LISTING OF CITATIONS - ABERDEENSHIRE VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE Hearing on 10th November 2021 at 10.00 am in Council Chamber, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 1 91032/79796 SHOOTING RIGHTS FIM TIMBERLAND LP P 750 750 SOUTH GLENBUCHAT GLENBUCHAT STRATHDON SAVILLS A 2 92655/80026 SHOOTING RIGHTS M BRUCE & PARTNERS P 180 180 PART WRANGHAM INSCH SAVILLS A 3 96304/82715 WAREHOUSE VULCAN COMPLETION PRODUCTS UK T 25,000 25,000 UNIT 6A KINGSHILL COMMERCIAL PARK EAST VENTURE DRIVE F G BURNETT LTD A ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK 4 96271/81909 STABLES HIGHLANDS UNBRIDLED LTD T 4,900 4,900 MURLEY STEADING BALLOGIE ABOYNE 5 96192/82714 WAREHOUSE AMAZON UK SERVICES LTD T 665,000 665,000 SITE 1 CAIRNROBIN INDUSTRIAL PARK CAIRNROBIN WAY GL HEARN LIMITED A PORTLETHEN 6 96603/82713 SAWMILL WS & DJ DUNNETT P 11,000 11,000 NETHER THAINSTON FASQUE FETTERCAIRN J & E SHEPHERD A 7 96746/82712 SAWMILL FASQUE TIMBER PRODUCTS LTD T 35,750 35,750 FORDOUN AERODROME FORDOUN LAURENCEKIRK J & E SHEPHERD A 29/06/2021 Page 1 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 19/09/2018 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 100 33933/63604 FACTORY SCOTBEEF INVERURIE LTD T 88,000 88,000 BLACKHALL INDUSTRIAL ESTATE BURGHMUIR CIRCLE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A 349 21180/58182 WAREHOUSE ETC VION FOOD SCOTLAND LTD - P 88,500 88,500 PORTLETHEN INDUSTRIAL ESTATE MCINTOSH DONALD BARCLAYHILL PLACE PORTLETHEN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A 29/06/2021 Page 2 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 21/11/2018 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 495 33995/57389 WORKSHOP ETC LEITHS (SCOTLAND) LTD P 64,500 64,500 LOCHTON DURRIS BANCHORY RYDEN LLP A 29/06/2021 Page 3 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 26/06/2019 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 30 36864/53195 MEDICAL CENTRE DR GRAHAM S GORDON P 11,750 11,750 RHYNIE MEDICAL PRACTICE MANSE ROAD RHYNIE WYMRE A 32 16504/53235 CLINIC NHS GRAMPIAN P 6,500 6,500 ALFORD CLINIC GORDON ROAD ALFORD WYMRE A 34 16505/53310 SURGERY DR SHANKS P 38,750 38,750 ALFORD MEDICAL PRACTICE GORDON ROAD ALFORD WYMRE A 40 33890/53265 MEDICAL CENTRE DR POUL IPSEN T 5,600 5,600 WATERSIDE STRATHDON WYMRE A 48 17018/53236 CLINIC NHS GRAMPIAN P 5,600 5,600 KEMNAY CLINIC 56 FYFE PARK KEMNAY WYMRE A 49 17027/54964 SURGERY DRS PAUL GREEN SUSAN LEE P 13,500 13,500 10 HIGH STREET KAREN LEFEVRE ALASTAIR GLENNIE KEMNAY LAURA WADE & ANDREW RIGBY WYMRE A 60 17444/53268 SURGERY SCOTSTOWN MEDICAL GROUP P 5,300 5,300 WOODSIDE TERRACE UDNY STATION WYMRE A 191 33715/53230 MEDICAL CENTRE INVERURIE MEDICAL GROUP P 21,000 21,000 KINTORE MEDICAL CENTRE WELLPARK GARDENS KINTORE WYMRE A 238 19295/53210 HEALTH CENTRE NHS GRAMPIAN P 82,000 82,000 ELLON HEALTH CENTRE SCHOOLHILL ROAD ELLON WYMRE A 272 19912/53267 CLINIC NHS GRAMPIAN P 7,500 7,500 BRAEMAR CLINIC ST ANDREWS TERRACE BRAEMAR WYMRE A 418 20092/53216 CLINIC NHS GRAMPIAN P 31,500 31,500 BALLATER CLINIC 13 PROVOST CRAIG ROAD BALLATER WYMRE A 424 20238/53229 HEALTH CENTRE NHS GRAMPIAN P 16,000 16,000 TORPHINS HEALTH & RESOURCE CENTRE ST MARNAN ROAD TORPHINS WYMRE A 443 31916/53266 SURGERY ABOYNE MEDICAL PRACTICE T 10,500 10,500 THE SURGERY MARKET STANCE THE GREEN WYMRE A TARLAND 29/06/2021 Page 4 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 26/06/2019 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 449 20658/53213 SURGERY DR D G BARCLAY & PARTNERS P 69,500 69,500 BELLFIELD DEE STREET BANCHORY WYMRE A 450 35785/53214 CLINIC NHS GRAMPIAN P 45,250 45,250 BANCHORY CLINIC BELLFIELD DEE STREET WYMRE A BANCHORY 549 21715/53225 HEALTH CENTRE INVERBERVIE MEDICAL PRACTICE P 25,500 25,500 CHURCH STREET INVERBERVIE WYMRE A 571 34466/53233 SURGERY KEITH PIRIE P 8,400 8,400 MACKENZIE AVENUE AUCHENBLAE WYMRE A 583 36655/53222 OFFICE NHS GRAMPIAN P 12,250 12,250 ARDUTHIE LODGE KINCARDINE COMMUNITY HOSPITAL KIRKTON ROAD WYMRE A STONEHAVEN 586 22559/53209 MEDICAL CENTRE STONEHAVEN MEDICAL GROUP P 111,000 111,000 ROBERT STREET STONEHAVEN WYMRE A 29/06/2021 Page 5 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 30/10/2019 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 230 87045/67664 OFFICE KNIGHT PROPERTY GROUP PLC P 5,400 5,400 1F 3 KINGSPOINT HOUSE KINGSHILL PARK VENTURE DRIVE CBRE LTD A ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK 29/06/2021 Page 6 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 08/04/2020 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 114 18576/55847 HOTEL MELDRUM HOUSE ESTATES P 325,000 325,000 MELDRUM HOUSE T/A MELDRUM HOUSE HOTEL LTD OLDMELDRUM INVERURIE GERALD EVE LLP A 213 20757/53975 HOTEL TOR-NA-COILLE HOTEL LTD T 77,500 A 77,500 TOR NA COILLE HOTEL 2,500 R 2,500 INCHMARLO ROAD 75,000 N 75,000 BANCHORY 29/06/2021 Page 7 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 07/10/2020 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 1 15701/53218 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 158,000 158,000 JUBILEE HOSPITAL BLEACHFIELD STREET HUNTLY WYMRE A 50 17410/56832 RESEARCH CENTRE THE COURT OF THE UNIVERSITY P 164,000 164,000 OCEANLAB OF ABERDEEN MAIN STREET PER FACTOR NEWBURGH GERALD EVE LLP A 68 53954/53207 HEALTH CENTRE SKENE MEDICAL GROUP & OTHERS T 379,000 379,000 SKENE HEALTHCARE CENTRE DISCOVERY DRIVE ARNHALL BUSINESS PARK WYMRE A 75 17883/53211 HEALTH CENTRE NHS GRAMPIAN P 68,500 68,500 INVERURIE HEALTH CENTRE CONSTITUTION STREET INVERURIE WYMRE A 89 18208/53219 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 118,000 118,000 INVERURIE HOSPITAL UPPERBOAT ROAD INVERURIE WYMRE A 90 18208/69032 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 96,500 96,500 INVERURIE HOSPITAL UPPERBOAT ROAD INVERURIE WYMRE A 91 18208/69033 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 383,000 383,000 INVERURIE HOSPITAL UPPERBOAT ROAD INVERURIE WYMRE A 92 31516/53241 GARAGE LAWRENCE OF KEMNAY LTD O 110,000 110,000 ELPHINSTONE ROAD PORT ELPHINSTONE WYMRE A 107 60103/54965 HEALTH CENTRE FYVIE OLMELDRUM MEDICAL GROUP O 95,500 95,500 OLDMELDRUM MEDICAL CENTRE AND OTHERS ACADEMY WAY OLDMELDRUM WYMRE A 112 18861/53224 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 38,250 38,250 INSCH & DISTRICT WAR MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 11 RANNES STREET INSCH WYMRE A 143 52755/53215 MEDICAL CENTRE HADDO MEDICAL GROUP T 78,500 78,500 PITMEDDEN ELLON WYMRE A 191 20847/53220 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 110,000 110,000 GLEN O DEE HOSPITAL CORSEE ROAD BANCHORY WYMRE A 214 83406/52365 OFFICE ETC HYDRASUN LTD T 1,060,000 1,060,000 GATEWAY BUSINESS PARK MOSS ROAD NIGG RYDEN LLP A 29/06/2021 Page 8 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 07/10/2020 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 255 81888/53212 HEALTH CENTRE NHS GRAMPIAN P 121,000 121,000 LAURENCEKIRK HEALTHCARE CENTRE BLACKIEMUIR AVENUE LAURENCEKIRK WYMRE A 267 80816/68747 SHOP ETC THE FIRM OF MURRAY T MITCHELL P 25,500 25,500 CASTLETON FARM SHOP FORDOUN LAURENCEKIRK GRAHAM & SIBBALD A 270 84610/70280 SHOP ETC MR & MRS SWIRE P 16,000 16,000 THE COACHHOUSE BALMAKEWAN LAURENCEKIRK 288 37086/53221 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 97,500 97,500 KINCARDINE COMMUNITY HOSPITAL KIRKTON ROAD WYMRE A STONEHAVEN 289 37086/69918 HOSPITAL NHS GRAMPIAN P 118,000 118,000 KINCARDINE COMMUNITY HOSPITAL KIRKTON ROAD WYMRE A STONEHAVEN 29/06/2021 Page 9 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 04/11/2020 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 194 89660/57413 DISTILLERY BENRIACH DISTILLERY CO LTD P 67,000 67,000 BONDED WAREHOUSE GLENDRONACH FORGUE MONTAGU EVANS A HUNTLY 195 16202/57412 DISTILLERY BENRIACH DISTILLERY CO LTD P 180,000 180,000 GLENDRONACH FORGUE HUNTLY MONTAGU EVANS A 204 16890/53387 QUARRY BREEDON TRADING LTD P 5,700 M 2,850 CORRENNIE TILLYFOURIE INVERURIE GERALD EVE LLP A 217 49266/69008 GOLF COURSE TRUMP INTERNATIONAL P 235,000 235,000 MENIE GOLF LINKS SCOTLAND BALMEDIE RYDEN LLP A 221 17470/58015 SANDPIT JOSS (ABERDEEN) LTD P 74,500 74,500 LOCHHILLS 46,250 M 23,125 DYCE ABERDEEN RYDEN LLP A 298 65723/52469 BATCHING PLANT BREEDON TRADING LTD P 34,000 34,000 HARLAW WAY INVERURIE GERALD EVE LLP A 312 18626/56704 DISTILLERY MORRISON BOWMORE DISTILLERS LTD P 70,500 70,500 GLENGARIOCH DISTILLERY ROAD OLDMELDRUM MONTAGU EVANS A 313 89651/56705 DISTILLERY MORRISON BOWMORE DISTILLERS LTD P 17,000 17,000 VISITOR CENTRE GLENGARIOCH DISTILLERY ROAD MONTAGU EVANS A OLDMELDRUM 314 18925/56703 DISTILLERY BEAM SUNTORY UK LTD P 297,000 297,000 ARDMORE KENNETHMONT HUNTLY MONTAGU EVANS A 315 89659/56706 DISTILLERY BEAM SUNTORY UK LTD P 15,500 15,500 BONDED WAREHOUSE ARDMORE KENNETHMONT MONTAGU EVANS A HUNTLY 327 19755/54781 DISTILLERY DIAGEO PLC T 101,000 101,000 LOCHNAGAR CRATHIE BALLATER AVISON YOUNG A 343 20254/60608 QUARRY THE ABERDEENSHIRE COUNCIL T 48,750 48,750 CRAIGLASH PER HEAD OF PROPERTY SERVICES 24,500 M 12,250 KINCARDINE O'NEIL ABOYNE RYDEN LLP A 358 38461/53208 MEDICAL CENTRE PORTLETHEN GROUP PRACTICE P 140,000 140,000 PORTLETHEN MEDICAL CENTRE OLD PORTLETHEN ROAD PORTLETHEN WYMRE A 29/06/2021 Page 10 of 12 CASES CONTINUED FROM 04/11/2020 HEARING Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV 359 38461/54955 MEDICAL CENTRE PORTLETHEN GROUP PRACTICE P 161,000 161,000 PORTLETHEN MEDICAL CENTRE OLD PORTLETHEN ROAD PORTLETHEN WYMRE A 361 21179/58184 SLAUGHTERHOUSE VION FOOD SCOTLAND LTD - P 285,000 285,000 EAST COOKSTON MCINTOSH DONALD PORTLETHEN ABERDEEN KNIGHT FRANK LLP A 375 82188/63103 ATM SITE TESCO STORES LTD P 8,125 8,125 TESCO NEWTONHILL