1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE DATED THIS THE 4 TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2013 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE B.S.PATIL R.S.A.No.3/2012 c/w R.S.A.No.80/2012, R.S.A.No.2465/2011 IN R.S.A.3/2012 BETWEEN 1. SMT NAGAMMA AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS W/O LATE SHEENA SHETTY 2. SMT JAYANTHI AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS W/O JAYARAMA SHETTY BOTH R/AT SHIVA SHAKTI NIVAS, RAMDAS NAGAR POS T,KASARAGOD TALUK &DIST KERALA STATE 3. MISS VIJAYA AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS D/O LATE SHEENA SHETTY 4. SRI SHIVANANDA AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS S/O LATE SHEENA SHETTY 5. SMT NALINI AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS W/O PRAKASH SHETTY 3 TO 5 R/AT SAVITHRI COMPOUND, PINTO LANE, NEAR SATHYANARAYANA BHAJANA MANDIRA BOLAR, MANGALORE 2 6. SMT KALYANI SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS W/O SANJEEVA SHETTY R/AT KALYANI SHEDTHI COMPOUND BOKKAPATNA BOLOOR, MANGALORE-6 7. SMT SHOBHA SHETTY AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS W/O LATE KESHAVA SHETTY C/O SMT NAGAMMA KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND NEAR POLRAI KATTE,P O BEJAI MANGALORE-4 8. MASTER DEEPAK SHETTY AGED ABOUT 11 YEARS S/O LATE KESHAVA SHETTY C/O SMT NAGAMMA,KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND NEAR POLRAI KATTE,P O BEJAI MANGALORE-4,SINCE MINOR REP BY HIS MOTHE AND NEXT FRIEND NAMELY APPELLANT NO 7 9. YASHAVANTHA SHETTY AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS S/O LATE SHANKARA SHETTY R/AT KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND BEJAI,ANEGUDI MANGALORE 10. SMT SUMATHI SHETTY AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS W/O NAGARAJA SHETTY R/AT KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND POLARAI KATTE,P ON BEJAI MANGALORE. ... APPELLANTS (By Sri. NAGARAJA HEGDE, ADV.) AND 1. SMT SHAMBAVATHI AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS W/O VISHWANATHA RAI R/AT ENOLI,PAVOOR POST &VILLAGE MANGALORE 3 2. SMT SOMAKKE SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS W/O SHANTHA SHETTY R/AT IV BLOCK ,SITE NO 180,POST KATIPALL A,MANGALORE 3. SMT SEETHA SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS W/O AITHAPPA SHETTY R/AT ALIYAR HOUSE,AMBALAMOGARU VILLAGE MANGALORE TALUK 4. SMT APPI S PERGADE AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS W/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE R/AT KOPPARA THOTA HOUSE PUMPWELL, KANKANADY B VILLAGE KANKANADY, MANGALORE-02 5. MR TARANATH PERGADE AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS S/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE R/AT KOPPARA THOTA HOUSE PUMPWELL, KANKANADY B VILLAGE KANKANADY, MANGALORE-02 6. KRISHNA @ SATHISH PERGADE AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS S/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE 7. MR PADMA PERGADE AGED ABOUT 29 YEARS S/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE 4 TO 7 R/AT KOPPARA THOTA HOUSE PUMPWELL, KANKANADY B VILLAGE KANKANADY, MANGALORE-02 8. SRI VASANTHA ALVA AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHI R/AT THARIGUDDE,NEERMARGA MANGALORE 9. SMT GULABI SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS 4 W/O BHOJA SHEDTHI R/AT NEAR KRISHNAPUR MUTT,SURATHKAL MANGALORE 10. SHREE SEETHARAMA ALVA AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHI R/AT YEKKUR MANGALORE-10 11. SRI RAVINDRA ALVA AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHI R/AT MAJAPE KESANAMOGARU PODDU POST,BANTWAL TALUK,D.K 12. SRI NARASIMHA ALVA AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHI R/AT BELMA BARIKE HOUSE BELMA VILLAGE DERALAKATTE POST MANGALORE ,D.K. 13. SMT SAMPAVATHI ALVA AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS W/O SANKAPPA SHETTY R/AT PLOT NO54,WADUJKAR ESTATE BEGWAN ROAD,BARAMATHI -412102 POONA 14. SRI HEMANTHA ALVA AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHI R/AT HOTEL VINAYAKA MARGAW BUS STAND,BARAMATHI ,POONA 15. SMT SUNANDA SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS W/O JAYA SHETTY R/AT GURUPRASAD,NEAR YUVAKA MANDALA KRISHNAPURA, SURATHKAL MANGALORE TALUK 16. MR MOHAMMED KUNHI AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS KAPILA OIL,PUMPWELL 5 KANKANADY POST MANGALORE-02 17. MR U ABDULLA AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS PUMPWELL KANKANADY POST MANGALORE-02 18. SMT LEELA AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS W/O NBUJANGA SHETTY R/AT ENOLI,PAVOOR POST MANGALORE. ... RESPONDENTS IN R.S.A.80/2012: BETWEEN 1. SRI VASANTHA ALVA AGED ABUOT 69 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHI R/AT THARIGUDDE NEERMARGA MANGALORE 2. SMT GULABI SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS W/O BHOJA SHETTY RESIDING NEAR KRISHNAPUR MUTT, SURATHKAL, MANGALORE TALUK 3. SRI RAVINDRA ALVA AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHY R/AT MAJAPE KESANAMOGARU PUDU POST, BANTWAL TALUK, D K 4. SRI NARASIMHA ALVA AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHY R/AT BELMA BARIKE HOUSE BELMA VILLAGE, DERALAKATTE POST MANGALORE TALUK & DIST 6 5. SMT SUNAND SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS W/O JAYA SHETTY R/AT GURUPARSAD, NEAR YUVAKA MANDALA KRISHNAPURA, SURATHKAL MANGALORE TALUK & DIST. ... APPELLANTS (By Sri. K ANANDARAMA, ADV.) AND 1. SMT APPI S.PERGADE AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS W/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE 2. MR.TARANATH PERGADE AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS S/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE 3. KRISHNA @ SATHISH PERGADE AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS S/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE 4. MR PADMA PERGADE AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS S/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE 1 TO 4 R/AT KOPPARA THOTA HOUSE, PUMPWELL KANKANADI B VILLAGE, KANKANADY, MANGALORE- 575002 5. SMT NAGAMMA SHEDTHI ( DEAD) AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS W/O KRISHNA SHETTY 6. SMT KALYANI SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS W/O SANJEEVA SHETTY R/AT KALYANI SHEDTHI COMPOUND, BOKKAPATNA , BOLOOR, MANGALORE- 575006 7. SMT NAGAMMA AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS W/O LATE SHEENA SHETTY 7 8. SMT JAYANTHI AGED ABUOT 41 YEARS W/O JAYARAMA SHETTY R/AT SHIVA SHAKTI NIVAS, RAMDAS NAGAR POST, KASARGOD TALUK & DIST KERALA STATE 9. MISS VIJAYA AGED ABUOT 26 YEARS D/O LATE SHEENA SHETTY 10. SRI SHIVANANDA AGED ABUOT 24 YEARS S/O LATE SHEEN SHETTY 11. SMT NALINI AGED ABUOT 22 YEARS W/O PRAKASH SHETTY 9 TO 11 R/T SAVITHRI COMPOUND PINTO LANE, NEAR SATHYANARAYANA BHAJANA MANDIR , BOLAR, MANGALORE 12. SMT SHOBHA SHETTY AGED ABUOT 33 YEARS W/O LATE KESHAVA SHETTY C/O SMT NAGAMMA KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND, NEAR POLRAI KATTE, P O BEJAI, MANGALORE-575004 13. MASTER DEEPAK SHETTY S/O LATE KESHAVA SHETTY REP BY HIS MOTHER & NEXT FRIEND NAMELY RESPONDENT NO.12( A), R/AT KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND, POLRAI KATTE, P O BEJAI, MANGALORE-575004 14. YASHAVANTHA SHETTY AGED ABUOT 38 YEARS S/O LATE SHANKARA SHETTY R/AT KAMALA SHETTTY COMPOUND BEJAI ANEGUNDI MANGALORE 8 15. SMT SUMATHI SHETTY AGED ABUOT 51 YEARS W/O NAGARAJA SHETTY R/AT KAMALA SHETTTY COMPOUND POLRAI KATTE, P O BEJAI MANGALORE- 575004 16. SHREE SEETHARAMA ALVA AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHI R/AT YEKKUR MANGALORE 17. SMT SAMPAVATHI ALVA AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS W/O SANKAPPA SHETTY R/AT PLOT NO. 54, WADUJKAR ESTATE, BEGWAN ROAD, BARAMATHI- 413102, PUNE. 18. SRI HEMANTHA ALVA AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS S/O LATE VEERAMMA SHEDTHI HOTEL VINAYAKA MARGAW BUS STAND, BARAMATHI, PUNE 19. MR MOHAMMED KUNHI AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS KAPILA OIL PUMPWELL, KANKANADY POST MANGALORE-575002 20. MR U ABDULLA AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS KAPILA OIL PUMPWELL, KANKANADY POST MANGALORE-575002 21. SMT LEELA AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS W/O BUJANGA SHETTY R/AT ENOLI, PAVOOR POST MANGALORE 9 22. SMT SHAMBAVATHI AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS W/O VISHWANATHA RAI R/AT ENOLI, PAVOOR POST AND VILLAGE, MANGALORE 23. SMT SOMAKKE SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS W/O SHANTHA SHETTY R/AT IV BLOCK, SITE NO. 180, POST KATIPALLA, MANGALORE 24. SMT SEETHA SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS W/O AITHAPPA SHETTY R/AT ALIYAR HOUSE AMBALAMOGARU VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK. ... RESPONDENTS IN R.S.A.2465/2011: BETWEEN 1. SMT SHAMBHAVATHI AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS W/O VISHWANATH RAI R/AT ENOLI, PAVOOR POST MANGALORE 2. SMT SOMAKKAE SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS W/O SHANTHA SHETTY IV BLOCK, SITE NO. 180, KATIPALLA, MANGALORE , D.K 3. SMT SEETHA SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS W/O AITHAPPA SHETTY R/O ALIYAR HOUSE, AMBALAMOGSU VILLAGE, & POST, MANGALORE TALUK. ... APPELLANTS (By Sri.SANATH KUMAR SHETTY K., ADV.) 10 AND 1. SMT APPI S PERGADE AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS W/O LATE SHANTHARAM PERGADE 2. THARANATH PERGADE AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS 3. KRISHNA @ LATHISH PERGADE AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS 4. PADMA PERGADE AGED ABOUT 29 YEARS 2 TO 4 ARE S/O DECEASED SHANTHARAMA PERGADE R/AT KOPPARA THOTA VILLAGE, KANKANADY "B" VILLAGE, KANKANADY, MANGALORE- 575002 5. SMT KALYANI SHEDTHI AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS W/O SANJEEVA SHETTY KALYANISHEDTHI COMPOUND BOKKAPATNA BOLOOR, MANGALORE- 575006 6. SMT NAGAMMA AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS W/O LATE SHEENA SHETTY KAMALASHETTY NEAR POLLARI KATTE, BEJAI, MANGALORE- 575004 7. SMT JAYANTHI AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS W/O JAYARAM SHETTY R/O SHAKTHI NIVAS RAMADAS NAGAR, KASARATGODU DISTRICT KERELA – 671121 8. VIJAYA AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS D/O LATE SHEENA SHETTY R/O SHAKTHI NIVAS 11 R/O KAMALASHETTY COMPOUND, NEAR POLLARI KATTE, BEJAI, MANGALORE- 575004 9. SHIVANANDA AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS S/O LATE SHEENA SHETTY R/O KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND NEAR POLLARI KATTE, BEJAI, MANGALORE- 575004 10. SMT NALINI AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS W/O PRAKASH SHETTY SAVITHRI COMPOUND, PINTO LANE, NEAR SATYANARAYANA BHAJANA MANDIR, BOLOOR, MANGALORE- 575005 11. SMT SHOBHA SHETTY AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS W/O LATE KESHAVA SHETTY R/O KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND POLLARI KATTE, P.O. BEJAI, MANGALORE-575004 12. MASTER DEEPAK SHETTY S/O LATE KESHAVA SHETTY MINOR, REP BY HIS MOTHER AND NATURAL SMT. SHOBHA SHETTY, RESPONDENT NO.12, R/AT KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND, POLLARI KATTE, P.O. BEJAI, MANGALORE- 575004 13. YASHAVANTH SHETTY AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS S/O LATE SHANKARA SHETTY R/O KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND BEJAI, ANEGUNDI MANGALORE- 575004 14. SMT SUMATHI SHETTY AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS W/O NAGARAJA SHETTY R/O KAMALA SHETTY COMPOUND BEJAI, ANEGUNDI MANGALORE- 575004 12 15.