Q ua dr a nt $8.90 Australia I M ay 2018 I V ol.62 N o.5 M ay 2018 How to Break the Cycle of Low-GrowthPeter Murphy Big-Statism The Coming Age of De-Globalisation Martin Hutchinson Why Trump Dumped Business as Usual in Asia Daryl McCann How Richard Casey Made America Notice Australia Edward Cranswick The Family Court has Failed Gender-Dysphoric Children Stuart Lindsay The High Costs of Fatherlessness Augusto Zimmermann On Patrick O’Brian John Whitworth On Queen Mary Mark McGinness On Capability Brown Ian George On Michael Wilding Derek Turner Poetry I Geoff Page, Joe Dolce, Valerie Murray, Pascale Petit, Ted Witham, David Mason, Cally Conan-Davies Reviews I David Martin Jones, Wolfgang Kasper, Peter Craven Fiction I Michael Scammell Letters I Environment I Science I Literature I Economics I Religion I Media Theatre I Philosophy I film I Society I History I Politics I Education I Health SpeCIal New SubSCrIber offer renodesign.com.aur33011 Subscribe to Quadrant and Q ua dr a nt Policy for only $104 for one year! $8.90 Australia I M arch 2012 I Vol.56 No3 M arch 2012 The Threat to Democracy Quadrant is one of Australia’ Jfromohn O’Sullivan, Global Patrick MGovernancecCauley The Fictive World of Rajendra Pachauri and is published ten times a year.s leading intellectual magazines, Tony Thomas Pax Americana and the Prospect of US Decline Keith Windschuttle Why Africa Still Has a Slave Trade Roger Sandall Policy is the only Australian quarterly magazine that explores Freedom of Expression in a World of Vanishing Boundaries Nicholas Hasluck the world of ideas and policy from a classical liberal perspective. Conservatives and Same-Sex Marriage Michael Giffin, John Zerilli, John de Meyrick On Bob Dylan and Christopher Ricks Joe Dolce On myths about floating the dollar John Stone On David Hume and religion R oss Barham, Stephen Buckle To take advantage of this offer you can: On the art of acting Michael Connor fiction I Morris Lurie Poetry I Les Murray, Russell Erwin, Janine Fraser, Vivian Smith, • subscribe online at www.policymagazine.com Ron Pretty, Duncan McIntyre, Leon Trainor Reviews I Patrick Morgan, Victor Stepien, Jan Owen, Trevor Sykes • use the subscription card in the middle of this magazine Letters I chronicle I politics I environment I freedom of speech I history media I philosophy & ideas I economics I music I Society I film I first person • contact The Centre for Independent Studies: PO Box 92, St Leonards, NSW 1590 p: 02 9438 4377 f: 02 9439 7310 e: [email protected] * This offer is in Australian dollars (incl. GST), is only available to new Australian subscribers and is not AustrAliA’s secret WAr available to institutions. The renewal rate for a joint subscription is A$114.00 (including GST). HoW unionists sAbotAged our troops in World WAr ii HAL COLEBATCH Ten ’s new book, shocking, true, but until now largelyAustralia’s suppressed Secret and hiddenWar story of the war waged from 1939 to 1945 by a number of key Australian, tells trade the unions — against their own society and against the men and women of their Years own country’s fighting forces during the perils of World War II. Every major Australian warship was targeted by strikes, go-slows and of The sabotage at home. Australian soldiers fighting in New Guinea and the Pacific went without food, radio equipment and ammunition because Photographs © australian War memorial of union strikes. besT Waterside workers disrupted loading of supplies to the troops and pilfered from ships’ cargoes and soldiers’ personal effects. Other strikes 487 pOems by rail workers, iron workers, coal miners, and even munitions workers 169 auThOrs verse by renodesign.com.aur33011 and life-raft builders, badly impeded Australia’s war effort. “It has been known for decades”, Les Murray writes in his introduction to this It seems to me the best such occasional collection, “that poets who might fear relegation or professional sabotage from the collection I have ever read; better, for critical consensus of our culture have a welcome and a refuge in For you, or As A giFt instance, than ‘The Faber Book of Modern if they write well.” Verse’; which is saying quite a bit. ONLINE From the second decade of his Quadrant www.quadrant.org.au/store $44.95 — BOB ELLIS, —but only POST Table Talk here presents a selection of the best20 verse he published between Quadrant, Locked Bag 1235, North Melbourne years as literary editor of PhONE FAX Quadrant, Les Murray (03) 8317 8147 2001 (03) 9320 9065 VIC 3051, Australia Order This Landmark bOOk and 2010. 33011_QBooks_Ads_V2.indd 8 ONLINE www.quadrant.org.au/store POST $44.95 Quadrant, Locked Bag 1235, North Melbourne PhONE (03) 8317 8147 FAX VIC 3051, Australia 6/09/13 3:21 PM (03) 9320 9065 may 2018 No. 546 Volume LxII, Number 5 letters 2 Frank Pulsford, Marc T. Low editor’s column 3 Prophets of the Apocalypse Keith Windschuttle asperities 5 John O’Sullivan ASTRINGENCIES 8 Anthony Daniels politics 10 Prosperity Postponed Peter Murphy 18 The Coming Age of De-Globalisation Martin Hutchinson 24 Why Trump Dumped Business as Usual in Asia Daryl McCann 28 The Italian Elections and the Endless Appeal of Easy Money Alberto Mingardi law 32 The Family Court Has Failed Gender-Dysphoric Children Stuart Lindsay society 38 The High Costs of Fatherlessness Augusto Zimmermann 42 Jews, Nazis and Muslims Hal G.P. Colebatch education 44 Keeping Men Out of Schools Christopher Heathcote history 50 Putting Australia in America’s Worldview Edward Cranswick 56 Queen Mary: Love and Hope Mark McGinness philosophy & ideas 60 The Rise of Anti-Humanism Michael Kowalik economics 62 The Burial of Keynes’s Effective Demand Peter Smith books 65 John Selden and the Western Political Tradition by Ofir Haivry David Martin Jones 69 Enlightenment Now by Steven Pinker Wolfgang Kasper 72 Home Fire by Kamila Shamsie Peter Craven 73 Little Demon by Michael Wilding Derek Turner 74 Three Duties and Talleyrand’s Dictum by Alan Fewster Michael Fogarty literature 76 The Aubrey–Maturin Novels of Patrick O’Brian John Whitworth 79 Capers and Frisks Gary Furnell architecture 83 The Centenary of Jørn Utzon Philip Drew engineering 86 The Engineer’s Clarinet Andrew Botros theatre 90 The Regimented Muse Michael Connor landscape 95 Our Debt to Capability Brown Ian George first person 103 y On M Australian Poetry Timoshenko Aslanides story 109 Baby Jesus Michael Scammell sweetness & light 111 Tim Blair Poetry 7: A Single Sparrow Geoff Page; 21: The Last Voyage David Mason; 22: The Great Male-versus-Female Guitar Contest of 1933 Joe Dolce; Learning of the death of the Circus Girl Hal G.P. Colebatch; 27: Sailing Geoff Page; Wheelchair Vista Valerie Murray; 31: Jaguar Girl Pascale Petit; 49: Rainforest in the Sleep Room Pascale Petit; 55: The Picnic Table Ted Witham; 59: Tilt Joe Dolce; 85: Sister Cally Conan-Davies; 94: Homework Ted Witham Letters Then God created man, for the reasons listed above. I propose to Mr Caldersmith that theology is of greater value to Editor Theology and Cosmology cosmology than cosmology is to Keith Windschuttle theology. [email protected] Sir: n I the midst of speculation Frank Pulsford Editor, intErnational about black holes and the number Aspley, Qld John O’Sullivan of galaxies, Tony Caldersmith litEr ary Editor (Letters, March 2018), like many Les Murray fascinated by cosmology, wanders Victims of Technology into the field of theology in the dEput y Editor belief that his cosmological insights Sir: oThanks t Professor Jones for George Thomas equip him to make theological judg- “The Utopian Ambitions of Silicon Editor, Qua dr ant onlinE ments. Rather than dealing with the Valley” (March 2018). Worse than Roger Franklin fact of the position of the Earth in the data-mining that occurs in [email protected] relation to the Sun, Mr Caldersmith social media is the inbuilt obsoles- proposes a hypothetical: “If evolu- cence of the hardware and software Contributing Editor Theatre: Michael Connor tion went a slightly different way we are using. It is these inbuilt evils, and Earth was a bit closer to the rather than the gathering of data, Columnists Sun, it could have meant that this that will eventually lead to AI-type Anthony Daniels planet would never have had intel- interactions with the user. Tim Blair ligent life on it. Would that mean By purchasing an operating sys- there was no god?” tem we are immediately sedated by Subscriptions Putting aside the facts that the inbuilt stupidities of the sys- tem that could have been designed Phone: (03) 8317 8147 evolution did not go a slightly dif- Fax: (03) 9320 9065 ferent way and the Earth is not a better, but was made half-rotten Post: Quadrant Magazine, bit closer to the Sun, the answer as a principle of marketing. The Locked Bag 1235, to Mr Caldersmith’s question is, human mind and body are naturally North Melbourne VIC 3051 “No. Those things would not have inclined to detect and correct stress E-mail: quadrantmagazine@ meant that God does not exist. They elements in a machine if it is made data.com.au simply mean that there would have from scratch; but by disengaging been no one to whom God could ourselves with machines that are Publisher reveal Himself.” built this way, we become effectively Now, doesn’t that open up a mere appendages to the machines. Quadrant (ISSN 0033-5002) is field for consideration much more Popups that we don’t know how published ten times a year by fascinating than how many gal- to get rid of, keyboards which are Quadrant Magazine Limited, Suite 2/5 Rosebery Place, axies there are? It goes directly so user-unfriendly that we make Balmain NSW 2041, Australia to the age-old question of why stroke errors every few words, soft- ACN 133 708 424 we are here.