Critical exponents of nonequilibrium phase transitions in AdS/CFT correspondence Masataka Matsumoto and Shin Nakamura Department of Physics, Chuo University, Tokyo 112-8551, Japan We study critical phenomena of nonequilibrium phase transitions by using the AdS/CFT corre- spondence. Our system consists of charged particles interacting with a heat bath of neutral gauge particles. The system is in current-driven nonequilibrium steady state, and the nonequilibrium phase transition is associated with nonlinear electric conductivity. We define a susceptibility as a response of the system to the current variation. We further define a critical exponent from the power-law divergence of the susceptibility. We find that the critical exponent and the critical amplitude ratio of the susceptibility agree with those of the Landau theory of equilibrium phase transitions, if we identify the current as the external field in the Landau theory. I. INTRODUCTION tween a classical gravity theory and a strongly coupled quantum gauge field theory [3, 4]. This correspondence Nonequilibrium phenomena have wider variety com- provides a computational method for the gauge field the- pared to equilibrium phenomena. The number of param- ory beyond the linear response regime in terms of general 2 eters that control the nonequilibrium systems is larger relativity. than that of the equilibrium systems, in general. In For example, a NESS of strongly interacting gauge the- nonequilibrium steady states (NESSs), the typical addi- ory plasma was studied in Ref. [5]. It was shown in tional parameter that is absent from equilibrium systems Ref. [5] that the system exhibits not only positive dif- is current. For example, a system attached to two heat ferential conductivity (PDC) but also negative differen- baths of different temperatures has a heat current. In this tial conductivity (NDC) in the NESS driven by a con- case, the heat current is the \new" parameter, which is stant current. Furthermore, a first-order and a second- special to nonequilibrium systems. Another example is order nonequilibrium phase transitions associated with an electric current along an electric field in a conductor. the nonlinear conductivity were discovered in the same In this case, the equilibrium state is realized when the system [6].3 In Ref. [6], critical exponents β and δ for current is vanishing. the nonequilibrium phase transition were defined.4 In These new parameters, the heat current and the elec- the Landau theory of equilibrium phase transitions, crit- tric current, measure the rate of entropy production ical exponent δ is defined from the power-law dependence (when the electric field or the temperatures of two heat of the order parameter with respect to an external field baths are kept fixed), hence represent the \distance" from (e.g. a magnetic field in ferromagnets). In this case, the the equilibrium states. A primary question in nonequilib- external field does not drive the system into nonequilib- rium physics is how these parameters control the systems. rium states. On the other hand, the exponent δ in the In particular, investigation of phase transitions under the nonequilibrium phase transition was defined as the expo- presence of current is one important research subject.1 nent of the power behavior of the order parameter in the In this paper, we study nonequilibrium critical phe- variation of the current. Interestingly, the obtained val- nomena driven by an electric current density J. When ues of the β and the δ in the nonequilibrium phase tran- a system exhibits a second order phase transition under sition agreed with those of β and δ in the Landau theory the presence of J, a natural question is how the new pa- of equilibrium phase transitions, respectively, within the rameter J controls the critical phenomena. More specif- numerical error [6]. This result implies that a current ically, the following questions can be addressed. 1) Is it density J, which is a parameter that appears only in the possible to define a susceptibility with respect to J in a nonequilibrium system, plays a fundamental role in char- arXiv:1804.10124v2 [hep-th] 4 Dec 2018 sensible way? 2) If yes, how does it behave near the crit- acterizing the nonequilibrium phase transition. However, ical point? Are there any critical phenomena associated we still lack a complete answer to the questions 1), 2) and with the new parameter J? If it is the case, what are the 3) raised above. critical exponents? 3) Do we have more critical expo- In this paper, we further proceed calculations of critical nents for nonequilibrium phase transitions than what we exponents associated with J in the nonequilibrium phase have for equilibrium systems? Can we construct a theory transition. We define a susceptibility as a response of the for these critical exponents? system to the current variation. We also define a critical In order to reveal these issues, we employ the anti- de Sitter/conformal field theory (AdS/CFT) correspon- dence. The AdS/CFT correspondence is a duality be- 2 A review on application of the AdS/CFT correspondence to nonequilibrium physics is Ref. [2]. 3 A same type of phase transition was also observed later in a 1 A first-order phase transition in the presence of heat current has different setup of holography in Ref. [7]. been studied in [1]. 4 The critical exponent δ in this paper is δ~ in Ref. [6]. 2 exponent γ from the power-law divergence of the suscep- for T < Tc. If there is an external magnetic field in this tibility. We find that the susceptibility shows critical phe- system, the free energy is written as nomena and the value of the critical exponent γ agrees 2 4 with that in the Landau theory of equilibrium phase tran- F (M) = F0 + aM + bM − HM; (4) sitions. The critical amplitude ratio of the susceptibility where H is the external magnetic field. Then, the ther- also agrees with that in the Landau theory. Together mal equilibrium state is determined by the following re- with the results for β and δ, our results state that the lation: critical phenomena in the nonequilibrium phase transi- tion in question have remarkable similarity with those in @F (M) 3 the Landau theory of equilibrium phase transitions, if we = 2aM0 + 4bM0 − H = 0: (5) @M M identify the current as the external field.5 0 The organization of the paper is as follows. In Sec. II, Although the solution of Eq. (5) is complicated, M0 be- we review the Landau theory of equilibrium phase tran- comes simple for T = Tc: sitions. In Sec. III, we explain the setup of our model. 1 We focus on the so-called D3-D7 system. In Sec. IV, we H 3 M = : (6) propose the definitions of the susceptibility and the criti- 0 4b cal exponent γ mentioned above. We compute them and the results will be exhibited. We conclude in Sec. V. The magnetic susceptibility is defined as χ = @M=@H. We obtain this from Eq. (5) as 1 II. LANDAU THEORY AND CRITICAL χ = : (7) EXPONENT 2a + 12bM 2 For T > Tc with M = 0, we have We begin with a brief review of the Landau theory of 1 T equilibrium phase transitions. The new definitions of the χ = = c ≡ χ ; (8) T >Tc susceptibility and the critical exponents in Sec. IV will 2a 2k(T − Tc) be given by using an analogy with the Landau theory. Here we consider a phase transition of ferromagnets. whereas In the Landau theory, we assume the free energy is given 1 T χ = = c ≡ χ ; (9) as an even function of the magnetization because of the T <Tc 2a + 12b(−a=2b) 4k(Tc − T ) symmetry under the spin flip. Since we are interested in the critical point, we assume the magnetization is suffi- for T < Tc. From Eqs. (8) and (9), the ratio of the ciently small. Then we can expand the free energy as a coefficients of jT −Tcj, which is called as critical amplitude ratio, becomes two: χ /χ = 2. Note that this power series in the magnetization and ignore the higher T >Tc T <Tc order terms: value is independent of k and Tc we have introduced. Let us derive the specific heat from the free energy. 2 4 2 2 F (M) = F0 + aM + bM ; (1) The specific heat is defined by Cv = −T@ F (M0)=@T . For T < Tc and H = 0, where M is the magnetization as an order parameter. F0 and b are constants, whereas a = k(T − T )=T with a k2(T − T )2 c c F (M ) = F + aM 2 + bM 4 = F − c : (10) constant k. T is the critical temperature of the second- 0 0 0 0 0 2 c 4bTc order phase transition. Since a thermal equilibrium state is realized as a min- Thus we find that the specific heat is constant. imum of the free energy, we consider The divergent behaviors of various quantities at the critical point are characterized by the critical exponents. @F (M) 3 The definitions of the critical exponents in ferromagnets = 2aM0 + 4bM = 0; (2) @M 0 are given by M0 β M0 / jT − Tcj (T < Tc); (11) to obtain the thermal equilibrium magnetization M0: M / jHj1/δ (T = T ); (12) s 0 c r −γ a k(Tc − T ) χ / jT − T j (T < T ); (13) M = − = ; (3) c c 0 0 2b 2bTc −γ χ / jT − Tcj (T > Tc); (14) −α Cv / jT − Tcj (T < Tc): (15) In the Landau theory, the critical exponents are deter- 5 In the present paper, we employ the same notations α, β, δ and γ mined by Eqs. (3), (6), (8), (9), and (10) as: for the critical exponents of our nonequilibrium phase transition as those of the Landau theory given in Sec.