North Lanarkshire Council DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT Planning Applications for consideration of Planning and Environment Committee Committee Date : 12fhJuly 2005 Ordnance Survey maps reproduced from Ordnance Survey with permission of HMSO Crown Copyright reserved 20 APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 12 JULY 2005 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmentlLocus Recommendation 25 N/05/00546/FUL Mr & Mrs Bunce Extension to a Dwellinghouse - Grant 56 Ballayne Drive Moodiesburn 28 N/05/00655/FUL Muirhead Auto Parts Use of an Industrial Unit as a Grant Ltd Vehicular Dismantling Centre - Unit 2, Woodhead Road, Muirhead 33 N/05/00759/FUL Mr Koon Yung Chan Use of Building as Hot Food Refuse Take-Away - 58 Lochinvar Road, Greenfaulds, Cumbernauld 38 N/05/00793/FUL 02 (UK) Ltd Installation of a 17.5m High Grant Streetworks Style Telecommunication Mast and Ancillary Development - Land to the North of Baldorran Crescent, Eastfield Road, Cumbernau Id 44 N/05/00933/AMD Tarras Park Properties Amendment to Planning Grant Ltd Permission N/05/00359/FUL to Allow Class 1 (Retail) and Class 2 (Financial & Professional) Uses - Site Adjacent to Unit 6, West Burnside Street, Kilsyth 49 N/05/00979/FUL David Bill Change of Use from a Shop to an Grant Estate Agents (Class 2) - 145 Cumbernauld Road, Stepps 52 N/05/01014/FUL T-Mobile (UK) Ltd Erection of a 15 Metre High Grant Telecommunications Monopole and Associated Apparatus - Site to the North East of Old Inns Roundabout 74 Napier Road, Cumbernauld 57 C/04/01492/FUL Heritage Park Design Alteration to Road Layout Grant and Build (Amendment to Planning Permission 03/00637/FUL) - 85 Greengairs Road, Greengairs 65 C/05/004 15/FU L National Grid Transco Installation of New Demethaniser Grant LNG Storage Facility Tower and Coldbox (As Part of New Replacement Liquefacation Process Plant) - British Gas Plc, Mollinsburn Road, Glenmavis 69 George Wimpey West Erection of 45 dwellinghouses Grant Scotland Ltd and Incorporation of Open Space and Play Area - George Wimpey, Phase 6, Lancaster Avenue, Chapelhall 21 APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 12 JULY 2005 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmentlLocus Recommendation 76 C/05/00598/FUL Endowment Erection of Rear Extension to Grant Compensation Centre Office - Academy House, 31 Church Street, Coatbridge 81 C/05/00649/FUL John Brogan Two-Storey Side and Single- Grant Storey Rear Extension to Dwellinghouse - 26 Hawick Drive, Coatbridge 86 C/05/00673/0UT Mr & Mrs McAllister Erection of Dwellinghouse in Refuse (P) connection with existing caravan storage area - Whinrigg Farm, Stirling Road, Airdrie 91 C/05/00685/FUL Mr & Mrs Devlin Erection of Side and Rear Two Grant Storey Extension to Dwellinghouse and Erection of 1.8 metre Wall and Fencing - 30 Burnside Walk, Coatbridge 96 C/05/00693/FUL Mr & Mrs Murray Erection of Single Storey Side Grant Extension and Front Porch to Dwellinghouse - 13 Girvan Crescent Chapelhall 101 C/05/00802/FUL T-Mobile (UK) Ltd Installation of a 20m high Grant Telecommunications Monopole Incorporating 3 Antennas and 2 No. 600mm Transmission Dishes with Associated Equipment Cabinet - Land to the east of Unit 2, York Road Chapelhall 109 C/05/00815/FUL Mr & Mrs McCluskey Erection of Two Storey Side Grant Extension to Dwellinghouse - 18 Moorfield Crescent, Airdrie 114 C/05/00978/FUL Mr & Mrs Crossan Erection of Dwellinghouse - Refuse (P) Plot 1, Land north east of Pumping Station, Wilsons Road Hareshaw, Cleland 120 S/04/00781/OUT Mr & Mrs M Dougan Erection of a Dwellinghouse (In Grant Outline) - Land at 147 Mill Road Allanton, Shotts, Lanarkshire 126 S/05/00040/AMD Tritax Assets Ltd Amendment to Outline Consent Grant 522/91 to Change the Mix of Class 4, 5 and 6 to include Class 7 and Change of Use of Existing Class 5 Buildings to Classes 5 and 6 - Tritax (former (Chunghwa Picture Tubes (UK) Ltd), 1 Townhead Avenue Eurocentral, Holytown, Motherwell MLI 4XH 22 APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 12 JULY 2005 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmentlLocus Recommendation 132 S/05/00325/FUL Mr M Ashraf Change of Use of Disused Shop Grant to Hot Food Take-away - 49 Craigneuk Street Wishaw Lanarkshire ML2 7XD 135 S/05/00543/FUL T-Mobile (UK) Ltd Installation of 15 Metre High Refuse Telecom Mast with Associated Infrastructure - Land at Robertson Park, Old Edinburgh Road Uddingston 141 S/05/00627/FUL Mr & Mrs P Mitchell Erection of Detached Refuse Dwellinghouse - Land Adjacent to 35 Harvest Drive Motherwell Lanarkshire 146 S/05/00704/FU L Robert Hill Anderson Proposed Extension to Side of Grant House - 38 Cambusnethan Street Wishaw, Lanarkshire ML2 8NN 150 S/05/00766/FUL The Rolling Barrel Pub Formation of a Beer Garden to Grant CO Ltd the Front of an Existing Public House - Land west of Viewpark Shopping Centre, Old Edinburgh Road Uddingston 155 S/05/00769/FUL T-Mobile (UK) Ltd Installation of 15m High Flagpole Refuse with 3 No Antennas and Associated Equipment Cabinet - Webster Engineering Services 397 Coltness Road Wishaw Lanarkshire ML2 7ET 161 S/05/00823/FUL Thomas Woods Erection of Extension to Rear of Grant Dwellinghouse - 31 Second Street Uddingston G71 6AT 164 S/05/00874/FUL John Paul Costello Erection of Two Storey Side Grant Extension and Single Storey Rear Extension - 41 Coursington Gardens, Motherwell Lanarkshire MLI ILT 169 S/05/00919/FUL T-Mobile Installation of a 14.7M High Refuse Telecommunications Monopole, 2 No. Equipment Cabinets and Ancillary Development - Land south of 84 Shottskirk Road Shotts, Lanarkshire 23 APPLICATIONS FOR PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE 12 JULY 2005 Page No. Application No. Applicant DevelopmentlLocus Recommendation (P) C/O5/00673/FUL - Ifgranted, refer to Scottish Executive (contrary to policy) (P) C/05/00978/FUL - If granted, Section 75 required (occupancy restriction) 24 Application No: N/05/00546/FU L Date Registered: 12th April 2005 Applicant: Mr & Mrs C Bunce 56 Ballayne Drive Moodiesburn G69 OQB Development: Extension to a Dwellinghouse Location: 56 Ballayne Drive Moodiesburn Glasgow G69 OQB Ward: 67 Moodiesburn East & Blackwood West Councillor William Hogg Grid Reference: 269969 671078 File Reference: N/05/00546/FU L Site History: No relevant site history Development Plan: Residential Area in Northern Corridor Local Plan (Finalised Draft) 2000. Policies HG3 Retention of Residential Amenity and HG5 House Extensions apply Contrary to Development Plan: No Consultations: Representations: One Representation Letter Newspaper Advertisement: Not Required Comments : This application is in respect of two extensions to an end-terraced dwellinghouse located at the turning- circle end of Ballayne Drive, within an established residential area of Moodiesburn and facing a shared parking court. The first element of the application is a two storey side extension in matching materials, set back from the front of the building and with a stepped down roof ridge. This extension raises no amenity concerns and complies with the relevant Local Plan Policies HG3 (Retention of Residential Amenity) and HG5 (House Extensions). Two car parking spaces would remain, one in the driveway and one as an allocated space in the parking court. My Transportation Section would prefer a third car parking space in the small, attractive front garden area, but I am satisfied this is not required in this instance to serve what would effectively remain a 3-bedroom house, albeit with a playroom which could become a fourth bedroom in the future. 25 92 / / \ The second element of this application is a single storey rear extension measuring 3.6 metres deep across the rear of the house, and this is the subject of an objection by the neighbouring resident at No54 Ballayne Drive. Following concerns expressed on the original design for the rear extension, the applicant has submitted amended plans which have reduced the impact on the adjoining terraced house by lowering and ‘hipping’ the roof and pulling the extension back by 350mm from the mutual boundary. The objector is, nevertheless, still concerned at the reduction in light which would ensue to his rear kitchen / dining room and also his back garden, a situation exacerbated by his house being stepped down (by approximately 600mm) from the application property. The rear gardens are 9.5 metres deep and I do not consider the impact on the adjoining garden to be critical. There would be some loss of light into the kitchen / dining room, however I do not consider that the impact of the amended proposal would be so significant as to warrant refusal on amenity grounds. A daylight / sunlight test has been carried out in accordance with the Building Research Establishment’s guidance and this test is satisfied by the application. The applicant could, in any event, build a kitchen extension measuring up to 16 square metres as ‘permitted development’, which could affect the neighbouring property more than the current, amended scheme. Notwithstanding the concerns expressed by the neighbouring proprietor, I recommend that planning permission be granted. Recommendation: Grant Subject to the Following Conditions:- 1. That the development hereby permitted shall be started within five years of the date of this permission Reason: To accord with the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997. 2. That the facing materials to be used for the external walls and roof shall match in colour and texture those of the existing adjoining building. Reason: To safeguard the residential amenity of the area. Background Papers: Application