KAUNAS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY FACULTY OF SOCIAL SCIENCES, ARTS AND HUMANITIES IMPLEMENTATION, VALIDITY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF EUROPEAN UNION COUNTER-TERRORISM POLICIES IN THE CONTEXT OF CONTEMPORARY TRANSFORMATIONS OF TERRORISM Final project for Master degree Supervisor Assoc. Prof. Dr. Šarūnas Paunksnis KAUNAS, 2018 KAUNO TECHNOLOGIJOS UNIVERSITETAS SOCIALINIŲ, HUMANITARINIŲ MOKSLŲ IR MENŲ FAKULTETAS EUROPOS SĄJUNGOS KOVOS SU TERORIZMU POLITIKOS ĮGYVENDINIMAS, PAGRĮSTUMAS IR VEIKSMINGUMAS ATSIŽVELGIANT Į ŠIUOLAIKINIUS TERORIZMO POKYČIUS Baigiamasis magistro projektas Vadovas Doc. Dr. Šarūnas Paunksnis KAUNAS, 2018 2 KAUNO TECHNOLOGIJOS UNIVERSITETAS SOCIALINIŲ, HUMANITARINIŲ MOKSLŲ IR MENŲ FAKULTETAS EUROPOS SĄJUNGOS KOVOS SU TERORIZMU POLITIKOS ĮGYVENDINIMAS, PAGRĮSTUMAS IR VEIKSMINGUMAS ATSIŽVELGIANT Į ŠIUOLAIKINIUS TERORIZMO POKYČIUS Baigiamasis magistro projektas Europos Sąjungos tarptautiniai santykiai (kodas 621L20016) Vadovas (parašas) Doc. Dr. Šarūnas Paunksnis (data) 2018 01 09 Recenzentas (parašas) Doc. Dr. Gintaras Žilinskas (data) Projektą atliko (parašas) Edita Adomaitytė (data) KAUNAS, 2018 3 KAUNO TECHNOLOGIJOS UNIVERSITETAS Socialinių, humanitarinių mokslų ir menų (Fakultetas) Edita Adomaitytė (Studento vardas, pavardė) Europos Sąjungos tarptautiniai santykiai, 621L20016 (Studijų programa, kursas) Baigiamojo projekto „ Implementation, Validity And Effectiveness Of European Union Counter- Terrorism Policies In The Context Of Contemporary Transformations Of Terrorism “ AKADEMINIO SĄŽININGUMO DEKLARACIJA 20 18 m. sausio 8 d. Kaunas Patvirtinu, kad mano, Editos Adomaitytės, baigiamasis projektas tema „ Implementation, validity and effectiveness of European union counter-terrorism policies in the context of contemporary transformations of terrorism “yra parašytas visiškai savarankiškai ir visi pateikti duomenys ar tyrimų rezultatai yra teisingi ir gauti sąžiningai. Šiame darbe nei viena dalis nėra plagijuota nuo jokių spausdintinių ar internetinių šaltinių, visos kitų šaltinių tiesioginės ir netiesioginės citatos nurodytos literatūros nuorodose. Įstatymų nenumatytų piniginių sumų už šį darbą niekam nesu mokėjęs. Aš suprantu, kad išaiškėjus nesąžiningumo faktui, man bus taikomos nuobaudos, remiantis Kauno technologijos universitete galiojančia tvarka. (vardą ir pavardę įrašyti ranka) (parašas) 4 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS COREPER - The Committee of Permanent Representatives in the European Union CIA - Central Intelligence Agency CFSP - Common Foreign and Security Policy COM - Communication CT - Counter-Terrorism CTG - Counter-Terrorism Group EIDHR - European Initiative for Democracy and Human Rights EU - European Union EAW - European Arrest Warrant EC - European Commission ETA - Euskadi Ta Askatasuna (separatist group) Europol - The European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Cooperation FEMYSO - Forum of European Muslim Youth and Student Organization FRONTEX - European Border Agency G6 - The Group of Six (Germany, France, United Kingdom, Italy, Spain, Poland) GTD - Global Terrorism Database IRA - Irish Red Army IS - Islamic State ISIS - Islamic State in Iraq and Syria PWGT - Police Working Group on Terrorism SIS - Schengen Information System SITCEN/INTCEN - European Union Intelligence and Situation Centre TE-SAT - EU Terrorism Situation & Trend Report UN - United Nations US - United States USSR - Union of Soviet Socialist Republics WW2 - World War II 9/11 - 2001 terrorist attacks in United States 3/11 - 2005 terrorist attacks in Spain, Madrid 5 LIST OF GRAPHS AND TABLES Graph 1. The average number of terrorist attacks in 2001-2008 in EU Member States ..................... 16 Graph 2. The average number of terrorist attacks in 2009-2016 in EU Member States ..................... 17 Graph 3. The EU measurements on fight against terrorism ........................................................................ 43 Graph 4. The major axes of EU Counter-Terrorism ...................................................................................... 44 Graph 5. The main types of funding of terrorist cells in 1994-2013 ........................................................ 50 Graph 6. Issued & Executed European Arrest Warrant in 2005-2015 ..................................................... 54 Graph 7. Implementation, evaluation and monitoring of strategies, policies and measures in 2001- 2016 ............................................................................................................................................................................... 56 Table 1. Two-by-two matrix of EU Counter-Terrorism Strategy .....................................................45 Table 2. Prevention Strategies of hotspot EU Member States ..........................................................46 Table 3. Evaluation of two-by-two matrix of EU Counter-Terrorism Strategy ................................57 6 CONTENT LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ..............................................................................................................5 LIST OF GRAPHS AND TABLES .....................................................................................................6 CONTENT ...........................................................................................................................................7 INTRODUCTION ..............................................................................................................................10 1. CLARIFICATION OF TERRORISM PHENOMENA ..........................................................13 1.1. Contemporary Threats of Terrorism .......................................................................................13 1.2. The Threat of Terrorism to Europe .........................................................................................15 1.3. Factors contributing to the Radicalization of European Muslim communities .......................18 1.3.1. The Review of the Muslim communities in Europe ........................................................19 1.3.2. The Influence of radical Islamist preachers .....................................................................20 1.3.3 The Radical Islamist Movement Factor ...........................................................................22 1.3.4. The challenges of Integration policies .............................................................................23 1.4. The rise of Jihadi culture .........................................................................................................24 1.4.1. Al-Qaeda's and ISIS activities in Europe .........................................................................26 2. THE APPROACH OF COUNTER-TERRORISM IN THE EU ................................................28 2.1. The evolution of the EU's counter-terrorism policies ................................................................29 2.1.1. Counter-Terrorism in the EU prior 9/11 ..........................................................................30 2.1.2. Counter-Terrorism in the EU after 9/11 ...........................................................................33 2.1.3. Counter-Terrorism after Madrid attacks in 2004 .............................................................35 2.1.4. Counter-Terrorism after London attacks in 2005 ............................................................36 2.2. Recent initiatives after the attacks in 2015 and 2016 ..............................................................37 2.3. The Mechanism of EU Counter-Terrorism policy ..................................................................38 3. THE ANALYSIS OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF COUNTER-TERRORISM MEASURES 44 3.1. Methodology ...........................................................................................................................44 3.2. Prevent .....................................................................................................................................45 3.3. Pursue ......................................................................................................................................49 3.4. Protect ......................................................................................................................................51 3.5. Respond ...................................................................................................................................53 4. EVALUATION AND FUTURE TRENDS OF EU COUNTER TERRORISM POLICIES ......56 CONCLUSIONS ................................................................................................................................60 LIST OF REFERENCES ...................................................................................................................62 ANNEX 1. ..........................................................................................................................................67 ANNEX 2. ..........................................................................................................................................68 7 Adomaityte, Edita. Implementation, Validity And Effectiveness Of European Union Counter Terrorism Policies In The Context Of Contemporary Transformations Of Terrorism: Master ‘s thesis in Political Science / supervisor assoc. prof. Šarūnas Paunksnis. The Faculty of Social Sciences, Arts and Humanities, Kaunas University of Technology. Research area and field: 02 S Key words: counter, terrorism, European, Union, policies, Muslim, measurements. Kaunas, 2018. 68 p. SUMMARY Terrorism is one of the main threats