Supersymmetry breaking as a quantum phase transition Holger Gies, Franziska Synatschke and Andreas Wipf Theoretisch-Physikalisches Institut, Friedrich-Schiller-Universit¨at Jena, Max-Wien-Platz 1, D-07743 Jena, Germany We explore supersymmetry breaking in the light of a rich fixed-point structure of two-dimensional supersymmetric Wess-Zumino models with one supercharge using the functional renormalization group (RG). We relate the dynamical breaking of supersymmetry to an RG relevant control param- eter of the superpotential which is a common relevant direction of all fixed points of the system. Supersymmetry breaking can thus be understood as a quantum phase transition analogous to similar transitions in correlated fermion systems. Supersymmetry gives rise to a new superscaling relation between the critical exponent associated with the control parameter and the anomalous dimension of the field – a scaling relation which is not known in standard spin systems. PACS numbers: 05.10.Cc,12.60.Jv,11.30.Qc Supersymmetry is an important guiding principle for transition between the semimetallic and the superfluid the construction of models beyond the standard model phase as discussed in the context of ultracold atoms [2] of particle physics, as it helps parametrizing the problem or graphene [3]. As this transition occurs at zero temper- of a large hierarchy of scales, supports the unification ature, the critical value of the control parameter marks of gauge couplings, and facilitates an intricate combina- a quantum critical point of a quantum phase transition. tion of internal symmetries with the Poincar´egroup. On A standard approach to quantum phase transitions in the other hand, supersymmetry must be broken in na- strongly correlated fermion systems is the Hertz-Millis ture in a specific way without violating these attractive theory [4, 5] where composite bosonic fields are intro- features and other constraints imposed by the standard- duced by a Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation. Sub- model precision data. In addition to a variety of break- sequently, the fermionic degrees of freedom are integrated ing mechanisms often involving further hidden gauge and out, leaving a purely bosonic description which is dealt particle sectors, dynamical supersymmmetry breaking [1] with in a local approximation. As this strategy is not can play a decisive role in the formation of the low-energy always sufficient, a treatment of fundamental fermionic standard model. Generically, symmetry breaking is re- and composite bosonic degrees of freedom on equal foot- lated to collective condensation phenomena, often requir- ing beyond the Hertz-Millis theory has recently proved ing a nonperturbative understanding of the fluctuation- successful [6]. induced dynamics. Now, supersymmetric systems by definition are com- From the viewpoint of statistical physics, symmetry bined bosonic-fermionic systems with a high degree of breaking and phase transitions between ground states symmetry. A treatment of these degrees of freedom on of a differently realized symmetry are often related to equal footing is even mandatory to preserve supersym- fixed points of the renormalization group (RG). In ad- metry manifestly. Apart from this symmetry, we will dition, the quantitative properties of the system near a show that supersymmetry breaking has many similari- phase transition are determined by the RG flow in the ties to a quantum phase transition in strongly correlated fixed-point regime. As the understanding of symmetry fermion systems. Beyond these similarities, supersymme- breaking phenomena in quantum field theory and parti- try invokes additional structures which go beyond those arXiv:0906.5492v2 [hep-th] 19 Nov 2009 cle physics has often profited from analogies to statistical known in statistical physics. systems, this paper explores supersymmetry breaking in Euclidean two-dimensional = 1 Wess-Zumino mod- N the light of phase transitions and critical phenomena. els can be defined by the Lagrange density in the off-shell formulation = + with As a simple example, we concentrate on Wess-Zumino L Lkin Lint models with = 1 supercharges in two dimensions in N 1 µ i i µ 1 2 Euclidean spacetime. Dynamical supersymmetry break- kin = ∂µφ∂ φ + ψ∂ψ/ ∂µψγ ψ F , (1) L 2 4 − 4 − 2 ing in this and many other supersymmetric systems is 1 ′′ ′ governed by a control parameter of the superpotential int = W (φ)ψγ∗ψ W (φ)F, (2) L 2 − which plays the role of a bosonic mass term. This is very reminiscent to phase transitions in strongly correlated with superpotential W (φ), bosonic field φ, fermionic fermionic systems: here, symmetry breaking is governed fields ψ and ψ and auxiliary field F . The prime denotes by a composite bosonic order parameter, e.g., a super- the derivative with respect to φ, and we use a chiral rep- fluid condensate, the mass term of which serves as the resentation for the γ matrices. This model allows for control parameter of the phase transition. For instance, dynamical supersymmetry breaking if the highest power the inverse interaction strength of attractively interact- of the bare superpotential is odd. ing electrons on a honeycomb lattice governs the phase We use the functional RG to calculate the effective 2 action Γ of the theory. The functional RG can be formu- Let us start with the lowest-order derivative expansion, lated as a flow equation for the effective average action Γk corresponding to a local-potential approximation for the [7]. This is a scale-dependent action functional which in- superpotential. In this truncation, the effective action is terpolates between the classical action S = ( + ) approximated by Lkin Lint and the full quantum effective action Γ. TheR interpola- 1 ′′ ′ tion scale k denotes an infrared (IR) regulator scale, such Γk = dτ kin + Wk (φ)ψγ∗ψ Wk(φ)F (4) that no fluctuations are included for k Λ (with Λ be- Z L 2 − → ing the UV cutoff), implying Γ → S. For k 0, all k Λ → → with a k-dependent superpotential Wk. Projecting fluctuations are taken into account such that Γ → Γ k 0 → the flow equation (3) onto this truncation leads to is the full quantum solution. The effective average action the flow equation for the superpotential. For a sim- can be determined from the Wetterich equation [7] plified regulator choice with r1 = 0 and r2 = 2 2 −1 ( k/p 1) θ 1 (p /k ) , the superpotential flow re- 1 (2) k | |− − ∂tΓk = STr Γk + Rk ∂tRk , t = ln , (3) duces to 2 h i Λ 2 ′′ k Wk (φ) which defines an RG flow trajectory in theory space ∂tWk(φ)= 2 ′′ 2 . (5) (2) − 4π k + Wk (φ) with S serving as initial condition. Here, Γk = −→ ←− ab This regulator choice is convenient for analytical studies. δ Γ δ where the indices a,b summarize field com- δΨa k δΨb We have verified explicitly by using a variety of differ- ponents, internal and Lorentz indices, as well as space- ent regulators that all conclusions drawn below from this T ¯ time or momentum coordinates, i.e., Ψ = (φ, F, ψ, ψ). simple choice also hold for other regulators. The regulator function Rk is introduced in the form of The corresponding flow equation for the dimensionless a quadratic contribution to the classical action, ∆Sk = potential w = W /k admits a variety of nontrivial fixed- T k k Ψ RkΨ. Rk can thus be viewed as a momentum- point solutions: already a polynomial expansion for Z2 Rdependent mass term, implementing the IR suppression antisymmetric superpotentials to order n, of modes below k. Different functional forms of Rk cor- respond to different RG schemes. Physical quantities do ′ ∂wk 2 2 4 6 2n w = λ(φ a )+b4φ +b6φ + +b2nφ , (6) not depend on the regulator. k ≡ ∂φ − ··· For a manifestly supersymmetric flow equation, we de- reveal n independent solutions to the fixed-point equa- rive the regulator from a D term of a quadratic superfield tion ∂ w = 0, in addition to the Gaußian fixed point[20]. operator, similarly to our construction for supersymmet- t k The latter has infinitely many relevant directions in ric quantum mechanics [8]. The most general supersym- agreement with perturbative power-counting in two di- metric cutoff action in the off-shell formulation in mo- mensions. The number of relevant RG directions de- mentum space is given by creases for the other fixed points, culminating in a maxi- 1 2 2 2 2 mally IR-stable fixed point with only one relevant direc- ∆Sk = d p(r1ψγ∗ψ 2r1φF +p r2φ +r2ψpψ/ r2F ). 2Z − − tion. This relevant direction exactly corresponds to the parameter a2 in the superpotential, and it is common 2 The regulator shape functions r1,2 = r1,2(p ) determine to all other fixed points as well. As a2 is related to the the precise form of the Wilsonian momentum shell inte- bosonic mass term, we introduce a critical exponent νW gration. The form of ∆Sk guarantees that the whole RG for this direction, such that a2 scales as a2 k−1/νW at trajectory remains in the hypersurface of supersymmet- a fixed point. This critical exponent thus corresponds∼ to ric action functionals even within approximative calcula- the negative inverse of the associated eigenvalue of the tions; see [9, 10] for further supersymmetric RG studies. stability matrix. The exponent νW plays a similar role In general, the full quantum effective action consists for the superpotential, as the exponent ν for the effective of all possible operators which are compatible with the potential in Ising-type systems. At leading order in the symmetries of the theory. In this paper, we use a super- derivative expansion, we obtain from Eq. (5): νW LO = 1. covariant derivative expansion to systematically classify Fixed-point potentials and critical exponents at| next-to- these operators. Truncating the expansion at a given or- leading order will be discussed below.