Craigdarroch Military Hospital: A Canadian War Story Bruce Davies Curator © Craigdarroch Castle 2016 2 Abstract As one of many military hospitals operated by the federal government during and after The Great War of 1914-1918, the Dunsmuir house “Craigdarroch” is today a lens through which museum staff and visitors can learn how Canada cared for its injured and disabled veterans. Broad examination of military and civilian medical services overseas, across Canada, and in particular, at Craigdarroch, shows that the Castle and the Dunsmuir family played a significant role in a crucial period of Canada’s history. This paper describes the medical care that wounded and sick Canadian soldiers encountered in France, Belgium, Britain, and Canada. It explains some of the measures taken to help permanently disabled veterans successfully return to civilian life. Also covered are the comprehensive building renovations made to Craigdarroch, the hospital's official opening by HRH The Prince of Wales, and the question of why the hospital operated so briefly. By highlighting the wartime experiences of one Craigdarroch nurse and one Craigdarroch patient, it is seen that opportunities abound for rich story- telling in a new gallery now being planned for the museum. The paper includes an appendix offering a synopsis of the Dunsmuir family’s contributions to the War. 3 Table of Contents Introduction................................................................................................................................. 04 I. Canadian Medical Services During the Great War....................................................... 04 1. Route of Medical Care........................................................................................ 05 1.1. Regimental Aid Posts............................................................................ 07 1.2. Dressing Stations................................................................................... 08 1.3. Casualty Clearing Stations.................................................................... 09 1.4. Overseas Hospitals................................................................................ 10 2. Battlefield Conditions and Medical Staff........................................................... 13 2.1. Medical Officers.................................................................................... 13 2.2. Nursing Sisters...................................................................................... 15 3. The Work of Military Hospitals in Canada....................................................... 17 3.1. The Military Hospitals Commission or Department of Soldiers Civil Reestablishment.......................................................................................... 17 3.2. The Journey Home............................................................................... 18 3.3. Publicity............................................................................................... 20 3.4. Curative Work and Retraining............................................................. 21 3.5. Hospital Ward Aides and Occupational Therapy................................ 21 3.6. Vocational Retraining.......................................................................... 26 3.7. Farming and the case of Matson Farm, Vancouver Island.................. 29 4. Administrative Problems in Canadian Military Hospitals................................ 31 II. Craigdarroch Military Hospital.................................................................................. 34 1. A Hospital Takes Shape.................................................................................... 34 2. Craigdarroch Renovations................................................................................ 38 2.1. Overview.............................................................................................. 38 2.2. Basement Changes............................................................................... 43 2.3. First Floor Changes............................................................................. 44 2.4. Second Floor Changes.......................................................................... 45 2.5. Third Floor Changes............................................................................. 47 2.6. Fourth Floor and Tower........................................................................ 47 2.7. Exterior Changes................................................................................... 48 2.8. Interior Furnishings............................................................................... 48 4. Craigdarroch Hospital Operations...................................................................... 59 5. Staffing............................................................................................................... 62 6. Daily Life in Craigdarroch Military Hospital..................................................... 65 7. Craigdarroch Patients.......................................................................................... 65 7.1. Patients Who Died at Craigdarroch Military Hospital........................... 65 7.2. Patients Treated at Craigdarroch and Discharged.................................. 67 7.3. Probable Craigdarroch Patients.............................................................. 68 7.4. One Patient’s Story................................................................................. 70 8. Closing Craigdarroch Military Hospital.............................................................. 75 Conclusion................................................................................................................................... 77 List of Tables and Figures........................................................................................................... 78 Appendix 1: Bank of Montreal “at present” floor plans, Dated 1920.......................................... 85 Appendix 2: Current Craigdarroch Castle floor plans................................................................. 90 Appendix 3: Standard Construction Details for Canadian Military Hospitals............................. 95 Appendix 4: Dunsmuirs and The Great War................................................................................ 98 Appendix 5: Daily Life at Craigdarroch Military Hospital.......................................................... 108 Bibliography................................................................................................................................. 116 4 Craigdarroch Military Hospital: A Canadian War Story Introduction At the outbreak of WWI, there were about 8,000,000 people living in Canada. Roughly 600,000 of the country’s men and women joined the Canadian Expeditionary Force, and about 450,000 of them went overseas. Another 50,000 people in Canada joined British or allied armies. By the end of the war, 60,000 had been killed in action overseas or died from wounds, injury, and disease. 70,000 returned to Canada with varying degrees of sickness and disability.1 The nature of the disabilities suffered by veterans varied widely. Some disabilities were directly attributable to war service, such as dismemberment, while others suffered from pre-existing ailments exacerbated by war service. Others simply became ill while overseas, for example, through catching tuberculosis or developing cancer. About 20% of Canada’s recruits were deemed unfit for service when they arrived in Britain. In some cases, men had understated their age on recruitment. These were the so- called “thirty-niners.”2 This paper begins by outlining the medical care provided to Canadian soldiers in Europe and at home during The Great War. More detail is provided on military hospitals operated in Canada by the Military Hospitals Commission (1915-1918), and its successor, the Department of Soldiers’ Civil Reestablishment (1918-1927). After this background is provided, the paper’s focus becomes Craigdarroch Military Hospital. It explores renovations made to the building and how the Castle fit into the Canadian government’s strategy to care for wounded and sick veterans, helping them return to civilian life. Craigdarroch Military Hospital opened in September of 1919, but closed in early 1921. By 1927, the Department of Soldiers' Civil Reestablishment, based in Ottawa, was renamed the Department of Pensions and National Health. Craigdarroch Castle and its surviving hospital-era building modifications can be seen as tangible evidence of Canada’s first major intervention into the health and welfare of its citizens. This intervention helped to build the foundation of the nation’s modern health care system. I. Canadian Medical Services During the Great War 5 1. Route of Medical Care Medical services provided to soldiers by the Canadian Army Medical Corps on and off the battlefield during World War l were generally very good. Like all Commonwealth medical corps organizations, Canada’s medical corps conformed to the British system.3 Medical doctor and military officer Sir Andrew Macphail, in his Official History of the Canadian Forces in the Great War 1914-19: The Medical Services, explains the system designed to process casualties on the battlefield: The route of the wounded soldier was - regimental aid post, advanced dressing station, main dressing station, casualty clearing station, general hospital. From the general hospital, one of two routes was open to him according to the nature of his wound. If the condition were temporary