Imaging Black Holes and Jets with a VLBI Array Including Multiple Space-Based Telescopes Vincent L. Fisha,∗, Maura Sheaa,b, Kazunori Akiyamaa,c aMassachusetts Institute of Technology, Haystack Observatory, 99 Millstone Hill Road, Westford, MA 01886, USA bWellesley College, Whitin Observatory, Wellesley, MA 02482, USA cNational Radio Astronomy Observatory Jansky Fellow Abstract Very long baseline interferometry (VLBI) from the ground at millimeter wavelengths can resolve the black hole shadow around two supermassive black holes, Sagittarius A* and M87. The addition of modest telescopes in space would allow the combined array to produce higher-resolution, higher-fidelity images of these and other sources. This paper explores the potential benefits of adding orbital elements to the Event Horizon Telescope. We reconstruct model images using simulated data from arrays including telescopes in different orbits. We find that an array including one telescope near geostationary orbit and one in a high-inclination medium Earth or geosynchronous orbit can succesfully produce high-fidelity images capable of resolving shadows as small as 3 µas in diameter. One such key source, the Sombrero Galaxy, may be important to address questions regarding why some black holes launch powerful jets while others do not. Meanwhile, higher-resolution imaging of the substructure of M87 may clarify how jets are launched in the first place. The extra resolution provided by space VLBI will also improve studies of the collimation of jets from active galactic nuclei. Keywords: galaxies: jets; techniques: high angular resolution; techniques: interferometric; quasars: supermassive black holes c 2019. This manuscript version is made available Hirabayashi et al., 1998), and RadioAstron (Kardashev under the CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 license1 et al., 2013). Arrays with two space-borne elements have been proposed before at frequencies up to 43 GHz and 86 GHz (Hong et al., 2004; Murphy et al., 2005). 1. Introduction The EHT is a millimeter-wavelength VLBI array whose The angular resolution of an interferometric baseline primary goal is to image nearby supermassive black holes is approximately the observing wavelength divided by the and jets of active galactic nuclei (AGNs). Currently ob- baseline length λ/B. The choice of observing wavelength serving at λ = 1:3 mm (230 GHz), the fringe spacing (λ/B, is often fixed by source properties, and in any case atmo- where B is the projected baseline length) of the longest spheric absorption imposes site-dependent limits on what baselines correspond to an angular resolution . 25 µas, is possible. Many terrestrial arrays using very long base- which is sufficient to resolve the shadow of the supermas- line interferometry (VLBI), such as the Very Long Base- sive black holes of Sagittarius A* and M87. The EHT is line Array (VLBA) or the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT), currently upgrading telescopes to perform VLBI at λ = achieve high angular resolution by having telescopes that 0:87 mm (345 GHz), which will further improve angular are thousands of kilometers apart. Here too, the size of the resolution by a factor of 1.5. Earth imposes fundamental limits on the longest achiev- The EHT has developed imaging algorithms to produce able baseline from the ground. superresolved images to make the most out of its data arXiv:1903.09539v1 [astro-ph.IM] 22 Mar 2019 Longer baselines are achievable with space-borne ele- (e.g., Bouman et al., 2016; Chael et al., 2016; Akiyama et ments. Space VLBI has successfully been accomplished at al., 2017a,b; Kuramochi et al., 2018). Nevertheless, the centimeter wavelengths with the Tracking and Data Re- EHT is up against some hard limits. The Earth's atmo- lay Satellite System (TDRSS; Levy et al., 1986), Highly sphere quickly becomes unsuitable for ground-based VLBI Advance Laboratory for Communications and Astronomy at higher frequencies, and existing baselines already ap- (HALCA) VLBI Space Observatory Programme (VSOP; proach an Earth diameter. In order to achieve higher an- gular resolution, it will be necessary to incorporate space- borne elements into VLBI arrays of the future. ∗Corresponding author Adding space-borne antennas to the EHT opens up new Email address: [email protected] (Vincent L. Fish) science that is very difficult or impossible from the ground. 1http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Preprint submitted to Advances in Space Research March 25, 2019 Reconstructing reliable movies of Sgr A* is likely to require the cost per satellite, potentially allowing for more satel- fast (u; v) coverage not currently obtainable from Earth- lites to be built and launched. A rideshare strategy argues rotation aperture synthesis2 (Palumbo et al., 2018). The for choosing classes of orbits with frequent launches (e.g., ability to resolve and image fine-scale structures (smaller LEO and GEO) rather than requiring bespoke orbital pa- 2 than the gravitational radius, rg = GM=c ) in the flow rameters. around M87 will help enormously in understanding the Our vision assumes improvements in some space-borne details of how jets are launched. Adding to the EHT one telescope subsystems that we believe to be tractable within or more telescopes near geosynchronous orbit would enable less than a decade. We assume that an aperture of a few detailed study of other black hole sources such as the Som- meters in diameter with appropriate surface accuracy for brero Galaxy, an M87 analogue with a much weaker jet. observations at 1.3 mm can be deployed cheaply. One Space VLBI will also help answer the question of whether promising approach might be to stow the surface within a jet collimation is universal across a wide range of jet power. standard secondary payload volume and unfurl it in space. And, as is clear from the diversity of presentations at the Other approaches may become financially viable as the in- workshop \The Future of High-Resolution Radio Interfer- creasing number of commercial launch opporunities drive ometry in Space" held in Noordwijk, The Netherlands, in costs down. We assume that stable receivers and signal 20183, AGN jet science is just one of the many areas where chains with bandwidths of many GHz can provide ade- space VLBI could have a large impact. quate sensitivity at a cost that is not prohibitive. We as- In this work, we focus on the applicability of a 230 GHz sume that a very accurate frequency standard can be pro- space-VLBI array to AGN jet studies. We motivate an ar- vided at reasonable cost. Onboard atomic clocks on each chitecture and possible space-VLBI array from practical element may be the easiest solution, although distributed considerations (Section 2), generate synthetic data (Sec- signals with a round-trip loop may also be feasible. We as- tion 3), and examine the imaging power of such an ar- sume that laser communications links will be able to sup- ray (Section 4). We find that an array consisting of a port data rates of many gigabits per second. Transferring half dozen or so satellites of modest aperture can provide large amounts of data to the ground may require substan- the fast microarcsecond-scale angular resolution needed to tial onboard data storage and a geosynchronous satellite make next-generation breakthroughs in AGN jet science. acting as a relay. We have been purposefully vague in the preceding para- graph. Other scientific, industrial, and military applica- 2. Considerations for Designing a Space VLBI Ar- tions are already driving some of the assumed advances. ray Given adequate time and funding, focused efforts could 2.1. Technical Assumptions enable major progress in the remaining areas. All of the required pieces of technology for a space-VLBI 1.3 mm ar- This work focuses on what could be achieved scientif- ray exist, even if cost or performance issues may preclude ically by launching highly capable satellites into several advancing a complete mission today. Furthermore, as will classes of orbits around the Earth. Issues regarding tech- become clearer in Section 2.5, the achievable performance nology and engineering are necessarily beyond the scope of a space-VLBI array depends on multiple parameters of this work, and in any case it is impossible to predict (aperture size, aperture efficiency, bandwidth, and system with full accuracy what the landscape will look like in the temperature) of both the space-based and ground-based future. Nevertheless, it is worth specifying a few key tech- elements. Improvements in one of these parameters are nical assumptions to assess whether the concept described interchangeable with improvements in another. in this paper might be feasible within the next 5{10 years. The cost of access to space is decreasing. Rideshare op- 2.2. Timescales portunities are becoming plentiful, with reduced or even In order to produce static images or movies of a source zero marginal launch costs for secondary payloads. Tak- with varying structure, it is desirable to sample the (u; v) ing full advantage of these opportunities will likely require plane before the source structure changes appreciaby. A that space-VLBI payloads fit within the size and weight useful characteristic timescale for a black hole source is limits of a small satellite that could be launched from an t = GM=c3, the light-crossing time of the gravitational EELV (Evolved Expendable Launch Vehicles) Secondary g radius. For Sgr A*, whose mass is approximately 4:3 × Payload Adapter (ESPA) Grande ring, for instance. As an 106 M , this time is about 20 s. Structures in an ac- added benefit, keeping the payload size small may reduce cretion flow may be bigger than rg, and material in the accretion flow moves at subluminal velocities, so a source 2It is possible that a large number of additional ground stations may effectively be static over a timescale of a few tg.