Measuring the Rydberg Constant Using Circular Rydberg Atoms in an Intensity-Modulated Optical Lattice Andira Ramos1,∗ Kaitlin Moore2, and Georg Raithel1;2 1Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48105, USA and 2Applied Physics Program, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48105, USA (Dated: May 9, 2017) A method for performing a precision measurement of the Rydberg constant, R1, using cold circular Rydberg atoms is proposed. These states have long lifetimes, as well as negligible quantum- electrodynamics (QED) and no nuclear-overlap corrections. Due to these advantages, the measure- ment can help solve the \proton radius puzzle" [Bernauer, Pohl, Sci. Am. 310, 32 (2014)]. The atoms are trapped using a Rydberg-atom optical lattice, and transitions are driven using a recently- demonstrated lattice-modulation technique to perform Doppler-free spectroscopy. The circular-state transition frequency yields R1. Laser wavelengths and beam geometries are selected such that the lattice-induced transition shift is minimized. The selected transitions have no first-order Zeeman and Stark corrections, leaving only manageable second-order Zeeman and Stark shifts. For Rb, the projected relative uncertainty of R1 in a measurement under the presence of the Earth's gravity is 10−11, with the main contribution coming from the residual lattice shift. This could be reduced in a future micro-gravity implementation. The next-important systematic arises from the Rb+ polarizability (relative-uncertainty contribution of ≈ 3 × 10−12). PACS numbers: 06.20.Jr, 32.80.Rm, 42.62.Fi I. INTRODUCTION 1 0 0 0 | n = 5 3 , n = 1 , n = 1 , m = 5 0 Knowing the value of the Rydberg constant (R1) accu- 1 2 l rately has been of interest for decades due to its relation 5 0 0 - ) 0 to other fundamental constants and its role in calcula- a ( 0 + tions of atomic energy levels. More recently, the large z R b + + discrepancies in the proton [1, 2] and deuteron [3] radii - 5 0 0 that were found using muonic hydrogen and deuterium, - ∆ν= 9 3 . 6 5 7 G H z respectively, have reinforced the need to confirm the ac- curacy of R1. Previous precision experiments with this | n = 5 1 , n 1 = 0 , n 2 = 0 , m l = 5 0 goal have involved low-lying states of hydrogen, limited 5 0 0 ) 0 typically by statistical uncertainties, AC Stark shifts and a ( 0 + second-order Doppler shifts [4]. These have led to the z R b + current CODATA relative uncertainty for the Rydberg 0 constant value of 5:9 × 10−12 [5]. There has also been a - 5 0 0 study involving circular Rydberg states of hydrogen [6] - 1 0 0 0 −11 (relative uncertainty of 2:1 × 10 ) and a proposal in- 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 ρ volving circular states of lithium [7] (expected relative ( a 0 ) uncertainty of about 10−10). The approaches involving low-lying states and circular states deal with significantly different frequency regimes: optical versus microwave. FIG. 1. Normalized probability density, j j2, for the circular Therefore, measurements involving low-lying states of hy- state (bottom) and near-circular state (top) of the transition drogen can have a better relative uncertainty δν/ν than of interest in the proposed experiment. The kets are labeled in principal, parabolic and magnetic quantum numbers, n, n1, results for circular states (under the assumption of sim- + 2 ilar absolute uncertainty, δν). However, circular states n2, m [9]. Near the Rb core, j j = 0 for both states. The arXiv:1705.02682v1 [physics.atom-ph] 7 May 2017 signs refer to the polarity of . It is seen that the transition are insensitive to several systematics that are limiting requires a quadrupolar interaction. in spectroscopy of low-lying states, as discussed in this paper. It has also been proposed to measure the Ryd- trapped circular Rydberg atoms. Transitions are driven berg constant using high-angular momentum states of using a recently-developed spectroscopic method, which hydrogen-like ions [8]. is based on lattice modulation at microwave frequencies We propose an experiment to obtain an indepen- [10]. The critical advantages of circular states, in com- dent measurement of the Rydberg constant using cold, parison with low-lying states of hydrogen, are their long radiative lifetimes (on the order of ms) [11], their small QED corrections [12], and the absence of any overlap ∗ [email protected] with the nucleus, hence eliminating nuclear charge dis- 2 tribution effects (see Fig. 1). a) nF c) F, B In contrast with previous efforts to measure R [4, 13], 7/2 1 5D it is proposed to trap cold Rydberg atoms using a pon- 5/2 5P deromotive potential optical lattice (POL) [14] instead of 3/2 F, B using cold atomic beams. Trapping the atoms allows for 5S1/2 increased interaction times. The light shift introduced by the lattice trap can be addressed by the use of \magic" b) conditions under which the trap-induced shifts of upper |53, 1, 1, 50 and lower states cancel [15]. Residual imperfections in ∆ν =93.657 GHz α z the magic-lattice trap can be addressed by performing 3 |51, 0, 0, 50 the experiment under micro-gravity conditions, which al- low for an overall reduction in the magic-lattice shift. A key method is ponderomotive spectroscopy [10], FIG. 2. (color online). a) Excitation scheme used to pre- which allows for circular-to-near-circular transitions to pare atoms before circularization. b) After circularization, be driven by amplitude-modulating the ponderomotive the transition between an initial, circular state and a final, optical lattice. The method permits us to drive the near-circular state (expressed using parabolic quantum num- bers jn; n ; n ; m i) is driven by ponderomotive spectroscopy, quadrupolar transition needed in our work as a first-order 1 2 l indicated by the curly arrow. c) Parallel stabilization fields, process and to eliminate Doppler broadening. By driving F and B, define the quantization axis (z-axis) of the atoms. transitions between states of the same magnetic quantum The angles between different pairs of counter-propagating lat- number, we eliminate the first-order Zeeman effect. To tice beams, αi, can be varied to change the periodicities of the obtain a zero first-order Stark shift, we select states with lattice in the ith direction. parabolic quantum numbers n1 = n2. In these ways, the proposed experiment addresses im- In order to take advantage of the circular atoms' long portant issues that have been encountered in preceding lifetimes (tens of ms at 4 K), it is necessary to trap the Rydberg constant measurements. In addition, due to Rydberg atoms. To achieve this, a three-dimensional the elimination of nuclear charge overlap, the measure- standing-wave optical lattice is adiabatically turned on, ment of R1 is also independent of the radius of the pro- and the atoms are trapped via the ponderomotive po- −11 ton. Overall, a relative uncertainty of 10 is expected, tential [22] (see Fig. 2c). This ponderomotive poten- which would already be enough to shed light onto the tial emerges from the last term in the minimal-coupling proton radius puzzle. An improvement beyond the cur- Hamiltonian (in SI units), rent CODATA uncertainty, δν/ν = 5:9 × 10−12 [5], is possible by an implementation of the experiment under ^ 1 2 micro-gravity conditions. H = (2jejA(^r) · ^p + e A(^r) · A(^r)); (1) 2me which is proportional to laser intensity and arises when II. PROPOSED EXPERIMENTAL OUTLINE a quasi-free Rydberg electron is placed in a rapidly oscil- lating field. Here, A(^r) is the vector potential of the op- A. Atom Preparation and Spectroscopy tical field, ^p is the momentum operator, ^r is the position operator, me is the electron mass and e is the electron We use cold atoms to reduce interaction-time broad- charge. For non-degenerate states in a monochromatic ening and to limit the interaction volume, thereby reduc- lattice, the adiabatic trapping potential is given by ing field inhomogeneity effects. We propose to use 85Rb 2 Z atoms, pre-cool them in a MOT to ∼ 100 µK, and fur- e 2 2 3 Vad(R) = j (r)j jA(r + R)j d r; (2) ther cool them to ∼ 10 µK and ∼ 1 µK in bright and 2me gray optical molasses, respectively [16, 17]. Since the atom densities desired for this experiment are moderate where R is the atomic center-of-mass position. < 8 −3 (∼ 10 cm ), to avoid Rydberg-Rydberg interactions, The wavelength of the lattice is chosen to match a the use of optical molasses is ideal. \magic" condition for the desired transition (equal po- In order to circularize atoms, we use a modified adia- tentials for lower and upper states). To illustrate this, batic rapid passage (ARP) method [18, 19], which in Rb in Fig. 3a we show adiabatic lattice-potential depths ob- requires that the Rydberg atoms are initially prepared tained from Eq. 2 for the two states of interest, n=51 in ml=3. We employ a three-level excitation scheme, and n=53, as a function of wavelength. In the figure it 5S1=2 ! 5P3=2 (wavelength of 780 nm), 5P3=2 ! 5D5=2 is seen that for the two states considered there are two (776 nm), and 5D5=2 ! nF7=2 (1260 nm) (see Fig. 2a). options to achieve magic conditions, 290 nm and 532 nm. The modified ARP circularization method is optimal for For the proposed experiment we choose a 532-nm lattice. < states n ∼ 50 (our case). If much higher principal quan- The same ponderomotive term that traps atoms is tum numbers were desired, the \E×B" method [20, 21] also used to drive transitions between circular and near- could be used.