Everyone 7 128 1655 rep_agd_ID Draft 3 Chief Executives 1 0 57 rep_exe_IDsNo No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No NoENV1 04/11/2008 09:30:52 Chief Executive Old 52 1 East Dorset District Council Planning Committee Agenda Item No 6 4th November, 2008 Public Report Schedule of Planning Applications Item for Decision: To consider the planning applications contained within the schedule and to receive details of any withdrawn or requested deferred applications, if any. Contributors: Chief Executive Contact Officer: Michael Hirsh, Head of Planning & Building Control Financial Implications: None. Council Priorities: ENV1 Recommendations: It is RECOMMENDED that the applications contained in this schedule be determined or otherwise dealt with in accordance with the Head of Planning and Building Control's recommendation. 1. Applicable Lead Member Area(s) 1.1 Environment. 2. Crime and Disorder – Section 17 Implications 2.1 Where there is a specific crime and disorder matter that is a material planning consideration, it will form part of the report related to the particular application. 3. Equalities Implications 3.1 There are no implications associated with this report. 4. Risk Implications 4.1 There are no implications associated with this report. 5. Application Schedule No. Application No. Site Address Pg. 1. 3/08/0468/FUL 92 High Street, Sturminster Marshall, Wimborne 2 2. 3/08/0659/FUL 112 Station Road, West Moors, Ferndown 17 3. 3/08/0788/FUL Hunters Lodge, High Street, Sturminster Marshall 19 4. 3/08/0929/FUL Sutton Farm, Sutton, Wimborne 22 5. 3/08/0955/FUL Dudsbury Golf Club , 64 Christchurch Road, Ferndown 25 6. 3/08/0991/FUL 8 Freemans Lane, Colehill, Dorset 30 7. 3/08/1003/FUL Bucklers Hard, 3 Rowlands Hill, Wimborne 33 8. 3/08/1031/FUL 69 High Street, Sturminster Marshall, Wimborne 36 9. 3/08/1039/COU 133 Coppice Avenue, Ferndown, Dorset 39 10. 3/08/1080/FUL 33 Dudsbury Road, West Parley, Dorset 40 11. 3/08/1089/FUL 58 Heatherdown Road, West Moors, Ferndown 43 12. 3/08/1100/FUL 112 Station Road, West Moors, Ferndown 45 13. 3/08/1101/FUL Orchard House, Pentridge, Salisbury 46 14. 3/08/1104/FUL Land To The Rear Of, 112 Station Road, West Moors 50 1 Item Number: 1. Ref: 3/08/0468/FUL Proposal: Erect 21 Dwellings, access Road, Garaging, Parking and Play Area as amended by plans and additional plans rec'd 25.7.08 and add info rec'd 18.8.08 and 26.8.08 and 9.10.08 Site Address: 92 High Street, Sturminster Marshall, Wimborne, for Mr C Palmer Constraints Groundwater Protection Zone Site Notice expired: 8 May 2008 Advert expired: 9 May 2008 Nbr-Nfn expired: 24 October 2008 Sturminster Marshall Parish Objection: Council Comments: Access, Housing, Pavement, Disabled Access, Overlooking, Levels, Car parking, Play Area, Services, Water, Sewerage, Surface Water, Old Thatch, Hazard Sturminster Marshall Parish Objection: Council Comments: Parish Councils original objections are to stand. Also: Access, Levels, Car-parking, Surface Water, Flooding. Consultee Responses: County Highways Development No Objection, subject to conditions Liaison Officer Environment Agency No objection subject to following conditions and informatives as detailed in letter on file dated 07.05.08 in respect of following: Flood Risk Surface Water Drainage Water Efficiency Pollution Prevention During Construction Foul Water Drainage EDDC Design And The amended layout, received on 9 October, addresses Conservation some of our earlier design concerns and, overall, just about meets Building for Life design criteria. Good quality building materials and landscaping should raise the design standard further Neighbour Comments: Mrs Kerry Clark & Object Mr Stephen Clark Car lights 75 High Street Traffic/parking concerns Sturminster Marshall Noise Mr and Mrs R Blackburn Object 72 High Street Traffic Sturminster Marshall Floods Sewer system 2 Drains Mrs G Dyer Object 64 Churchill Street Traffic Congestion Sturminster Marshall Danger to Highway Users Near School Historic Part of Sturminster Marshall - Part of Character Owner And Occupier Object 114 High Street Overdevelopment Sturminster Marshall Out of Keeping Increase in Traffic Light Pollution Mr A Wickham Object Lark's Way Out of Keeping High Close Overcrowded Sewage System Overloaded Light Pollution Mrs Lamb Object 7 Churchill Close Roads Inadequate Sturminster Marshall Loss of Privacy S Myock Object 23 Moor Lane Increase in Traffic Sturminster Marshall Inadequate Sewer System Flood Risk Loss Of Privacy L And N Rule Object Rose Cottage Overdevelopment, Front Lane Safety Environment Village Needs Mrs Champion Object The Sett Access 85 High Street Flooding Street Lighting D K Martin Object 3 High Close Traffic Sturminster Marshall Parking Facilities Character of village Mrs Wallis Object 18 Charborough Way Parking Sturminster Marshall Overdevelopment Access Mr And Mrs Hopkins Object Kilvey Wildlife 26 B Church Hill Close Traffic Access R And M Daniels Object 10 Sheridan Way Boundaries Sturminster Marshall Overlooking Context Mr Butler Objection 6 Sheridan Way Overdevelopment Sturminster Marshall Out of character Loss of privacy Mr And Mrs Martin Object 3 8 Sheridan Way Overlooking Sturminster Marshall Loss of privacy Trees Siobhan Myock Object 2 Malwood Concerns re Traffic, Flooding and inadequate sewage Moor Lane system Over development of site Out of keeping with area Mr J Bennett Object 100 High Street Overlooking concerns Sturminster Marshall Concerns of location for affordable housing Green belt Mr And Mrs D Woodiwiss Objects 94 High Street Insufficient Parking / Danger to Highway Users Sturminster Marshall Increased Traffic Loss of Privacy Light Pollution Risk to Health Mrs S Dyer object 15 Churchill Close overdevelopment Sturminster Marshall traffic/parking concerns Wimborne, Dorset overlooking Mr And Mrs S Pugh Object 67 High Street Infrastucture is at full capacity Sturminster Minster Traffic/parking concerns Wildlife concerns Mr And Mrs Davison Object 5 King Street Surface water Sturminster Marshall Loss of character Traffic/parking Mr And Mrs Thomas Object 51 Churchill Close Parking/traffic Sturminster Marshall Mrs Anderson Object 65 High Street Access Sturminster Marshall Traffic/parking Mr Anderson Object 65 High Street Access Sturminster Marshall Traffic/parking R Tilling Object 61 High Street Floodplain Sturminster Marshall Sewerage Owner/occupier Object 142 High Street Traffic/parking Sturminster Marshall Too many dwellings E House Object 140 High Street Sturminster Marshall P Cross Object 77 High Street Access Sturminster Marshall J Tipping Object No Address Given Traffic/parking Sewers 4 Further e-mail rec'd 9/8/08 - Object Owner And Occupier Objects 105 High Street Historic Building Sturminster Marshall Flood Risk to Area Traffic Congestion will get Worse Residential Properties Overlooked Not in Keeping Detrimental to Wildlife Light Pollution M Woodbine Objects 4 Station Road Overloaded Sewer System Sturminster Marshall Inadequate Visibility at Access Light Pollution Wildlife Habitats Threatened Owner/Occupier Object 1 High Close Access Sturminster Marshall Flooding Drains V Gunther Object 95 High Street Sewers Sturminster Marshall Flooding Parking Traffic Safety Street Lighting R And G Boyd Object 16 Balls Lane Traffic Sturminster Marshall Amenities Remain a Village not a Town A And J Dean Object 28A Churchill Close Traffic Sturminster Marshall Sewers Mr And Mrs Taylor Object Forge Cottage Traffic 12 King's Street Sewers Ms Cure Object 41 Churchill Close Land should be green belt Sturminster Marshall Housing Needs Schools Sewers Water / Services Light Pollution Wildlife Mr And Mrs Jones Object 25 King's Street Infrastructure Sturminster Marshall Access Water Sewers Character of area S B Cobb Object 130 High Street Access Sturminster Marshall Traffic Safety Amenities 5 Drainage Mr And Mrs Fuller Objects 82 High Street Drainage issues Sturminster Marshall Congestion near to school Weighted towards financial gain not needs of local people Mrs Fernandez Object 102 High Street Sewers Sturminster Marshall Traffic Street Lighting Sue King I object to the planning application on the grounds that it is 3 Sheriden Way inappropriate to the character of the village to add yet Sturminster Marshall another housing estate in addition to the increase in traffic Dorset it would cause which would be detrimental to the village which has enough problems coping with traffic volume etc D F Monk Object 73 High Street Parking/traffic Sturminster Marshall Mr & Mrs P Windle Object 83 High Street Safety Sturminster Marshall Traffic Parking Rachel Bennion-Pedley Object 51 High Street traffic/parking Sturminster Marshall infrastructure Mr & Mrs Dance Object 69 High Street noise Sturminster Marshall traffic flooding light pollution overdevelopment P Hanwell Object 105b High Street traffic concerns Sturminster Marshall F Freeman Object 135 Church Street sewers Sturminster Marshall traffic flooding change the character of the area Mr And Mrs Davidson Object 5 Kings Street Land should be returned to green belt Sturminster Marshall Address should be listed and demolition prevented Mr And Mrs Williams Object 84 High Street sewerage/drainage Sturminster Marshall traffic/parking Owner/Occupier Object 16 Churchill Close parking/traffic Sturminster Marshall drains V Lewis Object 3 Reeves Orchard Sturminster Marshall Mr P Mounty Object 5 Sheridan Way infrastructure at full capacity Sturminster Marshall traffic/parking E Gant Object 6 106 High Street traffic/parking