Neighboring States- Comparison of Permit Fees April 12, 2019 State Permit-by- General Permit/General- Individual Permit Submerged Lands rule permit-by-certification New Jersey $0 $1,000 $500-$30,000 $100 minimum or $0.61/square foot annually for Coastal permits capped at 10 years with fee increase $30,000 2.5% per year New York $50 $50-$200 $900 Unable to obtain information Pennsylvania $1,950 $50-$750 $1,750 plus Annual Fee Temporary disturbance: $250-$5,000 $4000 X impact in 0.1 acre increments Permanent disturbance $8000 X impact in 0.1 acre increments Delaware $450 $450-$5,000 $450-$5,000 $225-$450 California $0 $3,023 $3,023-Max cap of $302,250 N/A • For the purposes of this chart, minor impacts were considered to be equivalent to New Jersey’s permits-by-rule or general permit. All other activities considered to be equivalent to individual permits. • New Jersey has broad regulatory authority over freshwater, coastal and flood hazard areas. This broad authority makes drawing a comparison between New Jersey and other states very difficult. Accordingly, great discretion was used in developing this chart. • New York, Pennsylvania, and Delaware do not have a Flood Hazard Area Permitting Program and therefore no comparisons could be made. • Pennsylvania has a limited wetland program: their regulatory authority is through State Programmatic General Permits and review of Water Quality Certificates which do not include a similar review as New Jersey • Delaware and New York also have a limited wetland program: their regulatory authority is primarily through a limited state program and through Water Quality Certificate Reviews. • California was added since they have robust land use permitting programs with various authorities similar in scope to New Jersey’s. Sources: Pennsylvania:http://files.dep.state.pa.us/ProgramIntegration/PA%20Pipeline%20Portal/AtlanticSunrise/Chapter105ColumbiaCounty /DVD%20to%20PADEP%20112116/Attachment%20B/B2_B-1a%20Fee_COLU_101116_v2.pdf New York: https://www.dec.ny.gov/permits/65153.html Delaware: http://www.dnrec.delaware.gov/wr/Documents/WSLS%20Fee%20Sheet.pdf California: https://documents.coastal.ca.gov/reports/2018/7/w6e/w6e-7-2018-report.pdf CONTAMINATION REPORT (PATERSON, GARFIELD) (04/11/2019) Preliminary Remedial Assessment Site Investigation Investigation Remedial Action Activity Report Due - Report Due - Report - Report Due - PI Number Number Street Address Line1 Street City Case Name Remediation Level Completed Date Completed Date Completed Date Completed Date SOIL/ or GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 000402 LSR120001 75 TO 77 GROVE ST Paterson City RAILROAD CONSTRUCTION COMPANY C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 3/25/2014 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 000416 PFR050001 221 BANTA AVE Garfield STULL CLOSURE TECHNOLOGIES C1: No Formal Design - Source Known or Identified-Potential GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 000460 LSR100001 601 MADISON AVE Paterson U-SAVE SERVICE STATION (FORMER) C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 5/4/2016 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 000536 LSR120001 649 651 MARKET ST Paterson SUPER VALUE-CITGO-BUSTOS AUTO C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 000793 LSR120001 290 PENNSYLVANIA AVE Paterson Eastern Tank Corporation C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 7/1/1996 5/2/2016 10/12/2017 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 000793 VIC190001 290 PENNSYLVANIA AVE Paterson EASTERN TANK CORP C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 000961 LSR120001 404 408 GRAND ST Paterson WINER INDUSTRIES INC C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 3/2/2005 3/2/2005 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 000981 LSR120001 780 MARKET ST Paterson BP S/S # 914 (#20933) C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 7/16/2018 5/11/2018 6/11/2018 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 001227 LSR120001 335 MCLEAN BLVD FORMERLYPaterson MORTON INTERNATIONAL INC D: Multi-Phased RA - Multiple Source/Release to Multi-Media Including GW 1/11/2018 5/2/2016 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 001227 VIC180001 335 MCLEAN BLVD FORMERLYPaterson MORTON INTERNATIONAL INC FORMER C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 001506 LSR140001 413 MIDLAND AVE Garfield GARFIELD CITY-CITY GARAGE C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 10/24/2016 5/1/2017 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 001506 LSR170001 413 MIDLAND AVE Garfield GARFIELD CITY B: Single Phase RA - Single Contamination Affecting Only Soils SOIL CONTAMINATION 001506 PFR050001 413 MIDLAND AVE Garfield GARFIELD CITY GARAGE C3: Multi-Phased RA - Unknown or Uncontrolled Discharge to Soil or GW SOIL CONTAMINATION 001744 LSR110001 606 MIDLAND AVE Garfield GETTY S/S #56924 C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 7/9/2013 9/21/2017 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 001744 LSR160001 606 MIDLAND AVE Garfield FORMER GETTY 56924 C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 1/9/2018 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 001828 LSR120001 100 OUTWATER LN Garfield Presto Lock, Incorporated D: Multi-Phased RA - Multiple Source/Release to Multi-Media Including GW 5/6/2016 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 001828 OSA140002 100 OUTWATER LN Garfield Presto Lock, Incorporated D: Multi-Phased RA - Multiple Source/Release to Multi-Media Including GW SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 001891 LSR120001 52 BERKSHIRE AVE Paterson KESSLER TRUCKING CO C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 002319 VIC170001 33 6TH AVE Paterson DAICOLOR POPE INC C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 002566 LSR120001 185 6TH AVE Paterson Facile Holdings Facility C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 11/22/2013 6/21/2018 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 002584 LSR120001 534 ELLISON ST Paterson RALSTON PURINA/ FORMERLY CONTINENTAL BAKING CO. C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 5/5/2016 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 002642 LSR100001 386 MIDLAND AVE Garfield MIDLAND AUTO ELECTRIC INC C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 002642 PFR150001 386 MIDLAND AVE Garfield MIDLAND AUTO ELECTRIC INC C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 002794 LSR110001 845 25TH ST E Paterson Amtech, Inc. Paterson Gear Motor Division C3: Multi-Phased RA - Unknown or Uncontrolled Discharge to Soil or GW SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 002857 LSR100001 253 259 PENNSYLVANIA AVE Paterson MARANGI SANITATION INC C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 4/25/2018 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 003122 PFR040001 394 MCBRIDE AVE Paterson KOZNICK'S AUTOMOTIVE C1: No Formal Design - Source Known or Identified-Potential GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 003424 LSR110001 15 19 1ST AVE Paterson CONTINENTAL PIECE DYEING & FINISHING C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 4/4/2018 4/4/2018 4/6/2018 4/6/2018 SOIL CONTAMINATION 003424 LSR150001 15 19 1ST AVE Paterson CONTINENTAL PIECE DYEING & FINISHING C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 4/4/2018 4/4/2018 4/6/2018 4/6/2018 SOIL CONTAMINATION 003886 LSR100001 70 WAIT ST Paterson Suburban Chemical Company C3: Multi-Phased RA - Unknown or Uncontrolled Discharge to Soil or GW 5/5/2016 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 004084 PFR000001 495 MARSHALL ST Paterson Superior Motors C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 004097 PFR100001 125 CLARK ST Garfield E C ELECTROPLATING INC C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 5/16/2002 SOIL CONTAMINATION 004294 LSR120001 375 BROADWAY W Paterson S & K AMOCO (#4288) C1: No Formal Design - Source Known or Identified-Potential GW Contamination 7/23/2018 1/24/2019 SOIL CONTAMINATION 004449 LSR110001 163 SCHLEY ST Garfield SKETCHLEY SERVICES MOA C3: Multi-Phased RA - Unknown or Uncontrolled Discharge to Soil or GW 8/6/2014 8/6/2014 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 004716 LSR100001 81 1ST AVE Paterson SHELL SERVICE STATION C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 7/1/2013 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 004717 LSR100001 10 18TH AVE - MARKET Paterson SHELL SERVICE STATION #138474 C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 3/1/2017 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 004850 LSR100001 15 LAFAYETTE ST Paterson RIVER STREET SERVICE STATION (US OIL - P C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination 6/7/2016 SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 004865 PFR000001 179 LAFAYETTE ST Paterson Fdr Services C1: No Formal Design - Source Known or Identified-Potential GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 004865 PFR000002 179 LAFAYETTE ST Paterson RIVERSIDE LINEN SUPPLY C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 004865 PFR080001 179 LAFAYETTE ST Paterson FDR SERVICES C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL CONTAMINATION 004917 LSR170001 500 MARSHALL ST Paterson City GARFCO URBAN RENEWAL CORP C2: Formal Design - Known Source or Release with GW Contamination SOIL and GROUNDWATER CONTAMINATION 005111 LSR150001 448 E 18TH ST Paterson RUNUM CORP C/O LAFAYETTE S/S