Second Schedule Environmental Impact Assessment Report Volume II of VI Linggi Base Sdn. Bhd. Proposed Reclamation and Development of Kuala Linggi International Port (KLIP) at Kuala Linggi, Malacca, Malaysia June 2016 62801230-RPT-02 Rev.02 This report has been prepared under the DHI Business Management System certified by Bureau Veritas to comply with ISO 9001 (Quality Management) Proposed Reclamation and Development of Kuala Linggi International Port (KLIP) at Kuala Linggi, Malacca, Malaysia Environmental Impact Assessment Report Prepared for Linggi Base Sdn Bhd Represented by Commander Ramli Johari (Rtd.) Project Layout Current Revision Approvals Name / Title Signature Date Siti Nurulfirdauz Binti Hashim; Tony Prepared by SNF; TWC; SMH Jun 30, 2016 Chiffings; Syed Mohazri Bin Syed Hazari Reviewed by Tania Golingi TAG Jun 30, 2016 Approved by Tania Golingi TAG Jun 30, 2016 Classification Open Restricted Confidential DHI Water & Environment (M) Sdn. Bhd. (535484-V) Kota Kinabalu Office • Tel: +60 88 260780 • Fax: +60 88 260781 Kuala Lumpur Office • Tel: +60 3 7958 8160 • Fax: +60 3 7958 1162 [email protected] • www.dhi.com.my This page is intentionally left blank Document Information Project No. 62801230 Proposed Reclamation and Development of Kuala Linggi International Port Project Title (KLIP) at Kuala Linggi, Malacca, Malaysia Subject Environmental Impact Assessment Report Client Linggi Base Sdn Bhd Document No. 62801230-RPT-02 Rev 02 Distribution Type of Data No of copies Linggi Base Sdn Bhd Hardcopy 1 Department of Environment Hardcopy+Digital 48+1 DHI Water & Environment (M) Sdn. Bhd. Hardcopy 1 Document Revision History Description of Change/ Rev Rev Date Prepared by Checked by Approved by Reason for Issue 01 Jun 20, 2016 Draft EIA to Client SMH TAG TAG 02 Jun 30, 2016 Submission to DOE SMH TAG TAG The information contained in this document produced by DHI Water and Environment (M) Sdn. Bhd. is solely for the use of the Client identified on the cover sheet for the purpose for which it has been prepared. DHI Water and Environment (M) Sdn. Bhd. makes no representation, undertakes no duty, and accepts no responsibility to any third party who may use or rely upon this document or the information. All rights reserved. No section or element of this document may be removed from this document, reproduced, electronically stored or transmitted in any form without the written permission of DHI Water and Environment (M) Sdn. Bhd. © DHI Water and Environment (M) Sdn. Bhd. DHI Water & Environment (M) Sdn. Bhd. (535484-V) 3A01 & 02, Block G, Pusat Dagangan Phileo Damansara 1, No. 9, Jalan 16/11, Off Jalan Damansara, 46350 Petaling Jaya Selangor Darul Ehsan, Malaysia Tel: +603 7958 8160• Fax: +603 7958 1162• [email protected] • www.dhi.com.my This page is intentionally left blank LIST OF DOCUMENTS VOLUME I: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY VOLUME II: MAIN EIA Chapter 1 Introduction Chapter 2 Statement of Need Chapter 3 Project Options Chapter 4 Project Description Chapter 5 Existing Environment Chapter 6 Evaluation of Impacts and Mitigation Measures Chapter 7 Environmental Management Plan (EMP) and Environmental Monitoring Chapter 8 Study Findings Chapter 9 References DRAWINGS No 1 Project Location No 2 Land use 5 km No 3 Environmental Sensitive Area (ESA) 10 km No 4 Environmental Sensitive Area (ESA) 5 km No.5 Physical Monitoring Stations No.6 Biological Monitoring Station (Land) No.7 Biological Monitoring Station (Marine) VOLUME III: APPENDICES A TO C Appendix A Project Supporting Information Appendix B Initial Environmental and Coastal Assessment Appendix C Baseline Report VOLUME IV: APPENDICES D TO F Appendix D Air and Noise Modelling Report Appendix E Fauna Report Appendix F Socio-economic Impact Assessment (SIA) Study Report VOLUME V: APPENDIX G Appendix G Hydraulic Study Report VOLUME VI: APPENDICES H TO M Appendix H Navigation Study Appendix I Navigation Simulation Report Appendix J Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) Appendix K Economic Valuation (EV) Study Report Appendix L Health Impact Assessment (HIA) Study Appendix M Traffic Impact Assessment (TIA) Study TOR CHECKLIST Additional Comments TOR Checklist 1. TOR Approval Conditions – DOE Ref: JAS (PN) 50/013/401/059 Item Issues/Comments Raised Reference in the Detailed EIA DOE Review (Chapter and Page) (i) To take into account all comments received by the All relevant comments in the Terms Department of Environment (DOE). This includes: of Reference (TOR) have been a, b comments from technical agencies and the review addressed according to the approved panel on the TOR report, Panel Review Minutes of Revised TOR. Meeting., including comments on the revised TOR received via DOE letter dated 8 September 2015 [Ref: AS (PN) 50/013/401/059 Jilid 1(23)]. c Comments on the Revised TOR from technical Refer to Section 2. agencies / reviewing panel: . Comments from the Port Dickson Municipal Council dated 17 May 2016 [Ref: Bil(38)dlm.MPPD329/3/2011 as attached in Appendix 1]; . Comments from the Malacca State Fisheries Department dated 24 May 2016 [Ref: Prk.Mlk.04/52 Jld.27 (69) as attached in Appendix 2]; . Comments from the Negeri Sembilan State Economic Planning Unit dated 24 May 2016 [Appendix 3]; . Comments from the Engineering Services Division, Ministry of Health Malaysia dated 25 May 2016 [Appendix 4]; . Comments from the Federal Department of Town and Country Planning Malaysia dated 26 May 2016 [Ref: JPBD BRFN 185/268/1/1 Jld.6 (12) as attached in Appendix 5]; and . Comments from the Marine Ecology Review Panel, Associate Professor Dr. Harinder Rai Singh dated 26 May 2016 [Appendix 6]. d The letter issued by DOE dated 25 April 2016 [Ref: This was further discussed with DOE. AS(PN)50/013/401/059 Jilid 2(3)] on the appeal by Given that the dredging will only the project proponent for exemption of the occur in Phase 4, in ten years’ time; dredging waste disposal activities study. the disposal activity shall be addressed in a separate EIA prior to but closer to the time of the proposed dredging activity. (ii) The development plans and concept for the Section 1.4.2, page 1-11 proposed project shall be in line with the national level development (National Physical Plan-2 and National Coastal Zone Physical Plan under the Department of Town and Country Planning Peninsular Malaysia) and state level plans (such as Structure Plan and Local Plan) which shall be referenced to and stated clearly in the EIA report. Checklist - 1 Item Issues/Comments Raised Reference in the Detailed EIA DOE Review (Chapter and Page) (iii) The EIA study shall be conducted quantitatively, Section 1.5.3, page 1-12. comprehensively and pollution control measures Chapter 6, page 6-1. shall be stated specifically and in detail for the critical issues identified. (iv) Description and detailed explanation regarding the - proposed project’s location which shall include: a The exact location of the proposed project site by Table 4.1, page 4-4. providing coordinates of the project area with at Section 4.5.4.1, page 4-24 least four (4) corner coordinate points which includes reclamation area, dredging area and the dredging waste disposal site; b A detail and complete current Land Use map Figure 5.113, page 5-98 within 5 km radius (shown for every 250 m Refer Drawings for A3 figures. according to the outline boundary of the proposed project site) which clearly shows the surrounding Environmental Sensitive Receptors (in A3-size) and to also take into account the Environmental Sensitive Receptors within the zone of impact; c The Land Use map should clearly show each Figure 5.113, page 5-98 Environmental Sensitive Receptors especially those within the zone of impact and to also include existing /planned land uses for socio-economic activities which includes industrial, settlements and villages, tourism, historical and heritage and commercial activities, institutions and others; d Maps / figures shown in the EIA report have to be Noted. recent, clear, complete with legend, showing the project location, direction sign and legible; e Sampling locations shall be displayed in the form Refer to Drawings in Volume I and of figures, maps or the likes of where the sampling Volume II for A3 figures. points are clearly shown. These figures / maps shall be presented in A3-size in the EIA report. f Sampling dates for the baseline studies shall be Physical survey: Table 5.1, page 5- stated in the EIA report. 47 Biological survey: Table 5.20, page 5-49 Human Environment: Section 5.3. 1 g Adequate and safe proposed Buffer Zone between Section 4.2, page 4-7 the project site boundary and the nearest Environmental Sensitive Receptors which was obtained through the EIA study shall be included in the EIA report and to be presented to the Local Authorities. h Any International Boundaries used in the figures / The Malaysia-Indonesia boundary maps shall be verified by the Department of was based on Indonesia-Malaysia Survey and Mapping Malaysia (JUPEM). Continental Shelf Boundary Treaty 1969 and Treaty between the Republic of Indonesia and Malaysia Checklist - 2 62801230-RPT-02 TOR CHECKLIST Additional Comments Item Issues/Comments Raised Reference in the Detailed EIA DOE Review (Chapter and Page) on Determination of Boundary Lines of Territorial Waters of the Two Nations at the Straits of Malacca, 1970. Section 4.1.1, page 4-5 i Reference maps used in the EIA report shall be Noted. Other than the recent satellite from a legitimate source, based on JUPEM. image (January 2016), reference map was based on: . JUPEM map Edition 1-PPNM 1996, Series DNMM5101, Sheet 152; . Indonesia-Malaysia Continental Shelf Boundary Treaty 1969 . Treaty between the Republic of Indonesia and Malaysia on Determination of Boundary Lines of Territorial Waters of the Two Nations at the Straits of Malacca, 1970.