Inverse renormalization group in quantum field theory Dimitrios Bachtis,1, ∗ Gert Aarts,2, 3, y Francesco Di Renzo,4, z and Biagio Lucini1, 5, x 1Department of Mathematics, Swansea University, Bay Campus, SA1 8EN, Swansea, Wales, UK 2Department of Physics, Swansea University, Singleton Campus, SA2 8PP, Swansea, Wales, UK 3European Centre for Theoretical Studies in Nuclear Physics and Related Areas (ECT*) & Fondazione Bruno Kessler Strada delle Tabarelle 286, 38123 Villazzano (TN), Italy 4Dipartimento di Scienze Matematiche, Fisiche e Informatiche, Universit´adi Parma and INFN, Gruppo Collegato di Parma, I-43100 Parma, Italy 5Swansea Academy of Advanced Computing, Swansea University, Bay Campus, SA1 8EN, Swansea, Wales, UK (Dated: July 01, 2021) We propose inverse renormalization group transformations within the context of quantum field theory that produce the appropriate critical fixed point structure, give rise to inverse flows in parameter space, and evade the critical slowing down effect in calculations pertinent to criticality. Given configurations of the two-dimensional φ4 scalar field theory with size V = 322, we apply the inverse transformations to produce rescaled systems of size up to V 0 = 5122 which we utilize to extract two critical exponents. We conclude by discussing how the approach is generally applicable to any method that successfully produces configurations from a statistical ensemble and how it can give novel insights into the structure of the renormalization group. I. INTRODUCTION Invertibility is a concept that emerges naturally in the mathematical and physical sciences. A simple example of an inverse problem can be defined as follows: given a set of configurations which are sampled in a Monte Carlo simulation, specify the most accurate coupling con- stants in the underlying Hamiltonian or action of the sys- FIG. 1. Illustration of the inverse renormalization group. tem that are able to reproduce them. The problem can Inverse transformations are applied to iteratively increase the be formally expressed as the minimization of a distance size L in each dimension by a factor of b, therefore evading metric between two probability distributions under the the critical slowing down effect. condition that the model distribution has a dependence on a set of variational parameters, which in the consid- ered case is the set of the coupling constants. The same the transition to quantum field theory will give rise to a concept underpins numerous approaches within machine variety of intricacies, the most simple being the concep- learning. An example arises in quantum field-theoretic tion of appropriate inverse transformations for systems machine learning algorithms where arbitrary continuous with continuous degrees of freedom. data can be reproduced based on representations con- To our knowledge, no inverse renormalization group structed by specifying the optimal values of the coupling approach has ever been explored within quantum field constants within algorithms derived from lattice field the- theory, despite the fact that computational applications ories [1]. pertinent to the standard renormalization group are nu- The renormalization group [2{4], which is omnipresent merous, for instance, see Refs. [8{10]. The benefits of in quantum field theory and statistical physics, is con- inverse renormalization would be tremendous: one could sidered to be a non-invertible concept. Scale transfor- apply the transformations iteratively in the vicinity of a arXiv:2107.00466v1 [hep-lat] 1 Jul 2021 mations which construct reduced self-similar represen- phase transition to increase the size of the system and tations of systems necessarily incur some loss of infor- eliminate the critical slowing down effect. Inverse flows mation about the original representation. One should in parameter space would then enable the accurate lo- then classify the renormalization group as a semi-group. cation of the critical fixed point, and relations between Nevertheless, the concept of inverse renormalization has observables of the original and the rescaled system could been discussed within the context of statistical physics be derived to calculate multiple critical exponents and to based on systems with simple degrees of freedom, such obtain complete knowledge of the considered phase tran- as the binary Ising model [5{7]. One then expects that sition. Compared to the standard renormalization group, which reduces the size of the system by eliminating de- grees of freedom and can hence be applied for only a ∗ [email protected] finite number of steps, inverse renormalization increases y [email protected] the size of the system and can therefore, in principle, be z [email protected] applied for an arbitrary number of steps. x [email protected] In this manuscript, we propose inverse renormaliza- 2 tion group transformations as a means to study phase on the distance t from the critical point; in the thermo- transitions in quantum field theory. We explore if the dynamic limit it diverges at K = Kc. Through the ap- application of inverse transformations is able to itera- plication of iterative transformations which increase the tively increase the size of the system and if it accurately correlation length, each of the rescaled systems will have produces the anticipated flows in parameter space. We a different distance t0 from the critical point and as a re- then derive expressions between observables of the orig- sult a different coupling constant K0. This is the essence inal and the rescaled system that enable the accurate of the renormalization group flow induced in parameter calculation of multiple critical exponents. The results space. are illustrated using the second-order phase transition of We now consider an intensive observable O in the orig- the two-dimensional φ4 scalar field theory. We conclude inal system which is a function of the coupling constant by discussing how the approach is generally applicable to K. Due to the divergence of the correlation length at any method that produces configurations from a statisti- the critical point Kc the intensive observable quantities cal ensemble and how it can give novel insights into the O and O0 of the original and the rescaled systems will be structure of the renormalization group. equal: 0 O(Kc) = O (Kc): (6) II. FUNDAMENTALS OF THE INVERSE This equation provides a self-consistent manner in lo- RENORMALIZATION GROUP cating the critical fixed point: specifically it is the point in parameter space where the observables of the two sys- To construct inverse transformations for systems on tems intersect. To locate the critical point it is advisable graphs or lattices we will devise a set of operations that to compare an original and a rescaled system of the same mimics the inversion of a previously induced transfor- lattice size to reduce finite size effects [11]. mation. Explicitly, we consider a system of lattice size Under the condition that observables O0 in the rescaled L in each dimension and apply a renormalization group system appear according to the probability distribution transformation to reduce its size as of the original system [11, 12], we can extrapolate O0 along the trajectory of a coupling constant K using his- L ! L0 = L=b; (1) togram reweighting [12{15], while relying on the action where b > 1 is the rescaling factor. Our aim is now to S of the original system: learn a set of operations that can mimic the inversion of PN 0 (0) (m) O exp[−(Km − Km )Sσ )] this transformation: hO0i = l=1 σl l ; (7) PN (0) (m) l=1 exp[−(Km − Km )Sσl )] L0 ! L = bL0: (2) where σl is a configuration of the system, N is the num- The benefit of the approach is that the operations can P (0) (m) ber of samples and the action S = m Km S of the be iteratively applied to arbitrarily increase the size of original system is expressed as a sum over products of the system (see Fig. 1). Specifically, if we consider an (0) coupling constants Km and their corresponding action initial system of size L in each dimension and correlation terms S(m). In this example the discussed histogram length ξ, then the consecutive applications will produce reweighting approach considers strictly the extrapola- systems of sizes L0 ! L1 = bL0 ! L2 = bL1 ! ::: tion of exclusively one coupling constant K in parameter where the relation describing the increase in the system space. size at step j is: A critical exponent that characterizes a phase tran- (j−i) sition is the exponent β which couples to the magneti- Lj = b Li: (3) β β zation mi ∼ jtij and mj ∼ jtjj , and which can be equivalently expressed in terms of the correlation length Here j > i ≥ 0, and L0 = L. The increase in the lattice −β/ν −β/ν size will additionally induce an increase in the correlation as mi ∼ ξi and mj ∼ ξj , where ν is the exponent length: that governs the divergence of ξ. By dividing, substitut- ing, and taking the natural logarithm of the expressions (j−i) ξj = b ξi; (4) we arrive at the relation: m m with ξ = ξ. To proceed we introduce the concept of β ln j ln j 0 = − mi = − mi : (8) a reduced coupling constant, which is a measure of the ν ln ξj (j − i) ln b distance of a coupling constant K from the critical point ξi Kc, and which can be defined as: The above expression can be redefined to be suitable for a finite system using l'H^opital'srule [11], arriving at K − K t = c : (5) the expression: Kc dmj dmj β ln ln The correlation length ξ arises dynamically in the = − dmi Kc = − dmi Kc : (9) vicinity of a phase transition and it inherently depends ν ln ξj (j − i) ln b ξi 3 FIG. 3. Illustration of the optimization approach. Trans- posed convolutions (TC) are applied on configurations pro- duced with the renormalization group (RG) to construct a FIG.