MATCH REVIEW PANEL MINUTES 13/05/2019 - MATTERS CONSIDERED Case Number: ON/704/19 Name: Liam Watts Club and shirt Castleford; 8 number: Match: Hull FC v Castleford Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 3rd minute (Taylor) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Approaches contact at upper thigh from behind opponent as Reason for NFA: opponent still making forward motion. Player does not apply pressure against opponent’s joint natural range of movement. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/705/19 Name: Liam Watts Club and shirt Castleford; 8 number: Match: Hull FC v Castleford Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 24th minute (Ellis) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player brings opponent to ground and lands on opponent’s Reason for NFA: foot accidentally. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/706/19 Name: Joe Westerman Club and shirt Hull FC; 13 number: Match: Hull FC v Castleford Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Raised knee in the 45th minute (Millington) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player raises knee and leans into contact on opponent with Reason for NFA: upper body. Does not make contact with opponent with point of knee. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/707/19 Name: Joe Westerman Club and shirt Hull FC; 13 number: Match: Hull FC v Castleford Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Late contact in the 52nd minute (Milner) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player makes contact on opponent after the ball is passed. Reason for NFA: Does not make contact with the head of opponent. Worthy of onfield penalty. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/708/19 Name: Micky Paea Club and shirt Hull FC; 23 number: Match: Hull FC v Castleford Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Raises knee in the 69th minute (McShane) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player brings ball into contact and raises knee but does not Reason for NFA: make contact on opponent. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/709/19 Name: Nathan Massey Club and shirt Castleford; 12 number: Match: Hull FC v Castleford Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 78th minute (Kelly) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player completes tackle on opponent, does not have grip on Reason for NFA: opponent. Other tackler comes down on top of player. Some pressure maybe applied but not through poor technique of player. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/710/19 Name: Jay Chapelhow Club and shirt Widnes; 8 number: Match: Wakefield v Widnes Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 8th minute (Fifita) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player lifts one foot off the ground and drops bodyweight Reason for NFA: through contact. Inner knee makes contact on opponent which does not apply pressure to opponent’s limb. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/711/19 Name: Jack Owens Club and shirt Widnes; 5 number: Match: Wakefield v Widnes Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 26th minute (Jowett) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player approaches contact as opponent turns following Reason for NFA: catching the ball. Player comes down on opponent to complete tackle. Footage doesn’t demonstrate any pressure applied on opponents head or neck. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/712/19 Name: Daniel Norman Club and shirt Widnes; 26 number: Match: Wakefield v Widnes Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangeorus Contact in the 29th minute (Fifita) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player wraps leg to use as lever to bring opponent to ground Reason for NFA: but does not apply pressure to opponent’s limb. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/713/19 Name: Jack Owens Club and shirt Widnes; 5 number: Match: Wakefield v Widnes Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 10th May 2019 Report received from: Referee; Dismissal Details of allegation: Uses foul or abusive language in the 64th minute Decision: Issue charge Details of Charge / Rule – 15.1(f) Reason for NFA: Detail – Questioning the integrity of a Match Official Grade – D Penalty Notice: Refer to Tribunal Case Number: ON/714/19 Name: Joey Lussick Club and shirt Salford; 14 number: Match: Salford v Hull KR Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 11th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 5th minute (Lawler) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player grips at feet and maintains loose grip on shin and rolls Reason for NFA: with the tackle. Player does not apply pressure to the joint. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/715/19 Name: Joel Tomkins Club and shirt Hull KR; 11 number: Match: Salford v Hull KR Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 11th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 19th minute (Mossop) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Approaches contact at waist height and as tackle moves an Reason for NFA: makes contact with the leg of opponent. Player pulls foot off the ground to destabilise. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/716/19 Name: Krisnan Inu Club and shirt Salford; 26 number: Match: Salford v Hull KR Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 11th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 24th minute (Shaw) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player approaches contact from the back of opponent. Makes Reason for NFA: contact with the fold of the knee and not against the joints natural range of movement. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/717/19 Name: Weller Hauraki Club and shirt Hull KR; 13 number: Match: Salford v Hull KR Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 11th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 31st minute (Welham) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player makes contact as opponent is turned in the tackle and Reason for NFA: comes down to the ground with opponent. Player makes allowances to let opponent’s head through the contact. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/718/19 Name: Mikey Wood Club and shirt Bradford; 13 number: Match: Bradford v Leeds Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 11th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 2nd minute (Merrin) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player grips at waist and drops weight to ground, does not Reason for NFA: make dangerous contact on opponent. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/719/19 Name: James Green Club and shirt Bradford; 16 number: Match: Bradford v Leeds Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 11th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Shoulder charge in the 40th minute (Merrin) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player drives into tackle on opponent and does not promote Reason for NFA: shoulder. Player demonstrates wrapping motion and doesn’t turn body into contact on opponent. Contact shoulder to shoulder. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/720/19 Name: Matty Wildie Club and shirt Bradford; 9 number: Match: Bradford v Leeds Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 11th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 41st minute (Hurrell) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player grips on opponent and attempts to use bodyweight to Reason for NFA: bring opponent to ground. Player does not apply pressure on the opponent’s limbs. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/721/19 Name: Matthew Costello Club and shirt St Helens; 24 number: Match: Huddersfield v St Helens Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 12th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: High tackle in the 6th minute (McIntosh) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player comes into contact as opponent is going to ground Reason for NFA: following contact on opponent from other tackler. Makes contact high on opponent, worthy of onfield penalty. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/722/19 Name: Suaia Matagi Club and shirt Huddersfield; 10 number: Match: Huddersfield v St Helens Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 12th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Late contact in the 8th minute (Lomax) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Opponent passes ball as player comes into contact. No Reason for NFA: contact with the head of opponent. Contact simultaneous as to ball being released by opponent. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/723/19 Name: Alex Walmsley Club and shirt St Helens; 8 number: Match: Huddersfield v St Helens Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 12th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: High tackle in the 29th minute (Frawley) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player makes contact just as the ball is passed, doesn’t make Reason for NFA: contact with the head. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/724/19 Name: Matty Lees Club and shirt St Helens; 19 number: Match: Huddersfield v St Helens Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 12th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Dangerous Contact in the 29th minute (Ta’ai) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Opponent forcefully fends player to ground, player lands on Reason for NFA: opponents ankle accidentally. Penalty Notice: N/A Case Number: ON/725/19 Name: Sean O’Loughlin Club and shirt Wigan; 13 number: Match: Warrington v Wigan Competition and Date: Challenge Cup; 12th May 2019 Report received from: MRPR Details of allegation: Leading with forearm in the 16th minute (Philbin) Decision: NFA Details of Charge / Player promotes arm into contact as ball carrier.