Psychotic Phenomena in Binge Eating Disorder: an Exploratory MMPI-2 Study

Psychotic Phenomena in Binge Eating Disorder: an Exploratory MMPI-2 Study

Archives of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, 2015; 2: 13–20 DOI: 10.12740/APP/43321 Psychotic phenomena in Binge Eating Disorder: an exploratory MMPI-2 study Massimiliano Aragona, Anna Maria Petta, Andrea Balbi Summary Aim of the study. To study putative psychotic phenomena in patients with Binge Eating Disorder (BED). Subject or material and methods: Sixty patients with a DSM-5 diagnosis of BED were studied. Scores at the Sc, Pa and other subscales of the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-2 (MMPI-2) were used to assess possible psychotic features. Eating phenomena were assessed by the Eating Disorder Inven- tory-2 (EDI-2). The relationship between them was studied. Results. Mean BMI was 38.24±8.43. The Sc and Pa scales of the MMPI-2 were above the cut-off in, re- spectively, 43.33% and 46.67% of patients. Regression analyses show that both Sc and Pa had a signif- icant effect on EDI-2 scores, although only the Sc scale remained significant after adjusting for their pos- sible interrelation. More than 40% of patients reported high scores (65 or more) at the following MMPI-2 “psychotic” subscales: Paranoia (Pa), Schizophrenia (Sc), Social Alienation (Sc1), Emotional Alienation (Sc2), and Lack of Ego Mastery, both cognitive and conative (Sc3 & Sc4). Perfectionism, Impulse Regu- lation, Ascetism, Social Insecurity, Interoceptive Awareness, Ineffectiveness, and Maturity Fears are the EDI-2 scales significantly influenced by the Sc and Pa MMPI-2 scores. Discussion. Several putative psychotic phenomena were reported in our sample of binge eaters, and they were related to higher scores on several dimensions of the EDI-2. Conclusions. At least in some patients, there might be an overlap between some psychotic basic phe- nomena (disordered sense of basic Self, of bodily experiences, and hyperreflectivity), and those basic dis- turbances in identity development and Self-schemas which are at the base of eating disorders. schizofrenia / phenomenology / psychosis / eiting disorders / binginng INTRODUCTION [1], the relationship between psychotic symp- toms and eating disorders has remained large- Although early classical psychopathological ly understudied for years [2]. More recent sur- reports on eating disordered phenomena con- veys have shown that schizophrenia, paranoia ceived them as part of a psychotic way of being and related features are not so rare in anorectic and bulimic patients [3]. Less evidence is avail- able for those eating disorders that were more Massimiliano Aragona1, Anna Maria Petta2, Andrea Balbi3: Clinical recently included in the DSM-5 [4], such as the Director of the Day Hospitalization Service for Eating Disorders “Villa Binge Eating Disorder (BED). The DSM-IV had Armonia Nuova”, ASL RMD, Rome (Italy); 2Crossing Dialogues Asso- ciation, Rome (Italy); 3Director of the Mental Health Department, ASL included BED in Appendix B among the puta- RMD, Rome (Italy). E-mail: [email protected]. tive disorders that needed more extensive study before inclusion in the official list of mental dis- Acknowledgments: The authors would like to thank the sanitary orders [5]. The DSM-5 recognized BED as an of- and administrative staff of the Villa Armonia Nuova Hospital (Rome, ficial disorder, describing it as the presence of re- Italy) for their important help. current and distressful episodes of binge eating, 14 Massimiliano Aragona et al. at least once a week for 3 months. An episode of (EDI-2) eating disorder-related phenomena in a binge eating is characterized by two criteria: a) group of patients with BED. eating , in a discrete period of time (e.g., with- in any 2-hour period), an amount of food that is definitely larger than what most people would MateriaLS AND METHODS eat in a similar period of time under similar cir- cumstances; and b) a sense of lack of control over Sample eating during the episode (e.g., a feeling that one All consecutive patients referring to a Day cannot stop eating or control what or how much Hospitalization Service specifically dedicat- one is eating). In DSM-5 such binge-eating ep- ed to Eating Disorders were asked to enter the isodes have to be associated with at least three study, to be clinically interviewed by both a psy- of the following features: a) eating much more chiatrist and a medical doctor specialized in nu- rapidly than normal; b) eating until feeling un- tritional issues, and to fulfil assessment instru- comfortably full; c) eating large amounts of food ments. All patients accepted and signed an in- when not feeling physically hungry; d) eating formed consent. Only those patients having a alone because of feeling embarrassed by how DSM-5 diagnosis of Binge Eating Disorder (BED) much one is eating; e) feeling disgusted with were included in the present study. oneself, depressed, or very guilty afterward. Fi- nally, the differential diagnosis between BED and bulimia nervosa is based on the lack of com- Assessment instruments pensatory behaviours in the former [6]. A recent PubMed Search (October, 30th, 2014) Body Mass Index (BMI) was computed at ad- found one study directly comparing obese fe- mission, in the same session including the psy- males with and without BED (7). It was shown chopathological and the psychodiagnostic eval- that BED patients had a more severe psycho- uations. Main socio-demographic variables were pathological profile than obese controls, in- recorded in a chart. Eating disordered behav- cluding higher SCL-90 interpersonal sensitiv- iours and other phenomena related to eating dis- ity (roughly corresponding to ideas of refer- orders were formally assessed by means of the ence), paranoid ideas, and psychoticism. More- Eating Disorder Inventory, 2nd Version (EDI-2), a over, such features were related to BED severity 91 items self-evaluated questionnaire specifical- (assessed with the Binge Eating Scale) [7]. Such ly designed and validated for Eating Disorders findings might be particularly relevant, because and widely used in previous research on these the co-occurrence of psychiatric disorders (such patients [9]. Patients have to evaluate how much as mood and psychotic disorders) and BED or often they had the described phenomenon. Items obesity has important public health and treat- are rated on a six-point scale, item responses be- ment implications, including the fact that the ing weighted as 0 (never, sometimes or rarely), treatment of BED and obesity co-occurring with 1 (often), 2 (usually), or 3 (always). It is possible psychopathology may be different from obesity to obtain a total EDI-2 score (a general measure without associated psychopathology [8]. of severity) and 11 subscales: Drive for Thinness Considering the rarity of studies systematical- (DT), Bulimia (B), Body Dissatisfaction (BD), In- ly addressing the relationship between BED and effectiveness (I), Perfectionism (P), Interpersonal possible psychotic phenomena, more research is Distrust (ID), Interoceptive Awareness (IA), Ma- needed on this topic, assessing possible psychot- turity Fears (MF), Ascetism (A), Impulse Regula- ic phenomena by means of different psychodi- tion (IR), and Social Insecurity (SI). Any dimen- agnostic instruments and correlating psychotic sional subscale is computed by summing item scores with dysfunctional areas which are typi- scores. cally related to eating disorders. The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inven- This study explores the relationship between tory-2 [10] has been used extensively to assess putative psychotic phenomena assessed with individuals with eating disorders [11]. It is a 567- the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Invento- item self-report questionnaire in which respond- ry-2 (MMPI-2), and Eating Disorder Inventory-2 ents are asked to indicate whether each state- Archives of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, 2015; 2: 13–20 Psychotic phenomena in Binge Eatinge Disorder 15 ment is generally true or false for them. The 567 patients included in the final statistical analysis items are computed to derive 3 validity indices were compared to patients that had not complet- (scales L, F, and K) and 10 clinical scales: Hypo- ed the assessment measures by means of Stu- chondriasis (Hs), Depression (D), Hysteria (Hy), dent’s T test or Chi Square Test. Psychopathic Deviation (Pd), Masculinity-Fem- In the study sample mean and standard de- ininity (M/F), Paranoia (Pa), Psychasthenia (Pt), viation values were computed for MMPI-2 and Schizophrenia (Sc), Hypomania (Ma), and Social EDI-2 scales. The number of patients with BED Introversion (SI). Raw scores on each scale are above the threshold scores of the MMPI-2 scales converted to T scores and values 65 and great- considered for psychotic phenomena were com- er are considered clinically significant [12]. In puted. Differences in EDI-2 scores between pa- this study, we focus our analysis on the Sc and tients scoring above and below the threshold for Pa scales of the MMPI-2. Although possible psy- the MMPI-2 Sc and Pa scales were compared by chotic phenomena are also included within oth- means of Student’s T test. er MMPI-2 scales (e.g. Ma and Pt scales), we de- Linear regression models were used to test the cided to focus only on those scales (Sc and Pa) influence of Sc and Pa on EDI-2 total scores. In where the likelihood of detecting possible psy- a second step a multiple linear regression mod- chotic phenomena is maximized. Indeed, se- el was used in order to consider the reciprocal vere mania and melancholic depression often influence of Sc and Pa as covariate independent present with psychotic features, but from a psy- variables on EDI-2 dimensions. chopathological point of view they were consid- ered by Jaspers as secondary phenomena arising from the basal disturbance of mood. As a con- RESULTS sequence, inclusion of bipolar symptoms was at risk of excessively decreased specificity of stud- Seventy-seven patients fulfilled DSM-5 crite- ied phenomena. For similar reasons we exclud- ria for BED and were included in the study.

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    8 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us