Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies Volume 4 Issue 2 Special section: Old Colony Mennonites Article 4 2016 The Dynamics of Boundaries: Obedience and Transgression among Bolivian Old Colony Mennonites Anna Sofia Hedberg Follow this and additional works at: https://ideaexchange.uakron.edu/amishstudies Part of the Anthropology Commons Please take a moment to share how this work helps you through this survey. Your feedback will be important as we plan further development of our repository. Recommended Citation Hedberg, Anna Sofia. 2016. "The Dynamics of Boundaries: Obedience and rT ansgression among Bolivian Mennonites." Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies 4(2):149-67. This Original Research Article is brought to you for free and open access by IdeaExchange@UAkron, the institutional repository of The University of Akron in Akron, Ohio, USA. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies by an authorized administrator of IdeaExchange@UAkron. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. The Dynamics of Boundaries: Obedience and Transgression among Bolivian Old Colony Mennonites Anna Sofia Hedberg1 Faculty Office for Humanities and Social Sciences Uppsala University Uppsala, Sweden Abstract Boundaries keep people apart just as they keep people together. Boundaries are social constructs made by man in order to maintain the natural order of things. The aim of this article is to elaborate on the social construct of boundaries and particularly acknowledge their dynamic character. Social and cultural boundaries are passable, changeable, and negotiable. Nonetheless, boundaries are fundamental to many peoples’ existence and survival as ethnic and cultural communities and must therefore be acknowledged as essential human needs. By focusing on the members of a conservative Christian community—Old Colony Mennonites in Bolivia—as they carry out practices in relation to the outside world, the article illustrates processes that help sustain the group’s boundaries towards the outside as well as processes that simultaneously challenge and to some extent transform these same boundaries. Keywords Boundaries; Obedience; Disobedience; Old Colony Mennonites; Bolivia; Ordnung Hedberg, Anna Sofia. 2016. “The Dynamics of Boundaries: Obedience and Transgression among Bolivian Old Colony Mennonites.” Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies 4(2):149-67. 150 Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies 4(2) Introduction Boundaries: physical or mental; visual or imagined; social, political, or religious. At first sight, they tend to seem so rigid, so permanent. Boundaries keep people apart just as they keep people together. Not only people but also phenomena, things, and ideologies are enclosed by boundaries. The raison d’être of boundaries is to maintain categories, to hinder the mixing of, for instance, ideas, things, and people that should be kept separate. Focusing on these separating and cohesive conceptual lines, the aim of this article is to elaborate on the social construct of boundaries and not least to acknowledge their dynamic character. By applying an anthropological perspective on daily practice among Old Colony Mennonites in Bolivia, this article lays bare processes that help sustain a group’s boundaries towards the outside.2 Mennonites have spread around the world in numerous waves of migration. The conservative farming Old Colony Mennonites reside in separate colonies in rural areas in Central and South America. Thus, in market places in Central and South American towns and cities, as well as on buses in the Bolivian, Paraguayan, and Mexican countryside, one may encounter representatives of this uniformly clad people—apparently of European origin—that stand out from the rest. The men’s bib-and-brace overalls and Panama hats and the long flowery dresses of the women reveal they are Old Colony Mennonites, and the fact that they avoid eye contact and speak a Low German dialect unfamiliar to most signals distance. Similar to many other Christian groups, the Old Colonists regard themselves as a people chosen by God. As such, they believe they should not mix with the outside “world” during their life-long striving for salvation. Just like other minorities that display explicit conservative and isolative tendencies (e.g., the Haredi, the Amish, and the Hutterites), the Old Colony Mennonites make great effort to maintain their own way of life, distinct from that of the surrounding society and the modern world. Such endeavors require boundaries. Representing an anthropological approach, this article departs from the assumption that boundaries are social constructs made by man—more or less consciously—in order to maintain and protect the “natural” order of things, as we envision it. Shortly stated, boundaries are social constructs in the sense that they are products of people’s construction of a perceived social reality (Berger and Luckman 1967; Hacking 2005). As most other social constructs, however, boundaries are seldom static. The people separated by the boundaries change, the circumstances surrounding the boundaries change, as well as the reasons for upholding the boundaries may change, increase, or even disappear. As a result, the boundaries also change. Boundaries are possible to trespass, alter, or negotiate. Depending on who you are, your possibilities for passing boundaries vary. Depending on your position, your influence over the boundary construct also varies. Depending on your cultural and social aptitude, your ability to negotiate boundaries may decrease or increase. Hedberg: Boundaries among Bolivian Mennonites 151 If not being the first to do so, anthropologist Mary Douglas (1966) has at least contributed a great deal to anthropologists’ and other social scientists’ notion of boundaries as social constructs. Making the universal human need for categorizing, orderliness, and distinction very clear to us, her theories are still of great value, and in our contemporary world, issues concerning social and cultural boundaries are as relevant as ever. Globalization is often held to have influenced human beings’ needs for boundaries in emphasizing distinction and/or similarity (Inda and Rosaldo 2007). Some hold that globalization erases boundaries as global flows of people, cultural influences, capital, services, and items have diminished the relevance of borders for many people in the world (Bauman 1998, 77). Others claim that processes of globalization rather tend to increase peoples’ need of making distinct boundaries between themselves and “others” (Billig 1995, 44; Yuval-Davis 2006, 202). Often enough, the smaller the difference between different groups, the greater is their urge to communicate distinctiveness (Barth 1969; Eriksen 2002). The main argument of this article is that it is crucial to recognize and study social and cultural boundaries as passable, changeable, transitory, and negotiable, yet simultaneously acknowledge the fact that boundaries are fundamental to many peoples’ existence and survival as ethnic and cultural groups. This I will demonstrate by drawing on examples from a people whose mere existence is dependent on clearly communicated and manifest boundaries, but who are also challenging these boundaries from within, keeping them under constant strain. Old Colony Mennonites in Bolivia This article draws primarily on 13 months of fieldwork between 2004 and 2006 in the Mennonite Old Colony Durango, which is located in the Bolivian Gran Chaco region (Figure 1). The Gran Chaco region is a frontier zone that stretches into Argentina, Paraguay, and Bolivia. Throughout the colonial period up until 1950, the entire Gran Chaco remained relatively isolated. Since then, the Bolivian government has been actively developing the region as a center of agricultural production, a process that has brought with it some increase in infrastructure and mobility. The Colony Durango and its three neighboring Old Colonies are located between the town of Charagua in the west and the geographical zone referred to as Izozog in the east. Besides the Mennonites, various groups of Guaraní as well as white Creole landowners and cattle breeders inhabit the area. The colony Durango covers about 12, 000 hectares and hosts approximately 3, 000 inhabitants. The residents arrived in 1995/96 from their former colony Colonia Nueva Durango, Curuguaty district, Paraguay. Due to internal disagreements concerning modernization processes and adjustments to the surrounding society, the colony in Paraguay split and those members who resisted change set off for Bolivia where the new colony was set up. There are more than 40,000 Low German speaking Mennonites in Bolivia living in approximately 40 different colonies, mainly concentrated around Santa Cruz de la Sierra. A few are also found near the towns of Charagua (like Durango) and Villa Montes farther south. The Mennonite colonies in Bolivia belong to separate denominations, differing in degree of 152 Journal of Amish and Plain Anabaptist Studies 4(2) conservatism, integration of modern equipment, and interaction with the neighboring society. Well over 50% are of Old Colony background. As such, they are generally more conservative and more hesitant towards external influence, unlike more progressive Mennonite communities that use electricity, cars, and telephones and have less strict clothing regulations. The colonies also differ in terms of size, place of origin, time of arrival, etc. Moreover, there are also Mennonites