Democratic Services Section Chief Executive’s Department Belfast City Council City Hall Belfast BT1 5GS 11th August, 2015 MEETING OF PLANNING COMMITTEE Dear Alderman/Councillor, The above-named Committee will meet in the Banqueting Room - City Hall on Tuesday, 18th August, 2015 at 5.00 pm, for the transaction of the business noted below. You are requested to attend. Yours faithfully, SUZANNE WYLIE Chief Executive AGENDA: 1. Apologies 2. Declarations of Interest 3. Routine Correspondence - Taxi Rank in Donegall Square (for notation) (Pages 1 - 2) 4. Area of Special Scientific Interest - Belvoir Area (for notation) (Pages 3 - 16) 5. Appeal Decisions Notified - (for notation) (Pages 17 - 18) 6. Delegated Decisions Issued - (for notation) (Pages 19 - 26) 7. Reconsidered Item - Z/2015/1518/F 362 Woodstock Road (Pages 27 - 32) 8. Reconsidered Item - Z/2013/1483/F St Thomas' Hall, 138a Lisburn Road (Pages 33 - 48) 9. Z/2015/0180/F - Clarendon Park, Somerdale Park (Pages 49 - 56) 10. Z/2014/0601/F - 12-20 Donegall Road and 7-21 Bradbury Place (Pages 57 - 64) 11. Z/2010/0245/F - 55-71 Ormeau Road (Pages 65 - 76) - 2 – 12. Z/2015/0021/A - Signage on Lower Ormeau Road and Cromac Street (Renewing the Routes) (Pages 77 - 84) 13. LA045/2015/0294/A - Signage on Newtownards Road (Renewing the Routes) (Pages 85 - 96) 14. Miscellaneous Items 15. DoE Listed Buildings Consultations (Pages 97 - 104) 16. Purpose-Built Student Accommodation (Pages 105 - 114) 17. Financial Report - Quarter 1 2015/2016 (Pages 115 - 122) 18. Place-Making Symposium for Councils (Pages 123 - 128) 19. Planning Committee - Continuing Development Programme (Pages 129 - 134) Appeal Decisions Notified between 24 July and 7 August 2015 Appeal Ref Location Proposal Ref No Outcome Appellant Decision Date 72 Upper Malone Road, Unauthorised construction Partially Malone Ridge 2014/E0021 EN/2014/0166 03/08/2015 Belfast of a housing development allowed Ltd Retention of Temporary Car 2014/A0220 99 & 99a Joy Street, Belfast Park Z/2013/1151/F Dismissed LCP Ltd 03/08/2015 Change of use to restaurant including new external deck 46-48 Stranmillis Road, 2014/A0170 and seating area to front Z/2014/0455/F Allowed Little Wing 04/08/2015 Belfast and side, extract chimney to front and bin store to rear. Delegated Planning Applications Decisions Issued Decision Issued From: 8/3/2015 12:00:00To: 8/7/2015 AM 12:00:00 AM Reference Proposal Location Date Decision Applicant Agent Number Issued LA04/2015/0082/A Shop Sign 140 North Queen Street 8/4/15 David McClay Belfast 12 Ballyduff BT15 1HQ Gardens Newtownabbey BT36 6XG LA04/2015/0116/LDEHouse of multiple occupation 35 Stranmillis Gardens 8/4/15 Angela Curran Piney Rentals Ltd 42 (HMO) Belfast 2A Quoile Brae Stranmillis Road BT9 5AT Strangford Belfast Road BT9 5AA Downpatrick BT30 6SD LA04/2015/0143/LDPImprovement works are proposed Ballyaghan Upper Service 8/4/15 Northern Ireland RPS Elmwood House within the existing NI Water Reservoir 5 Upper Castle Park Water 74 Boucher Road Service Reservoir site to facilitate Belfast BT15 5FG Westland House Belfast the deployment of emergency Old Westland BT12 6RZ tankering operations, if required Road during extreme weather Belfast conditions. The works include BT14 6TE enlargement/construction of turning head, widening at tight bends, existing stone pillars to be dismantled, stored and rebuilt in new location, new field gate to match existing Page 1 of 8 Delegated Planning Applications Decisions Issued Decision Issued From: 8/3/2015 12:00:00To: 8/7/2015 AM 12:00:00 AM Reference Proposal Location Date Decision Applicant Agent Number Issued LA04/2015/0175/F Single storey extension to front of 82 Kilcoole Park 8/4/15 G Foster 82 T McCoey 3 Thirlmore dwelling Belfast Kilcoole Park Gardens BT14 8LB Belfast Belfast BT14 8ZB BT15 5EF LA04/2015/0293/F 2 storey rear extension to provide 17 Mayo Park 8/4/15 A Sayers 17 A C Design 30d kitchen on ground floor with Belfast Mayo Park Woodburn Road extended bedroom and bathroom BT13 3BJ Belfast Carrickfergus above BT13 3BJ BT38 8PX LA04/2015/0323/F Single storey extension to front 144 Kilcoole Park 8/4/15 Mr & Mrs C A.L.D.A. Architects 537 and internal alterations Belfast McDonnell 144 Antrim Road BT14 8LD Kilcoole Park Belfast Belfast BT15 3BU BT14 8LD LA04/2015/0403/F Interal & external alterations to 20 Windemere Gardens 8/4/15 W G Konrad 20 Paul Jenkins 40 Mount rear return, works to include Belfast Windemere Merrion Park erection of mono pitch roof. Gardens Belfast Belfast BT6 0GB Y/2015/0071/F Internal alterations to existing 21 Beechgrove Park 8/4/15 Mr and Mrs Alan Warren 537 building and 2 storey extension to Castlereagh Munro 21 Antrim Road rear of dwelling Co. Down BT6 0NQ Beechgrove Belfast Park BT15 3BU Castlereagh BT6 0NQ Z/2014/1697/F Detached single garage 8 Danesfort Park North 8/4/15 Kevin Devlin 8 Dynan Architecture 147 incorporating utility room to rear Belfast Danesfort Park Sandown Road of dwelling (Retrospective) BT9 5RB North Belfast belfast BT5 6GX BT9 5RB Page 2 of 8 Delegated Planning Applications Decisions Issued Decision Issued From: 8/3/2015 12:00:00To: 8/7/2015 AM 12:00:00 AM Reference Proposal Location Date Decision Applicant Agent Number Issued Z/2015/0193/LDE House of Multiple Occupation 36 Eblana Street 8/4/15 Mary Louise Belfast McMahon 10 BT7 1LD Belvedere Park Belfast BT9 5GS Z/2015/0306/LDP proposal for single storey rear 24 Lucerne Parade 8/4/15 Claire Shiells Sarah McAuley extension onto existing dwelling Belfast 24 Lucerne Architect 96 Orby Drive BT9 5FT Parade Belfast Belfast BT5 6AG BT9 5FT LA04/2015/0133/LBCInstallation of new external ATM Santander 8/5/15 Alex Calvert 6 Royal Avenue 201 Grafton Belfast Gate East BT1 1DA Milton Keynes MK9 1AN LA04/2015/0138/F Single storey extension to rear 4 Hampton Manor 8/5/15 Adrian Browne Dynan Architecture 147 Belfast 4 Hampton Sandown Road BT7 3EL Manor Belfast Belfast BT5 6GX BT7 3EL LA04/2015/0148/A Fascia Header to ATM Santander 8/5/15 Alex Calvert 6 Royal Avenue 201 Grafton Belfast Gate East BT1 1DA Milton Keynes MK9 1AN LA04/2015/0149/F Installation of 1 new external Santander 8/5/15 Alex Calvert ATM 6 Royal Avenue 201 Grafton Belfast Gate East BT1 1DA Milton Keynes MK9 1AN Page 3 of 8 Delegated Planning Applications Decisions Issued Decision Issued From: 8/3/2015 12:00:00To: 8/7/2015 AM 12:00:00 AM Reference Proposal Location Date Decision Applicant Agent Number Issued LA04/2015/0151/F Proposed attic conversion to 1 Kincora Avenue 8/5/15 Mr And Mrs Contour Architectural existing dwelling house Belfast Joannides 1 Services Ltd 299 BT4 3DW Kincora Avenue Ormeau Road Belfast Belfast BT4 3DW BT7 3GG LA04/2015/0192/F Roof space conversion 158 Snugville Street 8/5/15 Mark Watters Paddy Birne Architects Belfast 158 Snugville 108 Appleton Park BT13 1NF Street Belfast Belfast BT11 9JF BT13 1NF LA04/2015/0212/F Single storey extension to rear to 1c Chichester Road 8/5/15 Mrs B Lemahieu A B Properties 206 form new sunroom Belfast BT15 5EJ 1c Chichester Gilnahirk Road Road Belfast Belfast BT5 7SH BT15 5EJ LA04/2015/0234/A 3 X Externally illuminated fascia, 155 Crumlin Road 8/5/15 Bestway Group Fiturama Signs 2 X window vinyl Belfast 1 Angel Square Olympia House BT14 7AA Manchester Lockwood Court M60 0AG Middleton Grove Leeds LS11 5TY LA04/2015/0261/A 1no internally illuminated fascia 332 Donegall Road 8/5/15 Bestway Group Futurama Signs and 1no internally illuminated Belfast 1 Angel Square Olympia House projector Co. Antrim Manchester Lockwood Court BT12 6FX M60 0AG Leeds LS11 5TY LA04/2015/0288/F Single storey rear extension 20 Upton Park 8/5/15 HT Watters Ltd Jeffrey Morrow 15 Belfast 1 Lanyon Place Finglush Road BT10 0LZ Belfast Caledon BT68 4XW Page 4 of 8 Delegated Planning Applications Decisions Issued Decision Issued From: 8/3/2015 12:00:00To: 8/7/2015 AM 12:00:00 AM Reference Proposal Location Date Decision Applicant Agent Number Issued LA04/2015/0291/A Erection of 1 gantry mounted slat Tesco Belfast Castlereagh 8/5/15 Tesco Stores DMD Architects no 5 and 9 pole mounted signs 200 Castlereagh Road Ltd Tesco Maidstone Buildens Co. Down BT5 5PT House Mews Delamare Road 72-76 Borough High Cheshunt Street EN8 9SL London SE1 1GN LA04/2015/0373/F Single storey side and rear 36 Strathmore Park South 8/5/15 Mr Paul Rodgers extension to dwelling Belfast 36 Strathmore BT15 5HL Park South Belfast BT15 5HL LA04/2015/0533/F Single storey rear extension 96 Sandown Road 8/5/15 Mr Peter Lavery JP Architects 58 Belfast 96 Sandown Oberon Street BT5 6GW Road Belfast Belfast BT6 8NZ BT5 6GW LA04/2015/0548/A 1no interpretive panel fixed to Yardmen Statue 8/5/15 Ulster-Scots railings alongside Yardmen Pitt Park Agency The statue Newtownards Road Corn Exchange Belfast 31 Gordon BT4 Street Belfast BT1 2LG LA04/2015/0127/F Single storey side extension to 40 Merrion Park 8/6/15 Angela allow ground floor bedroom, Poleglass Richmond 40 ensuite and utility room Lisburn Merrion Park BT17 0SF Poleglass BT17 0SF Page 5 of 8 Delegated Planning Applications Decisions Issued Decision Issued From: 8/3/2015 12:00:00To: 8/7/2015 AM 12:00:00 AM Reference Proposal Location Date Decision Applicant Agent Number Issued LA04/2015/0217/F Tyre exhaust repair garage George Fegan Tyres 8/6/15 Mr Georgwe Doherty Architects 6 92-102 Antrim Road Fegan George Kinnard Street Belfast Fegan Tyres Belfast BT14 6BE 92-102 Antrim BT14 6BE Road Belfast BT14 6BE LA04/2015/0422/DCADemolition of part stone wall for Victoria College 8/6/15 Victoria College Povall Worthington 5 temporary site access.