UNCLASSIFIED DepartmentofDefense Office for theAdministrative Review of the Detention ofEnemy Combatants at U.S. Naval Base Guantanamo Bay , Cuba 27 December 2007 To : MADNI, HAFES MOHAMMED SAAD IQBAL Subject: UNCLASSIFIEDSUMMARYOF EVIDENCEFORADMINISTRATIVE REVIEWBOARD IN THECASE OF MADNI, HAFESQARIMOHAMMEDSAAD IQBAL An AdministrativeReviewBoardwillbeconvenedto review your case to determine if your continueddetentionis necessary. 2. The AdministrativeReviewBoard will conduct a comprehensivereview ofall reasonably available and relevant informationregardingyour case. At theconclusionofthis review the Board will make a recommendationto: ( 1) release you to your home state; (2 ) transfer you to your home state, with conditions uponby the United States and your home state; or ( 3) continue your detentionunderUnitedStates control 3. The following primary factors favor continued detention : a ) Coromitment 1) The detainee stated he traveled to Indonesia, Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Afghanistan and many times to Pakistan . 2) The detaineestatedhewas the GeneralSecretaryofthe Sipah- e-IslamPakistan( ) The SIP was set up in 1994 by Sunni university students, as mirror ofthe group Sipah e - Sahaba Pakistan (SSP) . The detainee explained the SSP was an anti-Shia group which had been established to counter the Iranianrevolution. The SIP was supportedbythe SSP and members of the $ SP had dual membership in the The detainee claimed the SSP assassinated the IranianAmbassador to Pakistan inthe early 1990s. 3) The Sipah- -Sahaba Pakistan(SSP) is a Sunnisectariangroupthat followsthe Deobandi School Violently anti - , the SSP emerged in central Punjab inthe mid -1980s as a response to the Iranian Revolution. The group's activities range from organizing political rallies calling for Shi'as to be declared non -Muslims to assassinating prominent Shi'a leaders 4. The following primary factors favor release or transfer: ISN 743 DMO Exhibit 1 Page of2 UNCLASSIFIED 783 UNCLASSIFIED Subject: UNCLASSIFIEDSUMMARY OF EVIDENCEFORADMINISTRATIVE REVIEWBOARD INTHE CASE OFMADNI, HAFES QARI MOHAMMEDSAAD IQBAL a ) The that did not want to return to Pakistan because he would be labeled a terrorist b) The detainee stated that with regard to his relationship to a known jihadist, he made a mistake when he got involved with bad people at young age. 5. Youwill be affordeda meaningfulopportunitytobeheard and to present information to the Board; this includesan opportunityto bephysicallypresent at the proceeding. The Assisting MilitaryOfficer ( AMO) will assist you in reviewingallrelevant and reasonably available unclassifiedinformationregardingyour case. The AMO is not an advocateforor continueddetention, may the AMO form a confidential relationshipwith you represent you inanyothermatter. ISN743 DMOExhibit1 Page2 of2 UNCLASSIFIED 784.