Site Assessment Report 2019 1 Contents Page Contents Contents Page ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 2 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Sites Phased out at Stage 1 Assessment ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Sites Phased out at Stage 2 Assessment: ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 5 Sites Phased out at Stage 3,4 & 5 Assessment – Key and Statutory Consultees Consultation .................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 13 Sites that have been part allocated; part included within a settlement boundary; retained within settlement boundary but not allocated ........................................................................................................................................................... 36 Sites that cannot be assessed ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 47 Safeguarded/Designated/Countryside Sites ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 50 Allocated Sites ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 52 2 Introduction Local Development Plan Review i. Pembrokeshire County Council is preparing a replacement Local Development Plan (LDP) – Local Development Plan 2. When adopted, it will provide a revised and updated policy framework to guide development outside of the National Park and inform planning decisions taken by the County Council. During the Review, the existing Local Development Plan (up to 2021) will remain in place until Local Development Plan 2 (LDP2) is adopted. Site Assessment Report ii. This Background Paper Housing: Site Assessment Report has been produced to explain how the Authority has considered every Candidate Site submitted to it. The Candidate Sites Register lists all sites submitted to the Authority during its calls for Candidate Sites in 2018. This Assessment has been undertaken in accordance with the Authority’s Candidate Site Analysis Methodology, which was previously subject to public consultation1. The report identifies for each site why it has or has not been included in the Council’s Deposit Local Development Plan. iii. The Authority is publishing the Deposit Plan for consultation between the 15th January 2020 and the 11th March 2020. As part of this consultation members of the public have the opportunity to make representations in support or as an objection to the Plan. iv. Significant evidence base on a range of issues supports the Deposit Plan. This information is published to the Council’s website and has informed this paper https://www.pembrokeshire.gov.uk/local-development-plan-review/ldp2-evidence-base. This includes information on the overall level of Housing required, Calculation of a Windfall Figure, a Settlement Boundary Review methodology and specialist analysis of topics such as Minerals. In some cases sites without significant constraints have not been supported by the Authority because the overall housing need can be met by other sites which relate better to the built form of the settlement or are preferable because they are previously developed land. This approach supports that set out by Welsh Government in Planning Policy Wales Edition 10. v. In addition to the assessment of Candidate Sites recorded in this report, the Authority has also considered existing sites with planning permission. Those sites with planning permission which are considered to be deliverable within the Plan period have been identified within settlement boundaries and allocated where appropriate. 1 https://www.pembrokeshire.gov.uk/local-development-plan-review/candidate-sites 3 Sites Phased out at Stage 1 Assessment No sites were phased out at Stage 1 of the Candidate Sites assessment, using a criteria of 80% of the site being within either a SSSI, SAC or floodplain (where the use proposed was a residential use). Following the completion of the Council’s Strategic Flood Consequence Assessment (SFCA), which also factored in Climate Change, Surface Water Flooding and Sea Level Rise, the following sites were phased out. These are sites at 50% flood risk (red) where a residential element was proposed: The Strategic Flood Consequence Assessment is available as part of the Authority’s Local Development Plan evidence base. 2 Site Nearest Agent Proposed Area Screen Reason To Site Name Proposer Name Organisation Agent Organisation Current Use Expanded Reason Ref Settlement Name Use (Ha) Out Screen Out 088 North of Pen y Rhyd / I'r Abercych Huw Lewis Former Orchard / Hen Housing / 0.13 Y SFCA SFCA Category Red is too high to Gogledd Pen y Rhyd Berllan Tai be mitigated for residential use. 035 Adjacent to Grove Gardens / Pembroke / Mr & Mrs. RJ & Grazing (horses) / Pori Housing / 0.35 Y SFCA SFCA Category Red is too high to Cyfagos at Grove Gardens Penfro H Parnell (ceffylau) Tai be mitigated for residential use. 237 West of Dale Farm / I'r St Florence Miss. Kathryn Edward Perkins Mr. Wyn Harries Planning Agriculture / Housing / 0.57 Y SFCA SFCA Category Red is too high to Gorllewin o Dale Farm Perkins Chartered Surveyors Harries Design Managment Amaethyddiaeth Tai be mitigated for residential use. 251 Land at Mill Moor Field / Tir Stepaside Mr. Stephen Agriculture / Housing / 0.46 Y SFCA SFCA Category Red is too high to yn Mill Moor Field John Amaethyddiaeth Tai be mitigated for residential use. 2 https://www.pembrokeshire.gov.uk/local-development-plan-review/ldp2-evidence-base 4 Sites Phased out at Stage 2 Assessment: This phase focused on whether or not sites accorded with the Strategy of the Plan. This included consideration of whether sites were in locations identified in the Settlement Hierarchy as places where the Authority would support larger housing sites. The following sites were phased out at Stage 2 Assessment, because they were adjacent to a local village boundary where allocations (sites of 5+ houses) are not supported by the Preferred Strategy. However, these sites were considered during settlement boundary review for small portions of the site that could accommodate up to 4 dwellings. Below is the outcome of the settlement boundary review3: Reason Site Nearest Proposer Agent Area Screen To Site Name Organisation Agent Name Current Use Proposed Use Expanded Reason Ref Settlement Name Organisation (Ha) Out Screen Out 248 South of Nant Yr Eglyys / Ambleston / Mr. Cloverton Steve Hole Steve Hole Agriculture / Housing / Tai 0.4 Y Red 2 Proposal is adjacent to a Local Village boundary (and larger I'r Dde o Nant Yr Eglyys Treamlod Graham Properties Ltd Architects LLP Amaethyddiaeth than 0.15Ha). Significant development is not being sought in Perfect settlements in this position in the Settlement Hierarchy, and settlement boundary review concluded that no part of the site should be included. 037 Adjacent to The Oaks / Cold Blow Mrs. Jillian Julian Pembroke Design Agriculture / Housing / Tai 0.5 Y Red 2 Proposal is adjacent to a Local Village boundary (and larger Cyfagos at The Oaks Doreen Mansel- Limited Amaethyddiaeth than 0.15Ha). Significant development is not being sought in Griffiths Thomas settlements in this position in the Settlement Hierarchy, and settlement boundary review also concluded that no part of the site should be included. 176 Land at Little Hay / Tir yn East Williamston Janet Mr. James James Dwyer Garden / Gardd Housing / Tai 0.17 Y Red 2 Proposal is adjacent to a Local Village boundary (and larger Little Hay Drogan Dwyer Associates than 0.15Ha).