Journal of Glaciology http://journals.cambridge.org/JOG Additional services for Journal of Glaciology: Email alerts: Click here Subscriptions: Click here Commercial reprints: Click here Terms of use : Click here Glaciers in equilibrium, McMurdo Dry Valleys, Antarctica ANDREW G. FOUNTAIN, HASSAN J. BASAGIC, IV and SPENCER NIEBUHR Journal of Glaciology / FirstView Article / August 2016, pp 1 - 14 DOI: 10.1017/jog.2016.86, Published online: 29 July 2016 Link to this article: http://journals.cambridge.org/abstract_S0022143016000861 How to cite this article: ANDREW G. FOUNTAIN, HASSAN J. BASAGIC, IV and SPENCER NIEBUHR Glaciers in equilibrium, McMurdo Dry Valleys, Antarctica. Journal of Glaciology, Available on CJO 2016 doi:10.1017/jog.2016.86 Request Permissions : Click here Downloaded from http://journals.cambridge.org/JOG, IP address: 137.222.139.50 on 01 Aug 2016 Journal of Glaciology (2016), Page 1 of 14 doi: 10.1017/jog.2016.86 © The Author(s) 2016. This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons. org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Glaciers in equilibrium, McMurdo Dry Valleys, Antarctica ANDREW G. FOUNTAIN,1 HASSAN J. BASAGIC IV,1 SPENCER NIEBUHR2 1Department of Geology, Portland State University, Portland, OR 97201, USA 2Polar Geospatial Center, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN 55108, USA Correspondence: Andrew G. Fountain <[email protected]> ABSTRACT. The McMurdo Dry Valleys are a cold, dry polar desert and the alpine glaciers therein exhibit small annual and seasonal mass balances, often <±0.06 m w.e. Typically, winter is the accumulation season, but significant snow storms can occur any time of year occasionally making summer the accu- mulation season. The yearly equilibrium line altitude is poorly correlated with mass balance because the elevation gradient of mass balance on each glacier can change dramatically from year to year. Most likely, winds redistribute the light snowfall disrupting the normal gradient of increasing mass balance with elevation. Reconstructed cumulative mass balance shows that the glaciers have lost <2m w.e. over the past half century and area changes show minimal retreat. In most cases these changes are less than the uncertainty and the glaciers are considered in equilibrium. Since 2000, however, the glaciers have lost mass despite relatively stable summer air temperatures suggesting a different mechanism in play. Whether this trend is a harbinger of future changes or a temporary excursion is unclear. KEYWORDS: Antarctica, glaciers, mass balance 1. INTRODUCTION degrees below freezing. Meltwater from the glaciers feed The glaciers of Taylor Valley, McMurdo Dry Valleys (MDV), ephemeral streams, which flow for ∼6–10 weeks a year have been shown to be in equilibrium with the current (McKnight and others, 1999) before discharging into climate over the period, 1993–2001 (Fountain and others, enclosed perennially ice-covered lakes. Little snow falls in 2006). This finding is unusual in the global assessment of the valley bottom; the largest values are found at the coast, − glacier stability because the majority of glaciers during that typically >0.05 m w.e. a 1, with smaller values away from time period were not only receding, as they have over the coast (Fountain and others, 2010). Most of the snow much of the past century, but their retreat was accelerating accumulation sublimates before melting (Chinn, 1993; (Kaser and others, 2006; Lemke and others, 2007). The differ- Eveland and others, 2012). Consequently, glacial melt is ing behavior is due to the below freezing summer air tem- the most important source of water to the streams and lakes peratures in the MDV and the cooling trend in the decade in the valleys. The glaciers act as frozen reservoirs of water, of the 1990s (Doran and others, 2002b; Thompson and liberated when energy is available, feeding the streams, Solomon, 2002). In this report we update the measured lakes and supporting the microbial life that inhabits all land- mass-balance record to 2013 and reconstruct the time scape elements (Fountain and others, 1999; Gooseff and series back to 1965 to evaluate whether changes we others, 2011). Therefore, knowing the current stability of observe in recent decades differ from previous decades. these glaciers is also important for understanding the hydro- This is important for distinguishing temporary variations logical functioning of this polar landscape and the microbial from long-term trends and how the climate, as expressed ecosystem that it supports. by glacier variations, may be changing. Finally, because so The alpine glaciers of the MDV are polar glaciers frozen to few programs have monitored the mass balance of polar gla- the bed, consequently all meltwater is from surface melt (Bull ciers, we examine whether some of the basic concepts for and Carnein, 1970; Cuffey and others, 2000; Fountain and evaluating the balance of temperate glaciers apply to polar others, 2006). The accumulation zone is blanketed with glaciers. dry snow and firn with thin ice layers from brief episodic The MDV are the largest ice-free expanse in Antarctica, melt events. The ablation zone is typically snow-free year- ∼4500 km2 (Levy, 2012)(Fig. 1). The Trans Antarctic round because episodic snow accumulations are often Range blocks the flow of the East Antarctic ice sheet into swept away by winter winds. The glaciers terminate in tall the valleys and the precipitation shadow cast by the range (∼20 m) cliffs, typical of polar glaciers at high latitudes or ele- reduces snowfall, minimizing local glacier growth vations (Bull and Carnein, 1970; Mölg and others, 2008). (Fountain and others, 2010). The landscape is characterized Larger glaciers reach the valley floor forming a fan-like by broad expanses of a sandy gravel matrix with frequent lobe that accommodates much of the ablation zone. exposures of bedrock, particularly along the valley walls. Mass balance is controlled by snow accumulation and ab- Alpine glaciers descend from the local mountain ranges, lation like glaciers elsewhere. Unlike glaciers in temperate the largest of which reach the valley floor. A few outlet gla- regions, however, the mass balance regime is not entirely ciers of the East Antarctic ice sheet make their way into the defined by season (Chinn, 1981; Fountain and others, valleys terminating in the western margins. Average annual 2006). Snow accumulates any time of year and, from time air temperatures vary between −15 and −30 °C across the to time, summer is the accumulation season and winter valleys and summer temperatures commonly hover a few is the ablation season. Ablation occurs continually as 2 Fountain and others: Glaciers in equilibrium, McMurdo Dry Valleys, Antarctica Fig. 1. Satellite image of the McMurdo Dry Valleys, showing the study glaciers (labelled) and the Lake Hoare weather station (yellow dot). The image is from the Landsat Image Mosaic of Antarctica (http://lima.usgs.gov/index.php) and dates to1999–2002. sublimation, accounting for all ablation in winter and often Wright Valley (Calkin, 1964) followed by a study on the >50% in summer (Lewis and others, 1998; Hoffman and Meserve Glacier (Bull and Carnein, 1970). In the summer others, 2008, 2016). During the summer, snow typically sub- of 1969/70 the New Zealand Antarctic Program (NZAP) limates instead of melting because the below-freezing air established the first long-term glacier monitoring program temperatures and windy environment keep the surface cool as part of their annual hydrological surveys (Chinn, 1980). and solar heating is minimized by snow’s high albedo The program included mass-balance measurements on (Fountain and others, 2010). Ice too does not readily melt seven glaciers in Wright and Victoria valleys and repeatedly and the icy ablation zones are commonly dry to the touch. photographed terminus positions on these and other glaciers Surprisingly, most melt seems to occur in the subsurface from fixed markers on the landscape (Chinn and Cumming, due to a solid-state greenhouse effect (Brandt and Warren, 1983). After more than a decade of measurements the last 1993; Fountain and others, 2004a; Hoffman and others, were made in the 1982/83 season. Ten years later the Long 2008, 2016). Solar radiation is transmitted into the ice Term Ecological Research project (LTER) of the United where it is absorbed faster than heat conducted out of the States National Science Foundation initiated a long-term ice causing internal melt. Glacial runoff is common in program of physical and biological measurements in December and January, with a peak melt period of about neighboring Taylor Valley that included mass-balance 4 weeks long from mid-December to mid-January coinciding measurements on two glaciers, and ablation-zone-only mea- with the period of maximum solar radiation (Hoffman and surements on four other glaciers (Fountain and others, 2006). others, 2008, 2016). We define summer as the 3-month Both NZAP (Chinn and Cumming, 1983) and LTER (Fountain period from November–January, which brackets both peak and others, 2004b) programs photographed glacier terminus glacial runoff (ablation) and our summer mass-balance mea- positions. In addition, snow pits have provided data on surements. Winter is the remaining 9 months. Generally, the annual snow accumulation for the past 50 a (Welch, 1993; magnitudes of summer and winter ablation are equivalent al- Witherow and others, 2006; Bertler and others, 2006). though the rates are much higher in summer than winter (Fountain and others, 2006). The response time of these glaciers is slow, ∼103 a, based on the magnitude of annual 2. METHODS − − mass change at the terminus, ∼10 1 ma 1, and the We monitored mass balance on two glaciers, Commonwealth average ∼102 m thickness of the glaciers (Johannesson and and Howard. Commonwealth Glacier flows southward from others, 1989; Fountain and others, 2004b).