PARRAMATTA CITY COUNCIL - REGISTER OF VOTING ON PLANNING DECISIONS AT COUNCIL MEETINGS Commenced 9 February 2015 Voting Council Item Meeting DA/Ref No. Address/Subject Description Resolution For Against No. Date Tree removal, construction and operation of a concrete Councillors S H batching plant with a capacity Councillor S D Lloyd Chowdhury, G J of 150,000m3 of concrete and J P Abood, J 9 February 4-6 Shirley Street, Elmore, P Esber, 8.1 DA203/2014 annually. Approval is also Refused Chedid, R Dwyer, P J 2015 Rosehill J D Finn, J L sought for a temporary Garrard, J A Hugh, S Shaw and A A mobile concrete batching A Issa and B Makari. Wilson. plant on the northern part of the site Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, S H Chowdhury, R Demolition, tree removal, Dwyer, G J Elmore, P 9 February 40 Kissing Point alterations & additions to the Approval with Staff 8.2 DA/513/2014 Esber, J D Finn, P J Nil 2015 Road, Oatlands existing church & assembly Recommendations Garrard, J A Hugh, S hall. A Issa, B Makari, J L Shaw and A A Wilson. Demolition and construction Councillor S D Lloyd, of a 3 storey and part 4 J P Abood, J Chedid, storey shop top housing S H Chowdhury, R development containing 5 x 1 Dwyer, G J Elmore, P 9 February 28-36 Yates bedroom units, 8 x 2 Approval with Staff 8.3 DA/826/2013 Esber, J D Finn, P J Nil 2015 Avenue, Dundas bedroom units and 1x3 Recommendations Garrard, J A Hugh, S bedroom unit with 5 ground A Issa, B Makari, J L floor retail tenancies over Shaw and A A basement car parking with 20 Wilson. car parking spaces. 9 February 171-189 Approval with Staff Councillor S D Lloyd, Councillors G J 9.1 RZ/10/2013 Planning Proposal for Land 2015 Parramatta Road, Recommendations J Chedid, S H Elmore, J D Finn Register of Voting on Development Applications at Council Meetings Voting Council Item Meeting DA/Ref No. Address/Subject Description Resolution For Against No. Date Granville Chowdhury, R and A A Wilson. Dwyer, P Esber, P J Garrard, J A Hugh, S A Issa, B Makari and J L Shaw. Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, S H Chowdhury, R 9 February 184-188 George Approval with Staff Dwyer, G J Elmore, P Councillor A A 9.2 RZ/7/2014 Planning Proposal for Land 2015 Street, Parramatta Recommendations Esber, J D Finn, P J Wilson Garrard, J A Hugh, S A Issa, B Makari and J L Shaw. Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, R Dwyer, G J Councillors S H 9 February 142-154 Macquarie Approval with Staff 9.3 RZ/15/2014. Planning Proposal for Land Elmore, P Esber, J D Chowdhury and A 2015 Street, Parramatta Recommendations Finn, P J Garrard, J A Wilson A Hugh, S A Issa, B Makari and J L Shaw. Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, Demolition, tree removal and S H Chowdhury, R alterations and additions to Dwyer, G J Elmore, P 23 February 7 Crown Street, an Aged Care Facility, Approval with Staff 7.1 DA/598/2014 Esber, J D Finn, P J Nil 2015 Harris Park including an additional storey Recommendations Garrard, J A Hugh, S to increase the capacity of A Issa, B Makari, J L the centre to 60 beds Shaw and A A Wilson. Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, Councillors LE 23 February 80 Lavinia Street, Approval with Staff 7.2 TA/557/2014 Tree Permit S H Chowdhury, R Wearne and A A 2015 Merrylands Recommendations Dwyer, G J Elmore, J Wilson D Finn, P J Garrard, Register of Voting on Development Applications at Council Meetings Voting Council Item Meeting DA/Ref No. Address/Subject Description Resolution For Against No. Date J A Hugh, S A Issa, B Makari and J L Shaw. Councillor S D Lloyd, J Chedid, S H Chowdhury, R Conversion of existing 9 March 8 Crimea Street, Approval with Staff Dwyer, G J Elmore, P Councillor A A 8.1 DA/794/2014 garage into a secondary 2015 Parramatta Recommendations Esber, P J Garrard, Wilson dwelling J A Hugh, S A Issa, B Makari, J L Shaw. and L E Wearne Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, Section 96 (2) modification to S H Chowdhury, R the approved Torrens title Dwyer, G J Elmore, P 9 March 155 Kirby Street, Approval with Staff 9.1 DA/761/2012A subdivision of land into 12 Esber, P J Garrard, Nil 2015 Dundas Recommendations residential lots and one J A Hugh, S A Issa, B residue lot Makari, J L Shaw. L E Wearne and A A Wilson Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, S H Section 82A review for Chowdhury, R demolition, tree removal and Dwyer, G J Elmore, P 9 March 4 Ungarra Street, construction of an attached 2 Councillor J 9.2 DA/322/2014 Deferred Esber, P J Garrard, 2015 Rydalmere storey dual occupancy Chedid J A Hugh, S A Issa, B development with Torrens Makari, J L Shaw. L Title subdivision E Wearne and A A Wilson Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, Fitout and use of tenancy 1 9 March 111 Victoria Road, S H Chowdhury, R Councillor G J 9.3 DA/753/2014 as a remedial massage Refused 2015 Parramatta Dwyer, P Esber, P J Elmore business Garrard, J A Hugh, S A Issa, B Makari, J L Register of Voting on Development Applications at Council Meetings Voting Council Item Meeting DA/Ref No. Address/Subject Description Resolution For Against No. Date Shaw. L E Wearne and A A Wilson Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, S H Chowdhury, R 1 Parramatta Change the mix of approved Dwyer, G J Elmore, P 9 March Square (also known Approval with Staff 9.4 DA/769/2014 uses for a 15 storey building Esber, P J Garrard, Nil 2015 as 169 Macquarie Recommendations approved under DA/62/2013 J A Hugh, S A Issa, B Street) Parramatta Makari, J L Shaw. L E Wearne and A A Wilson Councillor S D Lloyd, J P Abood, J Chedid, S H Chowdhury, R Demolition of the Australia Dwyer, G J Elmore, P 9 March 153 Macquarie Post building, retention of the Approval with Staff 9.5 DA/865/2014 Esber, P J Garrard, Nil 2015 Street, Parramatta ground floor slab and Recommendations J A Hugh, S A Issa, B hardstand carparking area Makari, J L Shaw. L E Wearne and A A Wilson Councillor S D Lloyd, Councillors S H J P Abood, J Chedid, Chowdhury, G J 9 March Draft Amendment to Approval with Staff R Dwyer, P Esber, Elmore, J L 10.2 F2012/01980 Parramatta Square 2015 Parramatta DCP 2011 Recommendations P J Garrard, J A Shaw, L E Hugh, S A Issa and B Wearne and A A Makari Wilson (a) That the Department of Planning and Environment be Councillor S D Lloyd, advised that as Council did not support this Planning J P Abood, J Chedid, Proposal it does not wish to be the Relevant Planning S H Chowdhury, R 9 March Land at Niblick Authority and will not be submitting a Planning Proposal Dwyer, G J Elmore, P 10.3 RZ/4/2012 Nil 2015 Crescent, Oatlands for Gateway determination that proposes to rezone the Esber, P J Garrard, land along the western boundary of Oatlands Golf Course J A Hugh, S A Issa, B at Niblick Crescent, Oatlands from RE2 Private Makari, J L Shaw. L Recreation to R2 Low Density Residential. E Wearne and A A Register of Voting on Development Applications at Council Meetings Voting Council Item Meeting DA/Ref No. Address/Subject Description Resolution For Against No. Date (b) That the Department of Planning and Environment be Wilson requested to appoint an alternate Relevant Planning Authority to prepare the Planning Proposal. (c) Further, that the Department of Planning and Environment be advised that Council seeks to work closely with the appointed Relevant Planning Authority to ensure that a cohesive Planning Proposal is prepared. Demolition of existing Councillors J P Councillors S H structures, tree removal, and Refusal 22, 22A, and 24 Abood, J Chedid, R Chowdhury, P 23 March construction of a 3 storey 7.1 DA/607/2014 Burbang Crescent Dwyer, G J Elmore, S Esber, P J 2015 residential flat building Note: this application is subject to Rydalmere D Lloyd, J L Shaw Garrard, B Makari containing 18 units over a a rescission motion and A A Wilson and L E Wearne basement car park Councillors J P Demolition , tree removal and Abood, J Chedid, S H construction of a three storey Chowdhury, R 28-30 Burbang 23 March Residential Flat Building with Dwyer, G J Elmore, P Councillor P 7.2 DA/391/2014 Crescent, Refusal 2015 basement carparking under J Garrard, S D Lloyd, Esber RYDALMERE the Affordable Rental B Makari, J L Shaw, Housing SEPP 2009 L E Wearne and A A Wilson Councillors J P Abood, J Chedid, S H Demolition, tree removal and Chowdhury, R 63 William Street construction of a six storey 23 March Adopted with Staff Dwyer, P Esber, P J Councillor G J 7.3 DA/685/2014 and 35 Enid residential flat building 2015 recommendations Garrard, J A Hugh, S Elmore Avenue, Granville containing 18 apartments D Lloyd, B Makari, J over basement carparking L Shaw, L E Wearne and A A Wilson Alterations and additions to Councillors J P the principal dwelling and Abood, J Chedid, S H Councillors G J 23 March 210 Clyde Street, Adopted with Staff 7.4 DA/834/2014 conversion of the existing Chowdhury, R Elmore and J L 2015 South Granville recommendations double garage into a Dwyer, P Esber, P J Shaw secondary dwelling and Garrard, J A Hugh, S Register of Voting on Development Applications at Council Meetings Voting Council Item Meeting DA/Ref No.