The Perception of Medical Ethics Within the Case Study and Campaign of Jennerian Vaccination The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:37945151 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA The Perception of Medical Ethics within the Case Study and Campaign of Jennerian Vaccination Blake Edward De Leon A Thesis in the Field of History for the Degree of Master of Liberal Arts in Extension Studies Harvard University November 2018 Copyright 2018 Blake Edward De Leon ! ""! ! #$%&'()&!! ! *+(,,-./!"%!)'01"&01!(%!&20!10(1,"0%&!"340)&".5%!1"%0(%0!"3!2"%&.'67!8'.+!&20! $09"33"39!.4!&20!0"92&003&2!)03&5'6!%+(,,-./!:(%!&'0(&01!$6!"3%0'&"39!%+(,,-./! +(&&0'!"3&.!&20!('+!.4!(3!"31";"15(,7!<&!:(%!3.&!&20!"10(,!+0&2.1!.4!&'0(&+03&7!! =26%")"(3!>1:('1!?0330'!4'.+!(!6.539!(90!(%!(3!(--'03&")0@!:(%!"3&0'0%&01!"3!&20! 4.,A,.'0!.4!).:-./7!B.:-./!:203!).3&'()&01!$6!(!25+(3!:(%!'5+.'01!&.!+(A0!&20! "31";"15(,!53%5%)0-&"$,0!&.!%+(,,-./7!?0330'!%.592&!&.!$'"39!&2"%!4.,A,.'0!&.!&20! +(%%0%!"4!"3!4()&!).:-./!1"1!-'.&0)&!(9("3%&!%+(,,-./7!C0!10&0'+"301!&2'.592! 0/-0'"+03&(&".3@!&2(&!).:-./!-'.&0)&01!(9("3%&!%+(,,-./7!#%!(!'0%5,&!20!03&0'01!(! 10)(10%D,.39!)(+-("93!"3!.'10'!&.!%00!&2"%!+0&2.1!%(;0!,";0%!4'.+!&20!20,,!&2(&!:(%! %+(,,-./7!E20!0&2")%!.4!?0330'!:0'0!F50%&".301!&2'.592.5&!2"%!:.'A7!E2"%!'0%0(')2! 4"31%!&2(&!?0330'!).315)&01!2"%!0/-0'"+03&%!0&2")(,,67!E.!5310'%&(31!&20!0&2")%!.4! ?0330'!"&!"%!30)0%%('6!&.!-,()0!2"+!:"&2"3!&20!+01")(,!0&2")%!0%&($,"%201!-'".'!(31! 15'"39!2"%!0'(7!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! """! ! G01")(&".3%!! ! ! G01")(&01!&.!+6!:"40!(31!4(+",6@!<!,.;0!0()2!.4!6.5!10(',6H! E2(3A!6.5!4.'!(,:(6%!$0"39!&20'0@!<!&2(3A!I.1!4.'!0()2!.4!6.5!0;0'6!%"39,0!1(67! <!(+!&'5,6!(!$,0%%01!"31";"15(,!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ";! ! #)A3.:,0190+03&%!! ! ! <!:.5,1!,"A0!&.!()A3.:,0190!(31!&2(3A!='.40%%.'%!G(;"1!*25+:(6!?.30%!(31!G.3(,1! J%&'.:%A"7!E2(3A!6.5!$.&2!4.'!(%%"%&(3)0!15'"39!&2"%!-'.)0%%7! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ;! E($,0!.4!B.3&03&%! ! ! G01")(&".3%77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777";! ! #)A3.:,0190+03&%77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 ;! ! <7!<3&'.15)&".3 777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 K! ! <<7!G04"3"&".3!.4!E0'+%777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 L! ! <<<7!M()A9'.531 7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 N! ! <O7!C"%&.'6!.4!P01")(,!>&2")%!(31!&20!8"95'0%!:2.!B'0(&01!&20+ 7777777777777777777777777777777777777 KQ! ! O7!?0330'R%!B(%0!*&516!(31!=5$,")(&".3 77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 SL! ! O<7!?0330'R%!O())"3(&".3!B(+-("9377777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 QT! ! O<<7!M"$,".9'(-26 7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 LU! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ;"! ! B2(-&0'!<! <3&'.15)&".3! ! *+(,,-./!"%!)'01"&01!(%!$0"39!&20!10(1,"0%&!"340)&".5%!1"%0(%0!"3!2"%&.'67!<&!"%! '0%-.3%"$,0!4.'!A",,"39!.;0'!&2'00!2531'01!+",,".3!-0.-,07!*+(,,-./!1"1!3.&!A3.:! ),(%%!.'!'()0V!(36.30!).5,1!-.&03&"(,,6!1"0!4'.+!&2"%!1"%0(%07!E20'0!('0!3.!,.390'! 40('%!.4!%+(,,-./!.5&$'0(A%!150!&.!&20!'0%0(')2!(31!0/-0'"+03&(&".3!&2(&!+(10!&20! 0'(1")(&".3!.4!%+(,,-./!-.%%"$,07!E20%0!044.'&%!$09(3!:"&2!0"92&003&2!)03&5'6! '0%0(')20'!(31!-26%")"(3!>1:('1!?0330'!:2.!&..A!:2(&!).5,1!$0!).3%"10'01! 4.,A,.'0!&.!&20!%)"03&"4")!+(%%0%!(31!)'0(&01!(!;())"3(&".3!)(+-("93!&.!'"1!&20!:.',1! .4!%+(,,-./7!='0%"103&!E2.+(%!?0440'%.3!"3!(!,0&&0'!&.!?0330'!&2(3A01!2"+!(31! '0).93"W01!&20!"+-()&!20!:.5,1!2(;0!.3!&20!:.',17!='0%"103&!?0440'%.3!:'.&0@! XP01")"30!2(%!30;0'!$04.'0!-'.15)01!(36!%"39,0!"+-'.;0+03&!.4!%5)2!5&","&6Y!Z.5! 2(;0!0'(%01!4'.+!&20!)(,031('!.4!25+(3!(44,")&".3%!.30!.4!"&%!9'0(&0%&Y!P(3A"31!)(3! 30;0'!4.'90&!&2(&!6.5!2(;0!,";017[K!=26%")"(3%!(31!%)2.,('%!9030'(,,6!)'01"&!?0330'! 4.'!2"%!:.'A!.3!;())"3(&".3@!$5&!%.+0!F50%&".3!&20!0&2")%!(%!&.!2.:!?0330'!)(+0!&.! 2"%!4"31"39%7!E2"%!:.'A!:",,!4.)5%!.3!2.:!?0330'!)(+0!&.!2"%!;())"3(&".3@!&20! '0%5,&"39!;())"3(&".3!)(+-("93!(31!&20!0&2")%!20!.$%0';01!(,.39!&20!:(67! ! >1:('1!?0330'!).+-,0&01!2"%!)(%0!%&516!.3!%+(,,-./!"3!&20!,(&0!0"92&003&2! )03&5'6V!20!-0'4.'+01!(!%0'"0%!.4!&0%&!.3!"31";"15(,%!"3),51"39!)2",1'03@!&.!%00!&20! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! KE2.+(%!?0440'%.3@!X\0&&0'!&.!>1:('1!?0330'!.3!2"%!G"%).;0'6!.4!&20!*+(,,! =./!O())"30@[!P(6!KQ@K]^_@!2&&-`aa:::7,0&7'5973,a5%(a-'0%"103&%a&2.+(%D b0440'%.3a,0&&0'%D.4D&2.+(%Db0440'%.3ab04,KNT7-2-!KQ!80$'5('6!T^K]7! ! K! 0440)&%!.4!).:-./!.3!25+(3%!(31!"4!&20!).:-./!+(&&0'!&'(3%+"&&01!;"(!;())"3(&".3! &.!(3.&20'!"31";"15(,!-'0;03&01!&20+!4'.+!).3&'()&"39!%+(,,-./7!C0!-5$,"%201!2"%! 4"31"39%!"3!(!-5$,")(&".3!20!&"&,01!!"#$"%&'()#'"*+#*,-#./&0-0#/"1#233-4*0#+3#*,-# 5/('+6/-#5/44'"/-7#!#8'0-/0-#8'04+9-(-1#'"#0+:-#+3#*,-#;-0*-("#.+&"*'-0#+3#2"<6/"1=# >/(*'4&6/(6)#?6+&4-0*-(0,'(-#/"1#@"+A"#B)#*,-#"/:-#+3#*,-#.+A#>+C7!E2"%!-5$,")(&".3! :(%!1"'0)&,6!'0%-.3%"$,0!4.'!&20!.$%0';(&".3!.4!?0330'"(3!;())"3(&".3@!:2")2!,01!&.! %(;"39!+",,".3%!.4!,";0%7!?0330'!%&('&01!(!;())"3(&".3!)(+-("93!&2(&!&'(;0,,01!&20! :.',1!:0,,!(4&0'!2"%!10(&2!"3!K]TS7!C"%!044.'&%!).3&"3501!4.'!.;0'!(!)03&5'6!(31!(! 2(,4@!"3!KUNN!&20!c.',1!C0(,&2!J'9(3"W(&".3!2(1!4"3(,,6!%5))00101!"3!&20!0'(1")(&".3! .4!%+(,,-./7!<&!%-0(A%!;.,5+0%!&.!&20!20,,"%2!1"%0(%0!%+(,,-./!:(%@!2(;"39!&.!:.'A! &2(&!,.39!&.!'"1!&20!:.',1!.4!.30!.4!"&%!:.'%&!(1;0'%('"0%7!J3!P(6!]@!KUU^@!&20!c.',1! C0(,&2!#%%0+$,6!(33.53)01!&2(&!&20!:.',1!:(%!4'00!.4!%+(,,-./!(31!'0).++03101! &2(&!(,,!).53&'"0%!)0(%0!;())"3(&".3`!XE20!:.',1!(31!"&%!-0.-,0!2(;0!:.3!4'001.+! 4'.+!%+(,,-./@!:2")2!:(%!&20!+.%&!10;(%&(&"39!1"%0(%0!%:00-"39!"3!0-"10+")!4.'+! &2'.592!+(36!).53&'"0%!%"3)0!0(',"0%&!&"+0@!,0(;"39!10(&2@!$,"3130%%!(31! 1"%4"95'0+03&!"3!"&%!:(A07[T!! ! E20!0&2")%!.4!+01")(,!'0%0(')2!(31!-'()&")0!,"A0!(,,!0&2")(,!+(&&0'%!2(%! 0;.,;01!.;0'!&"+0@!(!+.10'3!+01")(,!0&2")!%)2.,('!:2.!.$%0';01!?0330'!%.,0,6!"3! &20!%&(31('1%!.4!&.1(6@!:.5,1!(,+.%&!)0'&("3,6!;"0:!?0330'!(%!530&2")(,7!!8'.+!2"%! 5%0!.4!25+(3!&0%&!%5$b0)&%@!&.!-5'-.%045,,6!"3&'.15)"39!"31";"15(,%!&.!2('+45,! $()&0'"(,!+(&&0'@!?0330'!"%!%5''.53101!$6!0&2")(,!F50%&".3%7!M5&!&2.%0!F50%&".3%!1.! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! T!*&04(3!d"010,@!X>1:('1!?0330'!(31!&20!C"%&.'6!.4!*+(,,-./!(31! O())"3(&".3@[!?(35('6!T^^L@!2&&-%`aa:::73)$"73,+73"279.;a-+)a('&"),0%a! =PBKT^^_U_a!e_!P(')2!T^K]f7! ! ! T! 3.&!'0%"10!%.,0,6!"3!&20!-'0%03&V!&20!0&2")%!.4!?0330'!:0'0!2"92,"92&01!(31!('9501!(&! &20!&"+0!.4!2"%!)(+-("93!&..7!c2",0!.30!)(3!-,()0!?0330'!:"&2"3!&20!0&2")%!.4!&.1(6@! &.!&'5,6!;"0:!&20!0&2")%!.4!?0330'@!"&!:.5,1!$0!30)0%%('6!&.!-,()0!2"+!:"&2"3!&20! 0&2")(,!%&(31('1%!)'0(&01!-'".'!(31!('.531!&20!&"+0!.4!2"%!%+(,,-./!)(%0!%&5167!E20! &0'+!X+01")(,!0&2")%[!:(%!3.&!)."301!53&",!K]^S!:203!-26%")"(3!E2.+(%!=0')";(,! "3&'.15)01!"&!"3!2"%!0-.36+.5%!$..A!D-1'4/6#-*,'407S!?0330'!2(1!(,'0(16!-0'4.'+01! 2"%!0/-0'"+03&%!(31!-5$,"%201!2"%!4"31"39%!$6!K]^S7!eD-1'4/6#2*,'40!:",,!%&",,!$0!(! )'"&")(,!-"0)0!&.!&2"%!:.'A!(%!"&!"%!%5)2!(3!"+-.'&(3&!'0%.5')0!"3!&20!2"%&.'6!.4! +01")(,!0&2")%f!E25%!:2(&!:0'0!&20!0&2")(,!95"10,"30%!(31!-'.)015'0%!4.'!(!+01")(,! '0%0(')20'!.'!-'()&"&".30'!&.!-0'4.'+!-'.-0'!+01")"30!$04.'0!(31!15'"39!&20!,(&0! 0"92&003&2!)03&5'6g!c2(&!0,0+03&%!.4!?0330'R%!)(%0!%&516!(31!)(+-("93!:0'0!%003! (%!$0"39!).3&'.;0'%"(,!0&2")(,,6g!C.:!1"1!?0330'R%!-00'%!;"0:!2"+%0,4@!2"%!1"%).;0'6@! (31!&20!.;0'(,,!0&2")%!.4!2"%!)(+-("93g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c2",0!?0330'!(31!2"%!:.'A!('0!)'"&")(,@!&20!:.'A%!.4!.&20'%!('0!.4!(3!0;03!9'0(&0'! "+-.'&(3)0!$0)(5%0!?0330'!(,:(6%!:'.&0!"3!(!;0'6!%"+-,0!+(330'@!20!1"1!3.&!9.!"3&.! +5)2!10&(",7!C"%!,()A!.4!10&(",!"%!(!+(b.'!-."3&!.4!('95+03&!4.'!&2.%0!:2.!%&..1! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! S!d.$0'&!M7!M(A0'!(31!\(5'03)0!M7!P)B5,,.592@!E,-#./:B('1<-#;+(61#F'0*+()# +3#D-1'4/6#2*,'40!eh0:!Z.'A`!B(+$'"190!i3";0'%"&6!='0%%@!T^^Uf@!S7! ! S! (9("3%&!?0330'7!\5)A",6!%)2.,('%!2(;0!:'"&&03!($.5&!?0330'!(31!2"%!)(+-("93@! -'.;"1"39!(+$,0!"3%"92&7! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Q! ! B2(-&0'!<<7! G04"3"&".3!.4!E0'+%! ! ?0330'"(3!;())"3(&".3`!&20!()&!.4!&(A"39!).:-./!+(&&0'!(31!"3%0'&"39!&20! +(&&0'!"3&.!%+(,,!"3)"%".3%!.3!&20!('+!.4!&20!&0%&!%5$b0)&7!=0'4.'+"39!&20!;())"3(&".3!