1 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION + + + + + NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON INSTITUTIONAL QUALITY AND INTEGRITY + + + + + MEETING + + + + + FRIDAY JUNE 10, 2011 + + + + + The Advisory Committee met in the Commonwealth Ballroom in the Alexandria Holiday Inn, 625 First Street, Alexandria, Virginia, at 8:30 a.m., Cameron Staples, Chair, presiding. PRESENT: CAMERON C. STAPLES, Committee Chair, Partner, Neubert, Pepe, & Monteith law firm ARTHUR J. ROTHKOPF, Committee Vice-Chair, President Emeritus, Lafayette College ARTHUR E. KEISER, Chancellor, Keiser Collegiate System EARL LEWIS, Provost and Executive Vice President for Academic Affairs, Emory University WILFRED M. McCLAY, SunTrust Bank Chair of Excellence in Humanities, University of Tennessee at Chattanooga ANNE D. NEAL, President, American Council of Trustees and Alumni WILLIAM PEPICELLO, Provost and President, University of Phoenix 2 SUSAN D. PHILLIPS, Provost and Vice-President for Academic Affairs, State University of New York at Albany BETER-ARON SHIMELES, Student Member, Fellow, Peer Health Exchange JAMIENNE S. STUDLEY, President and CEO, Public Advocates, Inc. LARRY N. VANDERHOEF, Former Chancellor, University of California, Davis FRANK H. MEMBER WU, Chancellor and Dean, University of California, Hastings College of Law FREDERICO ZARAGOZA, Vice-Chancellor of Economic and Workforce Development, Alamo Colleges STAFF PRESENT: MARTHA J. KANTER, Under Secretary MELISSA LEWIS SALLY WANNER KAY GILCHER CAROL GRIFFITHS ELIZABETH DAGGETT KAREN DUKE JENNIFER HONG-SILWANY JOYCE JONES CHUCK MULA STEVE PORCELLI CATHY SHEFFIELD RACHAEL SHULTZ 3 T-A-B-L-E O-F C-O-N-T-E-N-T-S Welcome and Introductions .................. 4 Election of New NACIQI Chair ............... 7 Terms of Chair and Vice Chair ............. 11 Issue Two - The Triad ..................... 17 Peter Ewell, Vice President, National Center for Higher Education Management Systems Marsha Hill, Executive Director, Nebraska Coordinating Commission for Postsecondary Education Public Commenters' Oral Presentations ..... 56 Issue Two Discussion ...................... 96 Issue Three - Accreditor Scope, Alignment and Accountability ........... 145 Judith S. Eaton, President, Council for Higher Education Accreditation Kevin Carey, Policy Director, Education Sector Shirley Tilghman, President Princeton University Ralph Wolff, President and Executive Director, Western Association of Schools and Colleges Accrediting Commissions for Senior Colleges and Universities Issue Three Discussion ................... 189 Public Commenters' Oral Presentations .... 260 4 1 P-R-O-C-E-E-D-I-N-G-S 2 8:37 a.m. 3 Welcome and Introductions 4 CHAIR STAPLES: I'd like to call 5 the meeting of NACIQI to order, and welcome 6 everyone who is here on the committee and in 7 the audience. 8 As you're aware, this is our third 9 day of deliberations and we're well into our 10 policy discussions, and we look forward to 11 having more discussions and hearing from 12 panelists and setting a better direction, in 13 terms of our policy recommendations. 14 Just before we start the official 15 part of the meeting, I'd like to have us go 16 around the table, since I know the audience 17 may be different each day, and it's useful to 18 have our introductions. My name's Cam 19 Staples. I'm the chair of NACIQI. Arthur? 20 MEMBER ROTHKOPF: Arthur Rothkopf, 21 Vice Chair. 22 MS. PHILLIPS: Susan Phillips, 5 1 Chair of the Policy Subcommittee, Provost and 2 Vice President for Academic Affairs at the 3 State University of New York in Albany. 4 MEMBER NEAL: Still Anne Neal, 5 president of the American Council of Trustees 6 and Alumni. 7 MEMBER SHIMELES: Aron Shimeles, 8 BRA Fellow, Peer Health Exchange. 9 MEMBER WU: Frank Wu, Chancellor 10 and Dean, University of California at Hastings 11 College of Law. 12 MEMBER KEISER: Arthur Keiser, 13 Chancellor of Keiser University. 14 MEMBER LEWIS: Earl Lewis, 15 Provost, Emory University. 16 MEMBER ZARAGOZA: Federico 17 Zaragoza, Vice Chancellor, Economic and 18 Workforce Development, Alamo Colleges. 19 MEMBER McCLAY: Wilfred McClay, 20 University of Tennessee. 21 MEMBER VANDERHOEF: Larry 22 Vanderhoef, University of California-Davis. 6 1 MEMBER PEPICELLO: Bill Pepicello, 2 President, University of Phoenix. 3 MEMBER STUDLEY: Jamienne Studley, 4 Public Advocate, San Francisco. 5 MS. GILCHER: Kay Gilcher, 6 Director of Accreditation Division, U.S. 7 Department of Education. 8 MS. LEWIS: Melissa Lewis, NACIQI 9 Executive Director, U.S. Department of 10 Education. 11 CHAIR STAPLES: Thank you, and I 12 think we may have, as the day wears on, I know 13 some members have other commitments in terms 14 of departing for the day. 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 7 1 Election of New NACIQI Chair 2 So we're going to move, we're going to 3 shift our agenda a little, and move to the 4 election of a new NACIQI chair, before we 5 start the panel discussions, to make sure we 6 have a quorum in sufficient numbers here. 7 Before we start that, I just want 8 to mention that I really have enjoyed serving 9 as chair. As I've mentioned to the members, 10 I'll be taking on a new position in July, and 11 I think this is a good move for me to step 12 down as chair. 13 I look forward to remaining as a 14 member, and it reminds me of stories about 15 boat owners, those of you who are boat owners. 16 The two happiest days in a boat owner's life 17 is the day you buy a boat and the day you sell 18 a boat. I was very happy to be elected chair, 19 and I'm finding I'm somewhat happy to be 20 stepping down as chair. 21 But I'm looking forward to 22 continuing to serve with you, and at this 8 1 time, I open the floor to nominations. 2 Arthur? 3 MEMBER ROTHKOPF: Yes. First, 4 before I make a nomination, I'd like to 5 express my own view, and I think those of, I'm 6 sure, other NACIQI members, to thank Cam for 7 his leadership in getting this group going. 8 It's a disparate group of people with a lot of 9 opinions, and always to keep us on track. 10 But Cam, thank you very much for 11 your leadership over these last several 12 months. 13 (Applause.) 14 CHAIR STAPLES: Thank you. 15 MEMBER ROTHKOPF: I'd like to 16 nominate, and Cam, I gather, is remaining -- 17 you're remaining as chair until June 30? 18 CHAIR STAPLES: Until June 30th, 19 that's right. 20 MEMBER ROTHKOPF: I'd like to 21 nominate as chair of NACIQI our colleague 22 Jamie Studley, and ask that she be elected 9 1 effective July 1 of 2011, and serve until the 2 end of her term, which is some time in 3 September of 2013. So I move that. 4 CHAIR STAPLES: There is a motion 5 on the floor. Is there a second? 6 MS. PHILLIPS: Second. 7 CHAIR STAPLES: Move and seconded. 8 Are there any other nominations? 9 (No response.) 10 CHAIR STAPLES: Seeing no 11 nominations, all in favor of electing Jamie 12 Studley as the next NACIQI chair, please raise 13 your hand? 14 (Show of hands.) 15 CHAIR STAPLES: Any opposed? 16 (No response.) 17 CHAIR STAPLES: Congratulations. 18 MEMBER ROTHKOPF: Other than 19 Jamie. 20 CHAIR STAPLES: We won't count the 21 opposing or abstentions. The motion passes 22 and Jamie will assume the chairmanship on July 10 1 1st. Congratulations. 2 MEMBER STUDLEY: Thank you very 3 much. It always looks great to have a vote 4 from the outside, so I too am honored. I 5 thank Arthur for the nomination and all of you 6 for your confidence, and I look forward to 7 working with you on these important issues. 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 11 1 Terms of Chair and Vice Chair 2 CHAIR STAPLES: Without trying to 3 take too much time on this, I do want to 4 mention that it may make sense for us as a 5 Committee to adopt a rule around the terms of 6 our leaders. As you may recall, when we 7 elected the officers last fall, we didn't 8 specify for how long. 9 Arthur and I wondered how long our 10 terms were. Arthur's motion sets Jamie's term 11 at effectively a three-year term, if you go 12 back to our swearing in in September, three 13 years from last September, and that would be 14 the length of her term of service. 15 So I guess it would make sense, in 16 my opinion, and I would invite any motion to 17 this effect, that we set the term of the chair 18 and the vice chair for a three-year period, 19 and that would allow for a rotation of 20 leadership on a cycle that is predictable. 21 Art? 22 MEMBER ROTHKOPF: I have a 12 1 question about that, because you know, for 2 Jamie it's not an issue. But for future, we 3 have this strange appointment times. 4 CHAIR STAPLES: Well, we checked 5 that out, Art. 6 MEMBER ROTHKOPF: I'm not sure -- 7 it's not going to flow, because we may have to 8 put somebody who's never done any chair, you 9 know, been a chair and just right at the 10 beginning of their term become the chair, 11 which may not be the best thing. 12 CHAIR STAPLES: Well, let me 13 answer your question, because we looked into 14 that. We weren't sure what the length of the 15 reappointment terms were, at least we couldn't 16 recall it by memory, and they are six years.