WOMEN’S MEDIA CENTER The Status of Women in the U. S. Media 2014 womensmediacenter.com WOMEN’S MEDIA CENTER The Status of Women in the U. S. Media 2 0 1 4 Copyright 2014 Women’s Media Center. No part of this publication can be reproduced without permission in writing from the Women’s Media Center. WOMEN’S MEDIA CENTER About the Women’s Media Center In 2005, Jane Fonda, Robin Morgan and Gloria Steinem founded the Women’s Media Center (WMC), a progressive, non-partisan, non-pro!t organization that is raising the visibility, viability and decision-making power of women in media, and ensuring that women’s stories get told and women’s voices get heard. To achieve these broad goals, the Women’s Media Center: Runs media advocacy campaigns. Researches and monitors sexism in the media. Creates original content through Women’s Media Center Live with Robin Morgan, a weekly CBS radio show, and through WMC Features, an online news and commentary site. Promotes women experts as media sources on a broad array of topics through WMC SheSource. Undertakes such special media initiatives as WMC Women Under Siege, which provides news coverage and other journalistic documentation of rape and sexualized violence committed during foreign wars and on the U.S. home front. Trains women and girls on how to optimally engage and understand the media. Follow WMC on Twitter @womensmediacntr and at www.facebook.com/womensmediacenter. TABLE OF CONTENTS Headlines, bylines and the box of!ce: How the presence and absence of women shape the story — A foreword by Women’s Media Center President Julie Burton .............................5 New research shines light on gender bias in major U.S. broadcast, print, online & wire outlets: Male journalists dominate most sectors .................................6 Executive summary of WMC Status of Women in U.S. Media report 2014 ...........17 In newspapers & magazines ........................................................................................19 Except among minorities, tally of women journalists barely budged as men accounted for two-thirds of newsroom staffers ............................................19 Men garnered three times as many page 1 quotes in The New York Times (But more women got quoted when women reported the story) ............................21 Op-ed writer ranks remained mostly white, mostly male ..........................................24 In television, radio & digital news ...............................................................................25 Progress and regress in broadcast news .....................................................................25 One woman’s MSNBC show boasted the highest proportion of black men and women of any on the Sunday talk show circuit ..........................................27 Women & Politics Institute: Men pols dominated Sunday shows ............................30 In ‘Heavy Hundred,’ two females in sports talk radio and 13 in news talk; no women ranked in top 10 ..............................................................31 In sports journalism ......................................................................................................32 90 percent male, 90 percent white: sports editors ranks have far to go ..................32 In !lm & entertainment media ....................................................................................35 How 500 top-grossing movies didn’t—and sometimes did— bridge the gender and race gap ................................................................................35 In vaunted Sundance line-up, ‘… Industry leaders … think male’............................37 Six percent of 100 top !lms casted the sexes in equal numbers ..............................40 The Center for the Study of Women in Television and Film/San Diego State !lm !ndings also showed women lagging ............................41 ‘Gender Inequality in Film,’ a New York Film Academy report .................................43 Critics’ choice? Says who? ............................................................................................44 ‘Boxed in’: TV’s behind-the-scenes female workforce inched up .............................45 Female TV characters with speaking parts peaked at 43 percent ............................47 2013’s Male !lm characters—often older and wiser—outnumbered females .........48 Without women directors, 25 percent of 200 TV series made the Directors Guild of America’s ’Worst Of’ list ...............................................................50 UCLA think tank: Diversity drives up viewership 51 ........................................................ WOMEN’S MEDIA CENTER The Status of Women in the U.S. Media 2014 womensmediacenter.com 3 The problem with ‘Baby Mamas’; Essence readers decried imbalance of popular media portrayals of black women.............................................................53 Study: Latinas with solid ethnic identity less inclined to adopt media’s widespread ‘skinny, white girl’ beauty standard .......................................................57 In the media pipeline ...................................................................................................58 Women communications grads mainly chose PR & advertising ..............................58 Though still outnumbered among male book reviewers and authors, women gained momentum at some signature publications ..................................................61 Women in gaming, social media & technology ........................................................63 Online, women’s social media use continued to outpace men’s ..............................63 Women were almost half of video-game buyers, but remain a fraction of that multi-billion industry’s developers .................................................67 About half of women leave that male-dominated !eld, where females lead a fraction of big tech !rms and start-ups ..................................68 Among corporate decision-makers, what place and power do women hold? .....70 Benchmarking women’s leadership study’ researchers link women’s status in media to well-being of all women workers ..................................70 Media mavens again made Forbes list of 100 Most Powerful Women ....................73 Afterword: A practical path toward parity .................................................................74 Post script ......................................................................................................................76 WMC media resources .................................................................................................77 Source citations ...........................................................................................................78 This report’s producers ................................................................................................79 WMC acknowledgments, board of directors & staff 80 ................................................ WOMEN’S MEDIA CENTER 4 The Status of Women in the U.S. Media 2014 womensmediacenter.com Foreword Headlines, bylines and the box office: How the presence and absence of women shape the story This Women’s Media Center annual report tracks how well the American media— ubiquitous shaper of images, ideologies and ideals—allow women to craft our own narrative and include our voices in a wide-ranging public discourse that’s moderated over the airwaves, in print and online. Indeed, we at the Center are acutely aware that we’re far from the days when nary a female could be found in the !lm director’s seat, when women journalists were relegated to the women’s pages, when a woman was hard-pressed to get an entertainment media project green-lighted. Today’s sure-enough strides show Shonda Rhimes breaking barriers in primetime TV; Jill Abramson helming the globally in"uential The New York Times, our national paper-of-record; and a small assortment of females-in-chief looming large in the digital sphere. Still, the Center’s new commissioned report on how women journalists fared during the last quarter of 2013 found that 64 percent of bylines and on-camera appearances went to men at the nation’s top 20 TV networks, newspapers, online news sites and news wire services. That reality, along with this report’s analysis of !ndings by an array of university scholars, media and watchdog organizations who monitor newsrooms, !lm lots, broadcast studios, the digital sphere and more, brings us to what has been an ongoing, concerning conclusion: The American media have exceedingly more distance to travel on the road to gender-blind parity. The Center’s own 2013 newsroom snapshot, research from those scholars and watchdogs groups and the true stories of women whose career trajectories that their trenchant data help gauge, spotlight an array of continuing obstacles. They suggest a troubling status quo and, in some places, a slipping back in time. The bleakest of realities show that those who steer sports news coverage remain overwhelmingly white and male, even as women’s sports and the ranks of sports fans who happen to be women are surging. Women of color in certain sectors of media— with their own singular urgency to help tell their myriad stories and help call the shots— are among those who have lost ground in recent years. They are being spotlighted in this yearly report for the !rst time. It matters that women of color and every one else in this diverse nation be part of the conversations conducted through the media. Unequivocally, it matters when all American