects catastrophically ac- crete non-annihilating dark matter, and the small dark core subsequently collapses, eating up the host star and transmuting it into a black hole. The wide range of allowed dark matter masses allows a smaller effective Chandrasekhar limit, and thus smaller mass black holes. We point out several avenues to test our proposal, focusing on the redshift dependence of the merger rate. We show that redshift dependence of the merger rate can be used as a probe of the transmuted origin of low mass black holes. Introduction { The recent detections of GW190425 [1] 1 GeV cm−3 [13, 54]. (We use ~ = c = 1 units hereafter.) and GW190814 [2], which are either the heaviest neutron The capture rate scales linearly with the ambient DM stars (NSs) or the lightest black holes (BHs) ever seen, density and has a strong dependence on the velocity dis- −3 have ignited interest in O(1) M BHs [3{7]. Usual stellar persion, (¯v ), so an O(1) Gyr old NS in a DM dense 3 −3 evolution cannot lead to sub-Chandrasekhar mass BHs, region (ρχ = 10 GeV cm ) inside a globular cluster and the observation of such black holes would augur new (¯v ∼ 10−5) can, in principle, implode due to a PBH physics. With the remarkable advances in gravitational transit. However, such overdense DM cores in a globular wave (GW) and multi-messenger astronomy, the detec- cluster are quite speculative and not yet well established. tion of a sub-Chandrasekhar mass (. 1.4 M ) BH may It has, in fact, been shown that globular clusters do not be just around the corner. have any DM over-densities [55{57]. Hence, the explana- The key question, assuming a future GW observa- tion of a sub-Chandrasekhar or O(1) M BH due to a tion of a merger involving a sub-solar-mass object, is PBH transit hinges on the contentious assumption of a how to pinpoint its identity? One recently popular can- high DM density in globular clusters, and remains uncer- didate is a primordial black hole (PBH). It is a well- tain until the provenance of globular clusters is settled. motivated dark matter (DM) candidate [8{11] that can In this Letter, we point out a simple mechanism that constitute all of the cosmological DM [12{14]. After a transmutes a sub-Chandrasekhar or O(1) M star to a critical reappraisal [15{18], numerous constraints now ex- comparable \low mass BH", and propose several tests ist on their abundance ([19{45], see also [46{48] and ref- for the proposal focusing on the cosmic evolution of the erences therein). However, there is no mechanism that merger rates. DM candidates share the universal fea- naturally produces the correct abundance of PBHs. The ture that they have a mass and interactions with or- initial abundance of PBHs is exponentially sensitive to dinary matter. We show, without appealing to any the spectrum of density perturbations and the thresh- other exotic features, that this is sufficient for making old for collapse; fine-tuning of parameters is required to transmuted black holes (TBHs). Continued accumula- achieve the observed DM abundance [49]. tion of non-annihilating DM particles in the core, fol- An alternative possibility is that the low mass BHs lowed by their gravitational collapse at a modified Chan- are of a non-primordial nature. DM accretion in a star drasekhar limit set by DM mass and spin, can produce arXiv:2009.01825v2 [astro-ph.HE] 8 Apr 2021 followed by its dark core collapse [50] or the exotic cool- sub-Chandrasekhar or O(1) M TBHs that are a viable ing of an atomic dark matter cloud [51] can lead to low alternative to PBHs. We answer a few basic questions: mass BHs. However, previously proposed models em- what particle physics parameter space can they explore, ploying a fermionic asymmetric DM with non-negligible how to test their origin, and especially, how to distinguish self-interaction or dark quantum electrodynamics are not them from PBHs? generic. Transit of a tiny PBH through a compact ob- Methods & Results { Transmutation of stellar objects ject and subsequent conversion of the host to a BH is also to BHs due to core collapse has been studied exten- thought to be a novel way to produce sub-Chandrasekhar sively, as a tool to set constraints on DM-nucleon scat- and O(1) M BHs [52, 53]. However, the estimated cap- tering cross section from the existence of old NSs [61{69], ture rate of a tiny PBH by a NS was recently shown from connection with type-Ia supernovae [70{73], as to be quite small, ∼ 10−17 yr−1 for a NS residing in a well as connections to several other astrophysical phe- Milky-Way-like galaxy with ambient DM density, ρχ = nomenon [74{78]. Non-annihilating DM [79, 80] scatters 2 3 3 - PandaX-II - -43 -43 Excluded from 10 -43 cm 10 cm PandaX-II Excluded from Transmuted BH existence of 10 Excluded from PSR J0437-4715 -43 existence of formation existence of 10 GeV -45 Transmuted BH PSR J0437-4715 GeV PSR J0437-4715 3 10 ρ 10 ] ] -45 ] formation ] χ ρ 10 2 2 10 2 2 = χ -45 = radiation = ρ 1 = 10 ρ radiation radiation χ 1 χ = GeV GeV χ = χ -47 ρ 1 ρ XENON1T 10 radiation GeV cm 10 3 cm cm - cm cm [ cm [ ρ 3 [ [ GeV χ cm - - -47 = 3 3 10 3 Transmuted BH n n 10 n n -45 Hawking ρ Hawking χ cm χ GeV χ -47 χ χ -49 Hawking = 10 formation 10 - cm 10 10 3 σ 3 σ - σ σ 3 Hawking GeV cm -49 -3 Efficient -51 Bosonic DM 10 Fermionic DM Bosonic DM Efficient Fermionic DM 10 Efficient -49 mϕ ∞ mϕ ∞ Efficient 10 mϕ = 10 MeV mϕ = 10 MeV 10-53 10-51 10-47 10 103 105 107 105 107 109 10 103 105 107 107 109 mχ [GeV] mχ [GeV] mχ [GeV] mχ [GeV] FIG. 1. DM mass and scattering cross section required for a dark core collapse and subsequent transmutation of a 1.3 M NS to a comparable mass BH are shown in the red shaded regions. The two panels on the left (respectively, right) correspond to interaction between DM and stellar nuclei mediated by an infinitely heavy mediator, i.e., mφ recoil momentum (resp. 10 MeV scalar). Scenarios with non-annihilating bosonic or fermionic DM are marked. Two representative values of ambient DM 3 −3 3 −3 density, ρχ = 1 and 10 GeV cm (only for the right panel, ρχ = 10 and 10 GeV cm ), are considered. Exclusion limits from underground direct detection experiments PandaX-II [58] and XENON1T [59] as well as from existence of an ∼ 7 Gyr old nearby pulsar PSR J0437-4715 [60{63] are also shown by the gray shaded regions. Green hatched regions mark the parameter space where efficient Hawking evaporation stops the implosion of the NS. The region of no thermalization is many orders of magnitude below [62], and is not shown for clarity. 10 with stellar nuclei, gets captured via single [81, 82] or and & O(10 ) GeV, respectively. multiple scattering [83{85], and accumulates inside a stel- Fig.1 shows the DM parameter space where a NS lar object linearly with time. A precise estimate of the (with mass 1:3 M ) can transmute to a low mass BH total number of captured DM particles inside a stellar for either bosonic or fermionic DM, for two choices of object can be found in [63, 86] for interactions medi- ambient DM density. DM-nucleon interactions medi- ated by any arbitrary mass mediators, and in the con- ated by an infinitely heavy mediator (light mediator of tact interaction approximation, respectively. Transmu- mass 10 MeV) is assumed in the first (last) two pan- tation occurs when the captured DM particles satisfy els. In the contact interaction approximation, asymmet- the collapse criterion, i.e., N j ≥ max N Cha;N self, χ tage χ χ ric bosonic (fermionic) DM of mass O(100) GeV (O(1) where N j is the total number of DM particles ac- χ tage PeV) in a DM dense environment can lead to a sub- cumulated within a celestial object throughout its age Chandrasekhar mass BH. For DM-nucleon interaction t . N Cha and N self, respectively, denote the Chan- age χ χ mediated via lighter mediators, transmutation of com- drasekhar limit (which depends on the DM particle spin) pact objects is easier, as exclusion limits weaken and and the number of DM particles required for initiat- implosions can be achieved with a wider range of pa- ing the self-gravitating collapse. For bosonic (fermionic) rameters. Similar analysis can also be performed for a DM, zero point energy is provided by the Heisenberg un- solar mass white dwarf (WD).