Experimental test of the differential fluctuation theorem and a generalized Jarzynski equality for arbitrary initial states Thai M. Hoang,1, ∗ Rui Pan,2 Jonghoon Ahn,3 Jaehoon Bang,3 H. T. Quan,2, 4, y and Tongcang Li1, 3, 5, 6, z 1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA 2School of Physics, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China 3School of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA 4Collaborative Innovation Center of Quantum Matter, Beijing 100871, China 5Purdue Quantum Center, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA 6Birck Nanotechnology Center, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA (Dated: October 3, 2018) Nonequilibrium processes of small systems such as molecular machines are ubiquitous in biology, chemistry and physics, but are often challenging to comprehend. In the past two decades, sev- eral exact thermodynamic relations of nonequilibrium processes, collectively known as fluctuation theorems, have been discovered and provided critical insights. These fluctuation theorems are gen- eralizations of the second law, and can be unified by a differential fluctuation theorem. Here we perform the first experimental test of the differential fluctuation theorem, using an optically levi- tated nanosphere in both underdamped and overdamped regimes, and in both spatial and velocity spaces. We also test several theorems that can be obtained from it directly, including a generalized Jarzynski equality that is valid for arbitrary initial states, and the Hummer-Szabo relation. Our study experimentally verifies these fundamental theorems, and initiates the experimental study of stochastic energetics with the instantaneous velocity measurement. In the past two decades, there were significant devel- ciple: the microscopic reversibility connecting forward opments in nonequilibrium statistical mechanics of small and reverse trajectories [1, 18, 24, 29, 31{33]. Testing systems in which thermal fluctuation is influential [1]. the DFT and other FT would deepen our understanding The most prominent progresses are the discoveries of of the second law and nonequilibrium physics, including various fluctuation theorems (FT), which connect mi- dissipation [19], hysterisis [34], and irreversibility [35]. croscopic dynamics with thermodynamic behaviors [1]. In order to test the DFT at its desired level of detail, These FT, such as the Jarzynski equality (JE) [2, 3] and we need large statistics and the ability to track individ- the Crooks fluctuation theorem (CFT) [4, 5], reformu- ual trajectories of a stochastic process in the phase space late the inequality of the second law into equalities, and [20], which requires the measurement of instantaneous reveal the universal laws that the fluctuating thermo- velocities of Brownian motion [36]. dynamic variables must obey in processes arbitrarily far from thermal equilibrium. As they are refinements of the In this work, we experimentally test the differential second law on individual trajectories, they provide criti- fluctuation theorem [20, 29] using an optically levitated cal understandings of behaviors of biological systems at nanosphere which can be trapped in air continuously for the single molecular level [3, 5{10] and nonequilibrium weeks for acquiring large sets of data. Our ultrasen- dynamics of a wide range of physical systems [11{28]. sitive optical tweezer can measure both instantaneous While JE and CFT are valid for processes far from ther- position and instantaneous velocity [36] of a levitated mal equilibrium, they require the initial state to be in a nanosphere to test DFT. Over one million experimen- thermal equilibrium state. tal cycles per setting (∼ 1010 position data points per setting with a 10 MHz acquisition rate) provide suffi- In 2000, a differential fluctuation theorem (DFT) con- cient statistics to validate the DFT at its desired level necting the joint probabilities of entropy production and of detail, e.g., testing DFT for nonequilibrium processes arbitrary generalized coordinates (e.g. position and ve- connecting two points in the position-velocity space [20]. locity coordinates) was derived by Jarzynski [29]. An Several fluctuation theorems, including the JE [2, 3], the arXiv:1706.09587v3 [cond-mat.stat-mech] 3 Jan 2018 equivalent DFT for work was derived by Nobel laureate CFT [4, 5], the Hummer-Szabo relation (HSR) [6{8], the Karplus and his colleagues Maragakis and Spichty in 2008 GJE [19, 24, 31], the extended fluctuation relation (EFR) [20]. It is remarkable that the DFT can unify various FT [9, 10], and the fluctuation theorem for ligand binding as long as detailed balance is not violated [20](see Fig. (FTLB) [37] can be unified by the DFT [18, 24, 31, 32]. S1 in the supplemental material for the relation between We have also tested several such theorems. In our ex- different fluctuation theorems [30]). The DFT also leads periment, the air pressure can be adjusted to test these to a generalized Jarzynski equality (GJE) for arbitrary theorems in both underdamped and overdamped regimes. initial states [24]. Such ability is rooted from the fact This study demonstrates a powerful approach applicable that most FT originate from the same fundamental prin- in exploring a wide range of nonequilibrium systems [3, 5{ 2 A Force Optical Trap A B t t t t f 2 3 2 3 400 on � | | | | c c 500 ::::::, 200 � 0 foff | | ... | | 0 t t t t () O 20 1 4 1 4 0 -��:150067 \ \ 20 \ \ B x(nm) 0 50 0 0.5 1 0 v (mm/s) -5050 v (mm/s) -7 50 0 O -19 x (nm) -25 -20 -50 x (nm) -20 -50 ) s / c D mm ( � � v c § 100 ::::::, 100 0 0 0 () () 25 0 20 -- t t t t 20 - 1 Forward2 3 Reverse 4 Time - - 0 50 0 5 v (mm/s 0 v (mm/s) 0 } _10 0 -15 x (nm) FIG. 1. A, Experimental scheme. A silica nanosphere (blue -20 -50 x (nm) -20 -50 sphere) is trapped in an optical tweezer formed by a focused 1550-nm laser beam (magenta). A series of 532-nm laser FIG. 2. Examples of arbitrary nonequilibrium initial states pulses (green) exerts an optical force on the nanosphere to of trajectory ensembles prepared by an information-based drive nonequilibrium processes. Within each pulse, an op- method. A, Nonequilibrium initial states with narrow distri- tical force is rapidly ramped from f at time t to f at off 1 on butions in position or velocity. B, An exotic nonequilibirum time t during the forward process (green pulse). The reverse 2 state with a P-shaped distribution in phase space. C, Uniform process from time t to t is the time-reversed correspon- 3 4 distribution within a rectangle (−15 nm < x < 0, −10 mm/s dence of the forward process. B, An example of experimen- < v < 0) in the phase space . D, A microcanonical ensemble tal data. Vertical slides represent the measured time snap- with the energy shell 1:3k T < E < 1:35k T: The number shots of the probability distributions at times t ; t ; t , and B B 1 2 3 of experimental trajectories started from each nonequilibrium t as illustrated in A. Black curves represent experimental 4 initial state is labeled next to its distribution. phase-space trajectories during forward processes initialized at (x1; v1) and finalized at (x2; v2), and during reverse pro- cesses initialized at the (x2; −v2) and finalized at (x1; −v1). Here x1 = −19 nm, x2 = 55 nm, v1 = −7 mm/s, and denotes a reversal of the velocity components of a or b. v2 = 7 mm/s. The nanosphere is levitated in air at 50 torr, 2 2 ∆F = −(fon − foff )=(2k) is the free energy difference be- and foff = 0, fon = 340 fN. tween the equilibrium states of the optical forces fon and foff . Here k is the trap stiffness. β = 1=(kBT ), where kB 13, 15, 16] since a complete description of the stochastic is the Boltzmann constant, and T = 296 K is the room system includes the information of both position and ve- temperature. locity. To test the DFT in detail, over one million experimen- Our experiments are carried out using a silica tal forward-reverse cycles (500 µs/cycle) are performed nanosphere levitated by a 1550 nm optical tweezer for a given irreversible setting. Their distributions in the (Fig. 1A) [38]. The nonequilibrium processes are con- position-velocity space are shown in Fig. 1B. The driv- trolled by a force parameter f which is an optical force ing optical forces significantly shift the distributions away exerted on the nanosphere by a 532-nm laser beam. In a from the undriven ones. Black curves in Fig. 1B are a few forward process, the optical force is ramped from foff at examples of measured trajectories evolving from a given time t1 to fon at time t2. The reverse process is from t3 to point to a different point in the phase space during for- t4. The DFT connects the forward and reverse processes ward (or reverse) processes. Due to thermal fluctuation, as [20, 29]: it is not possible to have two trajectories starting from exactly the same point in the phase space. Here we use ∗ ∗ −β(W −∆F ) PR(−W; b ! a ) PF (W; a ! b) = e ; (1) σx σv (x; v) to represent points within (x ± 11 ; v ± 11 ), where where a, b can be arbitrary generalized coordinates. In σx and σv are the standard deviations of the position and our work, a and b denote the position (x) and/or ve- velocity distributions, respectively. locity (v) coordinate of a levitated nanosphere, e.g., a Based on our large sets of experimental data and our can be x, or v, or (x; v). PF (W; a ! b) is the forward ability to measure both the instantaneous velocity and joint probability of performing nonequilibrium work W position of a nanoparticle, we develop an efficient method for those trajectories starting from a and ending at b, to prepare arbitrary nonequilibrium initial states by con- ∗ ∗ and PR(−W; b ! a ) is the reverse joint probability.
Details
-
File Typepdf
-
Upload Time-
-
Content LanguagesEnglish
-
Upload UserAnonymous/Not logged-in
-
File Pages8 Page
-
File Size-