8/16/2019 A Baker’s Dozen Of US FDA Efficacy Approvals Using Real World Evidence :: Pink Sheet This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use. For high-quality copies or electronic reprints for distribution to colleagues or customers, please call +44 (0) 20 3377 3183 Printed By A Baker’s Dozen Of US FDA Ecacy Approvals Using Real World Evidence 07 Aug 2018 ANALYSIS by Bridget Silverman [email protected] Executive Summary Fresenius Kabi’s Omegaven is most recent of 13 approvals, including three with breakthrough therapy designations, where FDA has relied on real world evidence to make a regulatory decision about efcacy. The exigencies of ultra-orphan drug development have provided the early testing ground for the US FDA’s limited use of real-world evidence (RWE) in approval decisions, resulting in 13 approvals identied by the Pink Sheet that relied on external or historical controls to place single-arm efcacy trials in context or derived data from case reports and expanded access protocols. FDA’s most recent approval using RWE – the July 27, 2018 clearance of Fresenius Kabi AG’s I.V. lipid emulsion Omegaven (sh oil triglycerides) to provide calories and essential fatty acids for pediatric patients with parenteral nutrition-associated cholestasis – is in many ways typical of the agency’s RWE-based approvals to date. Omegaven addresses a highly specialized niche market and has long been available under an expanded access protocol, making conventional clinical trials a challenge. FDA’s approval history suggests the agency prefers to bring products out of the expanded access/personal importation gray market and into light of the FDA review process, even if the reviewers have to make do with less-than-ideal data. (Also see "Emaza's 505(b)(2) Pathway Review: Rare, But With Precedent" - Pink Sheet, 31 Mar, 2017.) RWE Gets Ready For Prime Time RWE is expected to make the leap from the ultra-orphan ghetto to more widespread use in regulatory decision making as a result of the last Prescription Drug User Fee Act reauthorization, PDUFA VI, which directs FDA to explore the use of RWE in regulatory decision-making. FDA is working towards a draft guidance for drug development by the end of FY2021. To prepare, the agency has embarked upon rounds of demonstration projects, pilots, publications and stakeholder meetings. FDA’s breakthrough therapy designation (BTD) program, which offers greater interaction with the agency during development, has nurtured three novel agents to approval using RWE. In all three A Real-World Primer https://pink.pharmaintelligence.informa.com/PS123648/A-Bakers-Dozen-Of-US-FDA-Efficacy-Approvals-Using-Real-World-Evidence 1/4 8/16/2019 A Baker’s Dozen Of US FDA Efficacy Approvals Using Real World Evidence :: Pink Sheet cases, single-arm clinical trial data was compared The Pink Sheet has covered FDA's emerging thinking to historical controls. on real-world evidence over many years. Below are One of the BTD products, BioMarin Pharmaceutical links to stories with some key highlights. Inc.’s Brineura (cerliponase alfa) for late infantile US FDA Ofcials Provide Primer On Real-World Data neuronal ceroid lipofuscinosis type 2, ts with the Real-World Data Could Get Boost From Trial ultra-rare disorder prole of most of CDER’s RWE Replication Project approvals. Real-World Evidence Benets, Limits Explored In US Brineura cleared the agency on April 27, 2017 on FDA Demonstrations the basis of a non-randomized, single-arm dose escalation clinical study in 22 symptomatic Real-World Evidence Advice, Principles, And Examples pediatric patients with CLN2 disease and compared Emerge From FDA to 42 untreated patients with CLN2 disease from a When Will Real World Evidence Be Persuasive? FDA's natural history cohort (an independent historical Temple Offers Perspective control group). ( (Also see "BioMarin's Brineura Approval Shows FDA's Open Door For Orphan Drugs" - Pink Sheet, 2 May, 2017.)) The other two BTD approvals using external controls suggest a higher-prole future for RWE. Amgen Inc.’s Blincyto (blinatumomab) and EMD Serono Inc./Pzer Inc.’s Bavencio (avelumab) both were initially approved for an orphan indication, but neither product is strictly speaking an orphan drug. Both Blincyto and Bavencio are expected to be blockbuster oncologics – and could play an important role in setting the stage for greater acceptance of RWE. Importantly, FDA’s accelerated approvals of Bavencio for Merkel cell carcinoma and Blincyto in acute lymphoblastic leukemia have been or will be followed by larger conventional conrmatory trials – Phase III trials that could allay some of the concerns about using RWE in regulatory decisions if similar effect sizes are seen. (See sidebar for related story.) Companies like Roche, which is heavily invested in informatics through Flatiron Health and Foundation Medicine, are already using RWE- generated external controls in reimbursement Real-World Evidence At US discussions, with regulatory use expected in the FDA: Bavencio, Blincyto future. (Also see "Roche’s External Control Arms Show What Real-World Evidence Can Look Like In Practice " - Approvals Point Way Toward Pink Sheet, 14 Jun, 2018.) Broader Use FDA’s Historical Experience By Bridget Silverman 07 Aug 2018 With RWE Breakthrough-designated oncologics used historical comparator There is “very little historical use of RW experience data to determine efcacy threshold for pivotal Phase II studies in drug regulatory decisions about effectiveness,” supporting accelerated approval; Blincyto’s subsequent full CDER Director Janet Woodcock told a September approval offers validation with conventional controlled study. 2017 workshop, although RWE is “currently used Read the full article here ❯ extensively for evaluation of safety of marketed products.” https://pink.pharmaintelligence.informa.com/PS123648/A-Bakers-Dozen-Of-US-FDA-Efficacy-Approvals-Using-Real-World-Evidence 2/4 8/16/2019 A Baker’s Dozen Of US FDA Efficacy Approvals Using Real World Evidence :: Pink Sheet Woodcock identied two sets of circumstances where FDA has relied on RWE to determine efcacy: approvals “based on data from registry-like case series” and approvals where “we have used registry data as external controls.” Woodcock highlighted four examples of orphan drugs approved with RWE: Genzyme Corp.’s alglucosidase alfa for Pompe Disease, approved as Lumizyme in 2010 with reference to survival data from an international registry of infantile-onset disease Genzyme’s BLA for Lumizyme, or algucosidase alfa manufactured at greater scale than the company’s earlier Myozyme, relied on a placebo-controlled trial, LOTS, in late-onset Pompe disease, supported by clinical outcomes data in infantile- onset patients from the Pompe Registry, which was set up as a post-marketing commitment for the 2006 Myozyme approval. The registry data showed increased survival at 18 months in Lumizyme patients compared with age- and disease-matched historical controls, according to Division of Gastroenterology Products Director Donna Griebel’s summary review. The Myozyme approval also relied on a comparison to a 61-patient historical control group, she observed. Recordati Industria Chimica & Farmaceutica SPA/Orphan Europe’s Carbaglu (carglumic acid) for hyperammonemia due to NAGS deciency, approved in 2010 based on plasma level ammonia reductions in a case series Carbaglu is indicated to treat hyperammonemia due to NAGS deciency, an extremely rare disorder with only 50 known cases worldwide, Griebel noted in her summary review. “Retrospective case series summary data submitted in this NDA and the data from 3 patients with NAGS deciency treated in a prospective trial that investigated the impact of Carbaglu on restoration of ureagenesis provide substantial evidence of efcacy,” she said. The retrospective case series included 23 patients, but only 13 had complete plasma ammonia level data available. Nonetheless, the data established that Carbaglu “was associated with reduction in ammonia levels,” Griebel said. “These data are limited in both quality and quantity, but normalization of plasma ammonia levels would not be expected long-term in untreated patients with NAGS deciency. Therefore, when compared to natural history data, the effect of Carbaglu appears to be clinically signicant.” Asklepion Pharmaceuticals LLC’s Cholbam (cholic acid) for bile acid synthesis disorders, approved in 2015 based on data on growth, survival and reduction in abnormal cholestatic markers in a case series Cholbam was studied under a treatment IND opened in 1992 at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center (CCHMC). After Asklepion came on board in 2007, the company retrospectively devised a case report form from chart review of patients in the open-label, single-arm Expanded Access Protocol, review team leader Lara Dimick-Santos reported. The company also conducted a retrospective literature review to construct a historical control, she said. BTG PLC’s Voraxaze (glucarpidase) for methotrexate toxicity, which was approved based on data from 22 patients from NIH treatment protocol. The size of the efcacy data set was “less than optimal,” Division of Oncology Products 2 Director Patricia Keegan commented in her summary review, but a larger study was precluded by “the low incidence of the condition and inability to prospectively identify patients at high risk for this condition.” However, “given the extensive data, based on more than 40 years of clinical trials, the methotrexate excretion curves are well-characterized and can be used as an historical control against which the results of this trial can be assessed for efcacy,” she said. Historical Controls Often Key Historical controls were also key to the approvals of Wellstat Therapeutics Corp.’s Vistogard (uridine triacetate), approved in 2015 for overdose of 5-FU chemotherapy, and Fresenius Kabi’s recently approved IV lipid emulsion https://pink.pharmaintelligence.informa.com/PS123648/A-Bakers-Dozen-Of-US-FDA-Efficacy-Approvals-Using-Real-World-Evidence 3/4 8/16/2019 A Baker’s Dozen Of US FDA Efficacy Approvals Using Real World Evidence :: Pink Sheet Omegaven.